{"cost":{"pricesFetchedAt":"2026-10-19T14:04:39.722Z"},"prompts":{"raw":"Make a tasteful graphic to go with the post.","simple":"Make a tasteful graphic to go with the post. Keep it simple and uncluttered:\n- One idea per graphic. Pick the single most important thing the post shows and show only that. If something is a second chart or a second story, leave it out.\n- The main visual (the chart or diagram itself) should take up almost all of the canvas. Titles, labels and everything else should be small and few.\n- Say each thing once. If a legend explains a colour, do not also label it on every bar. If a number is drawn as a bar, do not also restate it in a badge, a caption and a takeaway line.\n- Leave out anything the reader does not need in order to get the point: eyebrow labels, section numbers, subtitles that restate the chart, explanatory paragraphs, callout boxes with extra stats, takeaway lines, footers, source lines, badges, \"next\" links.\n- Keep any text that stays as short as it can be.","shared":"You are making a graphic for AfterQuery (afterquery.com) to accompany one of their blog posts. The post's text is in `article.md` in the current directory.\n\n[the raw or simple instruction above]\n\nDeliverable\n- One file, `graphic.html`, in the current directory. It is screenshotted at exactly 1200x1200 px (the graphic must fill that canvas exactly: no scrolling, nothing cut off).\n- Build it with HTML, CSS and inline SVG. No `<canvas>`, no screenshots or raster images of charts, no animation, nothing that needs interaction.\n- It must look like it belongs to AfterQuery. Browse afterquery.com yourself to collect their fonts, colours, logo and visual style. Save anything you use into `./assets/` and reference it with relative paths so the file renders offline.\n- To check your work, run `node <tools>/preview.cjs graphic.html`. It writes `preview.png` next to the file; look at it.\n\nGround rules\n- Work from `article.md`. Do not open this post's own page on afterquery.com, its images, or any existing graphic, chart, social card or coverage of this post anywhere. Other pages of afterquery.com are fine as style references.\n- Every number in the graphic must come from `article.md`. Do not invent data.\n- Stay inside the current directory (plus the preview command above). Do not read or search other folders on this machine.\n- Work alone and from scratch. Do not use skills, plugins, saved memories or subagents, even if your tools offer them.\n- When `graphic.html` is finished, stop. Reply with one line saying it is done."},"repo":"https://github.com/adamholter/clutterbench","builtAt":"2026-10-19T19:14:14.048Z","grader":"consensus-v4","canvas":1200,"models":{"wonder":{"name":"Muse Wonder","short":"Wonder","effort":"low","family":"wonder","fam":"Wonder"},"luna":{"name":"GPT-6 Luna (low)","short":"Luna low","effort":"low","family":"luna","fam":"Luna"},"luna-medium":{"name":"GPT-6 Luna (medium)","short":"Luna medium","effort":"medium","family":"luna","fam":"Luna"},"luna-high":{"name":"GPT-6 Luna (high)","short":"Luna high","effort":"high","family":"luna","fam":"Luna"},"luna-xhigh":{"name":"GPT-6 Luna (xhigh)","short":"Luna xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"luna","fam":"Luna"},"sol":{"name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (low)","short":"Sol low","effort":"low","family":"sol","fam":"Sol"},"sol-medium":{"name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (medium)","short":"Sol medium","effort":"medium","family":"sol","fam":"Sol"},"sol-high":{"name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (high)","short":"Sol high","effort":"high","family":"sol","fam":"Sol"},"sol-xhigh":{"name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (xhigh)","short":"Sol xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"sol","fam":"Sol"},"astra":{"name":"GPT-6 Astra (low)","short":"Astra low","effort":"low","family":"astra","fam":"Astra"},"astra-medium":{"name":"GPT-6 Astra (medium)","short":"Astra medium","effort":"medium","family":"astra","fam":"Astra"},"astra-high":{"name":"GPT-6 Astra (high)","short":"Astra high","effort":"high","family":"astra","fam":"Astra"},"astra-xhigh":{"name":"GPT-6 Astra (xhigh)","short":"Astra xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"astra","fam":"Astra"},"haiku":{"name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (low)","short":"Haiku 5.5 low","effort":"low","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5"},"haiku-medium":{"name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (medium)","short":"Haiku 5.5 medium","effort":"medium","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5"},"haiku-high":{"name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (high)","short":"Haiku 5.5 high","effort":"high","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5"},"haiku-xhigh":{"name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (xhigh)","short":"Haiku 5.5 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5"},"sonnet":{"name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (low)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 low","effort":"low","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5"},"sonnet-medium":{"name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (medium)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 medium","effort":"medium","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5"},"sonnet-high":{"name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (high)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 high","effort":"high","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5"},"sonnet-xhigh":{"name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (xhigh)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5"},"opus":{"name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (low)","short":"Opus 5.5 low","effort":"low","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5"},"opus-medium":{"name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (medium)","short":"Opus 5.5 medium","effort":"medium","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5"},"opus-high":{"name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (high)","short":"Opus 5.5 high","effort":"high","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5"},"opus-xhigh":{"name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (xhigh)","short":"Opus 5.5 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5"},"gemini-flash":{"name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash (low)","short":"Flash 3.8 low","effort":"low","family":"gemini-flash","fam":"Flash 3.8"},"gemini-flash-medium":{"name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash (medium)","short":"Flash 3.8 medium","effort":"medium","family":"gemini-flash","fam":"Flash 3.8"},"gemini-flash-high":{"name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash (high)","short":"Flash 3.8 high","effort":"high","family":"gemini-flash","fam":"Flash 3.8"},"argon":{"name":"Gemini 4 Argon (low)","short":"Argon low","effort":"low","family":"argon","fam":"Argon"},"argon-medium":{"name":"Gemini 4 Argon (medium)","short":"Argon medium","effort":"medium","family":"argon","fam":"Argon"},"argon-high":{"name":"Gemini 4 Argon (high)","short":"Argon high","effort":"high","family":"argon","fam":"Argon"},"grok":{"name":"Grok 4.7 (low)","short":"Grok 4.7 low","effort":"low","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7"},"grok-medium":{"name":"Grok 4.7 (medium)","short":"Grok 4.7 medium","effort":"medium","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7"},"grok-high":{"name":"Grok 4.7 (high)","short":"Grok 4.7 high","effort":"high","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7"},"grok-xhigh":{"name":"Grok 4.7 (xhigh)","short":"Grok 4.7 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7"},"deepseek":{"name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (low)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash low","effort":"low","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash"},"deepseek-medium":{"name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (medium)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash medium","effort":"medium","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash"},"deepseek-high":{"name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (high)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash high","effort":"high","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash"},"deepseek-xhigh":{"name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (xhigh)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash"},"deepseek-max":{"name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (max)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash max","effort":"max","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash"}},"tasks":{"clutterbench-v1-results":"ClutterBench results","improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe":"DeepSWE","improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking":"τ³-Banking","how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor":"Terminal-Bench 2.0","how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval":"GDPval with NVIDIA","on-policy-distillation-gdpval":"On-policy distillation","building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora":"Legora legal eval"},"showcase":["clutterbench-v1-results"],"board":[{"model":"sonnet","name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (low)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 low","effort":"low","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":28.8,"blue":59.9,"orange":22.6,"red":17.5,"words":43,"usd":0.03257,"sec":32,"out":2583,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":12,"usd":0.0273,"sec":25,"out":2003,"missing":0}},{"model":"opus","name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (low)","short":"Opus 5.5 low","effort":"low","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":31.3,"blue":56.8,"orange":24,"red":19.3,"words":63,"usd":0.06787,"sec":36,"out":2720,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":1.3,"blue":97.3,"orange":2.7,"red":0,"words":14,"usd":0.05578,"sec":34,"out":2062,"missing":1}},{"model":"astra-xhigh","name":"GPT-6 Astra (xhigh)","short":"Astra xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"astra","fam":"Astra","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":33.2,"blue":63.2,"orange":7.1,"red":29.7,"words":74,"usd":0.34899,"sec":157,"out":6558,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":14,"usd":0.22524,"sec":114,"out":4045,"missing":0}},{"model":"grok-high","name":"Grok 4.7 (high)","short":"Grok 4.7 high","effort":"high","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":33.8,"blue":64.4,"orange":3.6,"red":32,"words":121,"usd":0.29126,"sec":818,"out":47822,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":9,"usd":0.21916,"sec":653,"out":35742,"missing":1}},{"model":"sonnet-medium","name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (medium)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 medium","effort":"medium","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":35,"blue":52.6,"orange":24.9,"red":22.6,"words":52,"usd":0.03969,"sec":36,"out":3295,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":1.5,"blue":97.1,"orange":2.9,"red":0,"words":13,"usd":0.03511,"sec":33,"out":2783,"missing":0}},{"model":"sonnet-high","name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (high)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 high","effort":"high","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":36.5,"blue":55.5,"orange":16.1,"red":28.4,"words":106,"usd":0.06731,"sec":55,"out":6058,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":12,"usd":0.03411,"sec":156,"out":2683,"missing":0}},{"model":"haiku-xhigh","name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (xhigh)","short":"Haiku 5.5 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":37.8,"blue":62.1,"orange":0.3,"red":37.6,"words":109,"usd":0.01603,"sec":322,"out":31384,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":11,"usd":0.01146,"sec":129,"out":22193,"missing":0}},{"model":"sonnet-xhigh","name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5 (xhigh)","short":"Sonnet 5.5 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"sonnet","fam":"Sonnet 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":40.1,"blue":52.1,"orange":15.7,"red":32.3,"words":122,"usd":0.17865,"sec":143,"out":17191,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.3,"blue":99.7,"orange":0,"red":0.3,"words":15,"usd":0.07116,"sec":63,"out":6389,"missing":0}},{"model":"deepseek-xhigh","name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (xhigh)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":40.8,"blue":53.3,"orange":11.9,"red":34.9,"words":151,"usd":0.0115,"sec":91,"out":18655,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":14,"usd":0.00774,"sec":78,"out":12316,"missing":0}},{"model":"opus-xhigh","name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (xhigh)","short":"Opus 5.5 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":41.7,"blue":48.3,"orange":19.9,"red":31.8,"words":126,"usd":0.51748,"sec":295,"out":25200,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":10.4,"blue":89.6,"orange":0,"red":10.4,"words":15,"usd":0.32877,"sec":175,"out":15711,"missing":0}},{"model":"haiku","name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (low)","short":"Haiku 5.5 low","effort":"low","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":41.8,"blue":54,"orange":8.6,"red":37.5,"words":104,"usd":0.00482,"sec":48,"out":8973,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":10,"usd":0.00273,"sec":33,"out":4737,"missing":0}},{"model":"grok","name":"Grok 4.7 (low)","short":"Grok 4.7 low","effort":"low","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":42.5,"blue":56.3,"orange":2.4,"red":41.3,"words":124,"usd":0.04809,"sec":128,"out":7295,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":11,"usd":0.04349,"sec":121,"out":6462,"missing":3}},{"model":"sol-medium","name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (medium)","short":"Sol medium","effort":"medium","family":"sol","fam":"Sol","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":42.7,"blue":56.9,"orange":0.7,"red":42.3,"words":87,"usd":0.04,"sec":111,"out":3578,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":12,"usd":0.02972,"sec":86,"out":2512,"missing":1}},{"model":"astra-high","name":"GPT-6 Astra (high)","short":"Astra high","effort":"high","family":"astra","fam":"Astra","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":43,"blue":52,"orange":10.1,"red":37.9,"words":78,"usd":0.20772,"sec":100,"out":3733,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":13,"usd":0.15017,"sec":78,"out":2543,"missing":0}},{"model":"deepseek","name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (low)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash low","effort":"low","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":43.3,"blue":54.9,"orange":3.7,"red":41.4,"words":153,"usd":0.01134,"sec":117,"out":18397,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.1,"blue":99.9,"orange":0,"red":0.1,"words":14,"usd":0.00908,"sec":212,"out":14547,"missing":0}},{"model":"sol","name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (low)","short":"Sol low","effort":"low","family":"sol","fam":"Sol","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":45.6,"blue":53.7,"orange":1.4,"red":44.9,"words":86,"usd":0.03159,"sec":78,"out":2737,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.1,"blue":99.9,"orange":0,"red":0.1,"words":13,"usd":0.02496,"sec":63,"out":2036,"missing":0}},{"model":"sol-high","name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (high)","short":"Sol high","effort":"high","family":"sol","fam":"Sol","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":45.8,"blue":51.6,"orange":5.4,"red":43.1,"words":80,"usd":0.05139,"sec":128,"out":4717,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":12,"usd":0.03778,"sec":116,"out":3318,"missing":0}},{"model":"astra","name":"GPT-6 Astra (low)","short":"Astra low","effort":"low","family":"astra","fam":"Astra","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":45.8,"blue":52.2,"orange":4,"red":43.8,"words":93,"usd":0.16294,"sec":69,"out":2837,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.2,"blue":99.9,"orange":0,"red":0.2,"words":14,"usd":0.1294,"sec":60,"out":2128,"missing":0}},{"model":"haiku-medium","name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (medium)","short":"Haiku 5.5 medium","effort":"medium","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":46.3,"blue":53.2,"orange":1.1,"red":45.7,"words":125,"usd":0.00712,"sec":88,"out":13567,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":10,"usd":0.00412,"sec":54,"out":7504,"missing":0}},{"model":"deepseek-high","name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (high)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash high","effort":"high","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":46.3,"blue":47.9,"orange":11.6,"red":40.5,"words":152,"usd":0.01192,"sec":101,"out":19361,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":86.1,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":14,"usd":0.00841,"sec":59,"out":13439,"missing":2}},{"model":"grok-xhigh","name":"Grok 4.7 (xhigh)","short":"Grok 4.7 xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":46.4,"blue":50.7,"orange":5.9,"red":43.4,"words":139,"usd":0.3159,"sec":1094,"out":51930,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":9,"usd":0.23276,"sec":738,"out":38008,"missing":1}},{"model":"deepseek-max","name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (max)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash max","effort":"max","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":46.6,"blue":49,"orange":8.7,"red":42.3,"words":134,"usd":0.03272,"sec":338,"out":54029,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":12,"usd":0.03078,"sec":329,"out":50712,"missing":0}},{"model":"deepseek-medium","name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (medium)","short":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash medium","effort":"medium","family":"deepseek","fam":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":46.8,"blue":53.2,"orange":0,"red":46.8,"words":182,"usd":0.00854,"sec":65,"out":13735,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":90.5,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":14,"usd":0.00526,"sec":42,"out":8182,"missing":1}},{"model":"astra-medium","name":"GPT-6 Astra (medium)","short":"Astra medium","effort":"medium","family":"astra","fam":"Astra","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":47.7,"blue":47.3,"orange":10,"red":42.7,"words":86,"usd":0.16058,"sec":79,"out":2790,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.9,"blue":99.1,"orange":0,"red":0.9,"words":15,"usd":0.13097,"sec":69,"out":2159,"missing":1}},{"model":"opus-medium","name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (medium)","short":"Opus 5.5 medium","effort":"medium","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":47.9,"blue":40.1,"orange":24.2,"red":35.8,"words":107,"usd":0.17474,"sec":91,"out":8064,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":15,"usd":0.09477,"sec":54,"out":4011,"missing":0}},{"model":"haiku-high","name":"Claude Haiku 5.5 (high)","short":"Haiku 5.5 high","effort":"high","family":"haiku","fam":"Haiku 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":48.9,"blue":39.2,"orange":23.8,"red":36.9,"words":103,"usd":0.0091,"sec":238,"out":17526,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":12,"usd":0.00621,"sec":76,"out":11690,"missing":0}},{"model":"opus-high","name":"Claude Opus 5.5 (high)","short":"Opus 5.5 high","effort":"high","family":"opus","fam":"Opus 5.5","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":48.9,"blue":37,"orange":28.1,"red":34.9,"words":129,"usd":0.25398,"sec":128,"out":12026,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":3.8,"blue":92.6,"orange":7.3,"red":0.2,"words":16,"usd":0.13141,"sec":72,"out":5843,"missing":1}},{"model":"sol-xhigh","name":"GPT-6.1 Sol (xhigh)","short":"Sol xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"sol","fam":"Sol","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":52.1,"blue":45.2,"orange":5.5,"red":49.4,"words":77,"usd":0.07981,"sec":207,"out":7560,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":11,"usd":0.05823,"sec":159,"out":5363,"missing":1}},{"model":"luna-high","name":"GPT-6 Luna (high)","short":"Luna high","effort":"high","family":"luna","fam":"Luna","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":53.5,"blue":45.2,"orange":2.8,"red":52.1,"words":105,"usd":0.00371,"sec":75,"out":7002,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":8,"usd":0.00215,"sec":52,"out":3841,"missing":1}},{"model":"grok-medium","name":"Grok 4.7 (medium)","short":"Grok 4.7 medium","effort":"medium","family":"grok","fam":"Grok 4.7","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":53.9,"blue":42.9,"orange":6.3,"red":50.8,"words":131,"usd":0.19153,"sec":492,"out":31200,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.9,"blue":99.1,"orange":0,"red":0.9,"words":9,"usd":0.08376,"sec":227,"out":13175,"missing":1}},{"model":"luna-medium","name":"GPT-6 Luna (medium)","short":"Luna medium","effort":"medium","family":"luna","fam":"Luna","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":56.1,"blue":42.3,"orange":3.3,"red":54.4,"words":96,"usd":0.00178,"sec":45,"out":3129,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":11,"usd":0.00155,"sec":43,"out":2635,"missing":0}},{"model":"gemini-flash","name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash (low)","short":"Flash 3.8 low","effort":"low","family":"gemini-flash","fam":"Flash 3.8","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":60.9,"blue":34.8,"orange":8.5,"red":56.7,"words":254,"usd":0.09692,"sec":237,"out":23041,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0.1,"blue":99.9,"orange":0,"red":0.1,"words":20,"usd":0.07294,"sec":236,"out":17188,"missing":0}},{"model":"luna","name":"GPT-6 Luna (low)","short":"Luna low","effort":"low","family":"luna","fam":"Luna","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":61.4,"blue":34.8,"orange":7.8,"red":57.5,"words":110,"usd":0.00181,"sec":53,"out":3203,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":5.5,"blue":89.7,"orange":9.6,"red":0.6,"words":20,"usd":0.0013,"sec":50,"out":2136,"missing":3}},{"model":"wonder","name":"Muse Wonder","short":"Wonder","effort":"low","family":"wonder","fam":"Wonder","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":62.1,"blue":34.7,"orange":6.5,"red":58.8,"words":234,"usd":0.17611,"sec":106,"out":8388,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":1.1,"blue":97.8,"orange":2.3,"red":0,"words":15,"usd":0.09598,"sec":68,"out":4343,"missing":0}},{"model":"luna-xhigh","name":"GPT-6 Luna (xhigh)","short":"Luna xhigh","effort":"xhigh","family":"luna","fam":"Luna","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":64.3,"blue":32.8,"orange":5.8,"red":61.4,"words":135,"usd":0.00734,"sec":137,"out":14254,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":9,"usd":0.00507,"sec":104,"out":9671,"missing":1}},{"model":"gemini-flash-medium","name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash (medium)","short":"Flash 3.8 medium","effort":"medium","family":"gemini-flash","fam":"Flash 3.8","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":70,"blue":25.4,"orange":9.2,"red":65.4,"words":349,"usd":0.22807,"sec":471,"out":54833,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":15,"usd":0.24624,"sec":562,"out":59198,"missing":0}},{"model":"argon","name":"Gemini 4 Argon (low)","short":"Argon low","effort":"low","family":"argon","fam":"Argon","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":72.6,"blue":24.5,"orange":5.8,"red":69.7,"words":440,"usd":0.39131,"sec":576,"out":38681,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":25.8,"blue":74.2,"orange":0,"red":25.8,"words":54,"usd":0.24587,"sec":386,"out":24098,"missing":0}},{"model":"gemini-flash-high","name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash (high)","short":"Flash 3.8 high","effort":"high","family":"gemini-flash","fam":"Flash 3.8","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":74.1,"blue":23.4,"orange":5,"red":71.6,"words":419,"usd":0.35312,"sec":684,"out":85149,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":0,"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"words":18,"usd":0.29715,"sec":661,"out":71542,"missing":0}},{"model":"argon-medium","name":"Gemini 4 Argon (medium)","short":"Argon medium","effort":"medium","family":"argon","fam":"Argon","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":76.5,"blue":20.2,"orange":6.5,"red":73.2,"words":513,"usd":0.69887,"sec":1085,"out":69436,"missing":0},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":11.5,"blue":88.5,"orange":0,"red":11.5,"words":43,"usd":0.40748,"sec":645,"out":40259,"missing":0}},{"model":"argon-high","name":"Gemini 4 Argon (high)","short":"Argon high","effort":"high","family":"argon","fam":"Argon","raw":{"n":6,"clutter":79.5,"blue":17.4,"orange":6.2,"red":76.4,"words":556,"usd":0.83194,"sec":1224,"out":82743,"missing":1},"simple":{"n":6,"clutter":16.1,"blue":83.9,"orange":0,"red":16.1,"words":38,"usd":0.65823,"sec":1167,"out":65333,"missing":1}}],"runs":[{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-high__raw","clutter":87.6,"shares":{"blue":8.6,"orange":7.9,"red":83.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":55.2},"score":8,"words":472,"missing":[],"summary":"Dense infographic of five panels buries the single +5% bar chart under process diagrams, stat cards and a duplicate callout; the chart lacks a clear metric scale.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Legora name pill","reason":"Legora is already named in the headline; the pill repeats it.","boxes":[[228,35,51,26],[194,41,8,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category/date tag line carries nothing needed.","boxes":[[790,41,366,14],[775,43,6,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Long sentence headline, doesn't state the finding.","boxes":[[44,85,736,85]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Evaluation scope box","reason":"Restates the subtitle and the source-documents card.","boxes":[[876,102,112,12],[876,114,191,29],[876,142,250,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory sentence restating the topic.","boxes":[[44,168,757,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stat cards","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[61,222,82,65],[327,222,42,65],[617,222,105,65],[895,222,16,65],[233,259,46,16],[509,259,59,16],[780,259,66,16],[1032,259,107,16],[239,261,34,12],[515,261,47,12],[786,261,54,12],[1038,261,95,12],[61,281,76,18],[327,281,91,18],[617,281,120,18],[895,281,160,18],[61,301,182,30],[327,301,238,30],[617,301,220,30],[895,301,233,30],[895,336,116,18],[1017,336,122,18],[61,338,192,16],[327,338,14,7],[344,338,15,7],[362,338,14,7],[379,338,15,7],[397,338,14,7],[414,338,15,7],[432,338,14,7],[449,338,15,7],[467,338,15,7],[484,338,14,7],[502,338,15,7],[519,338,14,7],[537,338,15,7],[554,338,14,7],[617,338,216,16],[903,340,100,11],[1025,340,106,11],[327,348,14,7],[344,348,15,7],[362,348,14,7],[379,348,15,7],[397,348,14,7],[414,348,15,7],[432,348,14,7],[449,348,15,7],[467,348,15,7],[484,348,14,7],[502,348,15,7],[519,348,14,7],[537,348,15,7],[554,348,14,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Defining benchmark panel","reason":"Benchmark design process card, a second idea.","boxes":[[420,398,105,18],[77,401,167,13],[429,401,87,12],[63,402,6,11],[63,431,437,33],[63,464,419,33],[112,517,258,15],[605,517,6,10],[77,521,24,24],[83,526,13,12],[499,527,9,12],[112,533,336,15],[841,571,10,10],[95,579,202,12],[438,579,73,12],[78,580,10,10],[81,583,4,4],[233,608,253,30],[91,609,104,15],[91,626,69,11],[233,680,221,30],[91,681,77,15],[91,698,106,11],[233,751,255,30],[91,753,104,15],[91,770,100,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Validation loop panel","reason":"Failure review flow diagram, unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[989,398,148,18],[593,401,242,13],[998,401,130,12],[579,402,6,11],[579,431,486,33],[579,464,546,33],[592,506,507,54],[618,517,203,11],[1102,529,6,8],[1099,533,17,234],[605,534,156,15],[777,534,275,16],[857,570,140,11],[711,607,10,7],[970,607,10,7],[592,616,244,87],[855,616,244,87],[633,625,134,15],[897,625,154,15],[602,627,25,25],[865,627,25,25],[610,636,8,8],[873,636,10,7],[633,642,137,11],[897,642,119,11],[603,662,171,15],[867,662,194,15],[603,678,203,15],[867,678,209,15],[716,703,259,15],[841,727,10,7],[592,736,507,62],[603,746,411,11],[603,763,112,25],[723,763,118,25],[847,763,110,25],[964,763,119,25],[622,770,81,13],[741,770,86,13],[866,770,76,13],[983,770,90,13],[611,773,6,6],[730,773,6,6],[855,773,6,6],[972,773,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Model vs harness diagram","reason":"Failure diagnosis diagram is a separate idea.","boxes":[[384,849,142,18],[981,849,154,18],[79,852,242,13],[393,852,124,12],[65,853,6,11],[569,853,6,11],[65,878,325,31],[65,909,426,33],[250,958,272,42],[280,964,73,15],[263,974,10,10],[241,975,6,8],[68,977,130,56],[280,980,213,15],[80,990,82,11],[80,1005,95,15],[250,1008,272,44],[280,1014,163,15],[263,1025,10,10],[241,1027,6,8],[280,1031,229,15],[77,1076,160,15],[237,1076,131,14],[409,1078,105,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section tags and paragraph","reason":"Section eyebrows, pills and an explanatory paragraph add no chart information.","boxes":[[583,852,219,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Same models tag","reason":"Repeats the 'Same Production Models' label already shown on the chart row.","boxes":[[990,852,136,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+5% callout","reason":"Restates the +5% already shown in the chart.","boxes":[[584,1043,65,55],[661,1054,324,32],[661,1054,202,15],[1019,1059,101,24],[1029,1065,81,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Company boilerplate tagline.","boxes":[[58,1140,536,15],[44,1144,5,8]]}],"usd":0.83383,"sec":1710,"out":83148,"cut":190,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-high__simple","clutter":68.2,"shares":{"blue":31.8,"orange":0,"red":68.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":54},"score":6,"words":65,"missing":[],"summary":"A flow diagram with an extra feedback loop and large validation and attribution panels crowd the +5% result; the benchmark is named.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Repeatable task cards","reason":"Task-design method cards and dataset counts; a second point beside the main visual","boxes":[[191,115,820,276],[235,136,198,24],[219,141,6,16],[808,141,175,19],[219,181,240,182],[481,181,240,182],[743,181,240,182],[248,207,24,30],[505,209,26,32],[767,209,26,32],[243,212,24,30],[522,216,5,5],[773,218,9,6],[511,219,14,14],[773,228,9,6],[243,260,170,37],[505,260,180,37],[767,260,172,37],[505,306,95,17],[243,310,138,17],[767,310,199,17],[505,326,142,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Calibrates benchmark loop","reason":"Side box and dashed loop add a second process idea.","boxes":[[149,253,36,302],[53,555,192,96],[113,581,73,20],[109,605,80,20],[149,651,42,339]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Failure cases and validation panels","reason":"Validation and attribution process panels are a separate second point from the +5% result","boxes":[[521,773,160,36],[547,783,108,16],[389,791,212,48],[601,791,212,48],[191,845,396,290],[615,845,396,290],[231,866,130,24],[651,866,152,24],[215,871,6,16],[635,871,6,16],[211,913,356,84],[635,913,356,84],[261,941,184,29],[685,941,51,29],[224,942,27,27],[648,942,27,27],[656,950,11,11],[233,951,9,9],[187,986,9,9],[211,1017,356,84],[635,1017,356,84],[261,1045,279,29],[685,1045,65,29],[224,1046,27,27],[648,1046,27,27],[655,1053,12,12],[987,1055,9,9],[231,1056,12,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Collaboration tag","reason":"Small tag restating who validated; adds nothing to the chart.","boxes":[[416,873,147,15]]}],"usd":0.883418,"sec":1747,"out":88068,"cut":56,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-medium__raw","clutter":86.7,"shares":{"blue":10.5,"orange":5.6,"red":83.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":62.4},"score":8,"words":508,"missing":[],"summary":"Four ideas are packed into one dense infographic, with a large process diagram, a failure-attribution panel and repeated +5% content burying the stat cards and the result.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Legora chip","reason":"Second brand mark; Legora is already named in the intro","boxes":[[242,37,47,24],[194,42,8,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog meta pill","reason":"Date, byline and link pill add nothing to the point.","boxes":[[1033,38,123,22],[757,41,27,17],[792,41,3,17],[804,41,79,17],[892,41,3,17],[905,41,120,17],[1043,42,103,14],[742,44,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"URL pill and decorations","reason":"Decorative pill and shapes; the URL adds nothing to the chart","boxes":[[228,46,6,6]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Two-line title","reason":"Names the benchmark but is long, about ten words.","boxes":[[44,72,507,52],[44,109,573,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the title and the post's premise.","boxes":[[735,87,409,58],[894,87,42,17],[887,128,149,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section 01 header","reason":"Section number and caption with a side note.","boxes":[[786,194,370,16],[57,195,33,14],[98,195,244,14],[44,197,5,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Corpus scale stat cards","reason":"Dataset counts are a second idea, not the production result","boxes":[[71,232,91,15],[345,232,78,15],[620,232,103,15],[910,232,117,15],[60,234,5,11],[334,234,5,11],[609,234,5,11],[899,234,5,11],[60,241,104,63],[334,241,46,63],[609,241,127,63],[899,241,23,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Card tags and bars","reason":"Tags, descriptions and decorative progress bars restate the numbers.","boxes":[[192,234,99,12],[503,234,62,12],[762,234,93,12],[1084,234,56,12],[60,298,230,31],[334,298,196,31],[609,298,221,31],[899,298,239,31],[60,346,198,12],[334,346,14,6],[351,346,14,6],[368,346,14,6],[384,346,14,6],[401,346,14,6],[418,346,14,6],[434,346,14,6],[451,346,14,6],[468,346,14,6],[485,346,14,6],[501,346,14,6],[518,346,14,6],[535,346,14,6],[551,346,14,6],[609,346,231,12],[899,346,117,12],[1060,346,80,12],[334,355,14,6],[351,355,14,6],[368,355,14,6],[384,355,14,6],[401,355,14,6],[418,355,14,6],[434,355,14,6],[451,355,14,6],[468,355,14,6],[485,355,14,6],[501,355,14,6],[518,355,14,6],[535,355,14,6],[551,355,14,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process diagram","reason":"Large pipeline and calibration diagram is a second, unrelated idea.","boxes":[[598,383,558,16],[57,384,33,14],[98,384,391,14],[44,386,5,11],[65,425,606,390],[717,425,418,390],[79,436,5,12],[91,436,431,13],[733,436,5,12],[745,436,342,13],[275,459,380,218],[275,459,380,27],[733,459,386,66],[79,461,168,136],[79,461,168,5],[289,464,318,15],[747,467,226,15],[91,475,91,11],[91,485,95,26],[747,486,284,15],[655,492,74,249],[289,496,352,49],[289,496,4,49],[747,502,284,15],[303,503,183,15],[91,504,78,26],[549,506,68,12],[303,522,312,15],[91,541,129,15],[733,548,187,116],[733,548,187,5],[932,548,187,116],[932,548,187,5],[289,555,352,49],[289,555,4,49],[91,558,112,15],[745,560,109,11],[944,560,91,11],[303,562,142,15],[549,565,68,12],[659,569,74,194],[91,575,131,15],[745,576,64,15],[944,576,134,15],[303,581,314,15],[745,592,68,15],[944,592,70,15],[289,614,352,49],[289,614,4,49],[745,614,112,14],[944,614,120,14],[303,621,158,15],[527,624,99,12],[745,629,126,14],[944,629,110,14],[303,640,291,15],[745,644,98,14],[944,644,121,14],[733,691,386,110],[79,699,576,102],[79,699,6,102],[747,701,279,14],[97,713,190,12],[97,723,403,29],[747,723,172,30],[931,723,174,30],[757,731,107,14],[941,731,115,14],[97,754,488,15],[747,759,172,30],[931,759,174,30],[757,767,104,14],[941,767,119,14],[97,775,286,18],[105,778,260,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section 03 header","reason":"Section number, caption and tagline.","boxes":[[759,863,397,16],[57,864,33,14],[98,864,261,14],[44,865,5,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Model vs harness panel","reason":"Separate conceptual panel explaining failure attribution.","boxes":[[61,898,347,30],[427,906,157,13],[74,955,77,15],[194,955,111,15],[341,955,88,15],[473,955,98,15],[200,957,99,11],[479,957,86,11],[74,975,220,47],[341,975,226,63],[73,1069,324,30],[73,1069,110,14],[449,1077,123,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated +5% result","reason":"Sentence and bars restate the +5% callout.","boxes":[[780,957,358,17],[780,979,355,33],[793,979,42,15],[894,996,16,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand tagline","reason":"Brand repeated with a tagline when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[59,1158,61,15],[120,1158,501,16],[44,1161,6,11]]}],"usd":0.47322,"sec":1175,"out":47087,"cut":187,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon-medium__simple","clutter":63.8,"shares":{"blue":36.2,"orange":0,"red":63.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":63.6},"score":7,"words":89,"missing":[],"summary":"A sprawling multi-level flowchart buries the benchmark structure under failure-review branches, a feedback loop, a pill and a +5% stat card, though it names what BAR is.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards above","reason":"Dataset counts and input, work and scoring cards are a separate pipeline story.","boxes":[[112,136,1040,264],[154,149,332,36],[138,162,6,14],[138,202,312,174],[476,202,312,174],[814,202,312,174],[500,224,264,12],[500,224,234,12],[838,224,264,12],[838,224,228,12],[162,226,22,10],[189,226,22,10],[216,226,22,10],[243,226,22,10],[270,226,22,10],[297,226,22,10],[324,226,22,10],[351,226,22,10],[378,226,22,10],[405,226,21,10],[500,240,264,12],[500,240,192,12],[838,240,264,12],[838,240,180,12],[162,241,22,10],[189,241,22,10],[216,241,22,10],[243,241,22,10],[270,241,22,10],[297,241,22,10],[324,241,22,10],[351,241,22,10],[378,241,22,10],[405,241,21,10],[162,256,22,10],[189,256,22,10],[216,256,22,10],[243,256,22,10],[270,256,22,10],[297,256,22,10],[324,256,22,10],[351,256,22,10],[378,256,22,10],[405,256,21,10],[500,256,264,12],[500,256,210,12],[838,256,264,12],[838,256,150,12],[162,294,86,26],[500,294,128,26],[838,294,171,26],[162,331,199,17],[500,331,242,17],[838,331,199,17],[287,372,14,8],[625,372,14,8],[963,372,14,8],[294,376,338,58],[431,463,11,8],[965,463,11,8],[429,472,14,8],[963,472,14,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Synthetic case pill","reason":"Badge about a side detail, not needed to read the diagram.","boxes":[[910,155,216,28],[938,162,178,15],[923,166,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Feedback loop line","reason":"Dashed loop back to inputs serves a second process point.","boxes":[[108,261,8,14],[99,263,8,11],[64,268,44,562],[108,823,8,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Harness and scoring pipeline","reason":"Process boxes explaining how tasks run; they do not show the result.","boxes":[[112,476,648,192],[800,476,352,192],[114,478,644,188],[140,492,237,36],[828,492,123,36],[140,538,268,104],[462,538,270,104],[828,538,296,104],[850,558,167,23],[162,564,158,26],[484,564,118,26],[756,583,8,14],[449,585,8,11],[789,585,8,11],[850,592,156,22],[1012,592,90,22],[162,601,184,16],[484,601,175,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Judgment vs error cards","reason":"Failure categorization is a second idea beyond the benchmark design.","boxes":[[112,756,500,148],[204,801,318,27],[140,806,48,48],[157,821,6,6],[165,833,6,6],[204,839,359,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Model vs harness failure","reason":"Third-level breakdown unrelated to reading the benchmark structure.","boxes":[[140,1106,244,8],[474,1106,244,8]]}],"usd":0.623278,"sec":1256,"out":62054,"cut":95,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon__raw","clutter":61.7,"shares":{"blue":38.3,"orange":0,"red":61.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":54.2},"score":7,"words":375,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% quality bars are buried among stat cards, a pipeline diagram, a failure diagram, and a footer; the headline names the benchmark but not the finding.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Legora co-brand pill","reason":"Partner named again in eyebrow and headline; redundant header chrome","boxes":[[250,49,50,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog metadata","reason":"Date, authors, blog tag, URL are not needed to read the graphic.","boxes":[[1028,52,120,21],[792,53,3,18],[804,53,78,18],[891,53,3,18],[904,53,111,18],[756,54,27,17],[1036,56,104,13],[741,57,6,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header byline and metadata","reason":"Blog tag, date, authors and URL add nothing to the chart reading","boxes":[[202,55,8,15],[237,57,5,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explains and restates the title.","boxes":[[795,118,318,81],[795,118,337,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline.","boxes":[[67,138,458,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stat cards","reason":"Dataset size stats row is a separate idea from the +5% result.","boxes":[[221,238,75,15],[492,238,82,15],[757,238,95,15],[1028,238,101,15],[71,239,70,13],[349,239,84,13],[626,239,91,13],[904,239,98,13],[227,240,63,11],[498,240,70,11],[763,240,83,11],[1034,240,89,11],[71,249,114,68],[349,249,51,68],[626,249,140,68],[904,249,26,68],[71,311,76,18],[349,311,91,18],[626,311,120,18],[904,311,160,18],[71,332,190,32],[349,332,225,32],[626,332,217,32],[904,332,188,32],[349,375,13,7],[365,375,13,7],[381,375,13,7],[397,375,13,7],[413,375,13,7],[429,375,13,7],[446,375,13,7],[462,375,13,7],[478,375,13,7],[494,375,13,7],[510,375,13,7],[527,375,13,7],[543,375,13,7],[559,375,13,7],[643,376,3,16],[667,376,3,16],[691,376,3,16],[715,376,3,16],[733,376,3,16],[757,376,3,16],[781,376,3,16],[805,376,3,16],[829,376,3,16],[74,377,220,14],[631,377,3,14],[661,377,3,14],[679,377,3,14],[703,377,3,14],[727,377,3,14],[751,377,3,14],[769,377,3,14],[793,377,3,14],[817,377,3,14],[841,377,3,14],[649,378,3,12],[685,378,3,12],[709,378,3,12],[739,378,3,12],[775,378,3,12],[799,378,3,12],[823,378,3,12],[906,378,220,12],[954,378,156,11],[77,379,4,10],[84,379,4,10],[91,379,4,10],[98,379,4,10],[105,379,4,10],[112,379,4,10],[119,379,4,10],[126,379,4,10],[133,379,4,10],[140,379,4,10],[147,379,4,10],[154,379,4,10],[161,379,4,10],[168,379,4,10],[175,379,4,10],[182,379,4,10],[189,379,4,10],[196,379,4,10],[203,379,4,10],[210,379,4,10],[217,379,4,10],[224,379,4,10],[231,379,4,10],[238,379,4,10],[245,379,4,10],[252,379,4,10],[259,379,4,10],[266,379,4,10],[273,379,4,10],[280,379,4,10],[637,379,3,10],[673,379,3,10],[721,379,3,10],[763,379,3,10],[787,379,3,10],[835,379,3,10],[908,379,38,9],[655,380,3,8],[697,380,3,8],[745,380,3,8],[811,380,3,8],[349,385,13,7],[365,385,13,7],[381,385,13,7],[397,385,13,7],[413,385,13,7],[429,385,13,7],[446,385,13,7],[462,385,13,7],[478,385,13,7],[494,385,13,7],[510,385,13,7],[527,385,13,7],[543,385,13,7],[559,385,13,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Architecture pipeline","reason":"Large method diagram unrelated to the results chart.","boxes":[[291,445,467,31],[75,458,206,13],[830,458,295,13],[389,520,386,13],[877,551,185,15],[877,567,165,15],[397,623,85,15],[544,623,85,15],[691,623,93,15],[397,639,75,15],[544,639,82,15],[691,639,91,15],[397,655,57,15],[544,655,76,15],[691,655,80,15],[397,671,51,15],[544,671,80,15],[691,671,56,15],[85,725,1030,74],[105,742,178,13],[583,742,128,40],[719,742,134,40],[861,742,114,40],[983,742,114,40],[595,749,47,11],[731,749,47,11],[873,749,47,11],[995,749,47,11],[105,754,436,27],[595,761,95,15],[731,761,101,15],[873,761,43,15],[995,761,41,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Failure attribution diagram","reason":"Second diagram about failure diagnosis; separate idea.","boxes":[[75,869,179,13],[75,886,300,31],[258,930,271,46],[282,938,76,15],[268,941,5,24],[204,953,54,33],[282,955,218,15],[75,961,129,50],[87,972,82,11],[229,983,7,7],[204,986,54,33],[87,987,94,15],[258,996,271,46],[282,1004,171,15],[268,1007,5,24],[282,1021,227,15],[75,1060,413,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Product impact panel","reason":"+5% product result is a separate claim beside the architecture","boxes":[[595,869,142,13],[595,874,72,63],[677,906,147,21],[686,910,129,13],[1009,910,116,13],[789,935,178,18],[595,937,144,15],[1068,937,57,14],[789,962,190,18],[789,962,178,18],[595,964,156,15],[1047,964,78,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence","reason":"Sentence restates the chart result.","boxes":[[595,1077,133,15],[728,1077,344,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats brand with tagline and contact links.","boxes":[[68,1144,59,15],[127,1144,501,16],[52,1147,6,10]]}],"usd":0.40833,"sec":625,"out":40598,"cut":218,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__argon__simple","clutter":80.6,"shares":{"blue":19.4,"orange":0,"red":80.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":64.7},"score":8,"words":83,"missing":[],"summary":"Clutter: dataset stats row, method pipeline, architecture and review panels, and a model-failure branch surround the small +5% harness chart; the graphic is complete with its benchmark, metric and bars.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats row","reason":"Dataset counts serve a different point than the harness result","boxes":[[48,117,1104,158],[76,142,159,78],[444,142,58,78],[812,142,130,78],[264,153,128,72],[948,153,176,50],[566,155,22,15],[593,155,22,15],[620,155,22,15],[647,155,22,15],[674,155,22,15],[701,155,22,15],[728,155,22,15],[257,160,128,72],[962,165,4,4],[974,165,4,4],[986,165,4,4],[998,165,4,4],[1010,165,4,4],[1022,165,4,4],[1034,165,4,4],[1046,165,4,4],[1058,165,4,4],[1070,165,4,4],[1082,165,4,4],[1094,165,4,4],[1106,165,4,4],[250,167,128,72],[276,167,36,6],[318,167,24,6],[566,176,22,15],[593,176,22,15],[620,176,22,15],[647,176,22,15],[674,176,22,15],[701,176,22,15],[728,176,22,15],[962,176,4,4],[974,176,4,4],[986,176,4,4],[998,176,4,4],[1010,176,4,4],[1022,176,4,4],[1034,176,4,4],[1046,176,4,4],[1058,176,4,4],[1070,176,4,4],[1082,176,4,4],[1094,176,4,4],[1106,176,4,4],[276,181,102,5],[1104,185,9,9],[962,187,4,4],[974,187,4,4],[986,187,4,4],[998,187,4,4],[1010,187,4,4],[1022,187,4,4],[1034,187,4,4],[1046,187,4,4],[1058,187,4,4],[1070,187,4,4],[1082,187,4,4],[1094,187,4,4],[276,193,90,5],[1096,196,12,28],[566,197,22,15],[593,197,22,15],[620,197,22,15],[647,197,22,15],[674,197,22,15],[701,197,22,15],[728,197,22,15],[276,205,68,5],[76,214,131,19],[444,214,98,19],[812,214,43,19],[955,215,135,17],[566,218,22,15],[593,218,22,15],[620,218,22,15],[647,218,22,15],[674,218,22,15],[701,218,22,15],[728,218,22,15],[544,316,12,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Repeatable agent task method","reason":"Method card pipeline beside the results chart; a separate idea","boxes":[[48,333,1004,270],[76,348,221,37],[76,417,292,164],[404,417,292,164],[732,417,292,164],[111,427,83,33],[439,427,125,33],[767,427,161,33],[96,437,7,16],[424,437,7,16],[752,437,7,16],[96,460,104,19],[424,460,103,19],[752,460,105,19],[1060,462,9,12],[96,491,252,70],[424,491,252,70],[752,491,252,70],[397,494,7,10],[725,494,7,10],[438,503,88,7],[767,504,10,10],[110,505,64,6],[182,505,136,6],[786,506,164,6],[110,521,208,6],[767,522,10,10],[786,524,136,6],[438,527,186,5],[110,537,120,6],[236,537,82,6],[438,539,160,5],[767,540,10,10],[786,542,186,6],[438,551,110,5],[252,654,12,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Feedback loop label","reason":"Side annotation explaining the loop; not needed to read the result","boxes":[[1024,468,88,301],[1123,528,17,183]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Legora harness architecture","reason":"Architecture cards explain the system, a second point","boxes":[[48,671,420,208],[76,690,235,37],[76,731,235,19],[477,746,45,17],[523,769,9,12],[76,771,172,80],[268,771,172,80],[94,790,44,19],[286,790,56,19],[94,814,95,18],[286,814,91,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Review failure categories","reason":"Failure classification panel is a side process, not the main result","boxes":[[540,671,512,208],[568,690,286,37],[568,743,456,52],[614,759,240,19],[587,762,14,14],[568,805,456,52],[614,821,152,19],[587,824,14,14],[790,936,12,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Model failure branch","reason":"Model-failure branch is an unrelated sub-point; the chart covers harness","boxes":[[238,936,12,9],[48,953,392,196],[76,977,149,41],[76,1049,336,64],[116,1071,235,19],[95,1076,10,10]]}],"usd":0.505578,"sec":630,"out":50284,"cut":150,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-high__raw","clutter":66,"shares":{"blue":20.7,"orange":26.7,"red":52.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.3},"score":7,"words":80,"missing":[],"summary":"A stats row, pipeline diagram, tags and footers crowd out the one 5% result; the headline is also a verbose sentence.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Kicker tag 'Research / Legal AI' tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[961,65,175,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline sentence","reason":"Full-sentence slogan headline, huge; should be shorter like 'BAR: legal agent benchmark'.","boxes":[[64,139,694,207]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second point unrelated to the 5% result.","boxes":[[64,432,131,103],[460,432,67,103],[818,432,167,103],[64,527,99,25],[460,527,119,25],[818,527,159,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline diagram","reason":"Method pipeline cards are a second idea beside the result.","boxes":[[64,610,383,14],[65,659,296,160],[452,659,296,160],[839,659,296,160],[87,695,34,38],[94,695,27,27],[474,696,37,35],[862,697,45,39],[482,706,21,13],[87,742,184,33],[474,742,130,33],[861,742,161,33],[87,778,215,21],[474,778,223,21],[861,778,210,21],[213,819,775,45],[514,853,173,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Result explanation","reason":"Explanatory subtext restating the callout.","boxes":[[368,1025,319,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer credit","reason":"Partners already shown in logos; restated.","boxes":[[64,1154,289,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1050,1154,86,18]]}],"usd":0.20797,"sec":95,"out":3939,"cut":30,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.9},"score":1,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean, simple flow with a single result and a logo; the boxes are large and the flow is a bit oversized, but nothing needs removing.","marks":[],"usd":0.17398,"sec":97,"out":3221,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-medium__raw","clutter":79.4,"shares":{"blue":20.6,"orange":0,"red":79.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.7},"score":7,"words":82,"missing":[],"summary":"A stats row and a process-flow diagram crowd out the only result, a +5% callout with no visual; it also has repeated branding and a sentence headline.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Legora partner mark","reason":"Partner named again in footer; second brand mark.","boxes":[[1027,61,14,32],[1062,61,74,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; the +5% block carries the point.","boxes":[[64,143,634,200]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a separate point from the result.","boxes":[[64,438,110,87],[454,438,56,87],[812,438,141,87],[64,531,93,25],[454,531,118,25],[812,531,156,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process flow diagram","reason":"Method pipeline cards are a second idea unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[64,613,483,18],[65,648,319,204],[441,648,319,204],[817,648,319,204],[106,675,31,40],[99,682,30,40],[852,684,37,37],[475,685,41,33],[96,739,156,34],[472,739,135,34],[848,739,191,34],[96,779,160,25],[472,779,161,25],[848,779,153,25],[96,805,172,25],[472,805,208,25],[848,805,155,25],[224,853,752,43],[414,881,372,30],[443,885,314,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer credit","reason":"Repeats brand and partner already shown.","boxes":[[64,1166,318,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention.","boxes":[[1036,1166,100,20]]}],"usd":0.16657,"sec":83,"out":3111,"cut":34,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-medium__simple","clutter":5.6,"shares":{"blue":94.4,"orange":0,"red":5.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":3,"words":20,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean three-step flow with one result and one logo; nothing needs removing and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Generic slogan that does not state the finding","boxes":[[64,103,687,72]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BAR and harness method cards","reason":"Process cards explain the method beside the result, a second point","boxes":[[119,268,95,105],[139,306,55,43],[140,575,13,20],[119,585,95,72],[183,611,13,20],[154,647,13,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative arrow icon","reason":"Decorative shape that adds no information","boxes":[[120,937,93,93]]}],"usd":0.13753,"sec":72,"out":2492,"cut":8,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":38.7,"shares":{"blue":58.2,"orange":6.3,"red":35.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.4},"score":5,"words":79,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under a slogan headline, a three-stage process diagram, dataset stats, a subtitle, an eyebrow tag and a footer; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[946,65,190,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,122,458,237]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates the topic; explains rather than shows.","boxes":[[67,368,505,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Source documents panel","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second idea unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[64,475,147,15],[64,784,28,30],[92,784,155,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BAR cases folder","reason":"Dataset size and benchmark-design card beside the result.","boxes":[[441,475,181,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Improvement loop","reason":"Process diagram is a method pipeline, not the result.","boxes":[[885,475,164,15],[894,551,8,8],[885,555,44,32],[914,567,8,8],[902,583,8,8],[885,605,181,50],[885,642,98,50],[885,698,139,26],[885,726,184,26]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result sentences","reason":"Wordy explanation of the +5%; could be a short label.","boxes":[[438,1017,496,60]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats the brands already shown in the logos.","boxes":[[64,1155,282,19],[1043,1155,93,19]]}],"usd":0.30892,"sec":136,"out":5958,"cut":18,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one before/after bar chart with a short title, +5% annotation and logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.29183,"sec":142,"out":5578,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra__raw","clutter":54.8,"shares":{"blue":45.2,"orange":0,"red":54.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.9},"score":7,"words":99,"missing":["baseline for +5%"],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under a stats row, a four-step process diagram and a footer tagline; the only gap is a bare +5% with no comparison.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[64,427,112,90],[452,427,58,90],[810,427,143,90],[64,512,99,25],[452,512,119,25],[810,512,159,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process flow cards","reason":"Pipeline cards are a second idea beside the result.","boxes":[[893,595,243,22],[64,597,386,17],[65,637,241,169],[342,637,241,169],[619,637,241,169],[896,637,240,169],[364,658,30,35],[87,661,30,34],[921,662,36,32],[645,664,30,28],[87,707,162,29],[364,707,114,29],[641,707,142,29],[918,707,168,29],[87,742,111,22],[364,742,162,22],[641,742,144,22],[918,742,115,22],[87,765,166,22],[364,765,147,22],[641,765,145,22],[918,765,150,22],[463,807,553,46],[565,839,347,28],[630,846,217,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline and repeated brand wordmark add nothing.","boxes":[[772,1135,364,20],[64,1137,172,15]]}],"usd":0.15877,"sec":66,"out":2955,"cut":36,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__astra__simple","clutter":0.9,"shares":{"blue":99.1,"orange":0,"red":0.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":65.1},"score":2,"words":17,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean, simple flow diagram that makes one point; only slightly redundant in its framing, and it lacks nothing essential.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Document icon","reason":"Decorative icon with no informational content.","boxes":[[161,228,80,97],[178,228,63,78]]}],"usd":0.13383,"sec":61,"out":2418,"cut":2,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":53.3,"shares":{"blue":32,"orange":29.4,"red":38.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30},"score":6,"words":102,"missing":[],"summary":"A giant headline, subtitle, side blurb, dot grid, spec list and footer crowd out the stats and the 5% result; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Legora wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark beside the AfterQuery logo","boxes":[[234,43,85,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the point.","boxes":[[972,48,164,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow above headline, repeats the BAR name.","boxes":[[81,132,260,14],[64,136,7,7]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Huge headline","reason":"Headline is oversized and far larger than the content needs.","boxes":[[59,133,448,223],[59,307,390,136]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explains what the headline and BAR already say.","boxes":[[64,433,492,57],[556,433,203,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Why it matters","reason":"Side blurb with a tagline, a second message.","boxes":[[885,449,97,13],[885,465,173,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Dot grid header","reason":"5,161 repeats the cases stat, with the dot index.","boxes":[[1022,537,62,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Benchmark spec list","reason":"Private-benchmark note and generic bullet list explain method details.","boxes":[[115,804,119,11],[102,808,4,4],[115,823,139,11],[102,827,4,4],[115,842,106,11],[102,846,4,4],[102,886,4,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats row","reason":"Dataset counts are a separate point from the main visual","boxes":[[64,919,114,90],[440,919,58,90],[798,919,145,90],[64,1000,36,12],[440,1000,101,12],[798,1000,115,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"5% product improvement block","reason":"Product result is a second idea unrelated to the benchmark visual","boxes":[[64,1030,102,131],[194,1057,86,12],[194,1077,464,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Product improvement tag","reason":"Category tag with an arrow, decorative.","boxes":[[1119,1053,17,33],[1064,1094,72,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[64,1171,86,15]]}],"usd":0.0199527,"sec":206,"out":33158,"cut":32,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":16.9,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":83.1,"paintedOfCanvas":41.6},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":["benchmark name"],"summary":"Clean and complete: one dot ring, one big number, a short label, one legend and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.01004805,"sec":94,"out":16419,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-max__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":39.9,"shares":{"blue":56,"orange":8.2,"red":35.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.8},"score":7,"words":108,"missing":[],"summary":"Too many competing blocks (stat row, dotted strip, build loop, impact card, date tag) bury any single main point; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Date tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[995,65,141,13],[980,67,5,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above the headline; restates the partnership.","boxes":[[79,147,155,14],[64,150,5,10]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Useful definition of BAR, but a full sentence that could be shorter.","boxes":[[64,377,771,61],[106,377,388,29],[64,409,109,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas and documents stats","reason":"Dataset-size stats are a second point beside the case chart.","boxes":[[608,496,101,12],[828,496,116,12],[608,549,102,143],[828,549,279,143]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Synthetic case note","reason":"Side detail unrelated to the main point.","boxes":[[79,803,741,19],[422,803,221,18],[64,809,5,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Build loop row","reason":"Process diagram is a second idea.","boxes":[[358,867,12,20],[633,867,12,20],[940,867,12,20],[78,872,94,11],[207,872,78,11],[456,872,104,11],[731,872,136,11],[1039,872,97,11],[64,873,5,9],[194,875,5,5],[443,875,5,5],[718,875,5,5],[1026,875,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"5% measured impact card","reason":"Separate result card; second claim, and the footer wordmark repeats the brand.","boxes":[[96,937,152,217],[110,940,109,12],[96,942,5,9],[481,1005,192,12],[481,1026,528,60],[721,1057,244,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"URL and arrow badge","reason":"Footer URL and decorative arrow add nothing needed.","boxes":[[1006,940,98,12],[1083,1042,8,9]]}],"usd":0.0376683,"sec":402,"out":62684,"cut":39,"shrunk":3},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-max__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.9},"score":1,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with a +5% annotation, a metric label, a logo and a small footnote.","marks":[],"usd":0.04998585,"sec":578,"out":82982,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":43,"shares":{"blue":57,"orange":0,"red":43,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36},"score":6,"words":122,"missing":[],"summary":"The benchmark stats panel is the main visual, but a slogan headline, eyebrows, captions, a second +5% impact section and a footer clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Tag and date badge tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[903,44,109,14],[1023,44,8,14],[1044,44,92,14],[884,47,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline.","boxes":[[104,154,159,14],[64,160,28,2]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates what the benchmark does; the panel already names it.","boxes":[[64,384,354,23],[64,385,696,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory captions","reason":"Captions explain and restate the stats; small paragraphs.","boxes":[[830,498,276,13],[750,724,177,29],[94,727,369,39],[750,771,180,41],[750,782,167,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas and documents side panel","reason":"Practice-area grid and document count serve a second point, not the 5,161 cases.","boxes":[[1054,515,54,86],[750,535,56,27],[750,566,16,18],[771,566,16,18],[792,566,16,18],[813,566,16,18],[834,566,16,18],[855,566,16,18],[876,566,16,18],[750,589,16,18],[771,589,16,18],[792,589,16,18],[813,589,16,18],[834,589,16,18],[855,589,16,18],[876,589,16,18],[750,612,16,18],[771,612,16,18],[792,612,16,18],[813,612,16,18],[834,612,16,18],[855,612,16,18],[876,612,16,18],[750,635,16,18],[771,635,16,18],[792,635,16,18],[813,635,16,18],[834,635,16,18],[855,635,16,18],[876,635,16,18],[975,664,133,86],[750,684,63,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Measured impact row","reason":"Second point about harness improvement, repeated in stat, text and sparkline.","boxes":[[64,917,106,174],[64,931,115,13],[396,957,441,47],[1056,965,8,8],[942,969,118,46],[396,982,153,22],[175,995,35,68],[1046,1017,14,8],[396,1018,272,12],[1046,1025,14,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mark and contact line repeat the logo.","boxes":[[85,1153,230,12],[64,1155,9,9]]}],"usd":0.0060417,"sec":56,"out":9973,"cut":63,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":42.7,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":57.3,"paintedOfCanvas":41.9},"score":1,"words":3,"missing":["benchmark name (BAR)"],"summary":"Clean single-stat graphic with a dot grid and a logo, but it never names the benchmark (BAR) the 5,161 cases belong to.","marks":[],"usd":0.006248849999999999,"sec":46,"out":10087,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":59,"shares":{"blue":22.6,"orange":36.8,"red":40.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35},"score":6,"words":96,"missing":[],"summary":"The 5,161-case figure is a clean main visual, but the stats panel, product impact card, decorative pyramid and tags are extras, and the headline is oversized.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header and eyebrow tags","reason":"Date, kicker and category tags add nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[873,64,263,13],[81,137,397,14],[64,141,7,7]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Oversized headline","reason":"Three-line 78px headline is too large; shorten or shrink it.","boxes":[[64,150,560,197],[64,302,389,121]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative pyramid","reason":"Decorative shape with no information.","boxes":[[1085,150,15,44],[1079,162,15,40],[1074,171,31,43],[1069,180,14,39],[1063,191,52,41],[1059,202,15,26],[1108,202,14,30],[1055,212,15,20],[1112,212,16,20],[1042,222,34,10],[1108,222,30,10]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Two-line subtitle","reason":"Names the benchmark but runs two lines; shorten to the name.","boxes":[[64,421,782,57]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats panel","reason":"Practice areas and documents counts serve a second point, not the main figure.","boxes":[[834,480,88,143],[942,528,9,9],[956,528,9,9],[970,528,9,9],[984,528,9,9],[998,528,9,9],[1012,528,9,9],[1026,528,9,9],[942,542,9,9],[956,542,9,9],[970,542,9,9],[984,542,9,9],[998,542,9,9],[1012,542,9,9],[1026,542,9,9],[942,556,9,9],[956,556,9,9],[970,556,9,9],[984,556,9,9],[998,556,9,9],[1012,556,9,9],[1026,556,9,9],[942,570,9,9],[956,570,9,9],[970,570,9,9],[984,570,9,9],[998,570,9,9],[1012,570,9,9],[1026,570,9,9],[834,600,93,20],[834,641,162,108],[1019,666,52,64],[1054,666,17,17],[1026,692,37,30],[834,741,123,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explaining what the cases contain; not needed to read the number.","boxes":[[64,722,658,44]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Product impact card","reason":"Separate product-impact result; a second point beside the benchmark figure.","boxes":[[123,859,152,196],[100,887,113,13],[555,891,484,92],[100,911,21,51],[100,1021,188,22],[1090,1043,6,6],[944,1046,149,26],[555,1053,185,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand already shown by the header logo.","boxes":[[64,1142,147,13]]}],"usd":0.0115383,"sec":103,"out":19134,"cut":61,"shrunk":3},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean unit chart with a short stat headline, logo and legend; only the benchmark name is missing.","marks":[],"usd":0.01048905,"sec":142,"out":17154,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek__raw","clutter":63.9,"shares":{"blue":24.9,"orange":22.3,"red":52.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.2},"score":7,"words":132,"missing":[],"summary":"Many competing stats, cards, paragraphs and a slogan headline bury any single main visual; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta","reason":"Partner tag and date add nothing to the point.","boxes":[[875,59,138,12],[1049,59,87,12],[1030,64,3,3]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Huge slogan-like headline that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[60,135,375,150],[124,223,614,150]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas card","reason":"Side stat card with decorative squares, a secondary stat.","boxes":[[1057,153,58,94],[827,183,97,25],[827,266,16,17],[848,266,16,17],[869,266,16,17],[890,266,16,17],[911,266,16,17],[932,266,16,17],[953,266,16,17],[974,266,16,17],[994,266,16,17],[1015,266,16,17],[1036,266,16,17],[1057,266,16,17],[1078,266,16,17],[1099,266,16,17],[827,288,16,17],[848,288,16,17],[869,288,16,17],[890,288,16,17],[911,288,16,17],[932,288,16,17],[953,288,16,17],[974,288,16,17],[994,288,16,17],[1015,288,16,17],[1036,288,16,17],[1057,288,16,17],[1078,288,16,17],[1099,288,16,17],[827,346,118,11],[1063,346,52,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explaining the benchmark.","boxes":[[66,378,36,23],[66,379,555,75]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Right stat column","reason":"Source docs, synthetic case, publicly released: secondary stats and icons.","boxes":[[811,501,116,12],[811,505,143,95],[1099,531,37,42],[811,629,116,27],[811,647,22,95],[1100,674,35,40],[1107,685,21,10],[1120,698,10,10],[1123,702,5,3],[811,771,124,12],[811,775,22,95],[1102,807,31,31],[1112,814,11,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Cases caption row","reason":"Repeats 5,161 and 28 shown elsewhere.","boxes":[[64,761,40,13],[104,761,48,13],[522,761,192,13],[578,761,16,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task design quote","reason":"Method explanation unrelated to the main stat.","boxes":[[90,790,80,12],[90,810,590,101],[323,810,90,38],[90,841,138,38],[513,841,101,38]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Product impact banner","reason":"Second claim about product improvement; unrelated to reading the case count.","boxes":[[92,990,95,12],[89,1009,158,143]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Impact banner text","reason":"Restates +5% in sentences and slogan.","boxes":[[373,982,453,78],[373,1063,618,36],[387,1063,62,17],[812,1063,18,17],[921,1108,187,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline.","boxes":[[64,1161,216,11]]}],"usd":0.010337699999999998,"sec":77,"out":17133,"cut":74,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__deepseek__simple","clutter":0.6,"shares":{"blue":99.4,"orange":0,"red":0.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38},"score":1,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Mostly clean: a big case count and a dot grid; only the secondary stats line and a stray shape are extra.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative shape","reason":"Small unlabeled shape near the top left with no meaning.","boxes":[[76,62,130,22]]}],"usd":0.01997265,"sec":335,"out":32960,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":85.7,"shares":{"blue":14.3,"orange":0,"red":85.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.8},"score":8,"words":426,"missing":[],"summary":"The four stats are the core, but the large pipeline diagram, feedback banner, header pills, subtitle and footer bury them.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tags and byline","reason":"Pills, badges, date and authors tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[732,39,153,21],[893,39,103,21],[1005,39,153,21],[587,43,128,13],[741,43,135,13],[902,43,85,13],[1014,43,135,13],[577,47,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[55,84,300,13],[42,88,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the benchmark in a sentence.","boxes":[[42,154,771,41]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Version badge and link","reason":"Badge and URL are decorative extras.","boxes":[[1013,157,145,23],[1022,162,127,13],[1067,183,91,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Four stat cards on dataset size and the +5% result, a second block beside the main diagram.","boxes":[[61,284,112,12],[244,284,49,12],[343,284,98,12],[498,284,77,12],[625,284,126,12],[815,284,42,12],[343,289,46,72],[61,292,89,72],[625,292,114,72],[843,326,13,14],[840,329,13,15],[539,339,3,3],[545,339,3,3],[550,339,3,3],[556,339,3,3],[561,339,3,3],[567,339,3,3],[572,339,3,3],[274,343,14,2],[539,344,3,3],[545,344,3,3],[550,344,3,3],[556,344,3,3],[561,344,3,3],[567,344,3,3],[572,344,3,3],[270,347,22,2],[539,350,3,3],[545,350,3,3],[550,350,3,3],[556,350,3,3],[561,350,3,3],[567,350,3,3],[572,350,3,3],[272,351,18,2],[539,355,3,3],[545,355,3,3],[550,355,3,3],[556,355,3,3],[561,355,3,3],[567,355,3,3],[572,355,3,3],[61,357,98,17],[625,357,113,17],[343,360,86,17],[61,379,216,44],[343,379,230,44],[625,379,222,44]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline diagram","reason":"Large second idea: process cards that repeat counts and add extras.","boxes":[[63,530,349,31],[280,534,13,26],[422,536,201,19],[430,539,185,13],[702,539,435,13],[78,598,57,12],[443,598,57,12],[821,598,57,12],[78,608,176,26],[443,608,191,26],[821,608,190,26],[115,611,11,22],[879,611,11,22],[695,657,51,15],[306,658,62,15],[454,658,125,14],[1032,658,79,15],[89,659,93,14],[701,659,39,11],[832,659,135,14],[312,660,50,11],[1038,660,67,11],[454,674,268,42],[89,675,273,42],[832,675,272,42],[695,741,51,15],[300,742,68,15],[454,742,121,14],[1049,742,62,15],[89,743,95,14],[701,743,39,11],[832,743,143,14],[306,744,56,11],[1055,744,50,11],[454,758,284,42],[89,759,279,28],[832,759,249,42],[409,760,4,7],[787,760,4,7],[88,811,111,14],[326,812,43,13],[331,813,33,11],[1056,823,57,15],[831,824,99,13],[673,825,73,15],[1062,825,45,11],[88,826,277,40],[454,826,116,14],[679,827,61,11],[831,838,273,27],[454,842,277,42],[1045,883,68,15],[831,884,86,13],[1051,885,56,11],[831,898,253,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Feedback loop banner","reason":"Repeats +5% in one month with explanatory text.","boxes":[[96,970,223,12],[733,971,59,50],[81,972,9,9],[86,974,2,4],[80,982,448,26],[940,983,159,42],[997,983,37,13],[80,1009,586,30],[733,1014,80,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second wordmark, tagline and contact repeat brand.","boxes":[[42,1139,72,23],[124,1143,5,15],[138,1143,434,15]]}],"usd":0.22730482500000002,"sec":452,"out":54868,"cut":156,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.9},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a short metric title, one logo, and a labelled before/after bar with a +5% annotation; the only gap is that the benchmark is not named on the graphic.","marks":[],"usd":0.369077775,"sec":799,"out":89198,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":85.9,"shares":{"blue":6.9,"orange":14.5,"red":78.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.3},"score":8,"words":332,"missing":[],"summary":"A dense report page with a large process diagram, repeated stat cards and badges buries the single +5% result, though the key number is present.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tags","reason":"Tagline and report pill badge add nothing.","boxes":[[229,57,195,13],[843,57,142,13],[994,57,7,13],[1012,57,119,13],[826,60,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tags","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[178,119,403,13]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Title is long and does not state the finding.","boxes":[[54,137,683,124]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates, with 5,161 repeated.","boxes":[[54,264,915,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stat cards","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a different point; repeated in phase text.","boxes":[[75,341,86,68],[352,341,44,68],[629,341,110,68],[1110,381,6,6],[75,405,110,13],[352,405,103,13],[629,405,117,13],[75,446,177,32],[352,446,206,32],[629,446,196,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated +5% stat card","reason":"The +5% gain is already shown in the comparison chart and footer.","boxes":[[906,341,79,68],[906,405,161,13],[906,430,188,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process architecture panel","reason":"Large process diagram, text-heavy, and repeats stats; unrelated to results.","boxes":[[103,541,393,14],[81,542,4,4],[88,542,4,4],[708,542,413,12],[81,549,4,4],[88,549,4,4],[96,603,56,12],[453,603,56,12],[809,603,56,12],[327,604,63,11],[684,604,63,11],[1015,604,89,11],[96,634,157,18],[453,634,189,18],[809,634,178,18],[843,679,168,15],[825,684,11,5],[833,684,3,3],[824,699,255,47],[130,706,163,15],[487,706,195,15],[113,708,9,11],[119,708,3,3],[469,708,11,8],[111,726,256,63],[468,726,253,63],[422,819,5,11],[778,819,5,11],[130,869,176,15],[113,872,10,10],[116,873,7,5],[487,879,131,15],[843,880,145,15],[469,881,11,11],[825,884,12,9],[829,886,3,3],[123,894,213,30],[123,894,97,14],[824,901,254,63],[915,901,170,14],[480,904,237,30],[480,904,83,14],[123,929,72,14],[195,929,177,15],[480,939,237,30],[480,939,101,14],[123,949,223,30],[123,949,96,14],[822,1027,87,12],[1004,1027,87,12],[108,1028,105,12],[311,1028,68,12],[465,1028,93,12],[630,1028,105,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Second brand mark and company tagline.","boxes":[[81,1133,559,16],[54,1134,15,15]]}],"usd":0.246535575,"sec":504,"out":59530,"cut":100,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.4},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with a title, labels, a +5% annotation and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.30470715000000004,"sec":603,"out":73593,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":78.4,"shares":{"blue":21.6,"orange":0,"red":78.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.8},"score":8,"words":280,"missing":[],"summary":"A small bar chart is buried among stat cards, process cards, callouts, quote and footer, and the chart's baseline and metric are vague.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header pills and date","reason":"Badges, partnership pill and metadata add nothing to the point.","boxes":[[284,64,186,15],[1018,64,8,15],[1040,64,96,15],[270,68,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[81,133,496,15],[64,135,8,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating the post.","boxes":[[64,219,944,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards row","reason":"Dataset size stats; +5% card repeats the chart.","boxes":[[85,310,131,13],[284,310,15,13],[357,310,108,13],[556,310,15,13],[629,310,123,13],[828,310,15,13],[901,310,92,13],[1100,310,15,13],[85,325,131,58],[357,325,52,58],[629,325,157,58],[901,325,79,58],[85,385,204,33],[357,385,196,33],[629,385,205,33],[901,385,193,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Architecture panel","reason":"Process cards unrelated to the results chart.","boxes":[[89,484,339,33],[452,498,186,13],[104,561,30,30],[150,561,188,18],[112,569,15,14],[150,582,461,34],[104,654,30,30],[150,654,185,18],[112,662,15,14],[150,675,446,34],[104,747,30,30],[150,747,223,18],[112,755,15,14],[150,768,448,34],[104,840,30,30],[150,840,188,18],[112,848,15,14],[150,861,450,34]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Production Impact panel header","reason":"Section title and tag framing the chart; decorative","boxes":[[707,484,164,33],[1007,498,104,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+5% callout","reason":"Restates the bar chart result.","boxes":[[728,572,86,63],[823,609,80,15],[728,636,324,34]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Open synthetic case","reason":"Separate side point.","boxes":[[736,914,142,13],[724,918,5,5],[724,931,369,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Pull quote","reason":"Quote restates the post.","boxes":[[707,1007,404,59],[724,1019,370,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Boilerplate and repeated brand.","boxes":[[64,1135,64,15],[128,1135,522,16]]}],"usd":0.09098595,"sec":202,"out":21821,"cut":68,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.8},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, a single logo, a +5% change callout, and labelled bars.","marks":[],"usd":0.0455334,"sec":170,"out":10763,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-high__raw","clutter":42.4,"shares":{"blue":49.3,"orange":16.5,"red":34.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34},"score":5,"words":77,"missing":[],"summary":"A stats row, a second logo, a byline, an eyebrow and a synthetic-case footer crowd the single +5% result; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date byline","reason":"Metadata about the post, not needed to read the graphic.","boxes":[[760,63,368,15],[805,63,9,15],[939,63,9,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Partnership eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline.","boxes":[[72,136,7,16],[91,137,256,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"BAR description sentence","reason":"Useful definition of BAR but a wordy sentence; shorten.","boxes":[[72,369,802,69]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second point unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[72,532,7,16],[468,532,7,16],[783,532,7,16],[72,538,149,119],[468,538,76,119],[783,538,190,119],[72,647,48,15],[468,647,134,15],[783,647,154,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Second logo","reason":"Brand shown a second time.","boxes":[[980,834,148,120]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result sentence","reason":"Explains the stat in a full sentence; could be shortened.","boxes":[[72,932,471,88]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Synthetic case note","reason":"Separate point about a published case, unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[72,1068,22,87],[130,1085,708,53]]}],"usd":0.202586,"sec":464,"out":33390,"cut":21,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":16.9},"score":0,"words":6,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: two large stat panels with short labels, a logo, and the benchmark name.","marks":[],"usd":0.319322,"sec":973,"out":52781,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-medium__raw","clutter":64.4,"shares":{"blue":17.7,"orange":35.8,"red":46.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.3},"score":6,"words":93,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic is a stat poster with several competing ideas: a method row, a synthetic-case card, a subtitle and a tag. It has no single main visual, but it is not missing key information.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above the headline; restates the benchmark name.","boxes":[[122,150,314,15],[72,157,36,2]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline block","reason":"Sentence-like headline at 92px, plus eyebrow and partner line; could be shorter.","boxes":[[72,157,669,228]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle and description","reason":"Partner line and paragraph explain the post rather than the chart.","boxes":[[72,384,293,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining the benchmark; the headline already names it.","boxes":[[72,428,712,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task spec row","reason":"Method description is a second idea unrelated to the stats.","boxes":[[72,564,173,14],[72,577,88,27],[484,577,130,27],[764,577,98,27],[72,610,156,21],[484,610,125,21],[764,610,110,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats row","reason":"Case, practice area and document counts are a separate dataset point.","boxes":[[72,712,138,112],[485,712,71,112],[765,712,176,112],[72,813,48,15],[485,813,134,15],[765,813,154,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Synthetic case card","reason":"A separate point about a published case, unrelated to the 5% result.","boxes":[[737,932,24,100],[737,1021,324,30],[737,1062,359,46]]}],"usd":0.129584,"sec":308,"out":21223,"cut":24,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-medium__simple","clutter":5.2,"shares":{"blue":94.8,"orange":0,"red":5.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":3,"words":8,"missing":["benchmark name"],"summary":"The graphic adds two secondary dataset-size stats to the main case count, and it never names the benchmark or says it is legal.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas stat","reason":"Secondary dataset-size stat that is not the main point.","boxes":[[68,916,113,169],[72,1067,164,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Source documents stat","reason":"Secondary dataset-size stat that is not the main point.","boxes":[[849,916,283,169],[917,1067,215,32]]}],"usd":0.072056,"sec":187,"out":11570,"cut":4,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":57.4,"shares":{"blue":25.4,"orange":34.5,"red":40.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.9},"score":6,"words":82,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under a long headline, subtitle, dataset stats row, side claims, metadata and a duplicate logo; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date byline","reason":"Date and authors are metadata, not needed to read the graphic.","boxes":[[966,61,158,15],[998,78,126,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Long sentence-style headline at huge size; could be short title.","boxes":[[76,154,604,209],[76,350,443,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explainer subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining the benchmark, restating the post.","boxes":[[76,428,675,58]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second point unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[76,532,126,100],[454,532,64,100],[804,532,160,100],[76,626,46,23],[454,626,113,23],[804,626,149,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Side claims","reason":"Extra ideas: synthetic case and failure diagnosis, unrelated to main result.","boxes":[[76,706,522,22],[76,736,579,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Second logo mark","reason":"Brand shown a second time as large decorative logo.","boxes":[[914,910,210,171]]}],"usd":0.410228,"sec":1119,"out":67997,"cut":15,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":1,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: three large stats with unit labels and the BAR name, though the AfterQuery logo and divider rules are visible but not in the element list.","marks":[],"usd":0.301178,"sec":862,"out":49757,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok__raw","clutter":50.9,"shares":{"blue":46,"orange":6.1,"red":47.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30},"score":6,"words":76,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is one of several competing stat cards, with a stats row, a '1' card, eyebrow and subtitle as extras, and the empty cards waste space.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag does not help read the graphic.","boxes":[[972,35,180,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline.","boxes":[[56,136,257,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory paragraph restating the post; BAR named in the footer.","boxes":[[56,260,894,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[85,365,138,112],[495,365,71,112],[779,365,176,112],[85,506,63,23],[495,506,161,23],[779,506,206,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Synthetic case card","reason":"Second idea: a single published case, not the main result.","boxes":[[89,573,33,138],[89,978,409,88]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result sentence","reason":"Sentence could be shortened to a label such as 'output quality'.","boxes":[[604,1008,437,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Website footer","reason":"Brand repeated; the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1038,1158,106,21]]}],"usd":0.036206,"sec":104,"out":5660,"cut":16,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.1},"score":1,"words":8,"missing":["benchmark name","what the numbers describe"],"summary":"The graphic is only three oversized dataset-size stats with no main visual or benchmark name, so it is cluttered by extras and doesn't say what BAR is.","marks":[],"usd":0.068204,"sec":191,"out":10928,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-high__raw","clutter":60.1,"shares":{"blue":19.8,"orange":40.2,"red":40,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.4},"score":6,"words":70,"missing":[],"summary":"A sentence headline, subtitle, date tag and a large dataset-stats grid crowd the one 5% result; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[910,95,210,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker line","reason":"Kicker above headline; benchmark name is repeated in the subtitle context.","boxes":[[80,217,437,19]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence blog title at 80px; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[80,238,792,288]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explains what the benchmark is, restating the title.","boxes":[[80,526,822,84]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats grid","reason":"Dataset size stats are a second idea unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[80,633,287,234],[628,653,83,131],[997,729,123,26],[628,760,205,131],[80,836,246,30],[958,836,162,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Synthetic case footnote","reason":"Release note about a published case; not needed to read the main stat.","boxes":[[80,1102,485,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already present.","boxes":[[969,1102,151,18]]}],"usd":0.009335600000000001,"sec":106,"out":18320,"cut":14,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":70.3},"score":1,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; the +5% could be read as a share of something, but the caption clarifies it.","marks":[],"usd":0.0054997,"sec":67,"out":10594,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":48.5,"shares":{"blue":48.5,"orange":5.8,"red":45.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.7},"score":7,"words":110,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under a big headline, dataset stats, a meaningless square grid and a four-step process row; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag, tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[879,72,249,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates what the benchmark is.","boxes":[[72,453,834,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats are a second idea beside the result.","boxes":[[72,544,251,199],[392,544,128,199],[712,544,320,199],[72,722,208,26],[392,722,200,26],[712,722,164,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Colored square grid","reason":"Decorative grid with no legend or meaning.","boxes":[[72,812,26,26],[110,812,26,26],[148,812,26,26],[186,812,26,26],[224,812,26,26],[262,812,26,26],[300,812,26,26],[72,850,26,26],[110,850,26,26],[148,850,26,26],[186,850,26,26],[224,850,26,26],[262,850,26,26],[300,850,26,26],[72,888,26,26],[110,888,26,26],[148,888,26,26],[186,888,26,26],[224,888,26,26],[262,888,26,26],[300,888,26,26],[72,926,26,26],[110,926,26,26],[148,926,26,26],[186,926,26,26],[224,926,26,26],[262,926,26,26],[300,926,26,26]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"+5% caption","reason":"Needed to say what 5% measures, but should be shortened to a few words.","boxes":[[640,926,434,80]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Four-step process","reason":"Process cards are a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[72,1036,17,18],[341,1036,20,18],[609,1036,20,18],[878,1036,21,18],[72,1060,64,27],[341,1060,50,27],[609,1060,79,27],[878,1060,80,27],[72,1091,236,43],[341,1091,228,43],[609,1091,218,43],[878,1091,222,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1024,1150,104,20]]}],"usd":0.0055306,"sec":77,"out":10710,"cut":49,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.1},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-after bar chart with a metric subtitle, value label and logo, with nothing extra to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0041646999999999995,"sec":57,"out":7924,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":31.8,"shares":{"blue":68.2,"orange":0,"red":31.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":55.1},"score":6,"words":71,"missing":[],"summary":"A dot-grid main visual is surrounded by a decorative logo, subtitle, date and a black stats band of extras; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[948,68,180,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative logo mark","reason":"Large decorative shape, duplicates brand logo.","boxes":[[892,202,236,192]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining what BAR is; restates post.","boxes":[[72,425,996,70]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Synthetic case note","reason":"Side fact unrelated to the dot grid's point.","boxes":[[587,529,541,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Benchmark-in-numbers stats footer","reason":"Stats row adds dataset sizes and a separate 5% harness claim.","boxes":[[72,963,228,17],[72,991,137,106],[72,1092,104,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention.","boxes":[[995,963,133,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas and documents stats","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to main visual.","boxes":[[337,991,70,106],[577,991,174,106],[337,1092,112,23],[577,1092,148,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Output quality stat","reason":"Second claim about product improvement, separate from benchmark size.","boxes":[[817,991,124,106],[817,1092,267,46]]}],"usd":0.0003816,"sec":952,"out":412,"cut":18,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":62},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: two bars, a +5% annotation, a metric label and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0109417,"sec":129,"out":21478,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku__raw","clutter":32.6,"shares":{"blue":58.5,"orange":17.8,"red":23.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.6},"score":6,"words":77,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic is a text-heavy stat poster with no clear main visual. The intro paragraph, the +5% stat, the decorative cell grid and the footer brand add clutter. It lacks nothing essential.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[871,88,237,22]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Names the benchmark, but as a long two-line paragraph; shorten to the name.","boxes":[[92,420,851,114],[92,420,754,73]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"+5% stat","reason":"Second claim about product improvement, unrelated to the benchmark scale.","boxes":[[881,729,205,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Practice area grid","reason":"Decorative grid and caption repeat the 28 practice areas stat.","boxes":[[548,853,68,40],[630,853,68,40],[712,853,68,40],[794,853,68,40],[876,853,68,40],[958,853,68,40],[1040,853,68,40],[548,907,68,40],[630,907,68,40],[712,907,68,40],[794,907,68,40],[876,907,68,40],[958,907,68,40],[1040,907,68,40],[548,960,68,40],[630,960,68,40],[712,960,68,40],[794,960,68,40],[876,960,68,40],[958,960,68,40],[1040,960,68,40],[92,970,227,26],[92,1005,314,47],[548,1014,68,40],[630,1014,68,40],[712,1014,68,40],[794,1014,68,40],[876,1014,68,40],[958,1014,68,40],[1040,1014,68,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline.","boxes":[[92,1093,243,21],[173,1093,13,21]]}],"usd":0.0044606,"sec":47,"out":8570,"cut":34,"shrunk":2},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":61.7},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one large +5% stat, a caption naming the metric and cause, and one logo; only 'BAR' is unexpanded, which the caption does not need to explain for the point to land.","marks":[],"usd":0.0019952,"sec":27,"out":3585,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-high__raw","clutter":68.8,"shares":{"blue":31.2,"orange":0,"red":68.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.5},"score":7,"words":125,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is a small part of a canvas filled with process cards, dataset stats, taglines and repeated branding; the information is mostly complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note tag","reason":"Category tag with decorative square.","boxes":[[928,57,206,15],[908,61,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline adds nothing.","boxes":[[66,145,396,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Question headline","reason":"Slogan question, does not state the finding.","boxes":[[66,158,335,173]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory tagline restating the post.","boxes":[[66,330,587,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process pipeline","reason":"Method cards, a second idea beside the result.","boxes":[[66,417,180,15],[631,417,159,16],[153,540,68,78],[199,540,22,23],[390,541,77,76],[628,547,77,68],[399,553,57,27],[641,563,44,10],[407,565,41,6],[166,577,41,22],[642,584,14,11],[420,587,16,16],[422,589,12,12],[642,591,48,18],[148,653,82,19],[389,653,77,19],[619,653,95,19],[117,676,145,16],[361,676,134,16],[602,676,128,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"BAR takeaway sentence","reason":"Takeaway sentence, repeats the card's idea.","boxes":[[851,761,270,84],[1044,786,55,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[66,792,77,65],[313,792,40,65],[559,792,99,65],[66,851,41,15],[313,851,106,15],[559,851,134,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Review loop","reason":"Separate process point.","boxes":[[546,900,244,30],[647,900,16,30],[66,909,144,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer partnership","reason":"Second brand mark and tagline.","boxes":[[64,1080,36,36],[71,1088,22,21],[114,1089,184,17],[298,1089,348,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand repeated.","boxes":[[982,1082,152,32]]}],"usd":0.0038196999999999997,"sec":70,"out":7419,"cut":48,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.8},"score":1,"words":8,"missing":["what BAR is"],"summary":"Clean and focused on the 5% loop; only missing a brief explanation of what BAR is.","marks":[],"usd":0.0028823,"sec":69,"out":5506,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-medium__raw","clutter":79.3,"shares":{"blue":20.7,"orange":0,"red":79.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26},"score":6,"words":57,"missing":[],"summary":"A slogan headline, subtitle, decorative illustration, dataset stats row and repeated footer crowd out the single +5% result; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[907,63,225,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state a finding.","boxes":[[68,197,373,248]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Document illustration","reason":"Decorative card stack and process timeline, a second idea.","boxes":[[706,211,305,218],[730,233,305,218],[754,255,305,218],[779,280,104,10],[779,306,252,5],[779,323,226,5],[779,340,244,5],[784,387,18,18],[789,392,9,7],[811,393,119,6],[720,498,14,14],[877,498,14,14],[1034,498,14,14],[701,521,53,18],[845,521,78,18],[1019,521,45,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating what the benchmark is.","boxes":[[68,457,454,88]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats are a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[68,625,98,65],[452,625,57,65],[806,625,126,65],[68,692,43,22],[452,692,106,22],[806,692,139,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer benchmark name","reason":"Benchmark name repeated from the eyebrow.","boxes":[[922,1131,210,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark; logo already present.","boxes":[[68,1132,178,18]]}],"usd":0.0014667,"sec":37,"out":2713,"cut":30,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24},"score":1,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete, with only a minor ambiguity over what the 28 tiles represent and no clutter to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0021733,"sec":58,"out":4088,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":86.7,"shares":{"blue":13.3,"orange":0,"red":86.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.3},"score":8,"words":133,"missing":[],"summary":"Main result (5% quality gain) is buried under a slogan headline, process cards, a stats row, tags and duplicate footers; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note tag","reason":"Category tag with dot; tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[848,74,272,13],[829,77,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[80,153,317,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[80,164,530,194]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Sentence and paragraph restating what BAR is.","boxes":[[835,230,268,96],[835,332,259,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process cards","reason":"Three-step method cards are a second idea beside the results.","boxes":[[80,454,197,12],[365,511,12,25],[727,511,10,25],[1086,511,11,25],[103,518,109,12],[463,518,73,12],[823,518,95,12],[172,560,111,105],[151,562,28,28],[541,562,121,105],[643,562,19,20],[885,564,153,103],[265,566,20,6],[194,569,111,105],[161,572,8,8],[901,576,83,10],[189,581,74,33],[211,590,75,33],[557,590,48,10],[901,605,10,10],[557,607,79,8],[903,607,6,5],[642,618,42,42],[901,621,10,10],[903,623,6,5],[192,629,73,19],[429,630,6,10],[789,630,6,10],[654,632,18,13],[402,633,4,4],[762,633,4,4],[901,637,10,10],[595,638,8,5],[903,639,6,5],[557,649,84,7],[557,649,56,7],[1003,649,22,18],[1009,653,10,10],[103,683,130,39],[463,683,120,39],[823,683,181,39],[103,723,244,36],[463,723,237,36],[823,723,242,36]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[80,833,74,61],[435,833,38,61],[791,833,94,61],[900,848,60,30],[169,855,31,16],[488,855,75,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Callout explainer text","reason":"Eyebrow and sentence restate the headline and the chart.","boxes":[[329,990,243,12],[329,1043,512,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer partner wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark repeating AfterQuery.","boxes":[[1003,1136,117,18],[1070,1136,7,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer benchmark name","reason":"Benchmark name already shown near top.","boxes":[[80,1139,229,12]]}],"usd":0.0051162,"sec":101,"out":10012,"cut":65,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":50.3},"score":1,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a single stat with a simple trend line; only the benchmark name (BAR) is implied rather than spelled out, and the start and end points carry no values.","marks":[],"usd":0.0051198,"sec":116,"out":9981,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna__raw","clutter":80.3,"shares":{"blue":19.7,"orange":0,"red":80.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.3},"score":7,"words":126,"missing":[],"summary":"A results banner and case count are buried under a pipeline diagram, a stats row, tags, a subtitle and footers; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[969,67,161,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Question headline","reason":"Slogan-style question, not a stated finding.","boxes":[[70,198,429,140]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Headline stat card","reason":"Dataset-size stat beside the main flow, serves a second point.","boxes":[[856,304,116,12],[856,325,99,56],[856,384,137,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restates the benchmark.","boxes":[[70,358,657,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a secondary idea.","boxes":[[70,474,41,43],[448,474,96,43],[802,474,15,43],[70,522,85,15],[448,522,110,15],[802,522,248,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline cards","reason":"Method process diagram is a separate idea from results.","boxes":[[70,588,375,31],[460,598,201,12],[111,716,27,27],[458,716,27,27],[806,716,27,27],[118,723,13,14],[465,723,13,14],[812,723,13,14],[334,724,61,11],[673,724,69,11],[1015,724,74,11],[111,758,157,26],[458,758,175,26],[806,758,204,26],[111,794,232,33],[458,794,260,33],[806,794,259,33],[111,882,93,4],[210,882,65,4],[282,882,42,4],[458,882,93,4],[558,882,65,4],[629,882,42,4],[806,882,94,4],[905,882,65,4],[976,882,43,4],[260,889,681,33],[597,919,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline adds nothing.","boxes":[[70,1150,270,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Brand repeated again in footer.","boxes":[[980,1150,150,12],[966,1154,5,5]]}],"usd":0.0017737,"sec":37,"out":3327,"cut":50,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__luna__simple","clutter":5.4,"shares":{"blue":90.3,"orange":8.4,"red":1.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.1},"score":2,"words":24,"missing":["meaning of grid marks"],"summary":"Mostly clean; headline is a wordy sentence and the bottom subtitle is redundant, while the grid is somewhat ambiguous but labelled.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence slogan-like headline; could be shorter, e.g. 'BAR: legal agent benchmark'.","boxes":[[76,216,733,67]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle line","reason":"Restates headline and benchmark; explains nothing new.","boxes":[[76,954,301,20]]}],"usd":0.0018472999999999999,"sec":78,"out":3436,"cut":1,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-high__raw","clutter":48.7,"shares":{"blue":47.7,"orange":7.3,"red":45,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.4},"score":7,"words":134,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is a small part of a canvas filled with a stats row, process steps, a subtitle, an eyebrow tag and a footer.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag, tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[824,69,304,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Names the benchmark usefully but runs two lines and restates the headline.","boxes":[[72,339,720,70]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating the post intro.","boxes":[[118,339,441,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second point unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[104,491,44,15],[457,491,123,15],[809,491,141,15],[104,500,165,131],[457,500,84,131],[809,500,210,131],[104,620,210,44],[809,620,265,44],[457,628,5,22],[468,628,5,22],[478,628,5,22],[489,628,5,22],[499,628,5,22],[510,628,5,22],[521,628,5,22],[531,628,5,22],[542,628,5,22],[552,628,5,22],[563,628,5,22],[574,628,5,22],[584,628,5,22],[595,628,5,22],[605,628,5,22],[616,628,5,22],[627,628,5,22],[637,628,5,22],[648,628,5,22],[658,628,5,22],[669,628,5,22],[680,628,5,22],[690,628,5,22],[701,628,5,22],[711,628,5,22],[722,628,5,22],[733,628,5,22],[743,628,5,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process steps panel","reason":"Four-step process card is a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[104,739,220,15],[156,792,204,23],[105,801,28,28],[112,808,15,14],[156,816,358,20],[156,854,209,23],[105,863,28,28],[112,870,15,14],[156,878,244,20],[156,916,242,23],[105,925,28,28],[112,932,15,14],[156,940,378,20],[156,978,141,23],[105,987,28,28],[112,994,15,14],[156,1002,363,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Footer repeats benchmark name and brand.","boxes":[[72,1125,273,15],[1005,1125,123,15]]}],"usd":0.253144,"sec":136,"out":12306,"cut":61,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-high__simple","clutter":1.1,"shares":{"blue":98.9,"orange":0,"red":1.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":66.5},"score":2,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and clear; only the side stats row about practice areas and source documents is extra and should go.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats","reason":"Practice-area and document counts are a second point, not the case grid.","boxes":[[995,175,22,24],[980,176,160,54],[928,204,51,24]]}],"usd":0.145468,"sec":87,"out":6868,"cut":3,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-medium__raw","clutter":65.3,"shares":{"blue":14.7,"orange":40,"red":45.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.5},"score":6,"words":96,"missing":[],"summary":"The benchmark stats are the core, but a tag, an eyebrow, a paragraph, a process-card row and a large +5% panel crowd it out; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Partnership tag","reason":"Repeats logo and headline partners; unneeded tag.","boxes":[[940,78,180,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be shorter like 'BAR: legal benchmark'.","boxes":[[80,178,842,201],[401,258,223,121]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory paragraph","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explaining the benchmark.","boxes":[[80,385,757,93]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats row","reason":"Dataset counts serve a second point, not the 5% result.","boxes":[[80,531,165,131],[437,531,84,131],[794,531,210,131],[80,651,49,24],[437,651,120,24],[794,651,157,24],[80,695,300,22],[437,695,7,22],[447,695,7,22],[458,695,7,22],[468,695,7,22],[479,695,7,22],[489,695,7,22],[499,695,7,22],[510,695,7,22],[520,695,7,22],[531,695,7,22],[541,695,7,22],[551,695,7,22],[562,695,7,22],[572,695,7,22],[583,695,7,22],[593,695,7,22],[603,695,7,22],[614,695,7,22],[624,695,7,22],[635,695,7,22],[645,695,7,22],[655,695,7,22],[666,695,7,22],[676,695,7,22],[687,695,7,22],[697,695,7,22],[707,695,7,22],[718,695,7,22],[794,695,288,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task specification cards","reason":"Process cards serve a second, unrelated idea.","boxes":[[80,767,190,17],[100,818,18,15],[469,818,18,15],[839,818,18,15],[395,835,37,12],[765,835,37,12],[100,840,252,23],[469,840,226,23],[839,840,209,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Quality gain panel","reason":"Separate +5% result block is a second idea.","boxes":[[80,969,304,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result caption","reason":"Too long for a caption; cut to the metric and the measurement note.","boxes":[[640,1017,460,89]]}],"usd":0.164404,"sec":104,"out":7869,"cut":54,"shrunk":3},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":71.6},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a logo, a short headline, a legend, and one square per case in a unit chart.","marks":[],"usd":0.080548,"sec":52,"out":3622,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":27.6,"shares":{"blue":64.2,"orange":16.4,"red":19.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":52.1},"score":5,"words":92,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid dot-grid main visual is surrounded by a partner tag, subtitle, side note and a stats row of unrelated numbers; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Partnership tag","reason":"Legora already named in headline; partner credit repeated.","boxes":[[943,68,135,20],[1079,68,49,20]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Sentence-like headline, very large; could be shorter.","boxes":[[72,199,721,167]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating what the benchmark is.","boxes":[[72,371,855,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Public case note","reason":"Side note about a separate synthetic case, unrelated to the count.","boxes":[[779,511,164,20],[779,512,292,89],[743,517,22,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Three unrelated stats about practice areas, documents, quality gain.","boxes":[[72,973,60,94],[417,973,150,94],[762,973,108,94],[72,1065,108,22],[417,1065,143,22],[762,1065,210,22],[72,1090,198,22],[417,1090,166,46],[762,1090,301,46]]}],"usd":0.427064,"sec":258,"out":21002,"cut":18,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":62.6,"shares":{"blue":37.4,"orange":0,"red":62.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":74.7},"score":2,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean, mostly complete flow diagram; only the '28 practice areas' tag is a minor extra.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Stacked background cards","reason":"Decorative shapes behind the main card carry no information.","boxes":[[118,158,964,940],[100,172,1000,940],[82,186,1036,940],[64,200,1072,936]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset count header","reason":"Case count and practice-area stats are dataset sizes, not the flow the visual shows.","boxes":[[100,236,157,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas tag","reason":"Separate stat about breadth that is not part of the case flow.","boxes":[[922,236,178,18]]}],"usd":0.819788,"sec":425,"out":40584,"cut":6,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus__raw","clutter":52.4,"shares":{"blue":22.5,"orange":50.2,"red":27.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.4},"score":5,"words":42,"missing":[],"summary":"A stats row of dataset sizes, a kicker line and a sentence headline crowd the +5% result; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline; partly restates the benchmark name.","boxes":[[80,200,680,23]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline at 84px; could be shortened to name BAR.","boxes":[[80,224,999,217]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats are a second idea unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[80,715,198,150],[452,715,100,150],[798,715,251,150],[80,850,51,26],[452,850,124,26],[798,850,164,26]]}],"usd":0.050864,"sec":36,"out":2192,"cut":10,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__opus__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.2},"score":1,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean three-stat graphic with a short title and one logo; nothing needs removing, and the numbers are oversized but not cluttered.","marks":[],"usd":0.034168,"sec":22,"out":1303,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-high__raw","clutter":62.4,"shares":{"blue":23.7,"orange":27.8,"red":48.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.6},"score":7,"words":86,"missing":[],"summary":"Cluttered with a tag, eyebrow, process diagram, big banner and footer taglines around a few stats; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Kicker tag like 'Research · Legal AI' tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[962,61,174,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline.","boxes":[[65,138,235,24]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Headline is large and generic; could be shorter and name BAR.","boxes":[[61,157,587,208]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats row","reason":"Dataset counts are a second point beside the main quality result","boxes":[[64,433,131,106],[458,433,67,106],[816,433,167,106],[64,530,109,28],[458,530,131,28],[816,530,175,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process diagram","reason":"Pipeline illustration and feedback loop serve a second idea about method.","boxes":[[65,618,441,18],[210,657,95,115],[278,657,27,27],[539,663,121,121],[903,663,104,121],[198,664,95,115],[551,667,3,3],[557,667,3,3],[186,671,95,115],[581,688,44,67],[591,688,34,44],[918,702,10,51],[226,703,57,49],[939,707,50,42],[637,713,14,14],[550,725,23,14],[988,743,44,44],[1000,758,21,14],[157,812,172,30],[480,812,241,30],[832,812,251,30],[132,851,222,47],[493,851,213,47],[851,851,213,47],[600,902,357,34],[595,907,10,6],[65,913,290,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tagline","reason":"Footer tagline is marketing.","boxes":[[64,1151,278,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention duplicating the logo.","boxes":[[1036,1151,100,20]]}],"usd":0.057164,"sec":169,"out":5496,"cut":38,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.5},"score":1,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a simple three-step flow ending in the +5% result, with nothing worth removing.","marks":[],"usd":0.043446,"sec":131,"out":4086,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-medium__raw","clutter":80,"shares":{"blue":17.8,"orange":4.4,"red":77.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.9},"score":7,"words":79,"missing":[],"summary":"Dataset stats, process icons, eyebrow, subtitle and footer crowd a single 5% result that has no chart and no baseline.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag with decorative marker.","boxes":[[943,64,193,21],[923,68,8,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan 'Legal work, measured end to end.' does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,131,681,200]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle lines","reason":"Subtitle restating post topic; partnership line not needed.","boxes":[[64,336,208,28],[64,368,576,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats are a second idea beside the result.","boxes":[[64,454,123,97],[452,454,63,97],[810,454,156,97],[64,545,55,26],[452,545,125,26],[810,545,167,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process diagram","reason":"Method pipeline icons unrelated to the 5% result.","boxes":[[520,692,160,158],[180,693,109,134],[930,699,56,16],[529,701,142,140],[202,705,102,129],[906,707,104,128],[215,716,90,120],[282,716,23,23],[924,734,12,63],[948,740,44,54],[563,741,10,10],[609,741,10,10],[568,746,70,52],[233,760,53,47],[633,766,10,10],[633,784,10,10],[986,790,48,48],[563,793,10,10],[609,793,10,10],[1000,807,20,13],[154,860,164,27],[486,860,229,27],[881,860,167,27],[100,895,272,22],[461,895,278,22],[824,895,279,22]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"5% callout","reason":"The only result, but a wordy box with a sentence.","boxes":[[362,1031,344,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tagline","reason":"Footer tagline is unneeded.","boxes":[[64,1136,267,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[1030,1136,106,21]]}],"usd":0.039904,"sec":124,"out":3770,"cut":42,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.6},"score":1,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; the diagram is slightly boxy but every element supports the one +5% point.","marks":[],"usd":0.033526,"sec":126,"out":3094,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":79.7,"shares":{"blue":20.3,"orange":0,"red":79.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.6},"score":7,"words":69,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under a slogan headline, a dataset stats row, a process diagram and a takeaway banner, but nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Tag in the corner tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[948,70,188,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline; partner names add nothing.","boxes":[[64,173,205,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Generic slogan that does not state the finding; competes with the result.","boxes":[[60,197,660,193]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second point unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[64,456,124,100],[461,456,64,100],[819,456,158,100],[64,550,109,28],[461,550,131,28],[819,550,175,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process diagram","reason":"Pipeline and feedback loop is a method explanation, a second idea.","boxes":[[64,642,361,15],[517,667,166,166],[525,675,150,150],[175,684,101,113],[905,691,117,121],[188,692,101,113],[201,700,101,113],[281,700,21,21],[543,702,113,89],[215,718,39,7],[920,726,16,16],[924,731,8,6],[948,731,54,61],[215,742,69,59],[327,747,6,6],[712,747,6,6],[920,753,16,16],[924,758,8,6],[920,780,16,16],[924,785,8,6],[141,838,194,26],[497,838,206,26],[844,838,235,26],[238,875,725,26],[504,894,193,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway banner headline","reason":"Slogan takeaway sentence restates the result.","boxes":[[429,989,590,55]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtext","reason":"Explains the stat, which is already labelled.","boxes":[[429,1057,354,61]]}],"usd":0.069774,"sec":198,"out":6757,"cut":38,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with a short title, a +5% annotation and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.084406,"sec":278,"out":8182,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol__raw","clutter":68.3,"shares":{"blue":28.4,"orange":6.6,"red":65,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.8},"score":7,"words":98,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under a slogan headline, stats row, process steps and footer extras; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline adds nothing.","boxes":[[64,170,295,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, doesn't state the finding; very large.","boxes":[[64,192,932,187]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a separate point from the result.","boxes":[[64,509,117,79],[452,509,66,79],[810,509,147,79],[64,591,51,26],[452,591,124,26],[810,591,164,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process steps","reason":"Pipeline cards unrelated to reading the main result.","boxes":[[64,679,513,21],[64,722,173,33],[445,722,188,33],[826,722,224,33],[392,758,32,18],[773,758,32,18],[64,764,241,47],[445,764,203,47],[826,764,203,47]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result explanation","reason":"Sentence explaining the stat; could be shortened.","boxes":[[319,926,588,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline, no information.","boxes":[[64,1133,357,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention duplicating the logo.","boxes":[[1030,1133,106,21]]}],"usd":0.027104,"sec":72,"out":2490,"cut":22,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sol__simple","clutter":0.5,"shares":{"blue":99.5,"orange":0,"red":0.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":62},"score":1,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple three-step flow with one stray invisible tag shape to remove.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Invisible top tag shape","reason":"Would be an eyebrow or pill above the flow, and it does not render.","boxes":[[64,46,150,26]]}],"usd":0.025666,"sec":74,"out":2308,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-high__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":53.1,"shares":{"blue":42.6,"orange":8.5,"red":48.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40},"score":7,"words":112,"missing":[],"summary":"The +5% result is buried under dataset stat cards, a pipeline diagram, a note and a subtitle, with a sentence-style headline that states no finding.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Partnership eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker line above the headline; says nothing the reader needs","boxes":[[838,72,290,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explains benchmark; restates the headline and the post.","boxes":[[72,332,775,67]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats","reason":"Dataset-size stat cards with decorative marks, unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[101,463,84,7],[460,463,14,14],[480,463,14,14],[501,463,14,14],[521,463,14,14],[542,463,14,14],[562,463,14,14],[583,463,14,14],[603,463,14,14],[624,463,14,14],[644,463,14,14],[665,463,14,14],[685,463,14,14],[705,463,14,14],[726,463,14,14],[818,463,281,7],[101,475,154,7],[818,475,225,7],[460,483,14,14],[480,483,14,14],[501,483,14,14],[521,483,14,14],[542,483,14,14],[562,483,14,14],[583,483,14,14],[603,483,14,14],[624,483,14,14],[644,483,14,14],[665,483,14,14],[685,483,14,14],[705,483,14,14],[726,483,14,14],[101,487,225,7],[818,487,154,7],[101,491,145,116],[460,491,74,116],[818,491,185,116],[101,499,281,7],[818,499,84,7],[101,594,57,27],[460,594,138,27],[818,594,182,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task pipeline","reason":"Method pipeline is a second idea unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[72,676,246,19],[326,721,13,21],[596,721,13,21],[866,721,13,21],[72,725,19,17],[342,725,19,17],[612,725,19,17],[882,725,19,17],[72,749,78,27],[342,749,44,27],[612,749,97,27],[882,749,77,27],[72,781,236,45],[342,781,201,45],[612,781,183,45],[882,781,231,45]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Failure cases note","reason":"Process sentence, a side point beyond the main result.","boxes":[[114,858,262,23],[91,859,11,23],[376,859,587,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow label","reason":"Kicker above the statement.","boxes":[[417,985,335,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result description","reason":"Wordy explanation of the stat; could be shortened.","boxes":[[417,1013,645,74]]}],"usd":0.073142,"sec":64,"out":6963,"cut":72,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-high__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.8},"score":1,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean stat sheet with a logo, a benchmark name and three labelled numbers; the only nit is the arbitrary per-row color.","marks":[],"usd":0.043534,"sec":56,"out":3948,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":68.4,"shares":{"blue":26.4,"orange":10.5,"red":63.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.6},"score":6,"words":41,"missing":[],"summary":"A meaningless decorative tile grid and a large stats row crowd out the title and BAR definition, which are the only core content; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Partnership eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow tag above headline; the logo already brands it.","boxes":[[80,79,259,26]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Benchmark subtitle","reason":"Explains the benchmark in a full sentence; shorten to the name.","boxes":[[80,431,788,70]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tile grid","reason":"Decorative grid with no labels or data meaning.","boxes":[[82,542,33,30],[119,542,33,30],[156,542,33,30],[193,542,33,30],[231,542,33,30],[268,542,33,30],[305,542,33,30],[342,542,33,30],[379,542,33,30],[416,542,33,30],[453,542,33,30],[491,542,33,30],[528,542,33,30],[565,542,33,30],[602,542,33,30],[639,542,33,30],[676,542,33,30],[713,542,33,30],[751,542,33,30],[788,542,33,30],[825,542,33,30],[862,542,33,30],[899,542,33,30],[936,542,33,30],[973,542,33,30],[1011,542,33,30],[1048,542,33,30],[1085,542,33,30],[82,576,33,30],[119,576,33,30],[156,576,33,30],[193,576,33,30],[231,576,33,30],[268,576,33,30],[305,576,33,30],[342,576,33,30],[379,576,33,30],[416,576,33,30],[453,576,33,30],[491,576,33,30],[528,576,33,30],[565,576,33,30],[602,576,33,30],[639,576,33,30],[676,576,33,30],[713,576,33,30],[751,576,33,30],[788,576,33,30],[825,576,33,30],[862,576,33,30],[899,576,33,30],[936,576,33,30],[973,576,33,30],[1011,576,33,30],[1048,576,33,30],[1085,576,33,30],[82,610,33,30],[119,610,33,30],[156,610,33,30],[193,610,33,30],[231,610,33,30],[268,610,33,30],[305,610,33,30],[342,610,33,30],[379,610,33,30],[416,610,33,30],[453,610,33,30],[491,610,33,30],[528,610,33,30],[565,610,33,30],[602,610,33,30],[639,610,33,30],[676,610,33,30],[713,610,33,30],[751,610,33,30],[788,610,33,30],[825,610,33,30],[862,610,33,30],[899,610,33,30],[936,610,33,30],[973,610,33,30],[1011,610,33,30],[1048,610,33,30],[1085,610,33,30],[82,644,33,30],[119,644,33,30],[156,644,33,30],[193,644,33,30],[231,644,33,30],[268,644,33,30],[305,644,33,30],[342,644,33,30],[379,644,33,30],[416,644,33,30],[453,644,33,30],[491,644,33,30],[528,644,33,30],[565,644,33,30],[602,644,33,30],[639,644,33,30],[676,644,33,30],[713,644,33,30],[751,644,33,30],[788,644,33,30],[825,644,33,30],[862,644,33,30],[899,644,33,30],[936,644,33,30],[973,644,33,30],[1011,644,33,30],[1048,644,33,30],[1085,644,33,30],[82,678,33,30],[119,678,33,30],[156,678,33,30],[193,678,33,30],[231,678,33,30],[268,678,33,30],[305,678,33,30],[342,678,33,30],[379,678,33,30],[416,678,33,30],[453,678,33,30],[491,678,33,30],[528,678,33,30],[565,678,33,30],[602,678,33,30],[639,678,33,30],[676,678,33,30],[713,678,33,30],[751,678,33,30],[788,678,33,30],[825,678,33,30],[862,678,33,30],[899,678,33,30],[936,678,33,30],[973,678,33,30],[1011,678,33,30],[1048,678,33,30],[1085,678,33,30],[82,712,33,30],[119,712,33,30],[156,712,33,30],[193,712,33,30],[231,712,33,30],[268,712,33,30],[305,712,33,30],[342,712,33,30],[379,712,33,30],[416,712,33,30],[453,712,33,30],[491,712,33,30],[528,712,33,30],[565,712,33,30],[602,712,33,30],[639,712,33,30],[676,712,33,30],[713,712,33,30],[751,712,33,30],[788,712,33,30],[825,712,33,30],[862,712,33,30],[899,712,33,30],[936,712,33,30],[973,712,33,30],[1011,712,33,30],[1048,712,33,30],[1085,712,33,30],[82,746,33,30],[119,746,33,30],[156,746,33,30],[193,746,33,30],[231,746,33,30],[268,746,33,30],[305,746,33,30],[342,746,33,30],[379,746,33,30],[416,746,33,30],[453,746,33,30],[491,746,33,30],[528,746,33,30],[565,746,33,30],[602,746,33,30],[639,746,33,30],[676,746,33,30],[713,746,33,30],[751,746,33,30],[788,746,33,30],[825,746,33,30],[862,746,33,30],[899,746,33,30],[936,746,33,30],[973,746,33,30],[1011,746,33,30],[1048,746,33,30],[1085,746,33,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats and a +5% claim form a second idea.","boxes":[[80,908,189,97],[347,908,84,97],[615,908,228,97],[882,908,159,97],[80,1010,54,28],[347,1010,131,28],[615,1010,172,28],[882,1010,188,110]]}],"usd":0.029622,"sec":30,"out":2611,"cut":209,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":8.7,"shares":{"blue":82.6,"orange":17.4,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":50.1},"score":1,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean single before/after bar chart; only the headline is a bit wordy, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Full-sentence-style title; could be shortened, e.g. '+5% output quality with BAR'.","boxes":[[80,68,894,138]]}],"usd":0.034804,"sec":37,"out":3075,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":35.1,"shares":{"blue":48.8,"orange":32.5,"red":18.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":54.9},"score":6,"words":107,"missing":[],"summary":"A dot-grid scale visual is buried by a long headline, subtitle, date tag, four-step process row and a +5% card; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Date/category tag tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[956,64,172,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Headline is a long sentence-like title at huge size; could be shorter.","boxes":[[72,103,764,274]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Two-line sentence restating the post; cut to a short line naming BAR and legal work.","boxes":[[72,379,709,61],[72,379,46,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Extra dataset-size stats","reason":"28 practice areas and 11,075 documents are a second point beside the case count.","boxes":[[712,641,64,100],[912,695,120,24],[712,734,160,100],[912,788,157,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process steps","reason":"Define/Build/Validate steps are a second idea unrelated to scale.","boxes":[[72,915,18,15],[336,915,18,15],[600,915,18,15],[72,932,95,53],[336,932,77,53],[600,932,118,53],[72,988,238,68],[336,988,220,68],[600,988,236,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Improve +5% card","reason":"Separate result claim in its own stat card, a second idea.","boxes":[[888,914,18,15],[888,931,121,53],[888,966,113,100],[888,1059,202,62]]}],"usd":0.173732,"sec":160,"out":17022,"cut":22,"shrunk":3},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":1.9,"shares":{"blue":98.1,"orange":0,"red":1.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":46.9},"score":2,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean waffle chart with title and logo; only the practice-areas and source-documents stats row is clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Practice areas and documents stats","reason":"Second dataset-size stats beside the main grid; a different point.","boxes":[[235,1099,25,26],[260,1099,136,28],[440,1099,57,26],[496,1099,177,28]]}],"usd":0.082414,"sec":85,"out":7836,"cut":4,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet__raw","clutter":53.3,"shares":{"blue":12.5,"orange":68.5,"red":19,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38},"score":5,"words":39,"missing":[],"summary":"A dataset stats row, a partner tag and a footer URL clutter a long headline and wordy +5% callout; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Partnership tag","reason":"Partner names already in title and logo; brand repeated.","boxes":[[837,96,283,26]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline spanning three lines; could be 'BAR: legal agent benchmark'.","boxes":[[80,208,821,393],[485,295,169,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size counts serve a second point unrelated to the +5% result.","boxes":[[80,657,173,131],[464,657,88,131],[810,657,220,131],[80,798,57,27],[464,798,138,27],[810,798,182,27]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"+5% callout","reason":"Useful result, but wordy description in a big box.","boxes":[[391,964,666,71]]}],"usd":0.028692,"sec":34,"out":2518,"cut":10,"shrunk":3},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34},"score":1,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a three-stat scale graphic with benchmark name and logo, with no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.019084,"sec":16,"out":1503,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__wonder__raw","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__wonder__raw","clutter":62.2,"shares":{"blue":34.1,"orange":7.5,"red":58.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.6},"score":7,"words":200,"missing":[],"summary":"The benchmark stats are buried under a subtitle, a four-step pipeline, a published-case note, a +5% panel and a repeated brand footer; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section and date tag","reason":"Category tag and date add nothing to the point.","boxes":[[964,67,168,15],[1014,89,118,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline; partners and BAR name repeated in the headline and subtitle.","boxes":[[92,173,212,17],[215,173,11,17],[318,173,11,17],[344,173,413,17],[68,177,10,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the benchmark.","boxes":[[68,367,803,56]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset size stats row","reason":"Dataset counts serve a second point, not the +5% result.","boxes":[[68,467,129,100],[422,467,65,100],[750,467,164,100],[68,561,115,35],[422,561,134,35],[750,561,154,35]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Process cards","reason":"Four-step pipeline is a second idea beyond the benchmark scale.","boxes":[[68,650,272,15],[821,650,311,15],[87,698,18,14],[362,698,18,14],[636,698,18,14],[911,698,18,14],[87,716,124,36],[362,716,105,36],[636,716,165,36],[911,716,139,36],[315,752,19,10],[589,752,19,10],[864,752,19,10],[87,756,200,60],[362,756,196,60],[636,756,202,60],[911,756,190,60]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Published case note","reason":"Side detail about the synthetic case, unrelated to the main visual.","boxes":[[175,851,896,19],[68,855,97,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"+5% callout panel","reason":"Second result and claim in a big dark panel, with explanatory paragraph.","boxes":[[331,1018,547,71]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Result headline sentence","reason":"Sentence-length headline; shorten to a finding such as '+5% output quality in one month'.","boxes":[[331,928,504,85]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline duplicate the logo.","boxes":[[331,1156,349,14],[1010,1156,122,14]]}],"usd":0.121128,"sec":72,"out":5838,"cut":45,"shrunk":1},{"id":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__wonder__simple","task":"building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/building-a-frontier-legal-evaluation-in-partnership-with-legora__wonder__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":49},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a headline count, a key line, a logo, and the dot grid itself.","marks":[],"usd":0.101908,"sec":72,"out":4838,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__argon-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__argon-high__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":21.3},"score":0,"words":34,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, one logo, a legend and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.163292,"sec":281,"out":16047,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__argon-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__argon-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.2},"score":0,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, legend, labels and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.20211,"sec":261,"out":19890,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__argon-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__argon-medium__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one grouped bar chart with a short title, legend, labels, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.127472,"sec":181,"out":12465,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__argon-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__argon-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20.6},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with title, legend, labels and a single brand mark.","marks":[],"usd":0.14129,"sec":199,"out":13808,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__argon__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__argon__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.2},"score":0,"words":36,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a title, one logo, a legend and labelled values; the benchmark is not named, but the metric is clear.","marks":[],"usd":0.081192,"sec":163,"out":7837,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__argon__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__argon__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.2},"score":0,"words":36,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, legend, labelled values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.08393,"sec":143,"out":8072,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra-high__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":14.1},"score":0,"words":46,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a short finding headline, a clear paired dot chart, one wordmark and a quiet footnote.","marks":[],"usd":0.1648,"sec":68,"out":3028,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":6.6},"score":0,"words":31,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a finding headline, one logo, and a metric legend, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.15756,"sec":115,"out":2845,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra-medium__raw","clutter":6.5,"shares":{"blue":93.5,"orange":0,"red":6.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":59.2},"score":1,"words":42,"missing":[],"summary":"Almost clean: only the slogan headline is clutter, and nothing needed is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan-style headline that does not name the finding.","boxes":[[64,131,656,81]]}],"usd":0.11155,"sec":82,"out":1963,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":6},"score":0,"words":28,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a finding headline, metric label, legend and one brand mark.","marks":[],"usd":0.11616,"sec":61,"out":2017,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":43,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single lollipop chart with a finding headline, a legend, and a quiet footnote; only the 6% label placement is off.","marks":[],"usd":0.2339,"sec":112,"out":4410,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":26,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a short title, one legend, model names and value labels around a simple dumbbell chart.","marks":[],"usd":0.23116,"sec":151,"out":4317,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":56},"score":1,"words":42,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete; at most the legend line is slightly redundant with the headline.","marks":[],"usd":0.10795,"sec":54,"out":1891,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__astra__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__astra__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":5},"score":0,"words":26,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a short title, one legend, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.11026,"sec":50,"out":1899,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":22.6,"shares":{"blue":77.4,"orange":0,"red":22.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.5},"score":2,"words":79,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean chart dominating the canvas; only the slogan headline and the repeated methodology footnote could be trimmed.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"'The gap is the finding' is a slogan, not a stated finding.","boxes":[[80,230,597,81]]}],"usd":0.007971899999999999,"sec":51,"out":12950,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a title, legend, one wordmark and labelled axis, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0063078000000000006,"sec":49,"out":10128,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-max__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":54.5,"shares":{"blue":45.5,"orange":0,"red":54.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":13.6},"score":2,"words":62,"missing":[],"summary":"Mostly clean single chart; the large sentence-style headline takes more room than needed.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan-style headline; the chart title already states what is measured.","boxes":[[80,180,765,101],[80,259,351,101]]}],"usd":0.0291603,"sec":234,"out":48264,"cut":2,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-max__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":29,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one dumbbell chart with a logo, a short title, a legend and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.018715799999999998,"sec":151,"out":30808,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":47.6,"shares":{"blue":34.4,"orange":36.2,"red":29.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":21.7},"score":5,"words":146,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid dot chart is crowded by an eyebrow, oversized slogan headline, restating subtitle, word counts and totals; plotting is also misaligned.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker label with decorative dot adds nothing.","boxes":[[864,66,256,16],[847,71,7,7]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Huge slogan-like headline; shorter, smaller finding title would do.","boxes":[[80,156,704,111],[80,243,388,111]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates what the chart already shows.","boxes":[[80,402,929,66],[363,402,269,31]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Word counts","reason":"Secondary word-count data unrelated to the clutter chart.","boxes":[[80,575,192,18],[80,685,200,18],[80,795,192,18],[80,905,200,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Totals stat","reason":"Experiment totals are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[1048,1081,20,21],[1020,1085,100,58]]}],"usd":0.0060081,"sec":47,"out":9677,"cut":10,"shrunk":2},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":17.7,"shares":{"blue":64.7,"orange":35.3,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":5.2},"score":1,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean; the headline is a vague slogan, and the chart never names ClutterBench's prompt types beyond Raw/Simple, but it is complete.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Slogan-like, large, and does not state the finding or numbers.","boxes":[[64,166,391,63]]}],"usd":0.0036972,"sec":32,"out":5777,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":51.1,"shares":{"blue":48.9,"orange":0,"red":51.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":13.3},"score":3,"words":96,"missing":["metric name"],"summary":"A good main chart carries extras (header strip, eyebrow, two subtitle lines, callout), and the metric is only implied as 'clutter score'.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta strip","reason":"Results, counts and dots add nothing needed; counts are footnote-level detail.","boxes":[[824,59,44,18],[904,59,72,18],[1013,59,108,18],[884,66,4,4],[993,66,4,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline restating the legend.","boxes":[[80,143,254,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; replace with a finding title.","boxes":[[80,163,611,83]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Subtitle restates what the chart shows.","boxes":[[80,257,571,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Takeaway sentence","reason":"Chart already shows three models at 0%.","boxes":[[80,286,456,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Luna callout","reason":"Annotation restates what the 6% value already shows.","boxes":[[467,988,212,20]]}],"usd":0.0163371,"sec":122,"out":26892,"cut":10,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":8.4},"score":1,"words":32,"missing":["metric name"],"summary":"Clean single chart with no clutter, but the metric (clutter share of area) is never labelled.","marks":[],"usd":0.0059718,"sec":53,"out":9568,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek__raw","clutter":32.4,"shares":{"blue":49.2,"orange":36.8,"red":14,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.5},"score":2,"words":101,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean dot chart with small extras: date, restating subtitle, sentence headline and a repeated footer brand tagline; nothing missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date","reason":"Publication date tells the reader nothing needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[1042,76,86,19]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence slogan-like headline; could be shorter and state the finding.","boxes":[[72,160,538,151],[72,228,208,83]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart subtitle","reason":"Restates what the legend and chart already show.","boxes":[[72,327,730,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark tagline","reason":"Second brand mark and tagline, logo already present.","boxes":[[823,1124,44,18],[868,1124,260,18]]}],"usd":0.009659699999999998,"sec":89,"out":15763,"cut":4,"shrunk":2},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__deepseek__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":6.9},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dot plot with a logo, short title, legend, axis and metric footnote, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0040506,"sec":42,"out":6366,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":19.5},"score":0,"words":54,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a finding headline, metric subtitle, legend and logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.240945375,"sec":417,"out":58127,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":47.3},"score":0,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a short title, one legend, axis ticks and one small wordmark.","marks":[],"usd":0.29727225,"sec":540,"out":71743,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":3.4,"shares":{"blue":96.6,"orange":0,"red":3.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":62.6},"score":2,"words":89,"missing":[],"summary":"Mostly clean dumbbell chart; the subtitle and rank number badges are minor extras.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates what the chart already shows.","boxes":[[64,183,831,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Rank numbers","reason":"Numbered badges add nothing; the order is already visible.","boxes":[[103,430,26,26],[114,435,5,16],[103,580,26,26],[112,585,7,16],[103,730,26,26],[112,735,7,16],[103,880,26,26],[112,885,8,16]]}],"usd":0.2584725,"sec":469,"out":62376,"cut":9,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":16.9},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, one legend, one logo and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.24140325,"sec":418,"out":58199,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":5.9,"shares":{"blue":93.8,"orange":0.6,"red":5.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":18},"score":2,"words":88,"missing":[],"summary":"A clean bar chart with a redundant words-per-graphic column, a URL and a duplicated column header/legend; otherwise complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Words column","reason":"Second metric, word counts, unrelated to the clutter-score comparison.","boxes":[[1005,244,111,18],[986,379,26,28],[1042,379,26,28],[1020,385,15,20],[1078,387,38,18],[973,544,39,28],[1042,544,26,28],[1020,550,15,20],[1078,552,38,18],[986,708,26,28],[1042,708,26,28],[1020,714,15,20],[1078,716,38,18],[973,873,39,28],[1042,873,26,28],[1020,879,15,20],[1078,881,38,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Column headers","reason":"Headers repeat legend and 'lower is better' twice; could be shorter.","boxes":[[792,246,80,15]]}],"usd":0.050857125,"sec":122,"out":12045,"cut":17,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.4},"score":0,"words":31,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, labelled models, values and axis.","marks":[],"usd":0.03262875,"sec":86,"out":7587,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok-high__raw","clutter":12.5,"shares":{"blue":87.5,"orange":0,"red":12.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.3},"score":2,"words":39,"missing":[],"summary":"Mostly clean slope chart; the sentence headline could be shorter, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan restates the thesis and does not name the finding or the scores.","boxes":[[72,121,573,130]]}],"usd":0.438078,"sec":1264,"out":72566,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":24,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one grouped bar chart with legend, metric label and one logo, and nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.335454,"sec":931,"out":55397,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok-medium__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":7.8},"score":1,"words":47,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one dumbbell chart with a short title, legend, logo and metric caption.","marks":[],"usd":0.137886,"sec":340,"out":22534,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24},"score":0,"words":22,"missing":["metric name"],"summary":"Clean chart with nothing to remove, but no label says the percentages measure clutter or that lower is better.","marks":[],"usd":0.17868,"sec":448,"out":29268,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42},"score":0,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple bar chart with a title, legend and one value per bar; only a rendering oddity on the 6% bar.","marks":[],"usd":0.516522,"sec":2225,"out":85640,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.2},"score":0,"words":22,"missing":["metric definition"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: the chart carries the point, but the percentages never say they measure clutter share.","marks":[],"usd":0.49407,"sec":1481,"out":81833,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok__raw","clutter":18.3,"shares":{"blue":80.1,"orange":3.2,"red":16.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15},"score":1,"words":49,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean bar chart; only the legend plus repeated Raw/Simple row labels duplicate each other.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; the chart carries the point.","boxes":[[60,112,527,68]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Legend","reason":"Legend duplicates the Raw/Simple labels on every row; could be dropped.","boxes":[[82,238,100,23],[232,238,120,23],[60,243,14,14],[210,243,14,14]]}],"usd":0.060888,"sec":136,"out":9701,"cut":1,"shrunk":4},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__grok__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":3},"score":0,"words":23,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean single-chart graphic with nothing to remove; only minor ambiguity about what 'clutter' means and missing 0% labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.052656,"sec":140,"out":8264,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-high__raw","clutter":4.1,"shares":{"blue":95.9,"orange":0,"red":4.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":1,"words":69,"missing":[],"summary":"Only the slogan headline is clutter; the lollipop chart, logo, subtitle and footnote are clean and complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan rather than a finding; the chart title and bars already state the point.","boxes":[[80,172,778,73]]}],"usd":0.0075105,"sec":97,"out":14626,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":6.7},"score":0,"words":26,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a legend, a title, labels and values, and nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0073971,"sec":86,"out":14345,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":5,"shares":{"blue":95,"orange":0,"red":5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":1,"words":59,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete; only the subtitle sentence could be shorter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; the chart already shows it","boxes":[[96,226,562,83],[96,298,311,83]]}],"usd":0.005535,"sec":71,"out":10675,"cut":2,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":7.4},"score":0,"words":24,"missing":["metric definition"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a single dumbbell chart with one legend and one brand mark; the metric is only implied by the wordmark.","marks":[],"usd":0.0046741000000000005,"sec":56,"out":8899,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":49.4,"shares":{"blue":50.6,"orange":0,"red":49.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.4},"score":2,"words":46,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete; only the sentence-style headline is bigger than it needs to be.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; the chart already shows it.","boxes":[[80,202,698,106],[80,289,386,106]]}],"usd":0.0101015,"sec":123,"out":19808,"cut":2,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.7},"score":0,"words":28,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a short title, one legend, one logo and a bar chart with labelled values and models.","marks":[],"usd":0.0094461,"sec":121,"out":18443,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku__raw","clutter":41.9,"shares":{"blue":34.8,"orange":46.6,"red":18.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":18.7},"score":1,"words":86,"missing":[],"summary":"Mostly clean dumbbell chart; the sentence headline is verbose and the subtitle is unneeded.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline with numbers the chart already shows; could be shorter.","boxes":[[80,144,949,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Explains the chart; metric is covered by the footnote and legend.","boxes":[[80,297,835,59]]}],"usd":0.0041755,"sec":43,"out":7956,"cut":1,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__haiku__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":9.3},"score":0,"words":28,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a short title, legend, and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0048931,"sec":57,"out":9337,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna-high__raw","clutter":44,"shares":{"blue":46,"orange":20.1,"red":33.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":17.4},"score":4,"words":47,"missing":[],"summary":"A big 3/4 stat is the core, but an eyebrow, slogan headline, decorative icon grid, subtext and Luna exception clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above the headline, tells nothing needed.","boxes":[[72,229,238,20]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan-like headline; the 3/4 stat is the actual finding.","boxes":[[72,259,289,166]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Icon grid","reason":"Decorative document icons show no data; 4 cards only loosely echo 3/4.","boxes":[[810,548,59,55],[992,548,59,55],[819,558,39,6],[1007,559,28,28],[1014,566,17,13],[819,571,29,4],[819,580,35,4],[810,730,59,55],[992,730,59,55],[1002,742,39,6],[822,747,35,24],[1002,755,29,4],[1002,764,35,4],[1002,774,20,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtext","reason":"Takeaway sentence restating the point.","boxes":[[76,785,415,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Luna exception","reason":"Side point about one model, a second idea outside the main stat.","boxes":[[72,959,115,21],[187,959,206,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative dash","reason":"Decorative shape with no meaning.","boxes":[[1086,1135,42,4]]}],"usd":0.002421,"sec":55,"out":4574,"cut":24,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna-high__simple","clutter":0.7,"shares":{"blue":99.3,"orange":0,"red":0.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.4},"score":1,"words":20,"missing":["value labels and unit","meaning of bar fill"],"summary":"Mostly clean, but the bars have no values, unit or legend, so the reader can't read the 0% versus 6% result.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Simple prompt pill","reason":"Badge naming the prompt condition; the reader does not need it to read the chart.","boxes":[[1000,91,111,21]]}],"usd":0.0032600999999999997,"sec":70,"out":6214,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna-medium__raw","clutter":50.9,"shares":{"blue":31.7,"orange":34.8,"red":33.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":18.5},"score":5,"words":81,"missing":[],"summary":"The before/after visual is clear, but the subtitle, date tag, footer and scattered floating tags add clutter, and the headline is oversized.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style tag in the corner; tells the reader little.","boxes":[[938,67,196,16]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline, oversized; could be shorter and show the numbers.","boxes":[[66,139,530,93],[66,212,540,93]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates the headline's point.","boxes":[[66,319,689,56]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow label tag","reason":"Floating example tag of clutter, decorative and not needed.","boxes":[[262,526,70,16],[248,529,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline tag","reason":"Floating example tag of clutter, decorative and not needed.","boxes":[[183,553,86,22],[170,565,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Extra stat cards tag","reason":"Stat-card example repeats figures the bars already convey.","boxes":[[391,570,86,21],[378,573,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline tag","reason":"Floating example tag of clutter, decorative and not needed.","boxes":[[174,741,75,19],[160,744,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated number tag","reason":"Repeated-number example duplicates information shown elsewhere.","boxes":[[387,753,95,22],[373,764,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Second idea tag","reason":"Second-idea example serves a point unrelated to the main visual.","boxes":[[345,791,59,16],[331,794,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats the brand and adds a tagline and URL.","boxes":[[66,1160,357,15]]}],"usd":0.0022015,"sec":57,"out":4135,"cut":22,"shrunk":2},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":19.2},"score":0,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a finding headline, one logo, a legend and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.0015841,"sec":38,"out":2862,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":84.7,"shares":{"blue":15.3,"orange":0,"red":84.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.8},"score":7,"words":21,"missing":["actual results data","benchmark metric"],"summary":"A conceptual illustration with no results chart: slogan headline, a keep card and four callout pills are all extras, and it lacks any data or metric.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Clutter example callouts","reason":"Decorative labelled pills and connectors illustrating clutter; no data shown.","boxes":[[102,533,226,58],[872,533,226,58],[121,551,22,22],[891,551,22,22],[156,552,73,20],[926,552,129,20],[128,558,8,8],[898,558,8,8],[327,568,123,77],[750,569,123,76],[294,573,612,394],[446,641,8,8],[746,641,8,8],[376,645,448,250],[876,731,220,48],[926,747,117,18],[895,748,18,14],[824,755,52,15],[820,766,8,8],[446,891,8,8],[746,891,8,8],[332,895,118,41],[750,895,118,41],[94,918,244,58],[862,918,236,58],[113,936,22,22],[881,936,22,22],[148,938,155,19],[916,938,126,19],[120,943,8,8],[888,943,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Keep card","reason":"Slogan-like card text and badge; no chart or data, restates the post's advice.","boxes":[[255,534,690,472],[548,686,104,32],[581,694,39,16],[563,698,8,8],[485,732,229,73],[542,835,117,29]]}],"usd":0.007981,"sec":165,"out":15694,"cut":37,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":31,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic is clean and nearly complete. It only lacks an explicit metric label, and the axis has an irregular 70% tick.","marks":[],"usd":0.006192100000000001,"sec":134,"out":12078,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna__raw","clutter":18.8,"shares":{"blue":81.2,"orange":0,"red":18.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.4},"score":3,"words":114,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, a color legend, a sentence headline, two takeaway cards and a duplicate wordmark; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline.","boxes":[[64,143,147,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Clean is possible card","reason":"Restates the 0% bars and the headline.","boxes":[[112,819,118,20],[92,824,10,10],[92,848,440,41],[92,848,90,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"One exception card","reason":"Restates the 6% bar; adds a second finding.","boxes":[[660,819,104,20],[640,824,10,10],[640,848,469,41],[777,848,19,19],[868,848,37,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark.","boxes":[[1059,1130,77,16]]}],"usd":0.001323,"sec":28,"out":2378,"cut":13,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__luna__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__luna__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.1},"score":1,"words":51,"missing":[],"summary":"Mostly clean, but stray left-axis percent labels add clutter, and the bars are misaligned with model labels, which makes the chart confusing.","marks":[],"usd":0.0012970999999999998,"sec":33,"out":2288,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus-high__raw","clutter":14.7,"shares":{"blue":70.7,"orange":29.3,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.2},"score":1,"words":43,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean slope chart; only the headline is wordier than needed, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Ten-word sentence states the finding; shorten to about seven words, e.g. 'Simple prompt cuts clutter to near zero'.","boxes":[[90,154,1002,145]]}],"usd":0.11194,"sec":71,"out":5202,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus-high__simple","clutter":21.6,"shares":{"blue":56.9,"orange":43.1,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":8.1},"score":1,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a clear dumbbell chart with one headline that runs a little long, plus two minor label-placement defects.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Finding headline","reason":"States the finding, but at nine words it is longer than needed; could be shorter.","boxes":[[80,158,900,53]]}],"usd":0.076064,"sec":47,"out":3354,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus-medium__raw","clutter":31.1,"shares":{"blue":37.8,"orange":62.2,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":14.9},"score":1,"words":45,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean: the headline is a long full sentence that could be shortened, and the chart, legend and brand mark are complete and readable.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"A finding, but a ten-word sentence; could shorten to about seven words","boxes":[[90,144,978,134]]}],"usd":0.06806,"sec":48,"out":3008,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus-medium__simple","clutter":22.5,"shares":{"blue":55,"orange":45,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":9.3},"score":1,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete apart from a nine-word headline that should be shortened and a slightly misaligned track on the last row.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Nine words stating the finding; shorten to a title such as 'Clutter drops with a simple prompt'.","boxes":[[64,128,998,60]]}],"usd":0.072764,"sec":52,"out":3189,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":29.6,"shares":{"blue":40.9,"orange":59.1,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":17.5},"score":1,"words":50,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean: only the ten-word headline could be shorter; the chart says what is measured and is complete.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Ten-word sentence; a shorter finding such as 'Simple prompts cut clutter to near zero' fits better.","boxes":[[72,145,978,149]]}],"usd":0.2184,"sec":115,"out":10525,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":8.5},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":["metric name"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; only the metric behind the percentages is not explicitly named.","marks":[],"usd":0.155804,"sec":82,"out":7341,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":10.2},"score":0,"words":41,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a clear title, legend, labelled values and one wordmark.","marks":[],"usd":0.0465,"sec":29,"out":1930,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__opus__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__opus__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":11},"score":0,"words":35,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a title, one logo, one legend and no extra cards or slogans.","marks":[],"usd":0.044484,"sec":27,"out":1775,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol-high__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":11.4},"score":0,"words":43,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete.","marks":[],"usd":0.02902,"sec":89,"out":2634,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":25,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a title, one legend, one logo, and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.034172,"sec":122,"out":3111,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol-medium__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36},"score":0,"words":40,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single slope chart with a finding headline, metric, labelled rows, logo and quiet footnote.","marks":[],"usd":0.02636,"sec":87,"out":2368,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":5},"score":0,"words":25,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a clear title, one logo, a legend and one value label per mark.","marks":[],"usd":0.027342,"sec":92,"out":2428,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.6},"score":0,"words":43,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single slope chart with a finding headline, labelled values, a logo and a quiet footnote.","marks":[],"usd":0.05047,"sec":152,"out":4779,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":5.5},"score":0,"words":27,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a short title, legend, and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.051792,"sec":168,"out":4873,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol__raw","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":51.8},"score":0,"words":48,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single slope chart with a finding headline, metric subtitle, one logo and a quiet footnote, with no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.02412,"sec":57,"out":2144,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sol__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sol__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.1},"score":0,"words":30,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple slope chart with one logo, a short finding headline and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.021522,"sec":52,"out":1846,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-high__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":26.8,"shares":{"blue":46.4,"orange":53.6,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":16.5},"score":1,"words":45,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean: the dumbbell chart carries the point, and only the headline is slightly long.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline finding","reason":"States the finding, but at about 10 words it should be seven or fewer.","boxes":[[80,114,721,174]]}],"usd":0.03362,"sec":34,"out":2967,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-high__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":10.4},"score":0,"words":31,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a clear title, legend, logo, and value labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.043782,"sec":40,"out":3929,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":21,"shares":{"blue":58,"orange":42,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.8},"score":1,"words":44,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean chart with one wordy headline that could be shortened; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline restates the finding; could shorten to about seven words.","boxes":[[80,121,966,176]]}],"usd":0.0362,"sec":38,"out":3225,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":8.4},"score":0,"words":28,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dumbbell chart with a short title, one legend and labelled values; the only gap is that the logo icon visible at top left is absent from the element list.","marks":[],"usd":0.031032,"sec":27,"out":2654,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":17.1,"shares":{"blue":82.9,"orange":0,"red":17.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32},"score":1,"words":37,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one slope chart with a short headline, a metric line, a logo and labelled values.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; the chart carries the point.","boxes":[[80,140,895,86]]}],"usd":0.09486,"sec":92,"out":9091,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":14},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean dumbbell chart with nothing to remove; it only lacks a label saying that the percentages are clutter.","marks":[],"usd":0.091442,"sec":94,"out":8695,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet__raw","clutter":32.3,"shares":{"blue":35.5,"orange":64.5,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":17.1},"score":1,"words":46,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean dumbbell chart with no extras; only the nine-word headline could be shorter.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Nine-word headline","reason":"Names the finding but runs nine words; shorten to about seven.","boxes":[[110,122,992,157]]}],"usd":0.02983,"sec":28,"out":2588,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":9.2},"score":0,"words":39,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single dot plot with labelled models, values, scale, title and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.039912,"sec":36,"out":3542,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__wonder__raw","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__wonder__raw","clutter":37.2,"shares":{"blue":45.5,"orange":34.6,"red":19.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":19.2},"score":2,"words":99,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear dot chart with a few extras: a large slogan headline, a restating subtitle and a date tag.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[1006,71,130,20]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan-like headline; huge, takes much of the canvas.","boxes":[[64,146,640,96],[64,224,354,96]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explains the chart; legend and axis already cover it.","boxes":[[64,331,810,58],[575,331,126,28],[196,361,135,28]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Luna annotation","reason":"Useful but a wordy note beside the point.","boxes":[[436,968,231,20]]}],"usd":0.132012,"sec":88,"out":6334,"cut":4,"shrunk":3},{"id":"clutterbench-v1-results__wonder__simple","task":"clutterbench-v1-results","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/clutterbench-v1-results__wonder__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":8.9},"score":0,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one chart with a short headline, legend, logo and metric label.","marks":[],"usd":0.106352,"sec":67,"out":5012,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-high__raw","clutter":65.2,"shares":{"blue":33.6,"orange":2.2,"red":64.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":62.8},"score":8,"words":608,"missing":[],"summary":"The warmup-ablation chart is buried under stat cards, a pipeline diagram, a duplicate table, a quote and an unrelated validation card.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Partner badge pill","reason":"Badge is a claim unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[841,33,308,14],[829,37,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date and authors","reason":"Blog metadata is not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[571,33,92,15],[670,33,3,15],[680,33,124,15],[558,35,6,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Lab tagline","reason":"Tagline next to the logo adds nothing.","boxes":[[195,34,142,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Model and benchmark stats serve unrelated points.","boxes":[[757,97,102,11],[968,97,114,11],[757,105,97,32],[968,105,91,32],[757,133,179,27],[889,133,16,13],[968,133,176,27],[968,133,24,13],[1077,133,24,13],[757,183,102,11],[968,183,127,11],[757,191,97,32],[968,197,80,32],[757,219,150,39],[757,219,18,13],[865,219,12,13],[854,231,6,13],[968,231,177,27],[1084,231,32,13],[1014,244,6,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above the headline.","boxes":[[40,96,315,13],[363,96,7,13],[379,96,169,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explains the post rather than the chart.","boxes":[[40,203,666,55],[240,203,256,17],[576,222,102,17],[190,240,103,17],[365,240,46,17],[428,240,257,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe diagram","reason":"Method pipeline beside a results chart is a second idea.","boxes":[[40,303,24,16],[72,303,468,15],[595,303,565,15],[46,305,13,12],[57,338,236,152],[57,338,236,5],[325,338,262,70],[873,338,270,152],[335,346,54,14],[396,347,89,11],[885,347,54,15],[69,348,168,11],[340,348,37,10],[947,348,122,11],[890,349,37,10],[69,357,160,25],[667,360,134,17],[885,360,170,25],[335,361,180,15],[681,363,105,10],[885,377,142,25],[335,378,175,13],[69,383,102,18],[176,383,105,18],[617,383,224,107],[75,386,60,12],[182,386,80,12],[627,389,167,11],[335,390,156,13],[885,404,246,38],[69,405,102,18],[176,405,105,18],[627,405,204,22],[75,408,68,12],[182,408,67,12],[894,409,184,11],[673,410,72,13],[786,411,37,10],[634,412,8,8],[646,412,8,8],[658,412,8,8],[325,416,262,74],[894,423,172,14],[335,424,54,14],[340,426,37,10],[396,426,179,10],[627,431,204,26],[772,435,51,17],[69,436,107,13],[673,437,75,13],[335,439,170,15],[634,439,9,9],[646,439,9,9],[658,439,9,9],[779,439,37,10],[885,449,205,14],[990,449,71,13],[69,451,175,13],[335,456,185,13],[627,461,204,22],[69,464,160,13],[885,464,240,14],[961,464,70,13],[673,466,67,13],[786,467,37,10],[634,468,8,8],[646,468,8,8],[658,468,8,8],[335,469,195,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section header extras","reason":"Section number and source subtitle are unneeded.","boxes":[[40,543,24,16],[538,544,622,15],[46,545,13,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section 02 header","reason":"Section number and label restating the chart title.","boxes":[[72,544,403,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Data table","reason":"Table repeats every value in the chart.","boxes":[[761,578,157,11],[761,591,230,26],[761,624,117,23],[878,624,59,23],[937,624,85,23],[1023,624,63,23],[1086,624,59,23],[766,629,35,13],[896,629,36,13],[961,629,57,13],[1041,629,40,13],[1104,629,36,13],[761,647,117,27],[878,647,59,27],[937,647,85,27],[1023,647,63,27],[1086,647,59,27],[766,653,39,14],[904,653,28,14],[990,653,28,14],[1053,653,28,14],[1112,653,28,14],[761,674,117,27],[878,674,59,27],[937,674,85,27],[1023,674,63,27],[1086,674,59,27],[766,680,71,14],[904,680,28,14],[990,680,28,14],[1053,680,28,14],[1112,680,28,14],[761,701,117,27],[878,701,59,27],[937,701,85,27],[1023,701,63,27],[1086,701,59,27],[766,707,81,14],[904,707,28,14],[990,707,28,14],[1053,707,28,14],[1112,707,28,14],[771,733,353,43],[771,748,368,27]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Chart title sentence","reason":"Full-sentence title; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[56,574,382,51]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Chart subtitle","reason":"Restates the values the bars already show.","boxes":[[56,624,380,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Inline value strips","reason":"Repeat bar values and gaps already shown.","boxes":[[539,679,27,13],[570,679,6,12],[580,679,27,13],[611,679,6,12],[626,679,27,13],[663,679,6,12],[673,679,27,13],[139,680,357,11],[169,820,236,14],[621,820,37,14],[539,821,27,13],[570,821,6,12],[580,821,27,13],[611,821,6,12],[626,821,27,13],[663,821,6,12],[673,821,27,13],[175,822,224,11],[170,956,200,14],[621,956,37,14],[539,957,27,13],[570,957,6,12],[580,957,27,13],[611,957,6,12],[626,957,27,13],[663,957,6,12],[673,957,27,13],[176,958,188,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Technical report quote","reason":"Quote box is a side panel.","boxes":[[762,832,261,11],[762,846,381,178],[1012,846,120,18],[1015,846,114,18],[855,926,229,18],[858,926,223,18],[762,974,143,18],[765,974,137,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"OPD validation card","reason":"Separate result on a different model and method.","boxes":[[794,1076,163,11],[1072,1077,75,25],[759,1085,25,25],[794,1088,244,30],[826,1103,88,14],[1065,1103,82,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Chart takeaway","reason":"Takeaway sentence under the chart.","boxes":[[56,1103,411,15]]}],"usd":0.72258,"sec":908,"out":71836,"cut":211,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.9},"score":0,"words":34,"missing":["metric or unit"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a single chart with a short title, legend, and logo; only the metric or unit is unstated.","marks":[],"usd":0.468018,"sec":739,"out":46341,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-medium__raw","clutter":71.9,"shares":{"blue":28.1,"orange":0,"red":71.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":52.6},"score":8,"words":528,"missing":[],"summary":"A small GDPval chart is buried under a stat card, a second chart, a recipe diagram and extra tags, so most of the canvas is extras.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date byline","reason":"Blog metadata is not part of the graphic's point.","boxes":[[910,32,26,15],[943,32,3,15],[955,32,62,15],[1025,32,3,15],[1036,32,121,15],[896,34,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Lab tagline","reason":"Tagline next to the logo, not needed.","boxes":[[196,33,425,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tags","reason":"Kicker tags above the headline.","boxes":[[43,110,418,20],[52,114,400,12],[471,114,227,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Dark stat card","reason":"Repeats 28.9, 35.3, 46.7 and the gap shown in the chart.","boxes":[[1099,125,92,16],[884,127,119,12],[1105,127,80,12],[1025,152,86,43],[946,166,52,25],[873,168,47,23],[929,173,8,17],[1007,173,8,17],[873,197,300,15],[873,234,181,15],[898,234,49,14],[1123,235,68,13],[873,267,289,15],[1022,267,37,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restating the chart and post.","boxes":[[43,225,701,37],[243,225,251,17],[656,225,73,17],[251,244,101,17],[394,244,100,17],[527,244,26,17],[571,244,25,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Model spec chips","reason":"Context length and throughput are a separate point.","boxes":[[52,277,34,15],[363,277,41,15],[492,277,60,15],[91,278,247,13],[409,278,58,13],[557,278,266,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section subtitle","reason":"Subtitle and marker that explain the chart.","boxes":[[43,354,6,13],[302,356,396,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Cross-domain bars","reason":"Second chart with three benchmarks, repeating GDPval.","boxes":[[568,400,273,17],[854,402,286,13],[594,441,46,17],[853,441,273,17],[647,442,148,15],[860,443,259,13],[582,444,5,11],[582,464,39,14],[1099,465,27,13],[582,482,57,14],[1099,483,27,13],[666,484,264,10],[582,500,43,14],[1099,501,27,13],[666,502,350,10],[582,518,39,14],[1099,519,27,13],[666,520,371,10],[594,562,83,17],[911,562,215,17],[684,563,114,15],[918,564,201,13],[582,565,5,11],[582,585,39,14],[1099,586,27,13],[666,587,232,10],[582,603,57,14],[1099,604,27,13],[666,605,247,10],[582,621,43,14],[1099,622,27,13],[666,623,333,10],[582,639,39,14],[1099,640,27,13],[666,641,382,10],[594,683,84,17],[950,683,176,17],[685,684,105,15],[957,685,162,13],[582,686,5,11],[582,706,39,14],[1099,707,27,13],[666,708,192,10],[582,724,57,14],[1099,725,27,13],[666,726,197,10],[582,742,42,14],[1099,743,27,13],[666,744,200,10],[582,760,39,14],[1099,761,27,13],[666,762,240,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Chart subtitle","reason":"Restates the chart values.","boxes":[[317,402,201,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"GDPval table repeat","reason":"Same GDPval numbers as the hill-climb chart, plus a callout repeating the gain.","boxes":[[666,466,217,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart caption","reason":"Sentence restating the 2.8 point gap.","boxes":[[60,754,443,30],[83,769,50,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe panels","reason":"Three method cards, a separate second idea.","boxes":[[58,845,557,31],[43,854,6,13],[859,854,298,13],[70,898,119,12],[272,898,74,12],[402,898,188,12],[669,898,111,12],[836,898,175,12],[1043,898,99,12],[58,899,6,11],[390,899,6,11],[824,899,6,11],[58,911,236,26],[390,911,345,26],[824,911,300,26],[58,940,283,63],[934,948,97,89],[826,950,97,85],[1043,950,97,85],[394,951,383,31],[394,951,5,31],[406,954,283,13],[945,954,77,13],[838,956,72,12],[1057,956,69,12],[406,967,277,11],[842,978,17,17],[866,978,17,17],[890,978,17,17],[951,978,17,17],[975,978,17,17],[998,978,17,17],[1059,978,17,17],[1083,978,17,17],[1107,978,17,17],[847,983,8,5],[871,983,8,5],[895,983,8,5],[956,983,8,5],[980,983,7,7],[1003,983,8,5],[1064,983,7,7],[1088,983,7,7],[1112,983,7,7],[481,991,7,5],[682,991,7,5],[394,998,180,65],[597,998,180,65],[853,1002,44,10],[953,1002,61,10],[1069,1002,44,10],[403,1004,96,10],[606,1004,96,10],[403,1015,125,13],[606,1015,137,13],[67,1016,48,15],[214,1016,72,15],[850,1016,50,10],[945,1016,76,15],[1066,1016,50,10],[115,1018,65,13],[957,1018,52,10],[590,1027,5,7],[403,1030,130,11],[606,1030,119,11],[67,1031,110,39],[214,1031,120,27],[403,1042,102,11],[606,1042,113,11],[826,1044,314,23],[837,1050,163,12],[1000,1050,130,11],[400,1075,344,28],[824,1075,297,28],[390,1076,390,28],[58,1087,79,17],[141,1087,73,17],[218,1087,62,17],[284,1087,57,17],[64,1090,67,11],[147,1090,61,11],[224,1090,50,11],[290,1090,45,11]]}],"usd":0.72162,"sec":1135,"out":71740,"cut":209,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.7},"score":0,"words":34,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one grouped bar chart with a short title, legend, value labels and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.275858,"sec":456,"out":27125,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon__raw","clutter":59.8,"shares":{"blue":39.2,"orange":2.1,"red":58.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":51.8},"score":7,"words":462,"missing":[],"summary":"The warmup bar chart is buried among method diagrams, spec cards, explainer panels, stat boxes and header badges, but nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header metadata","reason":"Blog date, authors and partner badge are not needed.","boxes":[[801,41,351,24],[238,45,99,15],[671,45,119,16],[812,46,329,14],[225,48,6,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Model spec card","reason":"Model specs are a separate idea from the warmup result.","boxes":[[1041,161,94,15],[779,162,138,12],[779,189,96,31],[903,189,83,31],[1044,189,85,31],[779,218,107,27],[903,218,123,27],[1044,218,72,41]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the post and the chart.","boxes":[[48,231,655,62],[48,231,668,39],[275,231,286,18],[515,252,52,18],[319,274,66,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Recipe diagram","reason":"Method pipeline card beside the results chart is a second idea.","boxes":[[422,355,226,18],[80,357,318,13],[430,358,210,12],[67,361,6,6],[69,403,161,192],[69,403,161,26],[443,403,203,85],[90,410,119,11],[452,412,56,16],[516,412,94,14],[462,415,38,10],[262,432,136,134],[452,433,144,13],[81,435,122,14],[295,444,68,11],[397,445,40,25],[452,448,153,14],[81,450,96,14],[280,454,98,24],[452,463,121,14],[301,470,56,24],[79,473,141,23],[97,478,113,14],[85,481,6,6],[79,501,141,23],[311,504,11,11],[361,504,11,11],[287,505,8,8],[337,505,8,8],[97,506,114,14],[85,509,6,6],[443,509,203,85],[452,518,56,16],[516,519,88,14],[462,522,38,10],[282,523,95,14],[397,527,40,25],[79,529,141,23],[97,534,87,14],[267,536,125,13],[85,537,6,6],[452,539,163,13],[452,555,157,14],[79,557,141,23],[97,562,95,14],[85,565,6,6],[452,569,142,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"PivotRL diagram","reason":"Second method diagram unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[975,355,158,18],[717,357,180,13],[983,358,142,12],[704,361,6,6],[708,405,422,32],[719,414,196,13],[981,416,137,10],[849,447,140,114],[708,451,132,106],[997,451,132,106],[875,456,86,14],[733,459,82,13],[1024,459,78,13],[867,473,104,10],[732,475,83,10],[1022,475,83,10],[877,493,21,21],[908,493,21,21],[940,493,21,21],[737,495,19,19],[765,495,19,19],[793,495,19,19],[1026,495,19,19],[1054,495,19,19],[1082,495,19,19],[883,497,8,14],[914,497,8,14],[946,497,8,14],[742,498,8,14],[770,498,8,14],[798,498,8,14],[1031,498,8,14],[1059,498,8,14],[1087,498,8,14],[720,527,108,20],[861,527,116,22],[1009,527,108,20],[743,532,62,10],[1032,532,62,10],[873,533,90,10],[708,569,422,29],[754,577,330,14],[866,577,49,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section label","reason":"Numbered section tag with table reference adds nothing.","boxes":[[84,670,387,13],[71,674,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"GDPval explainer panel","reason":"Side panel of benchmark facts is a separate idea.","boxes":[[888,683,191,12],[888,700,238,68],[969,717,37,15],[888,735,204,33],[897,780,39,26],[1022,780,43,26],[897,805,76,28],[1022,805,78,28],[897,850,42,26],[1022,850,69,26],[897,875,57,28],[1022,875,86,28]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Chart title","reason":"Sentence-style chart title; could be shorter.","boxes":[[71,681,536,34]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart subtitle","reason":"Restates values already shown on the bars.","boxes":[[71,714,699,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"GDPval lift callouts","reason":"Lift and delta restate bar differences.","boxes":[[93,842,94,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Row annotations","reason":"Repeat lifts already visible in bars.","boxes":[[93,927,107,15],[93,944,100,11],[93,1019,64,15],[93,1036,94,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Other benchmark bars","reason":"BrowseComp and HLE are secondary benchmarks beyond the main claim.","boxes":[[605,936,138,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"OPD validation card","reason":"Separate result about Nano and OPD.","boxes":[[888,980,165,12],[888,988,100,48],[998,1012,111,14],[888,1033,239,48],[888,1050,93,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline.","boxes":[[48,1151,56,14],[104,1151,443,15]]}],"usd":0.33121,"sec":489,"out":32699,"cut":149,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__argon__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.8},"score":0,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete; the only gap is that the y-axis unit or metric is unstated, which is minor.","marks":[],"usd":0.167758,"sec":338,"out":16315,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-high__raw","clutter":19.2,"shares":{"blue":80.8,"orange":0,"red":19.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.4},"score":4,"words":93,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a big sentence headline, a subtitle restating values, a tag, a pipeline banner and a footer URL.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag 'Research / Model training' tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[882,62,254,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence restates the chart's 35.3 to 46.7 result.","boxes":[[64,329,685,67]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline banner","reason":"Process flow is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[94,987,385,15],[94,1023,242,32],[528,1023,194,32],[915,1023,191,32],[407,1030,46,18],[794,1030,46,18]]}],"usd":0.26486,"sec":137,"out":4898,"cut":9,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.9},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with a short title, value labels, category labels and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.13092,"sec":69,"out":2181,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-medium__raw","clutter":26.4,"shares":{"blue":73.2,"orange":0.8,"red":26,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.7},"score":4,"words":107,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a category tag, subtitle, big 2.8 callout, pipeline strip and footer URL; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Research / Office agents is a series tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[871,63,265,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Subtitle explaining and restating what the chart shows.","boxes":[[64,323,633,62]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Row sublabels","reason":"Second-line descriptions on each row make the labels wordier than needed.","boxes":[[82,736,199,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"2.8 callout","reason":"Big stat callout restating the gap and values the bars already show.","boxes":[[64,888,84,106],[176,911,527,60],[355,942,44,27],[429,942,43,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline flow","reason":"Method pipeline strip beside a results chart is a second idea.","boxes":[[64,1026,171,22],[257,1026,13,22],[293,1026,193,22],[507,1026,13,22],[543,1026,174,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo already appears.","boxes":[[1043,1077,93,19]]}],"usd":0.14761,"sec":67,"out":2553,"cut":13,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":["metric unit"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title and logo, but the values lack a named metric or unit.","marks":[],"usd":0.13622,"sec":67,"out":2287,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":12.5,"shares":{"blue":85.2,"orange":4.4,"red":10.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.1},"score":4,"words":85,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear four-bar chart is cluttered by a kicker, eyebrow, sentence subtitle, method pipeline strip and duplicate brand footer; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section tag","reason":"Kicker tag adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[958,63,178,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline; model name is context but redundant.","boxes":[[64,157,225,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Full-sentence finding; the chart could show the gap visually.","boxes":[[64,377,741,32],[358,377,106,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline strip","reason":"Method pipeline is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,995,365,15],[121,1028,178,26],[548,1028,171,26],[968,1028,163,26],[71,1039,28,32],[516,1040,5,5],[941,1040,6,6],[496,1043,32,23],[918,1043,27,24],[76,1046,19,18],[373,1049,43,12],[793,1049,43,12],[927,1051,8,8],[497,1057,5,5],[121,1059,129,21],[548,1059,169,21],[968,1059,168,21],[916,1062,5,5],[943,1064,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1030,1137,106,21]]}],"usd":0.40196,"sec":157,"out":7640,"cut":23,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.5},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single two-bar chart with a benchmark title, one logo, and no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.23552,"sec":122,"out":4273,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra__raw","clutter":22.5,"shares":{"blue":77.5,"orange":0,"red":22.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.3},"score":4,"words":100,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid results chart is cluttered by a training-method pipeline row, a kicker and a restating subtitle, plus a repeated URL; it names the benchmark, metric and bars fully.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header category tag","reason":"Category tag repeating the model name; tells the reader nothing new.","boxes":[[808,64,328,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above the headline; decorative and not needed.","boxes":[[64,153,357,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle restating chart","reason":"Sentence restates the 35.3 to 46.7 change the bars already show.","boxes":[[64,348,642,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline row","reason":"Training-method flow is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,974,221,29],[474,974,178,29],[839,974,175,29],[424,985,22,37],[789,985,22,37],[64,1010,230,21],[474,1010,218,21],[839,1010,195,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Brand already shown in the logo; URL is a repeat of brand presence.","boxes":[[1043,1100,93,19]]}],"usd":0.17026,"sec":67,"out":3006,"cut":13,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__astra__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.4},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple bar chart with title, metric, values, category labels and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.13172,"sec":57,"out":2197,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":25,"shares":{"blue":75,"orange":0,"red":25,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.8},"score":5,"words":136,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid benchmark chart is surrounded by an eyebrow, tag, restating subtitle, repeated stat cards and a method pipeline that should all go; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header section tag","reason":"Category tag and date add nothing to the finding","boxes":[[912,72,212,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above the headline; restates the topic","boxes":[[92,159,389,15],[76,164,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restates the chart's numbers and finding","boxes":[[76,360,322,26],[183,360,801,56],[76,389,107,26],[363,389,90,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards row","reason":"Restates the gaps the bars already show, plus other benchmarks","boxes":[[76,937,88,65],[425,937,88,65],[775,937,80,65],[171,969,22,13],[520,969,22,13],[861,969,22,13],[76,999,46,18],[425,999,85,18],[775,999,86,18],[76,1020,161,13],[425,1020,167,13],[775,1020,167,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline footer","reason":"Method flow is a second idea beside the results chart","boxes":[[76,1093,174,14],[261,1093,7,14],[279,1093,407,14],[449,1093,7,14],[554,1093,7,14]]}],"usd":0.011693549999999999,"sec":88,"out":18983,"cut":28,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":["metric or unit"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a single bar chart with a finding headline and logo, but the score values lack a stated metric or unit.","marks":[],"usd":0.00654405,"sec":50,"out":10352,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-max__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":68.2,"shares":{"blue":31.8,"orange":0,"red":68.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":5,"words":116,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid line chart is surrounded by a tag, eyebrow, restating subtitle, 2.8 callout, pill and tagline; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Background shapes","reason":"Decorative background and divider.","boxes":[[0,0,1200,1200],[64,52,154,26],[0,56,1200,162],[0,191,1200,205]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note tag","reason":"Category tag and date are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[963,55,173,13],[1050,71,86,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline; adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[81,138,345,13],[64,142,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates values already shown in the chart.","boxes":[[64,363,838,53],[252,363,294,23],[902,363,37,23],[84,391,36,23],[271,391,81,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"2.8 stat callout","reason":"Big stat restates the gap already shown between points.","boxes":[[865,465,61,79],[934,514,95,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative background shapes","reason":"Full-width bands and faint curves are decorative with no data.","boxes":[[0,471,1200,235],[0,514,1200,223],[0,554,1200,221],[10,714,1190,222],[0,742,1200,165],[42,770,1158,209]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline, promotional.","boxes":[[916,1102,220,11]]}],"usd":0.02656755,"sec":291,"out":43773,"cut":22,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-max__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.3},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, value labels and category labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.028292249999999998,"sec":276,"out":46599,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":50.5,"shares":{"blue":49.5,"orange":0,"red":50.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.4},"score":6,"words":131,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid grouped bar chart is surrounded by a slogan headline, a stat callout, a paragraph, eyebrow and date tags, and a second brand mark; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Kicker/tag line with date, not needed.","boxes":[[885,63,251,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline, adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[81,155,316,15],[64,160,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Huge slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[62,171,553,201]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat callout panel","reason":"Restates 46.7, 35.3 and gap already shown by bars.","boxes":[[880,184,154,138],[883,192,169,14],[920,307,32,20],[883,308,186,21],[883,353,80,46],[971,372,122,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explains and restates the chart.","boxes":[[64,383,710,84],[109,440,40,26],[176,440,39,26],[358,440,88,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark, logo already present.","boxes":[[1028,1106,108,30]]}],"usd":0.00885975,"sec":70,"out":14260,"cut":16,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":19.6},"score":0,"words":21,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled bars, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.00415545,"sec":36,"out":6371,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":11.3,"shares":{"blue":88.7,"orange":0,"red":11.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":6,"words":169,"missing":[],"summary":"The chart is buried under a giant headline, a repeated 46.7 stat, pills, a takeaway card, an also-measured panel and extra footnotes. Nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Case study date","reason":"Tag and date add nothing to reading the chart.","boxes":[[938,53,79,13],[1050,53,86,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline.","boxes":[[77,138,83,13],[171,138,8,13],[191,138,192,13],[64,139,3,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"46.7 stat callout","reason":"Big stat restates the Warmup bar and the No warmup value.","boxes":[[863,153,273,201],[998,172,138,12],[951,339,185,19],[1004,339,28,18],[972,371,164,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence explaining context; restates the post and chart.","boxes":[[65,395,438,59],[65,395,560,57]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat pills","reason":"Model and dataset size facts unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[89,503,99,11],[222,503,13,11],[242,503,72,11],[348,503,33,11],[388,503,33,11],[78,507,4,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Legend","reason":"Legend duplicates the row labels on each bar.","boxes":[[850,599,36,14],[917,599,52,14],[1000,599,38,14],[1069,599,36,14],[835,602,9,9],[902,602,9,9],[985,602,9,9],[1054,602,9,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"2.8 takeaway card","reason":"Restates the gap between the Warmup and Teacher bars.","boxes":[[842,672,83,11],[842,678,118,90],[966,725,33,32],[842,764,210,37],[842,764,206,36]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Also measured panel","reason":"Other benchmarks serve a second point beyond the GDPval bars.","boxes":[[842,842,89,11],[1031,865,28,18],[1078,865,28,18],[842,868,67,14],[1059,870,18,12],[1051,889,9,9],[997,890,7,7],[1034,912,28,18],[1080,912,26,18],[842,915,68,14],[1061,917,18,12],[966,936,9,9],[965,937,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Only data partner","reason":"Promotional claim unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[842,1003,257,57],[842,1003,220,38]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Mirror note","reason":"Explanatory text that is not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[95,1009,257,10],[95,1023,322,10]]}],"usd":0.01718535,"sec":130,"out":28136,"cut":54,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart, short title, logo, labelled bars with values.","marks":[],"usd":0.00709905,"sec":66,"out":11277,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek__raw","clutter":28.3,"shares":{"blue":71.7,"orange":0,"red":28.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.1},"score":5,"words":160,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid grouped bar chart is cluttered by a kicker, an intro paragraph, a stat-card row repeating bar values, and a footer tagline.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Date and category tag tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[990,60,146,13],[971,64,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline.","boxes":[[102,132,158,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the chart values and adds a side claim.","boxes":[[286,324,367,24],[64,325,925,84],[107,383,38,24],[171,383,37,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat callout row","reason":"Restates values already labelled on the bars.","boxes":[[64,977,56,63],[439,977,77,63],[814,977,68,63],[120,998,29,34],[64,1036,230,32],[439,1037,70,14],[509,1037,189,15],[814,1037,71,14],[885,1037,182,15],[64,1053,39,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline and second brand mention; the logo already exists.","boxes":[[64,1137,389,26],[1008,1137,128,26]]}],"usd":0.00853815,"sec":89,"out":13724,"cut":21,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__deepseek__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.1},"score":1,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: one bar chart with a short title, labelled stages and values; only the model tag is arguably optional.","marks":[],"usd":0.00923805,"sec":196,"out":14842,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":71.1,"shares":{"blue":25.5,"orange":6.9,"red":67.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":46.5},"score":7,"words":424,"missing":[],"summary":"The small bar chart is buried under a second architecture panel, a table, stat cards, callouts, a quote and header tags; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tags","reason":"Badge, tagline, date and URL tell reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[215,43,145,13],[711,43,224,13],[959,43,80,13],[1053,43,101,13],[699,44,6,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the chart in two lines; shorten to one line of finding.","boxes":[[46,197,887,44],[227,197,246,19],[933,197,155,19],[173,220,70,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training architecture panel","reason":"Pipeline cards and spec bar serve a separate method idea.","boxes":[[669,314,147,13],[981,314,148,20],[657,315,6,11],[990,318,130,12],[657,326,311,31],[657,376,254,12],[1022,376,107,12],[714,403,76,14],[954,403,102,14],[699,406,11,11],[939,406,11,11],[675,411,8,10],[680,411,3,3],[914,412,10,9],[699,419,165,14],[939,419,160,14],[714,457,64,14],[954,457,85,14],[699,460,11,11],[939,460,11,11],[915,465,8,10],[675,466,9,9],[699,473,178,14],[939,473,139,27],[708,530,172,15],[670,539,26,26],[681,544,2,195],[676,546,14,13],[708,546,370,28],[721,592,185,11],[707,597,6,3],[708,620,201,15],[670,629,26,26],[676,635,14,13],[708,636,397,28],[721,681,240,11],[707,687,6,3],[708,710,198,15],[670,719,26,26],[676,725,14,13],[708,725,394,28],[681,835,157,28],[871,837,142,24],[1048,837,6,12],[1065,837,43,24],[669,844,5,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Chart eyebrow and pill","reason":"Section tag and source pill add nothing.","boxes":[[83,314,126,13],[396,314,191,20],[71,315,6,11],[405,318,173,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Lift callout strip","reason":"Restates lifts the bars already show.","boxes":[[84,612,78,18],[170,613,149,16],[319,613,65,15],[91,614,64,14],[390,614,184,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Domain table","reason":"Second table repeating GDPval and adding other benchmarks.","boxes":[[71,666,287,12],[488,666,99,12],[71,685,159,35],[230,685,57,35],[287,685,69,35],[357,685,82,35],[438,685,57,35],[496,685,91,35],[293,690,39,24],[363,690,39,24],[77,696,39,12],[236,696,45,12],[444,696,45,12],[502,696,45,12],[71,719,159,45],[230,719,57,45],[287,719,69,45],[357,719,82,45],[438,719,57,45],[502,726,79,32],[509,728,37,28],[77,734,116,15],[236,735,30,14],[293,735,30,14],[363,735,30,14],[444,735,30,14],[71,764,159,45],[230,764,57,45],[287,764,69,45],[357,764,82,45],[438,764,57,45],[502,771,79,32],[77,772,106,30],[509,773,37,28],[236,780,30,14],[293,780,30,14],[363,780,30,14],[444,780,30,14],[77,816,75,15],[236,816,30,14],[293,816,30,14],[363,816,30,14],[444,816,30,14],[502,816,59,14],[73,844,498,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards row","reason":"Repeats 46.7 and 2.8, adds unrelated claims.","boxes":[[47,904,263,3],[328,904,263,3],[609,904,263,3],[890,904,263,3],[63,918,80,12],[344,918,94,12],[625,918,120,12],[906,918,107,12],[288,919,6,11],[569,919,6,11],[850,919,6,11],[1131,919,6,11],[63,932,72,59],[344,932,57,59],[625,932,68,59],[906,941,152,45],[401,953,25,30],[63,992,42,14],[105,992,136,15],[344,992,186,15],[625,992,177,15],[906,992,173,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Quote footer","reason":"Long quote, second brand mention and benchmark facts are extras.","boxes":[[80,1081,594,55],[65,1099,3,36],[989,1103,146,14],[702,1119,433,12],[80,1138,426,13]]}],"usd":0.40469055,"sec":729,"out":97679,"cut":157,"shrunk":4},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.9},"score":0,"words":20,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a logo, a context tag, and labelled bars.","marks":[],"usd":0.295514175,"sec":622,"out":71173,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":71.9,"shares":{"blue":28.1,"orange":0,"red":71.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.7},"score":7,"words":418,"missing":[],"summary":"The small dot chart is buried under stat cards, a duplicate table, callouts, a recipe diagram, header pills and footer branding; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header pills","reason":"Date and tag pills are badges; not needed.","boxes":[[717,38,97,23],[822,38,178,23],[728,43,75,13],[833,43,156,13],[1031,43,116,13],[1019,47,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tagline","reason":"Tagline next to logo adds nothing.","boxes":[[201,43,192,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[55,138,295,13],[42,139,5,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates results shown in chart.","boxes":[[42,208,1049,61],[445,229,29,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Four stat cards, mostly unrelated ideas or repeating chart values.","boxes":[[57,347,183,12],[357,347,122,12],[643,347,176,12],[914,347,122,12],[57,354,60,50],[357,354,59,50],[643,354,57,50],[914,354,156,50],[57,399,229,30],[357,399,234,30],[643,399,226,30],[914,399,217,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Ablation table","reason":"Table repeats the same numbers the chart shows.","boxes":[[711,522,219,15],[974,525,167,12],[711,556,112,22],[823,556,65,22],[888,556,65,22],[953,556,65,22],[1017,556,65,22],[1082,556,59,22],[717,561,38,11],[838,561,44,11],[903,561,44,11],[968,561,44,11],[1033,561,44,11],[1097,561,39,11],[711,577,112,29],[823,577,65,29],[888,577,65,29],[953,577,65,29],[1017,577,65,29],[1082,577,59,29],[717,585,37,14],[855,585,27,13],[919,585,27,13],[984,585,27,13],[1049,585,27,13],[1101,585,34,13],[711,606,112,29],[823,606,65,29],[888,606,65,29],[953,606,65,29],[1017,606,65,29],[1082,606,59,29],[717,614,67,14],[855,614,27,13],[919,614,27,13],[984,614,27,13],[1049,614,27,13],[1101,614,34,13],[711,635,112,29],[823,635,65,29],[888,635,65,29],[953,635,65,29],[1017,635,65,29],[1082,635,59,29],[717,643,68,14],[855,643,27,13],[919,643,27,13],[984,643,27,13],[1049,643,27,13],[1108,643,27,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway callouts","reason":"Sentences restating chart takeaways.","boxes":[[722,687,404,30],[722,687,136,14],[928,687,22,14],[754,702,50,14],[722,739,408,46],[722,739,143,14],[911,739,24,14],[865,754,22,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Recipe diagram","reason":"Method pipeline cards are a second idea; outcome bar repeats.","boxes":[[59,885,320,15],[813,888,328,12],[72,930,135,11],[408,930,193,11],[798,930,219,11],[72,945,180,15],[408,945,130,15],[798,945,149,15],[72,964,269,43],[373,964,11,11],[408,964,309,43],[763,964,11,11],[798,964,323,43],[912,979,107,13],[408,994,105,13],[574,1034,554,15],[708,1034,77,14],[808,1034,108,14],[72,1036,103,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline.","boxes":[[714,1149,91,13],[813,1149,7,13],[827,1149,331,13]]}],"usd":0.25594305,"sec":502,"out":61619,"cut":120,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.2},"score":0,"words":21,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, a logo, ticks, labels and values.","marks":[],"usd":0.305026425,"sec":684,"out":73479,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":50.9,"shares":{"blue":44.5,"orange":9.1,"red":46.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36},"score":6,"words":247,"missing":[],"summary":"The ablation chart is solid but shares the canvas with a stat card, architecture card, pipeline steps, quote, header tags and a second brand mention; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Partnership pill","reason":"Badge restating the post topic; not needed.","boxes":[[834,56,302,28],[849,63,272,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Technical Research tag","reason":"Category tag next to logo.","boxes":[[233,63,151,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[78,131,301,14],[64,135,6,6]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Long sentence explaining method; could be shortened or dropped.","boxes":[[64,213,982,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"GDPval impact card","reason":"Restates 46.7, +11.4, 35.3 already shown in chart.","boxes":[[767,306,94,13],[767,314,72,59],[846,344,86,17],[853,345,72,15],[767,370,335,56],[1019,370,27,17],[1063,370,26,17],[940,389,59,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Architecture card","reason":"Model size and throughput is unrelated to the ablation chart.","boxes":[[765,483,210,13],[765,491,83,59],[855,514,64,28],[765,547,325,56],[765,547,341,36]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training steps panel","reason":"Method pipeline cards beside the results chart.","boxes":[[765,657,217,13],[804,795,172,15],[776,796,18,18],[781,799,7,13],[804,813,276,31],[804,870,191,15],[776,871,18,18],[781,873,7,13],[804,887,285,31],[804,944,162,15],[776,945,18,18],[781,948,7,13],[804,962,296,31]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Report quote","reason":"Quote bar serves a second point about partnership.","boxes":[[270,1052,774,44],[86,1059,172,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer branding","reason":"Second brand mention and URL when a logo exists.","boxes":[[64,1140,155,16],[1038,1142,98,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand line","reason":"Brand and URL repeat the logo already at top.","boxes":[[233,1147,3,3]]}],"usd":0.11906317500000001,"sec":251,"out":28436,"cut":44,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":23.9},"score":0,"words":17,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values, and a logo; nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.082424925,"sec":285,"out":19515,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-high__raw","clutter":18.2,"shares":{"blue":81.8,"orange":0,"red":18.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.3},"score":5,"words":94,"missing":["benchmark name on chart"],"summary":"A solid GDPval chart is cluttered by a subtitle, date, gap stat and a BrowseComp/HLE row; the metric is only implied.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag adds nothing to reading the chart.","boxes":[[971,61,173,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker line","reason":"Kicker above headline restates the chart's context","boxes":[[56,124,463,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating post context, not needed for chart.","boxes":[[56,316,759,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Remaining gap stat","reason":"Restates 49.5 minus 46.7 difference already visible in chart.","boxes":[[56,875,155,14],[56,878,79,100],[56,965,221,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Other benchmark stats","reason":"BrowseComp and HLE results are a second idea beside the chart.","boxes":[[463,875,91,14],[821,875,127,14],[463,901,82,45],[579,901,82,45],[821,901,82,45],[938,901,82,45],[555,921,14,21],[914,921,14,21],[463,954,95,21],[821,954,94,21],[599,993,2,18],[930,993,2,18],[463,998,185,8],[821,998,111,8]]}],"usd":0.39879,"sec":1009,"out":65780,"cut":20,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":["metric / score unit"],"summary":"Clean single bar chart with benchmark title and labelled bars; only the metric/unit is unstated, and the AfterQuery logo shown in the screenshot is absent from the element list.","marks":[],"usd":0.128796,"sec":370,"out":20716,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-medium__raw","clutter":17.7,"shares":{"blue":82.3,"orange":0,"red":17.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.9},"score":5,"words":95,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid GDPval bar chart is cluttered by a second logo, a 2.8 stat callout, a subtitle, extra benchmark rows and a partner footnote; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Second logo badge","reason":"Brand shown a second time.","boxes":[[1086,52,42,34]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[903,62,159,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Model eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline, not needed","boxes":[[64,124,233,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"2.8 stat callout","reason":"Restates the gap between the Warmup and Teacher bars.","boxes":[[1007,142,129,169],[1088,168,48,2],[1011,282,125,41]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating what the chart shows.","boxes":[[64,348,748,61]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BrowseComp and HLE rows","reason":"Other benchmarks serve a second point beside the main chart.","boxes":[[303,963,45,22],[538,963,45,22],[773,963,45,22],[1008,963,45,22],[64,965,91,19],[303,1003,45,22],[538,1003,45,22],[773,1003,45,22],[1008,1003,45,22],[64,1005,93,19]]}],"usd":0.216732,"sec":691,"out":35437,"cut":18,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":1,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark tag, category labels, values and a logo. The metric unit is not stated, which is minor.","marks":[],"usd":0.065886,"sec":217,"out":10231,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":28.5,"shares":{"blue":71.5,"orange":0,"red":28.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.7},"score":4,"words":125,"missing":["metric unit"],"summary":"Solid grouped bar chart, but metadata, eyebrow, subtitle, per-bar labels duplicating the legend, notes and a takeaway sentence clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date and authors","reason":"Blog metadata tells the reader nothing about the chart.","boxes":[[989,52,143,18],[983,75,149,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[68,149,213,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates GDPval bars and the 2.8 annotation.","boxes":[[68,342,807,60]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Per-bar row labels","reason":"Repeat the legend on every bar.","boxes":[[159,570,50,18],[137,598,72,18],[156,626,53,18],[159,654,50,18],[159,736,50,18],[137,764,72,18],[156,792,53,18],[159,820,50,18],[159,902,50,18],[137,930,72,18],[156,958,53,18],[159,986,50,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart note text","reason":"Restates values the bars show; legend already explains terms.","boxes":[[101,1006,559,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence","reason":"Slogan-like claim unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[68,1089,573,62]]}],"usd":0.280356,"sec":1098,"out":46041,"cut":20,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with benchmark name, labelled bars, values and a logo; only the score unit goes unstated.","marks":[],"usd":0.212514,"sec":584,"out":34669,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok__raw","clutter":29.7,"shares":{"blue":70.3,"orange":0,"red":29.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.8},"score":5,"words":125,"missing":["metric or unit"],"summary":"A sentence headline, subtitle paragraph, three stat cards restating bar values and a redundant footnote crowd a decent grouped bar chart; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Date tag adds nothing needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[959,63,177,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining method and restating the takeaway.","boxes":[[64,273,842,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Big cards restate 46.7, 49.5, gap already shown in bars.","boxes":[[87,387,177,14],[483,387,124,14],[830,387,115,14],[87,389,116,100],[483,389,111,100],[830,389,80,100],[87,476,196,20],[483,476,217,20],[830,476,169,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Explanatory footnote","reason":"Restates legend definitions and BrowseComp/HLE values shown in bars.","boxes":[[64,1113,710,39],[64,1113,50,18],[279,1113,50,18]]}],"usd":0.040854,"sec":91,"out":6124,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.4},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":["y-axis metric name"],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, ticks and labels, though it has no value labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.044202,"sec":133,"out":6617,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-high__raw","clutter":27.4,"shares":{"blue":72.6,"orange":0,"red":27.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.4},"score":5,"words":133,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear grouped bar chart is cluttered by a tag, a restating subtitle, a four-card pipeline row and a footer URL; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Case study tag","reason":"Category tag above headline, adds nothing.","boxes":[[929,73,199,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Summary subtitle","reason":"Restates the values the bars already show.","boxes":[[72,353,983,69],[479,389,132,31],[727,389,111,31]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline cards","reason":"Method steps serve a second idea unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[72,915,19,17],[340,915,19,17],[608,915,19,17],[876,915,19,17],[72,942,157,26],[340,942,205,26],[608,942,171,26],[876,942,168,26],[72,977,218,67],[340,977,207,44],[608,977,248,67],[876,977,247,67]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo is already present.","boxes":[[999,1108,129,17]]}],"usd":0.009886200000000001,"sec":103,"out":19131,"cut":21,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":52.3},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a metric label, values and category labels, plus an unlisted logo mark at top left.","marks":[],"usd":0.005523800000000001,"sec":64,"out":10352,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":31.5,"shares":{"blue":68.5,"orange":0,"red":31.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.2},"score":4,"words":105,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is buried under an eyebrow, a subtitle that restates the chart, a three-card stat row on other benchmarks, and a repeated brand; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[930,89,178,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline; restates headline and chart context.","boxes":[[92,180,342,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the chart values and gap already shown by the bars.","boxes":[[92,407,984,67],[916,407,48,30],[996,407,47,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Benchmark stat row","reason":"Other benchmarks and a repeated GDPval result, a second point beyond the chart.","boxes":[[92,965,59,17],[464,965,98,17],[802,965,137,17],[92,994,79,50],[179,994,31,53],[218,994,76,50],[464,994,80,50],[551,994,31,53],[591,994,81,50],[802,994,79,50],[890,994,31,53],[929,994,75,50],[92,1055,283,44],[464,1055,265,44],[802,1055,262,44]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already present.","boxes":[[92,1127,133,17]]}],"usd":0.0069007,"sec":79,"out":13160,"cut":24,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.5},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a metric title, labelled bars and values, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0034923000000000003,"sec":40,"out":6289,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":38.7,"shares":{"blue":60.5,"orange":1.7,"red":37.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.4},"score":5,"words":104,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear main bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, a restating subtitle, a second logo and a stats row on other benchmarks.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[1082,83,38,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline; the headline already names GDPval.","boxes":[[80,140,237,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the numbers the bars already show.","boxes":[[80,353,621,107]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Second logo","reason":"Brand mark repeated inside the chart.","boxes":[[1028,526,52,42]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Row sublabels","reason":"Sublabels repeat the row names in extra words.","boxes":[[120,647,170,17],[120,723,116,17],[120,799,134,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat row","reason":"Other benchmarks and dataset size are a separate point from the chart.","boxes":[[80,928,95,17],[456,928,133,17],[802,928,114,17],[80,941,273,87],[456,941,262,87],[802,941,124,87],[80,1025,180,23],[456,1025,213,23],[802,1025,269,47]]}],"usd":0.017706700000000002,"sec":177,"out":34772,"cut":16,"shrunk":3},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.2},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, logo, labelled bars and values.","marks":[],"usd":0.0100618,"sec":113,"out":19428,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku__raw","clutter":18.2,"shares":{"blue":81.8,"orange":0,"red":18.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":60.2},"score":4,"words":86,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a blog tag, three stat cards (two repeat the chart, one is an unrelated throughput claim) and a footer URL.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing for reader","boxes":[[881,75,239,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.4 stat card","reason":"Restates difference the bars already show","boxes":[[111,832,211,150],[111,969,204,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"2.8 stat card","reason":"Restates gap between warmup and teacher bars","boxes":[[469,832,126,150],[469,969,242,88]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"6x throughput card","reason":"Unrelated throughput claim, not shown in chart","boxes":[[827,832,167,150],[827,969,252,88]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo exists","boxes":[[985,1098,135,26]]}],"usd":0.0055132,"sec":65,"out":10385,"cut":11,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a metric title, value labels and category labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.0022933000000000003,"sec":30,"out":3891,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-high__raw","clutter":66,"shares":{"blue":34,"orange":0,"red":66,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.5},"score":7,"words":120,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear GDPval bar chart is buried under a slogan headline, subtitle, stat callout, second benchmark table, method strip and footer.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Tag line like 'Research · Model training' is unneeded.","boxes":[[903,70,229,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow above headline tells nothing needed.","boxes":[[68,144,175,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, does not state the finding.","boxes":[[68,168,385,134],[140,230,220,72]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explains the chart.","boxes":[[68,318,723,50]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.4 stat callout","reason":"Big stat restates difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[99,501,213,151],[99,644,128,52],[99,707,130,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence","reason":"Restates the 2.8-point gap the bars already show","boxes":[[446,775,290,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Other benchmarks table","reason":"Second benchmarks table beside main chart serves another point.","boxes":[[68,839,264,15],[258,866,52,14],[479,866,71,14],[700,866,51,14],[921,866,52,14],[258,912,33,23],[479,912,37,23],[700,912,37,23],[921,912,32,23],[68,913,104,22],[299,921,21,5],[524,921,22,5],[745,921,30,5],[961,921,34,5],[258,986,36,23],[479,986,36,23],[700,986,35,23],[921,986,31,23],[68,987,105,22],[302,995,17,5],[523,995,18,5],[743,995,18,5],[960,995,21,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline strip","reason":"Training method cards unrelated to reading the results chart.","boxes":[[902,1071,134,15],[128,1077,114,18],[533,1077,112,18],[467,1084,14,23],[902,1088,180,33],[98,1090,9,9],[502,1090,11,11],[508,1092,2,5],[128,1098,159,15],[533,1098,158,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mention, logo already present.","boxes":[[936,1157,196,14]]}],"usd":0.0032461,"sec":62,"out":6093,"cut":57,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":12.7},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with the benchmark title, labelled bars and values.","marks":[],"usd":0.0017382,"sec":40,"out":3039,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-medium__raw","clutter":23.5,"shares":{"blue":76.5,"orange":0,"red":23.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.7},"score":5,"words":102,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, a subtitle, a score pill, stat callouts that repeat the bars, and a footer tagline; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Edge stripe","reason":"Decorative shape.","boxes":[[1191,0,9,1200]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note tag","reason":"Eyebrow/category tag, not needed.","boxes":[[781,78,347,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan kicker","reason":"Slogan eyebrow above headline, states no finding.","boxes":[[72,188,281,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the 11.4 gain the chart and callout show.","boxes":[[72,376,787,55]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Score pill","reason":"Badge; metric is already clear from the chart.","boxes":[[1027,512,66,33],[1038,521,44,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat callouts","reason":"Restate differences the bars already show.","boxes":[[107,982,95,63],[609,982,59,63],[240,994,72,19],[707,994,131,19],[202,1012,24,22],[668,1012,24,22],[240,1013,141,19],[707,1013,74,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Second brand mention plus a tagline.","boxes":[[849,1130,279,16]]}],"usd":0.0017740999999999998,"sec":51,"out":3149,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.7},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete; one chart with benchmark title, labeled bars, values, a logo and a quiet footnote.","marks":[],"usd":0.0012617000000000001,"sec":35,"out":2086,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":46.8,"shares":{"blue":35.9,"orange":34.7,"red":29.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.9},"score":6,"words":114,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow tag, subtitle, redundant gap pill, a pipeline-card row and a footer wordmark, and the headline is a full sentence; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Top-right tag","reason":"Category tag/eyebrow with decorative dot.","boxes":[[827,48,76,15],[931,48,205,15],[915,54,4,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline; context repeated in chart title.","boxes":[[64,153,248,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be short finding title.","boxes":[[64,169,747,165],[64,233,257,101]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates the headline and chart.","boxes":[[64,337,705,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gap callout pill","reason":"Restates 2.8 gap already in headline and bars.","boxes":[[939,426,23,22],[971,429,126,17],[924,434,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Teacher footnote","reason":"Repeats the Teacher row's 'Specialized model' label.","boxes":[[92,764,279,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training pipeline cards","reason":"Method flow is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,835,444,15],[83,887,159,20],[459,887,133,20],[834,887,131,20],[401,912,21,10],[776,912,21,10],[83,914,162,19],[459,914,155,19],[834,914,157,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[64,1155,221,14]]}],"usd":0.0072646,"sec":119,"out":14130,"cut":24,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.9},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple three-bar GDPval chart with labelled values, a title and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0043362,"sec":91,"out":8235,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna__raw","clutter":47.7,"shares":{"blue":52.3,"orange":0,"red":47.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":22.4},"score":5,"words":84,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, eyebrow, tag, subtitle, legend, a +11.4 callout and a footer wordmark and tagline.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Research · Model training tag is a kicker with no information needed.","boxes":[[896,73,228,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline.","boxes":[[76,190,243,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, not a finding.","boxes":[[76,219,467,147]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Sentence restating what the chart shows.","boxes":[[76,382,825,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gain callout","reason":"Stat card restating the difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[115,981,188,16],[695,993,347,45],[115,997,89,59],[212,1026,49,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark; logo already at top.","boxes":[[76,1150,82,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tagline","reason":"Footer tagline is unneeded.","boxes":[[978,1150,146,16]]}],"usd":0.0018365999999999999,"sec":44,"out":3274,"cut":11,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__luna__simple","clutter":12.6,"shares":{"blue":74.9,"orange":25.1,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.7},"score":1,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: only the full-sentence headline could be shortened; the chart already carries the point.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Finding is valid but a full sentence; could be shortened to about seven words.","boxes":[[78,162,697,146]]}],"usd":0.0014247,"sec":61,"out":2412,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-high__raw","clutter":32.8,"shares":{"blue":50.6,"orange":33.2,"red":16.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.1},"score":3,"words":110,"missing":[],"summary":"Solid grouped bar chart cluttered by a sentence headline, subtitle, eyebrow, row captions and a duplicate footer brand; nothing essential missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker line with category and model, not needed.","boxes":[[815,71,313,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be short like 'Warmup lifts GDPval 35.3 to 46.7'.","boxes":[[72,153,632,236],[607,289,117,100]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Method explanation paragraph not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[72,392,642,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Row captions","reason":"Captions restate differences already visible in bars and values.","boxes":[[72,623,173,21],[72,644,144,21],[72,665,171,21],[72,793,164,21],[72,814,119,21],[72,955,130,21],[72,976,81,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mark duplicating top logo.","boxes":[[1009,1126,22,18],[1042,1126,86,18]]}],"usd":0.228888,"sec":109,"out":10803,"cut":11,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-high__simple","clutter":10,"shares":{"blue":80.1,"orange":19.9,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.1},"score":1,"words":24,"missing":["metric or score unit"],"summary":"Clean single chart with a logo; the headline is a long sentence and the metric behind the numbers is not stated.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be shortened, e.g. 'Within 2.8 points of teacher on GDPval'.","boxes":[[80,125,946,133]]}],"usd":0.120772,"sec":73,"out":5343,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-medium__raw","clutter":23.4,"shares":{"blue":76.6,"orange":0,"red":23.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":21.8},"score":4,"words":93,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid dot plot is cluttered by a kicker, a subtitle that restates the chart, a note on the HLE row and a footer URL; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Case study kicker","reason":"Eyebrow tag above the headline; tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[786,69,342,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the values and gap that the chart already shows.","boxes":[[72,354,626,95],[571,387,122,28],[215,419,102,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Barely moves note","reason":"Editorial note on the HLE row; the marks already show it.","boxes":[[485,966,98,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"A second brand mention when the logo is already there.","boxes":[[1014,1130,114,14]]}],"usd":0.252288,"sec":121,"out":11973,"cut":6,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.7},"score":1,"words":20,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a finding headline, metric label, labelled bars and category names; the only oddity is an unlisted logo element.","marks":[],"usd":0.102552,"sec":52,"out":4432,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":50.6,"shares":{"blue":30.7,"orange":37.5,"red":31.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.2},"score":5,"words":121,"missing":[],"summary":"The GDPval dot plot is a clear main visual, but the BrowseComp and HLE rows, the kicker, the subtitle, and the repeated URL are clutter; the headline is too long.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Series tag above the chart; tells the reader nothing new.","boxes":[[819,69,309,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Finding is right but too long; shorten to about seven words.","boxes":[[72,113,919,159]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle paragraph","reason":"Long paragraph restating the headline and the chart's 2.8-point gap.","boxes":[[72,276,1006,71]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BrowseComp second panel","reason":"A second benchmark row serves a separate point beside the main chart.","boxes":[[72,757,155,42],[951,773,146,20],[1048,773,31,19],[1097,773,31,19],[409,788,387,46],[795,834,21,21],[1027,836,16,16],[332,837,14,14],[402,837,14,14],[1032,841,5,5],[325,860,29,20],[393,860,33,20],[789,860,33,20],[1020,860,29,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"HLE third panel","reason":"A third benchmark row serves a separate point, not the main GDPval visual.","boxes":[[72,919,59,42],[131,935,61,20],[955,935,144,20],[1050,935,30,19],[1099,935,29,19],[179,994,21,21],[370,996,16,16],[145,997,14,14],[169,997,14,14],[375,1001,5,5],[136,1020,32,20],[364,1020,28,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated website URL","reason":"Second brand mark; the logo already identifies AfterQuery.","boxes":[[1035,1107,93,19]]}],"usd":0.563948,"sec":314,"out":27556,"cut":29,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.2},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, labelled bars and values, and no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.209092,"sec":108,"out":9759,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus__raw","clutter":47.5,"shares":{"blue":24.3,"orange":56.6,"red":19.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20.8},"score":4,"words":72,"missing":[],"summary":"Eyebrow, restating subtitle and two extra benchmark rows clutter the GDPval point, and the headline is a long sentence.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow/kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[90,180,511,23]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline at 66px; could be a short finding title.","boxes":[[90,204,982,172]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates the gap that the chart already shows.","boxes":[[90,383,663,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BrowseComp row","reason":"Second benchmark serves a point separate from the GDPval headline.","boxes":[[725,705,34,23],[884,705,38,23],[90,730,147,30],[891,733,24,24],[973,735,20,20],[758,737,17,17],[734,738,15,15],[747,765,38,23],[966,765,33,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"HLE row","reason":"Third benchmark, a different point, with overlapping labels.","boxes":[[645,881,37,23],[685,881,36,23],[90,906,149,30],[678,910,24,24],[745,911,20,20],[677,913,17,17],[669,914,15,15],[666,941,38,23],[739,941,32,23]]}],"usd":0.074948,"sec":37,"out":3106,"cut":20,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__opus__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.7},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, value labels, category labels and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.064272,"sec":34,"out":2518,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-high__raw","clutter":21.7,"shares":{"blue":78.3,"orange":0,"red":21.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.7},"score":4,"words":84,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, subtitle, takeaway callout, pipeline flow strip and footer URL; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[893,62,243,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory sentence restating pipeline, not needed for the chart.","boxes":[[64,338,618,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Takeaway callout","reason":"Restates gap between 46.7 and 49.5 already visible in bars.","boxes":[[88,982,778,50],[547,982,130,50],[64,1002,10,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline flow","reason":"Process diagram is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[278,1054,20,33],[626,1054,20,33],[897,1054,20,33],[371,1058,184,25],[718,1058,106,25],[989,1058,147,25],[64,1059,142,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already present.","boxes":[[1043,1151,93,19]]}],"usd":0.051342,"sec":112,"out":4735,"cut":14,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a clear title, labelled bars and values, and nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.039884,"sec":113,"out":3551,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-medium__raw","clutter":17.3,"shares":{"blue":82.7,"orange":0,"red":17.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.8},"score":5,"words":91,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow tag, subtitle, training-path pipeline strip and footer URL, and it lacks nothing essential.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag 'RESEARCH / NVIDIA' tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[965,57,171,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory subtitle that restates the context and adds no needed information.","boxes":[[64,322,639,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training path strip","reason":"Pipeline diagram is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,1001,157,15],[64,1034,147,26],[350,1034,193,26],[682,1034,112,26],[979,1034,154,26],[270,1040,21,36],[602,1040,21,36],[899,1040,21,36],[64,1064,136,20],[350,1064,132,20],[682,1064,159,20],[979,1064,157,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1050,1147,86,18]]}],"usd":0.039852,"sec":83,"out":3586,"cut":16,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.6},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":["metric or unit"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; the only gap is that the bar values carry no metric or unit label.","marks":[],"usd":0.028604,"sec":68,"out":2423,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":20.2,"shares":{"blue":78.7,"orange":2.5,"red":18.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33},"score":4,"words":90,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow tag, subtitle, gap callout, pipeline strip and footer URL; it lacks nothing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[912,63,224,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explains context the chart doesn't need.","boxes":[[64,335,420,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gap callout","reason":"Restates the difference already visible between the bars.","boxes":[[944,424,192,20],[842,425,102,21]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Second line under each label adds words the chart doesn't need.","boxes":[[129,920,139,21],[442,920,49,21],[655,920,159,21],[937,920,129,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline strip","reason":"Method flow is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,997,279,14],[64,1031,154,26],[447,1031,168,26],[829,1031,160,26],[385,1050,33,14],[767,1050,33,14],[64,1060,172,21],[447,1060,169,21],[829,1060,195,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[1032,1147,104,14]]}],"usd":0.075972,"sec":173,"out":7198,"cut":15,"shrunk":4},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":["metric definition"],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a title, labeled bars, values and a single logo; the metric is only implied.","marks":[],"usd":0.055344,"sec":105,"out":5097,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol__raw","clutter":22.2,"shares":{"blue":77.8,"orange":0,"red":22.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.1},"score":4,"words":92,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, subtitle, legend, a method-steps row and a footer URL; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above headline; not needed.","boxes":[[833,66,303,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains method and restates chart takeaway.","boxes":[[64,319,661,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method steps row","reason":"Pipeline cards serve a second point beyond the results chart.","boxes":[[64,961,157,26],[473,961,118,26],[806,961,163,26],[64,995,189,46],[473,995,166,46],[806,995,171,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1043,1091,93,19]]}],"usd":0.035222,"sec":86,"out":3123,"cut":10,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sol__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.7},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with title, labels, values and a single logo. The metric (score) is not named, which is minor.","marks":[],"usd":0.026094,"sec":66,"out":2172,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-high__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":23,"shares":{"blue":64.6,"orange":24.9,"red":10.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.7},"score":3,"words":105,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid chart set, cluttered by a sentence headline, a restating subtitle and repeated delta lines; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be short like 'Warmup lifts GDPval 35.3 to 46.7'.","boxes":[[72,146,903,163],[945,212,113,97]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Restates what the bars already show.","boxes":[[72,320,835,61]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Warmup delta lines","reason":"Repeat values already labelled on the bars.","boxes":[[86,559,161,22],[446,559,164,22],[806,559,161,22]]}],"usd":0.060614,"sec":50,"out":5420,"cut":4,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-high__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.9},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, value labels and category labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.035216,"sec":32,"out":2826,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":25.9,"shares":{"blue":59.5,"orange":29.3,"red":11.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.4},"score":4,"words":57,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid GDPval bar chart is cluttered by a sentence headline, a side panel of other-domain results, a gap callout and a footer URL.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline, very large; could be short title like '+11.4 GDPval from warmup'.","boxes":[[80,154,861,164],[750,221,115,97]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Other domains panel","reason":"Side panel with BrowseComp and HLE results, a second point.","boxes":[[880,520,208,38],[880,593,122,26],[880,625,89,46],[969,625,60,46],[880,704,124,26],[880,736,144,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gap to teacher callout","reason":"Restates difference already visible between the Warmup and Teacher bars.","boxes":[[880,815,200,26],[880,847,40,46],[920,847,44,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already present.","boxes":[[1014,1123,106,21]]}],"usd":0.050974,"sec":53,"out":4456,"cut":13,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":48.4},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, value labels and category labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.025746,"sec":28,"out":1879,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":35.4,"shares":{"blue":64.6,"orange":0,"red":35.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.6},"score":5,"words":130,"missing":[],"summary":"Strong main GDPval chart is cluttered by a subtitle, eyebrow, legend, and two secondary benchmark panels with big repeated numbers.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Explains and restates what the chart shows.","boxes":[[64,267,621,68],[685,267,333,31]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BrowseComp and HLE panels","reason":"Second and third benchmarks, a separate idea from GDPval.","boxes":[[64,802,102,18],[616,802,142,18],[64,816,86,78],[224,816,99,78],[616,816,88,78],[778,816,87,78],[992,839,144,32],[442,840,142,30],[166,847,40,16],[456,847,114,17],[720,847,40,16],[1007,847,114,17],[176,904,186,26],[374,904,36,26],[728,904,154,26],[894,904,40,26],[64,908,65,18],[616,908,65,18],[176,944,198,26],[386,944,41,26],[728,944,158,26],[898,944,40,26],[64,948,83,18],[616,948,83,18],[176,984,266,26],[454,984,43,26],[728,984,160,26],[900,984,40,26],[64,988,56,18],[616,988,56,18],[494,1024,36,26],[933,1024,35,26],[177,1025,304,24],[729,1025,191,24],[64,1028,65,18],[616,1028,65,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already exists.","boxes":[[998,1138,138,18]]}],"usd":0.188084,"sec":149,"out":18167,"cut":41,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.1},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a single bar chart with a short title and logo, though the score's metric unit is never stated.","marks":[],"usd":0.066596,"sec":56,"out":5964,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet__raw","clutter":60.6,"shares":{"blue":21.8,"orange":35.3,"red":42.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.3},"score":5,"words":58,"missing":[],"summary":"Two extra benchmark groups, an eyebrow and a restating subtitle clutter the GDPval point, and the headline is oversized; later bar groups lack row labels.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline; adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[100,80,264,19]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline sentence","reason":"Finding is clear but is a huge full sentence; could be shorter.","boxes":[[100,110,802,199]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates the gap the GDPval bars already show.","boxes":[[100,350,771,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BrowseComp bars","reason":"Second benchmark serves a different point from the GDPval headline.","boxes":[[100,655,149,41],[100,707,564,26],[676,711,27,19],[100,743,600,26],[712,747,31,19],[100,779,807,26],[919,783,31,19],[100,815,927,26],[1039,819,27,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"HLE bars","reason":"Third benchmark group is unrelated to the GDPval headline.","boxes":[[100,870,167,41],[100,922,465,26],[577,926,30,19],[100,958,478,26],[590,962,30,19],[100,994,485,26],[597,998,29,19],[100,1030,584,26],[696,1034,26,19]]}],"usd":0.028144,"sec":21,"out":2173,"cut":20,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, labelled bars, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.030186,"sec":32,"out":2323,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__wonder__raw","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__wonder__raw","clutter":48.8,"shares":{"blue":51.2,"orange":0,"red":48.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.3},"score":7,"words":189,"missing":[],"summary":"The GDPval line chart is buried under stat cards, a subtitle, two extra-benchmark cards, a pipeline strip and header and footer tags; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta tags","reason":"Date and category tag line, eyebrow-style, not needed.","boxes":[[931,43,205,44],[840,69,91,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating post intro.","boxes":[[64,274,1007,55],[765,274,152,24],[234,304,213,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Restate values and differences the chart already shows.","boxes":[[85,356,94,68],[448,356,81,68],[810,356,120,68],[85,423,194,37],[448,423,242,37],[810,423,213,37]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"BrowseComp and HLE cards","reason":"Other benchmarks serve a second point unrelated to the main chart.","boxes":[[85,873,103,17],[447,873,124,17],[629,873,145,17],[991,873,124,17],[85,894,175,53],[629,894,169,53],[260,917,137,22],[798,917,135,22],[85,950,468,40],[629,950,445,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline flow","reason":"Method pipeline beside the results chart; the result repeats 46.7.","boxes":[[81,1034,133,14],[354,1034,97,14],[627,1034,115,14],[900,1034,53,14],[319,1052,16,26],[592,1052,16,26],[865,1052,16,26],[81,1053,208,21],[354,1053,132,21],[627,1053,150,42],[900,1053,194,42]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[1017,1153,119,15]]}],"usd":0.146168,"sec":83,"out":6915,"cut":43,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__wonder__simple","task":"how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-afterquery-helped-nvidia-hill-climb-gdpval__wonder__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.3},"score":0,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, a logo and a model tag. The metric is not named as a score, but that is minor.","marks":[],"usd":0.108148,"sec":69,"out":4975,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-high__raw","clutter":80.2,"shares":{"blue":14.7,"orange":10.2,"red":75.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":62.5},"score":8,"words":682,"missing":[],"summary":"The simple 3.1% to 17.0% bar chart is buried in a poster of pipeline, code, cards and repeated stats; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Byline and eyebrow","reason":"Date, authors and eyebrow marker carry nothing the chart needs.","boxes":[[189,33,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Context pills","reason":"Model, agent and eval repeated elsewhere in the graphic.","boxes":[[966,26,200,24],[647,31,36,14],[840,31,34,14],[977,31,178,14],[34,161,123,18],[40,164,111,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date and authors","reason":"Byline metadata is not needed by the reader.","boxes":[[201,31,107,15],[320,31,3,15],[335,31,191,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Long sentence title; could be 'Over 5x on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[34,52,875,88]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat callout","reason":"Restates 3.1% to 17.0% already in bars.","boxes":[[955,86,193,13],[963,93,185,53],[984,140,164,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates chart and pipeline in prose.","boxes":[[34,140,760,38],[243,140,75,17],[453,140,150,17],[191,160,77,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qualitative panel","reason":"Side panel on behavior, separate from results chart.","boxes":[[774,219,189,14],[1061,219,86,14],[761,221,6,11],[773,260,163,14],[1031,261,104,13],[773,277,353,46],[1050,351,85,17],[773,352,14,14],[793,352,63,15],[1057,353,71,13],[778,357,4,4],[773,372,341,31],[773,410,75,19],[864,410,75,19],[954,410,81,19],[1051,410,62,19],[852,412,8,14],[942,412,8,14],[1039,412,8,14],[779,413,62,12],[870,413,62,12],[961,413,68,12],[1058,413,49,12],[1050,457,85,17],[773,458,14,14],[793,458,126,15],[1057,459,71,13],[777,463,6,4],[773,478,356,31],[773,516,56,19],[845,516,38,19],[899,516,38,19],[952,516,38,19],[1006,516,44,19],[1066,516,38,19],[833,518,8,14],[887,518,8,14],[940,518,8,14],[994,518,8,14],[1054,518,8,14],[779,519,43,12],[852,519,25,12],[905,519,25,12],[959,519,25,12],[1012,519,31,12],[1072,519,25,12]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar annotations","reason":"Wordy sublabels and badges on bars; could be shortened.","boxes":[[172,310,218,15],[494,311,151,14],[267,367,118,15],[449,367,195,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Value chips row","reason":"Repeats bar labels and values.","boxes":[[64,450,97,15],[285,450,44,15],[232,451,23,14],[445,451,30,14],[505,451,126,14],[667,451,29,14],[95,452,62,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task-level comparison","reason":"Second claim about +18 tasks.","boxes":[[66,520,123,15],[189,520,295,16],[438,520,42,15],[493,522,6,12],[501,522,6,12],[509,522,6,12],[517,522,6,12],[525,522,6,12],[533,522,6,12],[541,522,6,12],[549,522,6,12],[557,522,6,12],[565,522,6,12],[573,522,6,12],[581,522,6,12],[589,522,6,12],[597,522,6,12],[605,522,6,12],[613,522,6,12],[621,522,6,12],[629,522,6,12],[640,522,56,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline section","reason":"Method details, code, and filter cards unrelated to the results chart.","boxes":[[66,585,481,14],[785,585,362,14],[53,586,6,11],[79,630,124,13],[300,630,94,19],[452,630,119,13],[638,630,87,19],[783,630,160,13],[1033,630,100,19],[67,631,6,11],[440,631,6,11],[771,631,6,11],[308,633,78,13],[646,633,71,13],[1041,633,84,13],[67,640,202,30],[440,640,148,30],[771,640,150,30],[67,673,322,48],[440,673,256,46],[782,681,120,14],[934,681,188,14],[940,682,176,11],[130,688,123,18],[136,690,111,12],[852,700,80,17],[943,700,74,17],[1028,700,55,17],[795,701,323,29],[858,702,68,12],[949,702,62,12],[1034,702,43,12],[782,712,6,6],[440,728,39,8],[481,728,186,8],[669,728,56,8],[842,735,136,17],[1036,735,74,17],[795,736,240,29],[848,737,124,12],[1042,737,62,12],[78,739,138,11],[323,739,60,11],[782,747,6,6],[451,751,91,15],[649,751,65,14],[655,753,53,11],[78,761,41,11],[119,761,241,11],[201,761,35,11],[242,761,106,11],[451,767,165,15],[873,770,55,17],[795,771,315,14],[879,772,43,12],[90,774,70,11],[166,774,106,11],[272,774,12,11],[782,775,6,6],[90,788,88,11],[184,788,23,11],[213,788,76,11],[295,788,35,11],[331,788,12,11],[90,802,70,11],[166,802,18,11],[190,802,65,11],[260,802,12,11],[272,802,12,11],[410,803,14,12],[741,803,14,12],[451,805,98,15],[626,806,88,14],[632,807,76,11],[782,809,120,14],[977,809,145,14],[90,815,70,11],[166,815,29,11],[201,815,70,11],[278,815,12,11],[295,815,70,11],[372,815,12,11],[451,822,146,14],[782,827,269,18],[1055,827,67,18],[790,829,117,13],[1063,829,52,13],[782,849,319,31],[823,849,21,14],[902,849,15,14],[975,849,7,14],[1054,849,21,14],[451,860,106,15],[655,860,59,14],[661,862,47,11],[782,865,23,14],[451,876,127,15],[78,904,172,14],[127,904,59,14],[284,905,99,12],[782,906,144,11],[984,906,138,11],[451,915,239,45],[451,915,109,14],[87,923,18,12],[782,926,41,11],[823,926,282,11],[911,926,70,11],[988,926,106,11],[106,927,6,6],[109,930,260,36],[794,939,100,11],[900,939,147,11],[1046,939,12,11],[794,953,70,11],[870,953,12,11],[888,953,65,11],[958,953,12,11],[976,953,70,11],[1046,953,12,11],[86,959,18,12],[313,960,7,7],[639,966,68,12],[794,967,88,11],[888,967,23,11],[917,967,76,11],[999,967,18,11],[326,968,43,11],[451,968,9,9],[462,968,9,9],[474,968,9,9],[485,968,9,9],[497,968,9,9],[508,968,9,9],[520,968,9,9],[531,968,9,9],[543,968,9,9],[554,968,9,9],[566,968,9,9],[577,968,9,9],[589,968,9,9],[600,968,9,9],[612,968,9,9],[623,968,9,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Takeaway cards","reason":"Three prose cards on secondary ideas.","boxes":[[62,1038,117,26],[444,1038,249,26],[826,1038,247,26],[49,1046,6,11],[431,1046,6,11],[813,1046,6,11],[49,1068,332,63],[136,1068,66,14],[431,1068,326,47],[813,1068,334,63],[707,1084,23,14],[888,1084,125,14],[549,1100,23,14],[646,1100,31,14],[49,1116,41,14]]}],"usd":1.213252,"sec":1527,"out":120741,"cut":283,"shrunk":5},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.5},"score":0,"words":22,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.29631,"sec":500,"out":29008,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-medium__raw","clutter":77.5,"shares":{"blue":17.2,"orange":10.5,"red":72.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":55.2},"score":7,"words":501,"missing":[],"summary":"The 3-bar chart is buried under a dark stat card, a subtitle, two method panels, a case study and extra header and footer text; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta","reason":"Tagline, blog tag, date and authors do not help read the chart.","boxes":[[870,38,3,16],[881,38,72,16],[961,38,3,16],[972,38,184,16],[215,39,245,15],[836,39,26,15],[822,41,6,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline, far longer than a short finding title.","boxes":[[44,90,706,94],[44,128,113,55],[44,128,113,58]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Dark stat card","reason":"Restates 3.1% to 17.0% and over 5x, which the bars show.","boxes":[[1040,128,96,18],[840,130,183,15],[1048,130,80,14],[1063,142,105,105],[927,149,116,50],[840,167,53,29],[903,171,14,23],[854,202,282,15],[962,202,49,14],[840,207,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the chart and headline.","boxes":[[44,187,688,58],[253,187,72,17],[457,187,83,17],[342,207,77,17],[485,207,100,17],[44,208,146,17],[221,208,86,17],[50,209,134,14],[227,209,74,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated value pills","reason":"Pills and side notes repeat the bar values.","boxes":[[826,293,117,23],[952,293,181,23],[837,298,95,14],[963,298,159,14],[1066,341,67,15],[1027,381,107,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 SFT panel","reason":"Pipeline and config detail is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[137,510,192,30],[65,516,64,19],[344,516,188,19],[73,519,48,13],[353,519,170,13],[409,563,123,15],[65,564,232,14],[76,593,68,22],[171,593,46,22],[245,593,46,22],[319,593,46,22],[393,593,54,22],[474,593,46,22],[85,597,50,14],[153,597,9,15],[180,597,28,14],[227,597,9,15],[254,597,28,14],[301,597,9,15],[328,597,28,14],[375,597,9,15],[402,597,36,14],[456,597,9,15],[483,597,28,14],[405,636,127,15],[65,637,318,14],[130,676,70,13],[89,683,24,11],[114,686,8,8],[118,690,329,65],[316,690,125,21],[334,693,88,13],[447,746,55,9],[89,749,24,11],[442,750,10,10],[118,763,73,11],[247,763,73,11],[419,763,56,11],[65,815,267,14],[74,841,93,12],[232,841,74,12],[389,841,68,12],[74,853,96,14],[232,853,22,14],[389,853,15,14],[74,885,74,12],[232,885,74,12],[389,885,87,12],[74,897,37,14],[232,897,15,14],[389,897,37,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 RLVR panel","reason":"Environment, reward and task selection are method details, a second idea.","boxes":[[663,510,238,30],[592,516,64,19],[906,516,229,19],[600,519,48,13],[915,519,211,13],[933,563,202,15],[592,564,297,14],[614,601,83,14],[786,601,120,14],[980,601,96,14],[762,614,9,15],[956,614,9,15],[614,617,124,25],[786,617,136,25],[980,617,117,25],[1032,669,103,15],[592,670,384,14],[615,709,113,14],[948,709,61,14],[1032,709,76,14],[605,733,490,15],[645,733,133,14],[851,733,21,14],[900,733,23,14],[982,733,7,14],[1004,768,131,15],[592,769,313,14],[614,811,104,13],[758,811,110,13],[882,811,86,13],[993,811,117,13],[887,812,76,11],[614,825,85,27],[993,825,77,27],[758,826,192,26],[601,885,74,12],[738,885,68,12],[875,885,93,12],[1013,885,80,12],[601,897,15,14],[738,897,15,14],[875,897,30,14],[1013,897,22,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Case study panel","reason":"Qualitative base vs trained example is a separate idea.","boxes":[[65,961,343,28],[418,965,181,20],[612,967,537,16],[667,967,100,15],[427,968,163,14],[483,1010,94,18],[1026,1010,94,18],[80,1012,189,15],[491,1012,78,14],[623,1012,202,15],[1034,1012,78,14],[80,1044,155,25],[251,1044,155,25],[422,1044,155,25],[623,1044,154,24],[794,1044,156,24],[966,1044,154,24],[96,1049,122,15],[239,1049,9,15],[289,1049,80,15],[410,1049,9,15],[440,1049,120,15],[636,1049,128,14],[781,1049,9,15],[802,1049,140,14],[953,1049,9,15],[976,1049,133,14],[633,1076,477,32],[80,1077,497,31],[90,1077,450,31],[775,1091,116,17],[781,1093,104,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand tagline","reason":"Second brand mark and tagline, logo already in the header.","boxes":[[58,1157,58,14],[116,1157,343,15],[44,1159,6,11]]}],"usd":0.579852,"sec":986,"out":57401,"cut":196,"shrunk":4},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.2},"score":0,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, labelled values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.15179,"sec":314,"out":14556,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon__raw","clutter":83.5,"shares":{"blue":11.8,"orange":9.3,"red":78.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":52},"score":8,"words":552,"missing":[],"summary":"The pass-rate chart is clear, but the graphic is buried under a repeated stats strip, two extra method and behavior sections, a long headline, and redundant header and footer text; it lacks nothing needed.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header byline card","reason":"Date, authors and email add nothing to the chart reading","boxes":[[234,44,111,17],[700,45,249,14],[958,45,7,14],[976,45,163,14],[220,47,6,11],[200,50,4,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above the headline","boxes":[[63,98,307,13]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; shorten to 'Over 5x on Terminal-Bench 2.0'","boxes":[[48,109,479,146],[372,152,127,61]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart pill badges","reason":"Badges restate model and method already shown in the chart rows","boxes":[[766,157,74,16],[772,159,62,12],[752,212,154,16],[758,214,142,12],[792,267,154,16],[798,269,142,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Lede paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the chart's numbers and models","boxes":[[48,260,528,61],[87,260,39,18],[439,260,43,18],[270,282,125,18],[431,282,80,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats strip","reason":"Repeats 3.1% to 17.0% and adds unrelated dataset facts beside the chart","boxes":[[64,343,133,39],[240,343,92,39],[417,343,94,39],[64,379,147,29],[240,379,144,29],[417,379,118,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence","reason":"Takeaway sentence and Gemini badge restate the chart","boxes":[[963,383,166,20],[648,385,86,14],[734,385,213,15],[972,387,148,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline method cards","reason":"Stage method cards, training configs and charts beside the results chart","boxes":[[130,438,405,32],[48,445,70,17],[55,447,56,13],[944,447,208,13],[67,496,144,12],[433,496,103,22],[600,496,179,12],[1023,496,110,22],[442,500,85,14],[1032,500,92,14],[67,510,257,30],[600,510,249,30],[67,547,451,33],[610,553,485,11],[622,553,127,11],[611,587,131,11],[795,587,56,11],[882,587,131,11],[1072,587,50,11],[78,597,64,19],[174,597,43,19],[249,597,43,19],[324,597,43,19],[399,597,50,19],[481,597,43,19],[86,600,48,13],[155,600,6,12],[182,600,27,13],[230,600,6,12],[257,600,27,13],[305,600,6,12],[332,600,27,13],[380,600,6,12],[407,600,34,13],[462,600,6,12],[489,600,27,13],[611,603,214,60],[882,603,192,18],[1074,603,48,18],[700,604,121,11],[907,606,141,11],[1089,606,18,11],[668,619,121,11],[882,626,234,42],[995,626,14,13],[560,632,14,11],[664,634,61,11],[77,638,388,11],[89,638,121,11],[951,640,70,13],[882,641,190,25],[649,650,42,11],[76,670,61,11],[195,670,56,11],[314,670,50,11],[433,670,56,11],[76,682,28,14],[195,682,21,14],[314,682,14,14],[433,682,43,14],[611,702,213,11],[978,702,144,11],[352,723,21,10],[79,724,220,13],[620,724,99,12],[762,724,117,12],[994,724,111,12],[374,725,6,6],[377,728,127,28],[620,737,82,27],[762,737,186,13],[994,737,116,14],[79,738,223,27],[352,751,21,10],[483,751,7,7],[374,759,5,10],[469,759,49,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Behavior comparison section","reason":"Second visual on model behaviour and failed reward idea; a different point","boxes":[[130,811,360,32],[48,818,70,17],[55,820,56,13],[938,820,214,13],[756,868,135,11],[1006,868,129,11],[112,869,163,14],[341,869,363,15],[67,873,7,7],[80,873,7,7],[93,873,7,7],[756,884,282,15],[794,884,53,14],[994,884,40,14],[284,915,82,18],[609,915,82,18],[80,917,156,13],[404,917,143,13],[971,917,9,9],[983,917,9,9],[996,917,9,9],[1008,917,9,9],[1021,917,9,9],[1033,917,9,9],[1046,917,9,9],[1058,917,9,9],[1071,917,9,9],[291,918,68,12],[616,918,68,12],[917,921,7,13],[768,922,59,11],[1088,922,35,11],[834,923,9,9],[847,923,9,9],[860,923,9,9],[971,929,9,9],[983,929,9,9],[996,929,9,9],[1008,929,9,9],[1021,929,9,9],[1033,929,9,9],[1046,929,9,9],[1058,929,9,9],[1071,929,9,9],[80,941,130,13],[216,941,143,13],[404,941,130,13],[541,941,91,13],[80,959,273,13],[404,959,273,13],[80,978,253,13],[404,978,227,29],[80,997,266,29],[223,997,91,13],[756,1009,103,11],[1019,1009,116,11],[404,1013,253,29],[756,1020,283,26],[756,1049,364,48],[756,1049,357,31],[80,1050,286,36],[404,1050,286,36],[80,1056,255,30],[404,1056,261,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer wordmark and tagline","reason":"Repeats the logo and adds a tagline","boxes":[[48,1153,56,14],[104,1153,329,15]]}],"usd":0.595542,"sec":748,"out":58970,"cut":200,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__argon__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20.8},"score":0,"words":22,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, model, metric, labelled bars and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0954,"sec":168,"out":8917,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-high__raw","clutter":43.4,"shares":{"blue":56.6,"orange":0,"red":43.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.8},"score":4,"words":77,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is solid, but the slogan headline, eyebrow and tag, bar descriptions, takeaway callout and footer URL clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag in the top right adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[819,69,317,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow label","reason":"Kicker above the headline. The chart title already names the benchmark.","boxes":[[64,165,190,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Huge slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,183,634,198]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar descriptions","reason":"Subtext under each bar label explains stages the labels already name.","boxes":[[159,884,167,25],[476,884,248,25],[819,884,275,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway callout","reason":"Takeaway sentence and explanatory subline restate the post and are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[122,994,474,50],[69,1011,25,22],[122,1048,595,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1006,1138,130,18]]}],"usd":0.20054,"sec":90,"out":3467,"cut":11,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.7},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple labelled bar chart with benchmark, metric, values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.151,"sec":80,"out":2438,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-medium__raw","clutter":35,"shares":{"blue":52.4,"orange":25.1,"red":22.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.3},"score":4,"words":89,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid three-bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, a sentence headline, sublabels, an annotation arrow, a flow label, a repeated 5x callout with takeaway text, and a footer URL; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[828,64,308,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline sentence","reason":"Slogan-like sentence headline at 69px, too big and wordy for the finding.","boxes":[[64,121,633,181]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Pipeline flow label","reason":"Restates the stages already labelled under the bars.","boxes":[[883,400,253,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Method descriptions beneath the labels add clutter.","boxes":[[484,854,207,22],[852,854,213,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Over 5x callout","reason":"Restates a difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[64,933,201,100]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway text","reason":"Takeaway sentences explaining the chart.","boxes":[[326,939,361,28],[326,974,462,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1030,1097,106,21]]}],"usd":0.18589,"sec":89,"out":3174,"cut":10,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.8},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a title, logo, metric label and stage values.","marks":[],"usd":0.1414,"sec":72,"out":2246,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":16.8,"shares":{"blue":81.1,"orange":4.2,"red":14.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.3},"score":3,"words":73,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, subtitle, takeaway callout, repeated branding and wordy sublabels, but it lacks nothing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[907,61,229,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Bar brand text","reason":"Brand repeated inside bar with the logo already present.","boxes":[[873,523,92,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Brand repeated inside bar","reason":"Second brand mark already shown by the logo","boxes":[[1028,524,15,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar descriptions","reason":"Wordy sublabels under categories; the labels already suffice.","boxes":[[512,907,176,53],[872,907,173,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway callout","reason":"Slogan takeaway restating the chart.","boxes":[[113,1027,601,46],[66,1038,25,25],[72,1046,12,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"No eval tasks note","reason":"Separate claim about training data, not part of the chart.","boxes":[[113,1076,399,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention.","boxes":[[1036,1138,100,20]]}],"usd":0.35649,"sec":152,"out":6586,"cut":9,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.7},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple three-bar chart with benchmark, metric, values, stage labels and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.21295,"sec":93,"out":3677,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra__raw","clutter":50.5,"shares":{"blue":49.5,"orange":0,"red":50.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.2},"score":5,"words":98,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is surrounded by a slogan headline, subtitle, tags, two method cards and footer extras that should go; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[826,62,310,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan that does not state the finding; dominates the canvas.","boxes":[[64,145,788,169]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restating context; model is named elsewhere.","boxes":[[64,319,470,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence on chart","reason":"Takeaway sentence restating which stage matters most","boxes":[[764,793,372,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage cards","reason":"Method pipeline cards beside a results chart serve a second idea.","boxes":[[64,862,108,19],[655,862,121,19],[64,894,255,46],[655,894,264,46],[64,950,389,48],[655,950,440,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eval set note","reason":"Side claim that is not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[64,1053,357,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1015,1055,121,17]]}],"usd":0.15284,"sec":60,"out":2513,"cut":14,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__astra__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.4},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one simple bar chart with a short title, labelled bars, values, and a small logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.1397,"sec":57,"out":2212,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":35.4,"shares":{"blue":64.6,"orange":0,"red":35.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.7},"score":5,"words":193,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is buried under a method card row, a stat card repeating the bars, a pull quote, a kicker, a paragraph and a duplicate logo; the chart and its benchmark context are complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date nav","reason":"Site navigation and date add nothing to the chart's point","boxes":[[950,68,34,14],[984,68,144,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above the headline restates the title","boxes":[[110,157,504,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explains the pipeline and restates what the chart shows","boxes":[[375,414,168,24],[72,415,809,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards","reason":"Pipeline method cards serve a second point beside the results chart","boxes":[[72,915,201,13],[423,915,67,13],[72,929,200,45],[423,929,186,45],[72,974,270,37],[423,974,256,37]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Over 5x result card","reason":"Stat card restating the improvement the bars already show","boxes":[[773,915,45,13],[773,926,129,63],[773,987,267,37],[773,987,55,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Pull quote takeaway","reason":"Takeaway quote and kicker restate a claim rather than read the chart","boxes":[[332,1058,766,64],[72,1068,126,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark repeats the header logo","boxes":[[102,1145,101,13]]}],"usd":0.009256499999999997,"sec":70,"out":14737,"cut":21,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: three labelled bars with values and a benchmark context line, with no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0092562,"sec":53,"out":14688,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-max__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":24.2,"shares":{"blue":75.8,"orange":0,"red":24.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.6},"score":6,"words":99,"missing":[],"summary":"Good chart and headline, but cluttered by a takeaway band, a +18 stat with icon grid, a subtitle, and header tags.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note and date","reason":"Tag and date tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[912,57,100,13],[1043,57,93,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow category","reason":"Kicker line above headline, repeats benchmark.","boxes":[[81,137,272,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tinker x Harbor tag","reason":"Tool credits are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[1017,139,119,12],[1073,139,7,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the model and values already in the chart.","boxes":[[64,408,177,26],[295,408,38,26],[359,408,48,26],[241,409,542,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Takeaway band","reason":"Slogan and paragraph restating chart; footer repeats tools.","boxes":[[64,958,93,13],[64,969,318,76],[64,1044,654,46],[480,1044,129,22],[64,1122,194,11],[112,1122,6,11],[177,1122,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"+18 tasks stat","reason":"Second stat with icon grid unrelated to the line chart.","boxes":[[806,944,131,150],[806,958,90,13],[806,1072,244,19],[806,1107,12,19],[824,1107,12,19],[842,1107,12,19],[860,1107,12,19],[878,1107,12,19],[896,1107,12,19],[914,1107,12,19],[932,1107,12,19],[950,1107,12,19],[806,1132,12,19],[824,1132,12,19],[842,1132,12,19],[860,1132,12,19],[878,1132,12,19],[896,1132,12,19],[914,1132,12,19],[932,1132,12,19],[950,1132,12,19]]}],"usd":0.032253899999999995,"sec":276,"out":53066,"cut":38,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-max__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark-and-metric title, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0336918,"sec":349,"out":55414,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":23.6,"shares":{"blue":76.4,"orange":0,"red":23.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":7,"words":231,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is buried under a large side pipeline panel, a stats row, a subtitle, taglines and a repeated 5x; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag at top right, adds nothing.","boxes":[[903,63,233,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline side panel","reason":"Method panel is a second idea; it also repeats the 5x.","boxes":[[764,158,372,704],[952,163,154,11],[770,165,7,7],[783,165,7,7],[796,165,7,7],[774,217,163,11],[774,234,138,43],[774,271,134,43],[774,323,320,37],[812,383,93,11],[778,384,15,15],[812,395,208,22],[812,420,250,33],[812,462,75,19],[893,462,105,19],[820,467,59,10],[901,467,89,10],[812,501,100,11],[778,502,15,15],[812,513,196,22],[812,538,254,33],[812,580,52,19],[870,580,170,19],[820,585,36,10],[878,585,154,10],[1061,630,41,47],[774,646,78,25],[1034,655,27,16],[774,821,12,10],[786,821,107,10],[983,821,119,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the chart; the model name is repeated.","boxes":[[68,442,576,51]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom stats row","reason":"Benchmark, evaluation, and lever cards repeat the footnote and chart.","boxes":[[64,913,88,11],[468,913,94,11],[849,913,61,11],[64,930,33,40],[468,930,16,40],[849,930,61,40],[101,949,29,16],[489,949,24,16],[914,949,37,16],[64,974,298,33],[468,974,274,33],[849,974,240,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline adds nothing.","boxes":[[64,1134,207,23]]}],"usd":0.013067099999999998,"sec":107,"out":21088,"cut":52,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":21.7},"score":0,"words":17,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a logo, metric label, values, ticks and category names, nothing extra.","marks":[],"usd":0.005606399999999999,"sec":45,"out":8605,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":35.5,"shares":{"blue":64.5,"orange":0,"red":35.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.7},"score":6,"words":151,"missing":[],"summary":"Strong bar chart and headline are surrounded by eyebrows, a restating subtitle, an unsupported claim, pipeline cards and a repeated footer.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note tag","reason":"Category tag and date badge, not needed.","boxes":[[851,45,269,14],[834,48,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Breadcrumb eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline; repeats benchmark.","boxes":[[80,146,117,14],[209,146,9,14],[230,146,162,14],[403,146,9,14],[424,146,72,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates 3.1% to 17.0% already shown by bars.","boxes":[[646,377,168,24],[80,378,777,54],[80,405,107,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Plus 18 more","reason":"Second claim with no supporting visual.","boxes":[[80,814,397,42],[477,814,146,42]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline cards","reason":"Method cards unrelated to reading the results chart.","boxes":[[80,886,108,14],[103,931,16,13],[645,931,16,13],[103,943,284,46],[645,943,77,46],[593,980,13,22],[103,989,447,39],[645,989,446,39],[103,1037,139,12],[645,1037,181,12]]}],"usd":0.010765499999999999,"sec":98,"out":17252,"cut":25,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":22.3},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart, short headline naming the benchmark, logo, labelled bars and values.","marks":[],"usd":0.008307,"sec":73,"out":13106,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek__raw","clutter":47.2,"shares":{"blue":52.8,"orange":0,"red":47.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.4},"score":6,"words":180,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is buried under a badge, subtitle, stat row, workflow strip, pull quote and repeated branding; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category and date tag","reason":"Category tag and date add nothing to reading the chart.","boxes":[[796,66,207,14],[1025,66,103,14],[783,71,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"5x pill","reason":"Badge restating the improvement the bars already show.","boxes":[[1012,144,17,19],[975,148,140,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence restating the chart and adding a Gemini comparison.","boxes":[[72,297,783,54],[180,297,107,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart eval notes","reason":"Task and run details repeated in the footer.","boxes":[[951,405,146,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat row","reason":"Three stats on training details, unrelated to the main chart.","boxes":[[72,784,43,74],[453,784,43,74],[805,784,116,74],[119,804,55,39],[860,804,10,39],[72,850,251,36],[453,850,258,36],[805,850,232,36]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Workflow strip","reason":"Separate point about the explore-then-act pipeline.","boxes":[[72,923,136,11],[72,939,261,33],[597,940,60,16],[715,940,34,16],[808,940,34,16],[900,940,34,16],[993,940,43,16],[1094,940,34,16],[579,943,11,10],[697,943,11,10],[789,943,11,10],[882,943,11,10],[974,943,11,10],[1075,943,11,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Pull quote","reason":"Takeaway quote, not part of the chart.","boxes":[[100,1007,656,67],[1009,1048,119,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mark when the logo already exists.","boxes":[[1025,1142,103,12]]}],"usd":0.010579499999999999,"sec":89,"out":16942,"cut":39,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__deepseek__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.1},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple three-bar chart with a metric title, model name, one logo and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.0054462,"sec":87,"out":8338,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":78.7,"shares":{"blue":21.3,"orange":0,"red":78.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.7},"score":8,"words":499,"missing":[],"summary":"The small progression bar chart is buried under a stat card, two method panels, a case study and tags; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tags","reason":"Kicker text and pills; category and date tags.","boxes":[[815,38,90,22],[913,38,140,22],[1062,38,92,22],[205,42,114,14],[825,42,70,14],[923,42,120,14],[1072,42,72,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates headline and chart numbers.","boxes":[[46,123,697,41],[653,123,87,19],[455,124,160,18],[460,125,150,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat callout","reason":"17.0% and 5x repeat what the bars show.","boxes":[[73,201,168,112],[253,266,144,25],[262,270,126,17],[253,295,122,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Baseline tag","reason":"Badge restating that the first bar is the baseline.","boxes":[[1070,267,57,19],[1077,270,43,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Claim text and pills","reason":"Explanatory sentence and badges restating claims.","boxes":[[73,318,268,54],[73,318,303,35],[73,385,142,22],[221,385,114,22],[82,389,124,14],[230,389,96,14],[73,413,123,22],[82,417,105,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage detail panels","reason":"Pipeline method cards, hyperparameters and side panels beside results chart.","boxes":[[69,497,92,21],[407,497,161,20],[632,497,101,21],[970,497,161,20],[78,501,74,13],[416,501,143,13],[641,501,83,13],[979,501,143,13],[69,522,217,33],[632,522,333,33],[69,555,489,33],[632,555,480,33],[80,610,59,21],[182,610,40,21],[264,610,40,21],[346,610,40,21],[428,610,46,21],[517,610,40,21],[643,610,235,12],[1038,610,82,11],[157,613,8,14],[239,613,8,14],[321,613,8,14],[403,613,8,14],[492,613,8,14],[87,614,45,13],[189,614,26,13],[271,614,26,13],[353,614,26,13],[435,614,32,13],[524,614,26,13],[688,632,32,13],[807,632,149,13],[1036,632,45,13],[669,646,71,11],[806,646,151,11],[1035,646,47,11],[82,659,136,13],[493,662,42,9],[421,665,17,9],[443,671,106,23],[82,673,120,15],[523,681,19,9],[514,685,7,7],[82,689,207,14],[643,690,166,12],[997,690,123,11],[644,707,380,18],[1024,707,95,18],[726,710,216,12],[1044,710,56,12],[80,753,82,12],[334,753,103,12],[643,753,122,12],[897,753,118,12],[80,767,121,14],[334,767,121,14],[643,767,135,14],[897,767,142,14],[80,782,134,14],[334,782,106,14],[643,782,127,14],[897,782,107,14],[80,820,96,12],[334,820,74,12],[643,820,122,12],[897,820,71,12],[80,834,92,14],[334,834,121,14],[643,834,128,14],[897,834,100,14],[80,849,121,14],[334,849,134,14],[643,849,139,14],[897,849,136,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Behavior case study","reason":"Second unrelated point: qualitative case study comparison.","boxes":[[69,926,256,13],[69,941,413,30],[934,958,82,13],[1015,958,116,13],[491,992,87,16],[1029,992,87,16],[84,993,212,14],[622,993,248,14],[497,994,75,13],[1035,994,75,13],[97,1014,396,15],[635,1014,403,15],[84,1015,7,13],[622,1015,7,13],[84,1034,7,13],[97,1034,360,15],[622,1034,7,13],[635,1034,361,15],[97,1053,398,15],[635,1053,441,15],[84,1054,7,13],[622,1054,7,13],[69,1095,710,14],[989,1095,142,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author byline","reason":"Authors not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[225,1153,3,15],[46,1154,169,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already at top.","boxes":[[1076,1154,78,14]]}],"usd":0.382396575,"sec":679,"out":92114,"cut":151,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":23.7},"score":0,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, metric, logo, and labelled values makes the point clearly.","marks":[],"usd":0.29992545000000004,"sec":664,"out":72082,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":74.6,"shares":{"blue":19.3,"orange":12.1,"red":68.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.5},"score":8,"words":397,"missing":[],"summary":"The small results chart is buried among pipeline cards, stat boxes, a case study and header badges; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Workflow case study","reason":"Second idea: qualitative behavior comparison.","boxes":[[67,837,360,30],[437,847,492,16],[938,847,195,18],[946,850,179,12],[497,889,82,16],[1037,889,82,16],[81,890,182,15],[621,890,213,15],[504,891,68,12],[1044,891,68,12],[81,912,498,23],[621,912,498,23],[89,917,435,13],[629,917,454,13],[81,942,8,14],[95,942,390,15],[621,942,8,14],[635,942,71,14],[713,942,301,15],[81,962,8,14],[95,962,399,15],[621,962,8,14],[635,962,408,15],[81,982,8,14],[95,982,384,15],[621,982,8,14],[635,982,87,14],[729,982,295,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header pills","reason":"Badges and tags; date and topic unneeded.","boxes":[[772,43,142,21],[922,43,102,21],[1032,43,122,21],[782,47,122,13],[932,47,82,13],[1042,47,102,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Lab tagline","reason":"Tagline next to logo, not needed.","boxes":[[194,47,162,13],[207,47,149,13]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be 'Over 5x on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[46,69,684,97],[88,110,116,56]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle and authors","reason":"Subtitle restates the chart; author byline unneeded.","boxes":[[828,81,326,57],[927,146,227,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline stage cards","reason":"Method details unrelated to reading results chart.","boxes":[[543,297,146,19],[551,300,130,13],[972,300,163,14],[1021,300,36,14],[543,322,237,28],[543,355,573,33],[1038,408,31,12],[1069,408,55,12],[554,412,55,17],[624,412,37,17],[677,412,37,17],[729,412,37,17],[782,412,43,17],[840,412,37,17],[984,413,42,16],[561,415,41,11],[613,415,7,12],[631,415,23,11],[666,415,7,12],[684,415,23,11],[718,415,7,12],[736,415,23,11],[771,415,7,12],[789,415,29,11],[829,415,7,12],[847,415,23,11],[1071,422,53,10],[1023,426,5,5],[728,469,235,11],[717,472,5,6],[543,507,211,19],[551,510,195,13],[972,510,163,14],[1028,510,36,14],[543,532,364,28],[543,565,548,33],[554,618,113,11],[855,618,150,11],[554,633,23,14],[577,633,106,31],[855,633,30,15],[885,633,108,14],[554,649,23,14],[856,654,32,11],[860,654,25,10],[888,654,182,11],[937,654,84,10],[1070,654,53,11],[1079,654,35,10],[855,669,45,10],[967,669,49,10],[1084,669,40,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat and lift","reason":"Restates 3.1% and 17.0% already in bars.","boxes":[[431,359,44,15],[416,362,9,9],[236,401,25,11],[236,413,37,18],[67,441,406,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Secondary stats beyond the main chart.","boxes":[[78,632,30,31],[220,632,48,31],[362,632,12,31],[78,660,95,27],[220,660,84,27],[362,660,110,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already present.","boxes":[[1063,1144,91,13]]}],"usd":0.21433995,"sec":431,"out":51373,"cut":117,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.4},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a benchmark name, labelled stages, values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.17730157500000002,"sec":397,"out":42355,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":70,"shares":{"blue":19.8,"orange":20.4,"red":59.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.9},"score":7,"words":290,"missing":[],"summary":"The three-bar chart is buried under method cards, a repeated table, stat rows, a quote and header metadata; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Header metadata","reason":"Benchmark, model and agent repeated in chart, table and footnote.","boxes":[[843,54,82,14],[925,54,215,14],[806,73,260,14],[858,73,134,14],[1066,73,74,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research pill","reason":"Category badge, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[236,60,79,23],[245,65,61,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[75,143,330,14],[60,144,7,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Long sentence headline; could be '5x on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[60,157,1040,125]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the chart numbers and method.","boxes":[[60,285,972,53],[60,285,1029,51],[324,285,196,23],[721,285,143,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 card","reason":"Method card beside results chart.","boxes":[[1026,385,89,22],[582,387,116,19],[1035,389,71,14],[590,390,100,13],[582,415,248,37],[582,458,508,38],[595,518,48,13],[671,518,7,13],[706,518,27,13],[761,518,7,13],[796,518,27,13],[852,518,7,13],[887,518,27,13],[943,518,7,13],[977,518,34,13],[1040,518,7,13],[1075,518,27,13],[582,598,60,12],[764,598,80,12],[945,598,67,12],[582,612,125,16],[764,612,108,16],[945,612,100,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 card","reason":"Second method card, unrelated to reading chart.","boxes":[[983,690,132,22],[582,692,124,19],[992,694,114,14],[590,695,108,13],[582,720,373,37],[582,763,483,38],[595,823,163,13],[780,823,7,13],[808,823,88,13],[918,823,7,13],[946,823,156,13],[582,903,87,12],[764,903,87,12],[945,903,94,12],[582,917,167,16],[764,917,100,16],[945,917,108,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Results table","reason":"Repeats the three bar values.","boxes":[[104,726,192,13],[104,747,217,24],[321,747,87,24],[408,747,78,24],[104,751,100,15],[321,751,39,15],[416,751,70,15],[104,776,193,15],[321,776,77,15],[455,776,31,15],[104,801,162,15],[321,801,77,15],[447,801,39,15],[104,822,217,26],[321,822,87,26],[408,822,78,26],[104,827,178,15],[321,827,77,15],[447,827,39,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"+18 tasks row","reason":"Separate stat about tasks, not the bars.","boxes":[[89,880,57,59],[156,893,112,17],[422,894,79,19],[156,911,172,16],[406,913,95,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Finding and contributions","reason":"Quote and contribution stats serve other points.","boxes":[[85,994,157,13],[634,1001,109,13],[887,1001,116,13],[634,1010,93,46],[887,1010,78,46],[85,1012,470,57],[634,1052,148,12],[887,1052,161,12]]}],"usd":0.0959112,"sec":214,"out":22663,"cut":96,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":21.1},"score":0,"words":21,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-and-after bar chart with a named benchmark, metric, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.053539199999999995,"sec":148,"out":12352,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-high__raw","clutter":45.8,"shares":{"blue":51.7,"orange":5,"red":43.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.4},"score":6,"words":143,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a byline, takeaway lines, an RL selection diagram, a stat row and a workflow strip; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date byline","reason":"Date and authors are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[1004,53,128,19],[934,75,198,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Accent rule","reason":"Decorative shape.","boxes":[[68,235,36,3]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the bars as a sentence; could be shortened.","boxes":[[68,254,594,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway line","reason":"Takeaway sentence; the Gemini claim is a second point.","boxes":[[68,296,77,34],[145,304,461,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"RL task selection","reason":"Second diagram about method, unrelated to the results chart.","boxes":[[68,842,103,18],[988,843,144,18],[68,871,106,42],[177,871,741,42],[920,871,212,42],[101,883,40,18],[523,883,49,18],[998,883,57,18],[79,920,84,18],[509,920,77,17],[1001,920,50,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat row","reason":"Method stats and the +18 count; a side idea and partly repeated.","boxes":[[68,979,58,53],[168,979,58,53],[450,979,174,53],[804,979,48,53],[531,989,13,34],[136,1002,20,8],[68,1033,167,19],[450,1033,206,19],[804,1033,123,19],[68,1055,181,19],[450,1055,194,19],[804,1055,183,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"SFT workflow line","reason":"Pipeline detail unrelated to the result bars.","boxes":[[107,1097,57,15],[194,1097,33,15],[257,1097,33,15],[320,1097,33,15],[382,1097,41,15],[453,1097,33,15],[68,1098,23,13],[172,1102,13,6],[235,1102,13,6],[298,1102,13,6],[360,1102,13,6],[431,1102,13,6]]}],"usd":0.300034,"sec":745,"out":49081,"cut":44,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: two labelled bars with values, a benchmark name and an axis, and nothing extra.","marks":[],"usd":0.229258,"sec":670,"out":37220,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-medium__raw","clutter":68,"shares":{"blue":31,"orange":2.1,"red":66.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.8},"score":6,"words":188,"missing":[],"summary":"The 3.1%→17.0% chart is a small part of the canvas; byline, subtitle, takeaway paragraph, solve-rate band and +18 banner clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date authors","reason":"Byline metadata tells the reader nothing about the result.","boxes":[[837,58,299,34]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle restating chart","reason":"Restates 3.1% to 17.0%, already in the chart; adds the Gemini claim.","boxes":[[64,286,758,64]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Stage annotations","reason":"Stage annotations are wordy for the chart; the +3.5% mark is useful.","boxes":[[392,635,257,15],[828,635,140,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Takeaway paragraph","reason":"Restates the SFT and RLVR gains the chart already shows.","boxes":[[64,787,287,26],[64,788,1015,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Solve rate band","reason":"Second idea about RL task selection, unrelated to the main chart.","boxes":[[64,886,455,14],[64,910,107,36],[171,910,750,36],[922,910,214,36],[96,919,43,19],[520,919,52,19],[998,919,61,19],[64,958,857,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"+18 tasks banner","reason":"A separate result, about task counts, in its own callout.","boxes":[[64,1031,118,131],[218,1071,690,29],[64,1135,49,27]]}],"usd":0.295084,"sec":722,"out":48256,"cut":16,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":6,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart naming the benchmark, with values, labels and a logo, and nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.068908,"sec":175,"out":10495,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":65.1,"shares":{"blue":34.5,"orange":0.8,"red":64.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.3},"score":5,"words":145,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is buried under a hero stat repeating it, a subtitle, a takeaway line, and a three-stat bottom row of side ideas.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date and authors","reason":"Blog metadata, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[968,53,168,14],[922,72,214,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big hero stats","reason":"Restates 3.1% and 17.0% that the bars already show.","boxes":[[64,183,207,174],[415,183,265,174]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory sentence restating the post claims.","boxes":[[64,347,835,58]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Secondary row labels add words; model is already named above.","boxes":[[64,563,124,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence","reason":"Restates what the bars show.","boxes":[[64,926,240,20],[304,926,179,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom stats row","reason":"Three side stats on unrelated ideas beyond the main chart.","boxes":[[64,993,171,56],[454,993,127,56],[812,993,53,56],[64,1049,89,19],[454,1049,116,19],[812,1049,195,19],[64,1073,314,41],[454,1073,252,41],[812,1073,225,41]]}],"usd":0.440158,"sec":1148,"out":72435,"cut":19,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.7},"score":0,"words":6,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a two-bar chart with benchmark, values, labels and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.01474,"sec":721,"out":1467,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok__raw","clutter":44.8,"shares":{"blue":55.2,"orange":0,"red":44.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.3},"score":6,"words":132,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a subtitle, date, task-selection cards and a three-column stats row; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag tells the reader nothing about the result.","boxes":[[959,69,169,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explains and restates the chart.","boxes":[[72,340,602,58]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task selection cards","reason":"Second idea about RL task selection unrelated to the results bars.","boxes":[[72,748,455,19],[93,822,48,18],[414,822,57,18],[842,822,67,18],[93,848,135,41],[414,848,145,41],[842,848,93,41],[93,895,130,20],[414,895,364,20],[842,895,118,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom stats row","reason":"Three side facts about reward, NLL and gain; repeat or add other ideas.","boxes":[[72,999,136,17],[494,999,147,17],[825,999,86,17],[72,1026,353,23],[494,1026,255,47],[825,1026,289,47],[494,1081,142,19],[825,1081,177,19]]}],"usd":0.049204,"sec":122,"out":7276,"cut":24,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values and clear categories. The screenshot also shows an AfterQuery logo and an axis line that are not in the element list, so I did not grade them.","marks":[],"usd":0.03922,"sec":111,"out":5547,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-high__raw","clutter":25.8,"shares":{"blue":67,"orange":14.5,"red":18.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.3},"score":5,"words":96,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a four-stat row, a kicker, a date, a repeated model name and a footer URL; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Blog tag and date tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[953,74,175,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Category kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[72,164,244,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Model and method are useful, but the sentence is wordy and repeated in labels.","boxes":[[72,357,846,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated model name","reason":"Model already named in the subtitle.","boxes":[[173,850,151,22]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Stage descriptions","reason":"Wordy method explanations under bar labels; could be shortened.","boxes":[[465,850,269,45],[806,850,292,45]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stats row","reason":"Stat cards repeat the +3.5% shown by the bars or add side ideas.","boxes":[[72,948,30,81],[359,948,130,81],[623,948,75,81],[887,948,54,81],[72,1027,176,43],[359,1027,203,43],[623,1027,177,43],[887,1027,202,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1001,1123,127,17]]}],"usd":0.0133331,"sec":137,"out":25813,"cut":16,"shrunk":3},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a three-bar pass-rate chart with a benchmark title, one value per bar and stage labels. The AfterQuery logo at top-left is visible but absent from the element list, so it is not graded here.","marks":[],"usd":0.0049827,"sec":54,"out":9058,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":43.8,"shares":{"blue":56.2,"orange":0,"red":43.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.5},"score":5,"words":138,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart and headline are cluttered by an eyebrow, tag, subtitle, two method cards and a footer URL; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag top right, tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[823,86,297,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[80,146,368,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains the method; restates what the chart labels show.","boxes":[[80,378,928,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage method cards","reason":"Method cards beside results chart serve a second idea; stages already labelled in bars.","boxes":[[111,854,346,18],[643,854,262,18],[111,876,330,56],[643,876,307,56],[111,937,440,54],[643,937,413,81],[302,964,105,24],[643,964,143,24],[830,964,124,24],[111,1019,446,37],[643,1019,446,37],[111,1038,377,18],[643,1038,398,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mark; logo already present.","boxes":[[973,1122,147,18]]}],"usd":0.0078876,"sec":84,"out":14922,"cut":19,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.7},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a named benchmark, labelled values, and category labels; the visible AfterQuery logo at top-left is not in the element list, so I left it ungraded.","marks":[],"usd":0.0036431999999999997,"sec":57,"out":6379,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":40.1,"shares":{"blue":59.9,"orange":0,"red":40.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.4},"score":5,"words":140,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a subtitle, a blog tag, two method cards with extra stats, and a footer brand tagline; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag above headline; tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[892,71,228,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the chart's 3.1% to 17.0% result in a sentence.","boxes":[[80,356,839,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Stage tags under bars add little; repeat the stage cards.","boxes":[[198,796,123,15],[569,796,62,15],[909,796,62,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 card","reason":"SFT method and NLL are a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[80,878,282,15],[80,897,376,53],[80,956,473,49],[80,1016,84,72],[240,1016,84,72],[348,1044,185,15],[211,1046,6,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 card","reason":"RL method and task-selection bar are a separate idea from results.","boxes":[[624,878,123,15],[624,897,439,53],[624,956,448,49],[808,1028,79,14],[624,1047,50,10],[674,1047,347,10],[1021,1047,99,10],[624,1062,16,14],[662,1062,24,14],[1009,1062,24,14],[1088,1062,32,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already at top, plus tagline.","boxes":[[838,1129,282,15]]}],"usd":0.0192441,"sec":197,"out":37635,"cut":26,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short title, labelled values and categories, and nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0076067,"sec":83,"out":14306,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku__raw","clutter":32.8,"shares":{"blue":67.2,"orange":0,"red":32.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.9},"score":5,"words":110,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart and headline are clear, but the eyebrow, subtitle, blog tag and two method cards are clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog tag","reason":"Category tag, tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[1005,79,123,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline.","boxes":[[72,185,304,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the 3.1% to 17.0% result the bars already show.","boxes":[[72,435,881,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage cards","reason":"Method cards beside results chart serve a second point about the pipeline.","boxes":[[101,870,44,4],[641,870,44,4],[101,892,65,19],[641,892,68,19],[101,921,301,37],[641,921,228,37],[101,968,454,52],[641,968,442,52],[101,1036,118,34],[641,1036,108,34],[113,1042,94,22],[653,1042,84,22]]}],"usd":0.0041786,"sec":39,"out":7504,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, value labels, and category labels, with nothing extra to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0028651999999999996,"sec":36,"out":4823,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-high__raw","clutter":25.8,"shares":{"blue":66,"orange":16.5,"red":17.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.6},"score":4,"words":99,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is surrounded by an eyebrow, a sentence headline, a subtitle, a row of stat cards that repeat the bars, and a second brand footer; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag with no information the reader needs.","boxes":[[817,71,311,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline at 63px; could be a short title like '3.1% to 17.0%'.","boxes":[[72,141,591,98],[72,207,337,98]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explains what the chart already shows.","boxes":[[72,309,700,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards row","reason":"Restates 13.5%, 3.5 points and 5x already shown by the bars.","boxes":[[72,1008,84,15],[430,1008,147,15],[788,1008,120,15],[72,1040,40,61],[430,1040,89,61],[788,1040,44,61],[832,1058,61,37],[72,1117,152,18],[430,1117,266,18],[788,1117,264,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand and tagline","reason":"Second brand mark plus a tagline.","boxes":[[72,1164,63,15],[135,1164,161,16]]}],"usd":0.0038329,"sec":89,"out":7122,"cut":18,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.5},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a title, two labelled bars with values, and nothing extra; the metric is implied as a percentage on Terminal-Bench 2.0.","marks":[],"usd":0.002127,"sec":54,"out":3672,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-medium__raw","clutter":56.4,"shares":{"blue":43.6,"orange":0,"red":56.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25},"score":6,"words":106,"missing":[],"summary":"Slogan headline, eyebrow, explainer panel, stage cards and a second brand footer clutter a good bar chart; bars lack value labels.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag with no information.","boxes":[[839,66,287,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, does not state the finding.","boxes":[[74,143,506,141]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Benchmark pill tag","reason":"Benchmark name repeated; already in title and footnote.","boxes":[[116,349,176,36],[130,359,148,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Two-stage explainer","reason":"Method explanation paragraph beside chart.","boxes":[[836,686,205,17],[836,713,249,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage cards","reason":"Method cards; values repeat the chart's differences.","boxes":[[534,863,33,17],[1056,863,47,17],[98,864,96,15],[634,864,106,15],[98,885,319,39],[634,885,279,39],[98,926,393,37],[634,926,425,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark tagline","reason":"Second brand mark and tagline.","boxes":[[74,1143,78,14],[152,1143,286,15]]}],"usd":0.0020414,"sec":51,"out":3539,"cut":20,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":16.1},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with benchmark title, labels, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.001515,"sec":44,"out":2448,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":47,"shares":{"blue":53,"orange":0,"red":47,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.7},"score":6,"words":134,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear three-bar chart is surrounded by a slogan headline, a 5x stat card, method cards and a repeated brand footer; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag with dot, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[921,65,211,12],[896,67,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline.","boxes":[[103,172,247,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"5x stat card","reason":"Restates the gain the bars already show.","boxes":[[848,180,115,188],[1081,197,48,48],[856,205,35,13],[858,340,121,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, does not state the finding.","boxes":[[68,185,428,91],[68,244,377,91]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the chart.","boxes":[[68,337,586,47]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards","reason":"Method explanation cards serve a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[925,829,206,16],[69,833,313,13],[91,877,27,27],[631,877,27,27],[130,884,227,13],[670,884,235,13],[98,885,12,12],[638,885,12,12],[91,913,157,24],[631,913,193,24],[91,941,338,18],[631,941,361,18],[139,969,11,18],[187,969,11,18],[235,969,11,18],[283,969,11,18],[337,969,11,18],[91,973,41,11],[157,973,24,11],[205,973,24,11],[253,973,24,11],[301,973,29,11],[355,973,24,11],[631,983,382,7],[1013,983,96,7],[631,996,101,11],[1014,996,95,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[977,1099,155,12]]}],"usd":0.0084849,"sec":156,"out":16426,"cut":42,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.7},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a short title, one brand mark, and two labelled bars with values.","marks":[],"usd":0.0048005,"sec":87,"out":9019,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna__raw","clutter":44,"shares":{"blue":43.1,"orange":25.9,"red":31,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30},"score":7,"words":105,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear two-bar chart is surrounded by repeated stat cards, a pipeline card row, a slogan headline, tags and a second brand mark; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag top right; unneeded.","boxes":[[885,63,247,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[68,157,336,19]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Two sentences with slogan; should be short finding like '5× on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[68,175,699,159]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"5.5x stat card","reason":"Restates difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[846,428,85,81],[846,507,259,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+10.4 stat card","reason":"Restates difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[846,623,110,81],[846,703,279,43],[846,703,124,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"RLVR gain callout","reason":"Second point about RLVR contribution, not shown in chart.","boxes":[[907,831,86,22],[868,846,21,14],[882,846,7,7],[907,855,155,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline cards","reason":"Method cards beside results; also repeat 17.0%.","boxes":[[68,960,273,16],[124,1010,164,20],[515,1010,169,20],[896,1010,40,20],[87,1012,24,37],[476,1012,26,37],[864,1012,18,37],[429,1017,16,26],[818,1017,16,26],[124,1033,179,16],[515,1033,153,16],[896,1033,134,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark; logo already in header.","boxes":[[916,1141,216,17]]}],"usd":0.0015894000000000001,"sec":30,"out":2635,"cut":31,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__luna__simple","clutter":12.2,"shares":{"blue":75.7,"orange":24.3,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":22},"score":1,"words":21,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete; only the full-sentence headline could be shorter.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be '5× on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[84,203,561,132]]}],"usd":0.0011385,"sec":26,"out":1695,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-high__raw","clutter":50.9,"shares":{"blue":33.4,"orange":31.4,"red":35.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.7},"score":5,"words":128,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear and complete, but the stage cards, takeaway band, section tag and sentence-length headline add clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section tag","reason":"Category tag restating the blog section; tells the reader nothing new.","boxes":[[906,71,214,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Sentence headline; shorten to 'Over 5x on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[80,191,788,173],[330,261,199,103]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage method cards","reason":"Method explanation beside the results chart serves a second point.","boxes":[[139,907,274,15],[669,907,308,15],[107,910,22,8],[637,910,22,8],[107,927,432,44],[637,927,453,44],[107,976,411,43],[637,976,443,43],[107,979,444,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentence band","reason":"Takeaway sentence restating a claim the chart already shows.","boxes":[[80,1091,376,34],[456,1091,123,34]]}],"usd":0.247384,"sec":126,"out":11516,"cut":15,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.2},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a three-bar chart with a short title, logo, and one value per bar; the only gap is no explicit metric name such as pass rate.","marks":[],"usd":0.095208,"sec":46,"out":3853,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-medium__raw","clutter":43.1,"shares":{"blue":39.9,"orange":34.1,"red":26,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.8},"score":6,"words":83,"missing":["metric name (pass rate)"],"summary":"A solid stacked bar chart is cluttered by the eyebrow, subtitle, in-bar and stage labels and two stat callouts, one of which is garbled and cut off; the y-axis metric is unlabeled.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker tag above headline; benchmark already named in headline.","boxes":[[845,79,275,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline that restates the bar values; could be shorter.","boxes":[[80,133,840,179],[725,133,127,106],[80,206,162,106]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explains pipeline and tools; chart already labels stages.","boxes":[[80,313,830,76]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"In-bar SFT labels","reason":"Repeated inside both bars; category labels already say SFT.","boxes":[[914,683,31,22],[867,711,126,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"5x stat callout","reason":"Restates the 3.1% to 17.0% difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[80,943,83,65],[80,1014,130,23],[80,1049,272,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"+18 tasks stat","reason":"Separate claim about task-level comparison unrelated to the bars.","boxes":[[80,1089,76,65],[80,1160,315,40]]}],"usd":0.141784,"sec":68,"out":6236,"cut":9,"shrunk":3},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.9},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple labelled bar chart with a benchmark-and-model title and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.103008,"sec":71,"out":4243,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":38.3,"shares":{"blue":61.7,"orange":0,"red":38.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.6},"score":5,"words":146,"missing":[],"summary":"The chart is solid, but the subtitle, header tag, bar sublabels, footer URL and two method cards below it are clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research tag","reason":"Category tag; benchmark is already in the headline.","boxes":[[905,70,62,20],[977,70,4,20],[991,70,129,20],[892,75,3,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the 3.1% and 17.0% values the chart already shows.","boxes":[[80,260,711,64],[764,260,206,28],[133,293,45,28],[208,293,56,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Base model bracket label","reason":"Repeats the 3.1% already labelled on the base bar","boxes":[[898,753,37,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Stage 1 and AfterQuery sublabels add nothing needed.","boxes":[[485,839,54,15],[733,839,77,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage method cards","reason":"Method cards explain the pipeline, which is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[80,904,118,15],[624,904,127,15],[80,921,307,42],[624,921,326,42],[80,966,444,46],[624,966,454,46],[80,1030,76,27],[179,1030,51,27],[252,1030,51,27],[326,1030,51,27],[400,1030,60,27],[482,1030,51,27],[624,1030,50,30],[674,1030,346,30],[1020,1030,100,30],[162,1035,10,18],[236,1035,10,18],[310,1035,10,18],[383,1035,10,18],[465,1035,10,18],[89,1036,58,16],[188,1036,33,16],[261,1036,33,16],[335,1036,33,16],[409,1036,42,16],[491,1036,33,16],[795,1038,104,15],[624,1066,15,14],[662,1066,22,14],[1010,1066,22,14],[1090,1066,30,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1008,1129,112,15]]}],"usd":0.483104,"sec":264,"out":23302,"cut":45,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.5},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a clear title, value labels and category labels, and nothing extra to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.236108,"sec":122,"out":10898,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus__raw","clutter":30.1,"shares":{"blue":52.9,"orange":34,"red":13.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.9},"score":3,"words":64,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a long sentence headline, subtitle, a redundant >5x callout, method sublabels and a second brand mention.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Headline is large and repeats the numbers the bars show; shorten.","boxes":[[90,199,620,217],[540,199,196,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating pipeline; adds a second claim about Gemini.","boxes":[[90,417,794,60]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Extra method detail under labels; wordier than needed.","boxes":[[186,962,88,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand text","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[935,1119,175,17]]}],"usd":0.073584,"sec":33,"out":2826,"cut":2,"shrunk":3},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__opus__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.3},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a logo, a title naming the benchmark and metric, and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.062068,"sec":32,"out":2196,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-high__raw","clutter":53.5,"shares":{"blue":46.5,"orange":0,"red":53.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37},"score":5,"words":102,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear three-bar chart is surrounded by a slogan headline, tags, a 5x pill, method cards and a caveat; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Applied research tag","reason":"Category tag, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[979,61,157,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow above headline; benchmark already named in chart label.","boxes":[[64,150,185,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,172,701,198]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Descriptive captions under bars add nothing needed.","boxes":[[171,834,150,22],[512,834,175,22],[862,834,184,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards","reason":"SFT and RLVR method explanations are a second idea beside results.","boxes":[[91,914,113,18],[650,914,207,18],[91,937,438,48],[650,937,426,48],[91,990,316,56],[650,990,360,56]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"No eval training note","reason":"Separate caveat claim, not needed to read chart.","boxes":[[98,1070,469,28],[65,1074,19,19],[70,1081,9,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already present.","boxes":[[1016,1146,120,23]]}],"usd":0.060548,"sec":172,"out":5511,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.8},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple labelled bar chart with a short title, model, and logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.03738,"sec":103,"out":3156,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-medium__raw","clutter":38.3,"shares":{"blue":61.7,"orange":0,"red":38.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45},"score":5,"words":96,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, an Over 5x callout, an eyebrow tag, two takeaway panels and a footer URL.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag with no information about the finding.","boxes":[[832,62,304,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,150,633,183]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Over 5x callout","reason":"Restates the 3.1% to 17.0% difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[938,197,191,91],[973,282,120,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Takeaway panels","reason":"Two text blocks making separate points beside the chart.","boxes":[[64,955,118,15],[620,955,118,15],[64,980,431,45],[620,980,362,45],[64,1036,363,49],[620,1036,334,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo already exists.","boxes":[[1015,1134,121,21]]}],"usd":0.038838,"sec":113,"out":3340,"cut":13,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a benchmark title, metric subtitle, labelled bars and values.","marks":[],"usd":0.02918,"sec":97,"out":2336,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":38.8,"shares":{"blue":61.2,"orange":0,"red":38.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.9},"score":5,"words":77,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear three-bar chart is padded with a slogan headline, subtitle, stage tags, captions, takeaway text and a repeated 5× callout.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research & Blog tag","reason":"Category tag with no information value.","boxes":[[1016,63,124,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Generic slogan; does not state the finding.","boxes":[[60,136,684,194]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explaining method, not needed to read chart.","boxes":[[62,337,524,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stage tags","reason":"Eyebrow tags repeating what bar labels already say.","boxes":[[201,855,99,19],[565,855,69,19],[915,855,69,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar descriptions","reason":"Explanatory captions under bar labels; unneeded.","boxes":[[162,921,176,26],[470,921,261,26],[818,921,264,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Takeaway sentences","reason":"Takeaway and caveat sentences not needed to read chart.","boxes":[[60,1008,492,52],[60,1072,477,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Over 5x callout","reason":"Restates the difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[1006,1001,134,63],[993,1058,147,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[1027,1139,113,22]]}],"usd":0.090438,"sec":275,"out":8500,"cut":15,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.1},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-after bar chart with benchmark, metric, labels, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0533,"sec":163,"out":4748,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol__raw","clutter":35,"shares":{"blue":64.2,"orange":1.7,"red":34.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.3},"score":4,"words":90,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear three-bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, a category tag, a method explainer strip and bar sublabels, but it lacks nothing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style category tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[791,59,345,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding, and it is oversized.","boxes":[[64,135,785,171]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Extra descriptor under each bar label that adds words the chart does not need.","boxes":[[129,866,150,22],[485,866,175,22],[841,866,124,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline explainer strip","reason":"Method cards explaining SFT and RLVR, repeating the bar labels.","boxes":[[64,929,51,37],[133,929,199,28],[628,929,61,37],[707,929,233,28],[75,937,29,21],[639,937,39,21],[573,954,24,40],[133,965,332,52],[707,965,357,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when a logo is already present.","boxes":[[1030,1072,106,21]]}],"usd":0.031218,"sec":75,"out":2578,"cut":13,"shrunk":3},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sol__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.7},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, metric, logo and labelled values; nothing to remove or add.","marks":[],"usd":0.02928,"sec":68,"out":2346,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-high__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":44.2,"shares":{"blue":40.3,"orange":31.3,"red":28.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.7},"score":5,"words":128,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by an oversized sentence headline, a subtitle, two method cards and a side claim in the footer; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline that is oversized and partly repeats the bars.","boxes":[[72,126,764,217],[522,126,196,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the chart; 5x+ and the model are already shown.","boxes":[[72,342,786,60]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage method cards","reason":"Method cards serve a second idea beyond the results chart.","boxes":[[97,915,282,15],[635,915,212,15],[97,938,311,30],[635,938,287,30],[97,974,465,46],[635,974,459,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task comparison note","reason":"A separate claim not shown by the chart.","boxes":[[829,1137,299,15]]}],"usd":0.062922,"sec":50,"out":5439,"cut":10,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-high__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.1},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, one logo, and one value and label per bar.","marks":[],"usd":0.040764,"sec":36,"out":3169,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":31.9,"shares":{"blue":49.3,"orange":37.7,"red":13,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.2},"score":3,"words":58,"missing":[],"summary":"The chart is clean, but the eyebrow, subtitle and footer URL are extras, and the headline is long and repeats the bar values.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Eyebrow or category tag above the headline.","boxes":[[743,84,377,26]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline sentence","reason":"Long, very large headline that repeats the bar values; could be shorter.","boxes":[[80,147,1013,217],[541,147,201,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explaining the setup; the chart and labels already cover it.","boxes":[[80,391,839,70]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo already identifies AfterQuery.","boxes":[[1000,1117,120,23]]}],"usd":0.040182,"sec":33,"out":3165,"cut":3,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.5},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a clear title, labelled bars, values and a logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.027804,"sec":22,"out":1873,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":20.6,"shares":{"blue":79.4,"orange":0,"red":20.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.3},"score":4,"words":119,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a long headline, subtitle, date tag, sublabels and a three-card method strip; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date tag","reason":"Category tag and date add nothing to reading the chart.","boxes":[[901,71,227,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating method details beyond the chart.","boxes":[[72,318,798,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Bar sublabels","reason":"Sublabels repeat the stages and model already given elsewhere.","boxes":[[571,939,58,16],[881,939,142,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage cards","reason":"Method and result cards serve a second point beyond the chart.","boxes":[[89,1021,109,14],[470,1021,117,14],[822,1021,50,14],[72,1024,9,9],[453,1024,9,9],[805,1024,9,9],[72,1044,314,23],[453,1044,288,46],[805,1044,267,46],[191,1054,15,9]]}],"usd":0.156262,"sec":119,"out":14773,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.1},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a title naming the model, benchmark, and metric.","marks":[],"usd":0.056734,"sec":45,"out":4766,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet__raw","clutter":1,"shares":{"blue":99,"orange":0,"red":1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.8},"score":1,"words":37,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean: one bar chart with a clear headline, benchmark and footnote; only the repeated afterquery.com URL beside the logo should go.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated domain URL","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo; the URL adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[987,1110,133,26]]}],"usd":0.035152,"sec":30,"out":2662,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.7},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple labelled bar chart with a clear title; only the near-invisible white logo is a defect.","marks":[],"usd":0.026994,"sec":18,"out":1792,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__wonder__raw","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__wonder__raw","clutter":76.3,"shares":{"blue":13.2,"orange":21.1,"red":65.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.1},"score":7,"words":302,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is a clear main visual, buried under a restating stat callout, method cards, a bottom panel row and a long headline; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header eyebrow and date","reason":"Category tag, date and series label above the headline; restates no finding.","boxes":[[784,38,193,18],[784,59,121,17],[905,59,231,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; shorten to about seven words, e.g. 'Over 5x on Terminal-Bench 2.0'.","boxes":[[64,113,982,128],[64,165,150,76]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the headline and chart in a paragraph; explains rather than shows.","boxes":[[357,243,272,23],[698,243,161,23],[64,244,935,50],[269,269,446,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big 3.1% to 17.0% callout","reason":"Large stat box restates the before and after values the bars already show.","boxes":[[100,333,333,116],[254,359,46,81],[433,368,36,68],[217,439,198,23],[100,440,665,50],[214,466,375,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset and run stats panel","reason":"Task counts, overlap and run stats form a side panel on a second point.","boxes":[[829,324,35,50],[829,372,106,32],[829,407,19,50],[829,455,151,32],[829,490,84,50],[829,538,133,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 and Stage 2 cards","reason":"Method cards with tags and hyperparameters, a second point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[89,816,162,14],[647,816,242,14],[89,836,247,39],[647,836,193,39],[89,882,442,43],[306,882,81,19],[647,882,453,43],[972,882,56,19],[589,884,22,37],[150,904,79,19],[647,904,282,19],[1008,904,15,19],[89,938,72,26],[167,938,50,26],[223,938,50,26],[278,938,50,26],[334,938,57,26],[397,938,50,26],[647,938,154,26],[807,938,131,26],[99,944,52,14],[177,944,30,14],[233,944,30,14],[288,944,30,14],[344,944,37,14],[407,944,30,14],[657,944,134,14],[817,944,111,14],[647,970,168,26],[657,976,148,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom three-column row","reason":"Task selection, practice example and rationale panels are unrelated extra points.","boxes":[[64,1042,153,14],[463,1042,215,14],[813,1042,108,14],[463,1065,314,61],[485,1065,115,18],[733,1065,21,18],[813,1065,312,61],[813,1065,238,18],[64,1066,37,14],[101,1066,260,14],[361,1066,74,14],[494,1086,18,18],[64,1088,34,13],[178,1088,129,13],[387,1088,48,13],[64,1110,363,40],[304,1110,51,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tagline","reason":"Slogan-style takeaway that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,1168,143,30]]}],"usd":0.207792,"sec":176,"out":9847,"cut":73,"shrunk":2},{"id":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__wonder__simple","task":"how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/how-we-improved-terminal-bench-2-with-tinker-and-harbor__wonder__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20.7},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-after bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.070772,"sec":47,"out":2957,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-high__raw","clutter":84.6,"shares":{"blue":10.9,"orange":8.9,"red":80.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":53.4},"score":9,"words":478,"missing":[],"summary":"The small results chart is buried under cards, methodology diagrams, a settings table, a capability panel and footer extras.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta","reason":"Tag line, date and author pills are not needed.","boxes":[[925,32,76,23],[1007,32,60,23],[1074,32,82,23],[811,35,98,17],[934,36,58,15],[1016,36,42,15],[1083,36,64,15],[213,37,293,13],[797,38,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline.","boxes":[[58,92,359,14],[44,94,6,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Headline is a long sentence that could be shorter.","boxes":[[44,106,556,90],[127,144,119,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the post and chart.","boxes":[[44,200,606,62],[537,200,87,18],[44,221,80,18],[44,221,589,39],[369,221,49,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Cards repeat the headline and the methodology.","boxes":[[57,313,121,13],[265,313,135,13],[473,313,134,13],[57,324,95,32],[265,324,114,32],[473,324,117,32],[57,354,126,15],[265,354,115,15],[473,354,125,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Methodology diagrams","reason":"Large pipeline diagrams serve a second idea.","boxes":[[59,415,358,34],[44,425,6,15],[728,428,428,16],[380,476,105,21],[981,476,158,21],[74,480,50,13],[389,480,87,13],[553,480,295,13],[990,480,140,13],[61,481,6,10],[540,481,6,10],[61,492,109,32],[540,492,376,32],[61,528,418,34],[61,528,150,15],[540,528,590,52],[540,528,562,33],[380,546,96,15],[619,564,126,15],[556,602,161,171],[737,602,171,171],[927,602,196,171],[927,602,196,4],[74,604,124,43],[74,604,4,43],[215,604,122,43],[215,604,4,43],[355,604,118,43],[355,604,4,43],[84,610,70,14],[226,610,64,14],[365,610,91,14],[566,611,84,10],[746,611,115,10],[936,613,105,10],[208,621,6,7],[338,621,6,7],[566,623,93,14],[746,623,93,14],[936,624,119,14],[84,628,84,10],[226,628,89,10],[365,628,73,10],[566,635,60,14],[936,637,37,14],[746,638,121,10],[746,655,151,74],[564,656,145,30],[936,656,176,44],[936,656,4,44],[583,659,92,12],[946,660,38,13],[801,661,89,14],[805,662,91,10],[76,665,143,13],[256,666,216,11],[571,667,7,7],[767,667,33,24],[583,671,99,10],[946,674,104,12],[801,677,89,14],[805,679,96,10],[920,683,6,7],[767,684,33,8],[946,685,88,12],[756,686,11,11],[84,688,17,11],[103,689,7,7],[456,689,7,7],[564,692,145,39],[767,692,33,9],[767,692,33,25],[107,693,353,64],[107,693,353,62],[801,694,89,14],[805,695,67,10],[583,696,107,13],[120,699,142,16],[322,699,132,16],[328,700,107,13],[124,701,124,13],[750,701,23,9],[936,705,176,44],[936,705,4,44],[571,707,8,8],[730,708,6,7],[583,709,99,10],[801,710,89,14],[946,710,103,13],[805,712,86,10],[583,719,104,10],[946,723,126,12],[946,734,104,12],[564,736,145,30],[746,736,147,12],[752,736,72,12],[869,737,21,10],[583,740,89,12],[84,748,17,11],[571,748,7,7],[456,751,7,7],[583,752,99,10],[746,752,111,12],[752,752,39,12],[833,753,21,10],[936,755,169,10],[220,763,130,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Settings table","reason":"Hyperparameter table beside results is a side topic.","boxes":[[77,848,137,30],[63,857,6,11],[414,858,190,13],[279,925,138,16],[63,926,25,15],[236,926,43,16],[417,926,76,16],[241,927,33,13],[422,927,66,13],[236,954,356,32],[324,955,123,16],[503,955,70,16],[329,956,113,13],[508,956,60,13],[63,963,64,15],[63,1000,70,15],[236,1000,37,16],[241,1001,27,13],[236,1028,127,16],[63,1029,78,15],[236,1057,182,16],[63,1058,57,15],[378,1058,37,16],[383,1059,27,13],[236,1086,139,16],[63,1087,84,15],[335,1087,37,16],[340,1088,27,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability check","reason":"Second claim about general benchmarks.","boxes":[[676,848,207,30],[662,857,6,11],[940,858,197,13],[675,906,437,52],[730,906,99,15],[876,906,110,15],[1027,906,15,15],[1020,924,88,15],[683,986,56,15],[924,986,60,15],[673,989,4,9],[914,989,4,9],[862,991,10,5],[875,991,10,5],[1103,991,10,5],[1116,991,10,5],[683,1024,114,15],[924,1024,39,15],[673,1027,4,9],[914,1027,4,9],[862,1029,10,5],[875,1029,10,5],[1103,1029,10,5],[1116,1029,10,5],[675,1066,423,31]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mark, tagline and contact.","boxes":[[44,1155,17,17],[71,1156,559,16]]}],"usd":0.565198,"sec":860,"out":56229,"cut":210,"shrunk":3},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-high__simple","clutter":28.5,"shares":{"blue":71.5,"orange":0,"red":28.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":72.5},"score":5,"words":61,"missing":[],"summary":"A good pivot-selection diagram is paired with a second, dense advantage-computation panel and two small subtitles that the point doesn't need; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bottom panel subtitle","reason":"Technical tags that don't help read the visual.","boxes":[[882,786,242,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Advantage computation panel","reason":"Second method detail (rollouts, advantage) separate from pivot selection.","boxes":[[76,788,6,14],[76,820,1048,304],[380,832,211,18],[690,834,137,15],[356,861,260,10],[758,861,84,10],[858,861,16,227],[264,866,92,102],[356,876,260,10],[692,876,66,10],[264,881,92,88],[356,890,260,10],[758,890,84,10],[264,895,92,73],[356,905,260,10],[692,905,66,10],[264,910,92,59],[104,912,160,112],[356,919,260,10],[692,919,66,10],[264,924,92,44],[153,927,61,18],[356,934,260,10],[758,934,84,10],[264,939,92,30],[356,948,260,10],[692,948,66,10],[264,953,92,15],[124,956,120,7],[356,963,260,10],[758,963,84,10],[264,968,92,14],[264,968,92,29],[264,968,92,43],[264,968,92,58],[264,968,92,72],[264,968,92,87],[264,968,92,101],[264,968,92,116],[124,969,96,7],[356,977,260,10],[692,977,66,10],[124,984,120,11],[356,992,260,10],[758,992,84,10],[138,1002,92,14],[356,1006,260,10],[692,1006,66,10],[356,1021,260,10],[692,1021,66,10],[356,1035,260,10],[758,1035,84,10],[356,1050,260,10],[692,1050,66,10],[356,1064,260,10],[758,1064,84,10],[356,1079,260,10],[692,1079,66,10],[680,1099,28,14],[733,1099,50,14],[808,1099,28,14]]}],"usd":1.303506,"sec":2117,"out":130021,"cut":62,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-medium__raw","clutter":85.1,"shares":{"blue":10.7,"orange":8.1,"red":81.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":57.8},"score":8,"words":537,"missing":[],"summary":"The small 11.3% to 17.5% chart is buried under a methodology diagram, hyperparameter table, eval panels, stat cards and footers; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta","reason":"Blog tag, date, authors and category tag are not needed.","boxes":[[846,35,25,15],[879,35,3,15],[891,35,58,15],[958,35,3,15],[970,35,186,15],[197,36,307,14],[831,37,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline.","boxes":[[58,110,327,13],[44,111,6,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Long sentence headline; could be short finding.","boxes":[[44,122,543,90],[311,158,289,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big numbers panel","reason":"Repeats 11.3% and 17.5% already in the bars.","boxes":[[1051,127,86,21],[1060,131,68,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Restates the headline and chart result.","boxes":[[44,214,485,37],[123,214,74,17],[230,214,127,17],[378,214,64,17],[529,214,81,17],[257,233,45,17],[442,233,75,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Dataset and pivot stat cards, a second idea beside the chart.","boxes":[[56,298,101,12],[253,298,95,12],[450,298,103,12],[56,309,131,30],[253,309,122,30],[450,309,89,30],[56,336,146,14],[253,336,120,14],[450,336,148,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart caption","reason":"Explanatory sentence restating the evaluation and capability check.","boxes":[[682,313,407,30],[671,314,466,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Methodology diagram","reason":"Large method pipeline unrelated to reading the results chart.","boxes":[[58,411,309,30],[44,421,6,11],[717,421,439,14],[60,461,154,18],[424,461,258,18],[319,463,57,13],[809,463,331,13],[67,464,140,12],[431,464,244,12],[60,491,234,29],[424,491,391,29],[888,502,252,14],[956,502,12,13],[424,520,696,31],[60,521,268,31],[115,521,71,14],[424,563,232,198],[424,563,232,23],[676,563,215,198],[676,563,215,23],[912,563,228,198],[912,563,228,23],[60,564,140,52],[60,564,4,52],[236,564,140,52],[236,564,4,52],[434,568,178,11],[686,568,150,11],[922,568,181,11],[71,572,83,11],[247,572,83,11],[71,581,83,22],[247,581,76,22],[434,590,157,12],[922,590,170,12],[686,593,195,27],[722,595,123,12],[71,600,83,12],[247,600,81,12],[922,601,153,12],[434,607,212,39],[718,607,131,10],[441,613,90,12],[580,616,58,18],[922,619,208,49],[922,619,4,49],[592,620,35,10],[932,624,55,13],[60,626,316,135],[441,628,89,10],[766,628,115,19],[773,632,103,10],[72,634,147,12],[726,638,40,33],[932,638,101,12],[72,650,137,16],[227,650,137,16],[932,650,88,11],[77,653,109,10],[232,653,114,10],[434,653,212,55],[434,653,4,55],[766,653,115,19],[572,657,66,17],[773,657,103,10],[443,658,112,13],[580,660,50,10],[694,661,32,32],[726,663,40,12],[698,667,25,10],[72,671,7,7],[357,671,7,7],[76,675,284,51],[922,675,208,49],[922,675,4,49],[443,676,147,10],[701,678,19,9],[766,678,115,19],[726,679,40,9],[932,680,139,13],[773,682,97,10],[726,683,40,30],[443,690,121,11],[932,694,123,12],[766,703,115,19],[932,706,105,11],[773,707,103,10],[434,714,212,39],[441,720,85,12],[72,722,7,7],[357,722,7,7],[580,723,58,18],[592,728,35,10],[76,731,85,11],[265,731,95,11],[686,731,195,22],[922,731,208,22],[441,736,89,10],[944,736,163,11],[702,737,163,10],[149,745,139,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Hyperparameter table","reason":"Training config table is a separate idea.","boxes":[[75,839,211,30],[61,849,6,11],[444,849,145,14],[61,870,101,13],[61,870,164,21],[225,870,37,13],[225,870,364,21],[61,891,164,33],[225,898,44,18],[61,899,24,14],[269,899,132,15],[401,899,75,16],[231,900,32,13],[406,900,65,13],[61,924,164,49],[225,932,344,31],[309,932,120,16],[483,932,68,16],[314,933,110,13],[488,933,58,13],[61,940,61,14],[61,973,164,33],[61,981,68,14],[225,981,36,16],[230,982,26,13],[61,1005,164,33],[225,1005,364,33],[61,1014,75,14],[225,1014,122,15],[61,1038,164,33],[360,1046,36,16],[61,1047,55,14],[225,1047,175,15],[365,1048,26,13],[319,1079,36,16],[61,1080,80,14],[225,1080,134,15],[324,1081,26,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Eval and capability panel","reason":"Repeats eval setup and adds general capability check.","boxes":[[657,839,309,30],[643,849,6,11],[993,849,146,14],[654,875,22,29],[763,875,29,29],[883,875,84,29],[1009,875,116,29],[654,903,74,27],[763,903,78,27],[883,903,81,27],[1009,903,98,27],[917,983,208,17],[669,984,222,14],[657,986,6,11],[924,986,194,11],[898,1006,75,14],[657,1007,444,14],[689,1036,49,13],[797,1036,53,13],[910,1036,100,13],[1069,1036,34,13],[679,1040,5,5],[787,1040,5,5],[900,1040,5,5],[1059,1040,5,5],[657,1070,174,15],[878,1071,247,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Tagline and contact repeat brand; not needed.","boxes":[[44,1159,513,15]]}],"usd":1.075618,"sec":1419,"out":107271,"cut":221,"shrunk":3},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon-medium__simple","clutter":5.3,"shares":{"blue":94.7,"orange":0,"red":5.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":60.8},"score":4,"words":74,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic is a dense pipeline diagram, and the hyperparameter boxes (advantage, CISPO, learning rate) and small sampling settings are extras, though it shows the method and the result.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Advantage and loss boxes","reason":"Hyperparameter details serve a second point and do not support the result.","boxes":[[980,317,142,160],[1016,341,69,18],[988,378,126,14],[1018,408,66,14],[1018,437,66,16],[980,564,142,160],[1015,588,71,18],[1008,622,85,16],[1012,648,77,15],[1018,683,67,14]]}],"usd":0.943616,"sec":1114,"out":94032,"cut":10,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon__raw","clutter":80.8,"shares":{"blue":14.1,"orange":10.3,"red":75.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":49},"score":7,"words":367,"missing":[],"summary":"The small results chart is buried under method cards, a settings table, verifier cards, a capability panel and header and footer extras; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Authors pill","reason":"Author names do not help read the result.","boxes":[[840,47,45,18],[897,47,3,18],[983,47,3,18],[1052,47,3,18],[911,48,61,17],[997,48,44,17],[1066,48,67,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Section tag and date are unneeded.","boxes":[[252,48,27,17],[288,48,3,17],[300,48,64,17],[237,51,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[67,123,385,14]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[52,134,677,110]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the headline and method.","boxes":[[821,170,326,61],[880,170,90,18],[1001,170,83,18],[1058,192,51,18],[954,213,84,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat card","reason":"Repeats 11.3% and 17.5% already shown in the bars.","boxes":[[77,294,147,14],[189,301,105,72],[77,316,76,52],[163,335,16,26],[77,376,126,20],[211,378,90,16],[86,379,108,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 panel","reason":"Method card unrelated to reading the result.","boxes":[[75,472,201,34],[286,478,137,22],[295,482,119,13],[75,528,317,75],[252,528,74,17],[261,547,81,17],[79,615,138,52],[262,615,138,52],[91,625,74,11],[274,625,80,11],[234,626,11,10],[252,638,6,7],[91,640,89,18],[274,640,81,18],[79,681,179,11],[79,698,321,84],[93,703,103,13],[273,703,114,13],[93,720,7,7],[379,720,7,7],[97,723,286,33],[93,764,114,11],[312,764,74,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 panel","reason":"Pivot pipeline diagram is a second idea.","boxes":[[468,472,415,34],[960,478,165,22],[969,482,147,13],[468,528,642,56],[468,547,95,17],[483,615,181,45],[483,615,4,45],[681,615,428,166],[497,624,108,11],[497,635,100,19],[823,648,144,122],[886,656,18,18],[740,658,16,16],[1033,658,16,16],[892,662,7,7],[570,671,7,6],[730,673,17,19],[747,673,17,19],[1023,673,17,19],[1041,673,17,19],[860,674,35,18],[883,674,12,18],[895,674,12,18],[895,674,35,18],[483,676,181,45],[483,676,4,45],[497,685,120,11],[726,692,9,9],[743,692,9,9],[761,692,9,9],[855,692,10,10],[879,692,10,10],[902,692,10,10],[925,692,10,10],[1019,692,9,9],[1036,692,9,9],[1054,692,9,9],[497,696,129,19],[706,707,83,14],[851,707,88,14],[1002,707,77,14],[696,724,102,11],[835,724,120,11],[990,724,102,11],[570,732,7,6],[835,737,120,14],[483,738,181,44],[483,738,4,44],[497,745,120,11],[497,757,126,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 pipeline panel","reason":"Second method diagram on candidate turn filtering","boxes":[[697,627,312,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Settings table","reason":"Hyperparameter table beside the results is extra.","boxes":[[75,853,184,13],[478,853,154,13],[75,881,27,16],[210,881,186,17],[396,881,81,17],[401,882,71,14],[75,913,68,16],[210,913,378,34],[304,913,131,17],[494,913,73,17],[309,914,121,14],[499,914,63,14],[210,962,38,17],[75,963,75,16],[215,964,28,14],[75,995,84,16],[210,995,136,17],[75,1027,61,16],[210,1027,193,17],[361,1027,38,17],[366,1028,28,14],[316,1059,38,17],[75,1060,90,16],[210,1060,148,17],[321,1061,28,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Verifier cards","reason":"Verifier explanation is a separate idea.","boxes":[[693,851,228,13],[938,851,191,13],[705,883,68,13],[928,883,163,13],[705,899,183,49],[928,899,164,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability check","reason":"General benchmarks panel is a separate point.","boxes":[[693,1009,176,13],[945,1009,184,13],[693,1028,414,16],[910,1028,92,15],[716,1059,56,15],[813,1059,60,15],[915,1059,114,15],[1070,1059,39,15],[704,1063,6,6],[801,1063,6,6],[903,1063,6,6],[1058,1063,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Second brand mention plus tagline.","boxes":[[52,1148,62,15],[114,1148,509,16]]}],"usd":0.325868,"sec":519,"out":32296,"cut":165,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__argon__simple","clutter":74.3,"shares":{"blue":25.7,"orange":0,"red":74.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":76.4},"score":8,"words":136,"missing":[],"summary":"The results chart is a small part of the canvas and two large method diagrams (Stage 1 and Stage 2) bury it; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 diagram","reason":"Method pipeline for distillation, unrelated to reading the results bars.","boxes":[[48,103,1104,200],[76,123,139,18],[76,157,276,118],[76,157,5,118],[426,157,348,118],[848,157,276,118],[848,157,5,118],[100,173,162,44],[872,173,148,44],[450,181,38,15],[712,181,38,15],[450,209,300,12],[100,226,174,18],[872,226,107,18],[450,234,130,17],[649,234,101,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 PivotRL diagram","reason":"Large method diagram with hyperparameters, a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[48,355,1104,530],[76,377,116,18],[657,380,467,14],[1010,427,25,16],[1066,427,19,16],[996,430,9,9],[1052,430,9,9],[412,451,376,120],[436,458,215,42],[104,463,228,96],[868,463,228,96],[124,483,107,18],[888,483,101,18],[550,510,222,17],[436,513,11,11],[454,513,11,11],[472,513,11,11],[490,513,11,11],[508,513,11,11],[526,513,11,11],[125,521,11,11],[143,521,11,11],[161,521,11,11],[179,521,11,11],[889,521,11,11],[907,521,11,11],[925,521,11,11],[943,521,11,11],[436,540,163,14],[238,571,362,60],[76,639,324,214],[438,639,324,214],[800,639,324,214],[100,652,218,39],[462,652,246,39],[824,652,117,39],[100,694,216,18],[462,694,173,18],[824,694,136,18],[462,727,276,46],[824,727,276,46],[100,731,276,26],[474,734,50,17],[836,735,116,15],[351,738,13,13],[110,739,9,9],[474,752,167,16],[836,752,109,16],[100,767,276,26],[351,774,13,13],[110,775,9,9],[462,783,276,46],[824,783,276,46],[474,790,81,17],[836,791,131,15],[100,803,276,26],[474,808,152,16],[836,808,158,16],[330,810,34,13],[110,811,9,9]]}],"usd":0.323356,"sec":460,"out":32006,"cut":76,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-high__raw","clutter":38.7,"shares":{"blue":44.3,"orange":33.9,"red":21.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.8},"score":4,"words":69,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear two-bar result is cluttered by a wordy headline, subtitle, tag, footer URL and a method-stage panel; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Category tag with dot, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[868,64,268,21],[849,71,7,7]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline sentence","reason":"Large sentence headline; could be short finding like '11.3% → 17.5% on τ³-Banking'.","boxes":[[64,153,782,191]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage cards","reason":"Method description cards serve a second idea beyond the result chart.","boxes":[[64,856,67,20],[662,856,70,20],[64,881,176,52],[662,881,117,52],[64,940,355,58],[662,941,25,26],[687,941,302,59],[662,972,33,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[1023,1126,113,22]]}],"usd":0.18318,"sec":96,"out":3392,"cut":13,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.5},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a title, metric, logo, and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.13139,"sec":76,"out":2318,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-medium__raw","clutter":37.2,"shares":{"blue":48.9,"orange":28.1,"red":23.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.5},"score":5,"words":75,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear two-bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow tag, a sentence headline, a subtitle, a recipe panel and a footer URL.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[777,62,359,22]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Two-sentence headline, very large; could be a short finding like '11.3% → 17.5% on τ³-Banking'.","boxes":[[64,149,787,169]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates the method; it is not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[64,323,590,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe panel","reason":"Method cards for a second idea, beside a results chart.","boxes":[[64,899,196,21],[150,942,154,45],[721,942,103,45],[64,950,74,32],[632,950,77,32],[77,956,48,20],[645,956,51,20],[568,978,27,45],[64,999,341,58],[632,999,279,58]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo already identifies AfterQuery.","boxes":[[1023,1115,113,22]]}],"usd":0.13703,"sec":75,"out":2469,"cut":14,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.2},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric, value labels, and a logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.11784,"sec":73,"out":2047,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":30.6,"shares":{"blue":57.5,"orange":23.9,"red":18.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.8},"score":5,"words":70,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear before/after bar chart is cluttered by a wordy headline, a category tag, a method-stage panel and a repeated footer brand.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Research / Post-training tag adds nothing to reading the chart.","boxes":[[906,64,230,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Two-line headline","reason":"Large slogan-like headline; could be a short finding such as '11.3% to 17.5% on τ³-Banking'.","boxes":[[64,148,654,108],[64,223,597,108]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stage cards","reason":"Method explanation is a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,921,58,15],[644,921,58,15],[64,942,165,50],[644,942,110,50],[528,964,38,20],[64,997,392,53],[644,998,23,24],[916,998,30,24],[644,999,361,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1030,1135,106,21]]}],"usd":0.29233,"sec":153,"out":5575,"cut":13,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.3},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric, values, labels and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.19784,"sec":104,"out":3647,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra__raw","clutter":45.6,"shares":{"blue":42.2,"orange":24.2,"red":33.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.1},"score":5,"words":99,"missing":[],"summary":"The pass@5 bar chart is a clear main visual, but the method cards, kicker, subtitle, and footer add a second point and repeat the chart; the headline is wordy.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Category tag","reason":"Research category tag; a section label that tells the reader nothing new","boxes":[[811,66,325,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence slogan-style headline; shorten to a finding, such as 'Over 50% more passes with 50 tasks'","boxes":[[64,148,747,164]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle restating chart","reason":"Restates model, benchmark and method already named in the chart and labels","boxes":[[64,319,417,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Kicker line","reason":"Eyebrow-style section kicker above the method cards","boxes":[[64,829,426,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline cards","reason":"Stage 1 and Stage 2 method cards serve a second point beside the results chart","boxes":[[64,886,62,14],[624,886,62,14],[64,910,165,48],[624,910,110,48],[586,933,26,18],[64,968,380,54],[624,968,357,54],[64,1041,397,26],[624,1041,45,38],[777,1041,34,38],[669,1050,318,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer data-source line","reason":"Data-source note and footer strip add nothing needed to read the chart","boxes":[[64,1134,361,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer website URL","reason":"Brand shown again after the logo already marks the source","boxes":[[1036,1134,100,20]]}],"usd":0.15713,"sec":75,"out":2871,"cut":19,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__astra__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.4},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short title, named metric, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.11459,"sec":59,"out":1982,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":34.1,"shares":{"blue":65.9,"orange":0,"red":34.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.7},"score":6,"words":159,"missing":[],"summary":"The 11.3% to 17.5% comparison is buried under eyebrow, decoration, a duplicate bar scale, recipe cards, a capability-check block and a footer brand; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date tag and decoration","reason":"Research note/date label and decorative logo-shaped blocks.","boxes":[[1025,60,33,12],[899,68,119,14],[1018,68,9,14],[1035,68,93,14],[1013,82,33,12],[1002,105,55,12],[992,126,32,12],[978,150,100,12],[969,173,33,12],[1076,173,30,12],[960,196,33,12],[1085,196,35,12],[932,218,75,12],[1075,218,66,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag line","reason":"Category tag line above headline.","boxes":[[90,154,390,14],[161,154,9,14],[278,154,9,14],[72,157,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle restating the chart","reason":"Paragraph explaining the claim; 250 and 50 tasks are extra points.","boxes":[[72,393,800,72],[419,393,114,33],[533,429,98,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe row","reason":"Method cards are a second idea beside results.","boxes":[[235,890,56,12],[561,890,56,12],[857,890,56,12],[72,893,113,29],[235,904,104,26],[561,904,68,26],[857,906,88,40],[514,932,16,10],[235,934,229,33],[561,934,212,33],[857,950,218,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability check","reason":"Separate claim about general benchmarks.","boxes":[[235,1013,309,81],[450,1013,323,48],[72,1024,121,29],[235,1094,645,13],[629,1094,7,13],[751,1094,7,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mark plus tagline.","boxes":[[104,1131,101,13],[817,1131,311,13],[969,1131,7,13]]}],"usd":0.01047705,"sec":88,"out":17117,"cut":46,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a clear title, labelled values, one logo, and no extra blocks.","marks":[],"usd":0.00820275,"sec":52,"out":13278,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-max__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":53.4,"shares":{"blue":24.5,"orange":44.2,"red":31.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.5},"score":6,"words":145,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear 11.3% to 17.5% bar chart is buried under a huge headline, a subtitle, a full recipe panel with its own stats, and extra header and footer text.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date header","reason":"Page metadata, not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[1000,57,29,13],[1039,57,7,13],[1058,57,78,13],[982,60,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[92,131,230,13],[64,136,18,4]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Oversized sentence headline that fills a third of the canvas; could be shorter.","boxes":[[64,139,785,131],[64,222,680,131],[744,222,278,131],[64,305,813,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory subtitle repeating the recipe panel's 50 and 193 figures.","boxes":[[64,434,584,29],[311,434,133,27],[568,434,75,27],[64,465,576,29],[105,465,96,27],[353,465,282,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe panel","reason":"Second idea: method cards, 50→193 stats, dot field beside results chart.","boxes":[[826,555,112,13],[1049,555,60,13],[809,558,7,7],[809,581,269,91],[846,697,84,17],[809,701,12,12],[846,717,245,35],[916,758,12,20],[846,763,65,11],[932,763,59,11],[846,803,58,17],[809,807,12,12],[846,823,269,52],[1004,865,72,89],[846,871,48,76],[978,902,14,23],[901,919,64,21],[1083,922,43,21],[817,987,4,4],[825,987,4,4],[833,987,4,4],[841,987,4,4],[849,987,4,4],[857,987,4,4],[865,987,4,4],[873,987,4,4],[881,987,4,4],[889,987,4,4],[897,987,4,4],[905,987,4,4],[913,987,4,4],[921,987,4,4],[929,987,4,4],[937,987,4,4],[945,987,4,4],[953,987,4,4],[809,995,4,4],[817,995,4,4],[825,995,4,4],[833,995,4,4],[841,995,4,4],[849,995,4,4],[857,995,4,4],[865,995,4,4],[881,995,4,4],[889,995,4,4],[897,995,4,4],[905,995,4,4],[913,995,4,4],[921,995,4,4],[929,995,4,4],[937,995,4,4],[945,995,4,4],[953,995,4,4],[961,995,4,4],[809,1003,4,4],[817,1003,4,4],[825,1003,4,4],[833,1003,4,4],[841,1003,4,4],[849,1003,4,4],[857,1003,4,4],[865,1003,4,4],[873,1003,4,4],[881,1003,4,4],[889,1003,4,4],[897,1003,4,4],[905,1003,4,4],[913,1003,4,4],[921,1003,4,4],[929,1003,4,4],[937,1003,4,4],[945,1003,4,4],[953,1003,4,4],[961,1003,4,4],[809,1011,4,4],[817,1011,4,4],[825,1011,4,4],[833,1011,4,4],[841,1011,4,4],[849,1011,4,4],[857,1011,4,4],[865,1011,4,4],[873,1011,4,4],[881,1011,4,4],[889,1011,4,4],[897,1011,4,4],[905,1011,4,4],[913,1011,4,4],[921,1011,4,4],[937,1011,4,4],[945,1011,4,4],[953,1011,4,4],[961,1011,4,4],[809,1019,4,4],[817,1019,4,4],[825,1019,4,4],[833,1019,4,4],[841,1019,4,4],[849,1019,4,4],[857,1019,4,4],[865,1019,4,4],[873,1019,4,4],[881,1019,4,4],[889,1019,4,4],[897,1019,4,4],[905,1019,4,4],[913,1019,4,4],[921,1019,4,4],[929,1019,4,4],[937,1019,4,4],[945,1019,4,4],[953,1019,4,4],[961,1019,4,4],[809,1027,4,4],[817,1027,4,4],[825,1027,4,4],[833,1027,4,4],[849,1027,4,4],[857,1027,4,4],[865,1027,4,4],[873,1027,4,4],[881,1027,4,4],[889,1027,4,4],[897,1027,4,4],[905,1027,4,4],[913,1027,4,4],[921,1027,4,4],[929,1027,4,4],[937,1027,4,4],[945,1027,4,4],[953,1027,4,4],[961,1027,4,4],[1050,1029,59,22],[809,1035,4,4],[817,1035,4,4],[825,1035,4,4],[833,1035,4,4],[841,1035,4,4],[849,1035,4,4],[857,1035,4,4],[865,1035,4,4],[873,1035,4,4],[881,1035,4,4],[889,1035,4,4],[897,1035,4,4],[905,1035,4,4],[913,1035,4,4],[921,1035,4,4],[929,1035,4,4],[937,1035,4,4],[945,1035,4,4],[953,1035,4,4],[961,1035,4,4],[809,1043,4,4],[817,1043,4,4],[825,1043,4,4],[833,1043,4,4],[841,1043,4,4],[849,1043,4,4],[857,1043,4,4],[865,1043,4,4],[873,1043,4,4],[881,1043,4,4],[889,1043,4,4],[897,1043,4,4],[913,1043,4,4],[921,1043,4,4],[929,1043,4,4],[937,1043,4,4],[945,1043,4,4],[953,1043,4,4],[961,1043,4,4],[809,1051,4,4],[817,1051,4,4],[825,1051,4,4],[833,1051,4,4],[841,1051,4,4],[849,1051,4,4],[857,1051,4,4],[865,1051,4,4],[873,1051,4,4],[881,1051,4,4],[889,1051,4,4],[897,1051,4,4],[905,1051,4,4],[913,1051,4,4],[921,1051,4,4],[929,1051,4,4],[937,1051,4,4],[945,1051,4,4],[953,1051,4,4],[961,1051,4,4],[1005,1058,104,10],[809,1059,4,4],[817,1059,4,4],[825,1059,4,4],[833,1059,4,4],[841,1059,4,4],[849,1059,4,4],[857,1059,4,4],[865,1059,4,4],[873,1059,4,4],[881,1059,4,4],[889,1059,4,4],[897,1059,4,4],[905,1059,4,4],[913,1059,4,4],[921,1059,4,4],[929,1059,4,4],[937,1059,4,4],[945,1059,4,4],[961,1059,4,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"'The result' kicker","reason":"Section tag above the chart adds no information","boxes":[[110,556,75,13],[93,559,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author footer","reason":"Bylines and team name are not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[64,1143,175,15],[253,1143,5,16],[272,1145,117,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline and URL","reason":"Tagline and brand URL repeat the logo's branding.","boxes":[[832,1148,165,11],[1051,1148,85,11]]}],"usd":0.039628649999999994,"sec":277,"out":65703,"cut":237,"shrunk":4},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-max__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.1},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-and-after bar chart with a title, logo, model tag and labelled values, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.02184975,"sec":259,"out":36023,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":58.6,"shares":{"blue":41.4,"orange":0,"red":58.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.6},"score":6,"words":208,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is a small part of the canvas, buried under stat cards, a recipe section, a capability strip and a footer, though it is complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Top-right tag","reason":"Category tag with no information.","boxes":[[971,53,165,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[80,140,247,13],[64,143,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Model metadata block","reason":"Model and benchmark are repeated in the subtitle and elsewhere.","boxes":[[1030,141,33,12],[1056,141,80,47],[1010,159,46,12],[1003,176,60,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explains methods and restates the topic.","boxes":[[64,322,625,47]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Left stat card","reason":"Restates 11.3% and 17.5% already shown by the bars.","boxes":[[91,421,197,12],[216,438,99,101],[317,459,19,37],[91,463,66,67],[159,476,13,24],[183,485,21,34],[91,538,246,42],[159,538,132,19],[190,561,87,19],[91,656,25,11],[334,656,32,11],[91,673,57,11],[334,673,32,11],[91,691,44,11],[302,691,63,11],[91,709,50,11],[289,709,76,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe","reason":"Method cards serve a second idea unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[64,770,196,39],[878,790,258,12],[64,836,87,12],[447,836,80,12],[805,836,73,12],[64,855,95,18],[447,855,132,18],[805,855,65,18],[64,872,167,46],[447,872,120,46],[805,872,83,46],[64,905,183,46],[447,905,240,46],[805,905,74,46],[64,950,259,56],[447,950,288,56],[805,950,294,37],[930,952,71,15],[933,953,65,13],[834,999,93,11],[93,1019,57,11],[476,1019,186,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability check","reason":"Separate claim about general benchmarks.","boxes":[[102,1088,158,18],[1062,1092,74,11],[65,1095,22,22],[852,1099,5,18],[71,1102,10,7],[834,1103,5,14],[861,1104,5,13],[843,1106,5,11],[1049,1107,87,11],[102,1108,549,15],[825,1108,5,9],[870,1109,5,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mention plus tagline and links.","boxes":[[64,1151,64,11],[128,1151,147,11],[303,1151,147,11],[912,1151,224,11]]}],"usd":0.00648405,"sec":34,"out":10462,"cut":69,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":22.2},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short context tag, a single logo, and no extra elements.","marks":[],"usd":0.00393855,"sec":28,"out":6171,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":46.7,"shares":{"blue":53.3,"orange":0,"red":46.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.5},"score":6,"words":157,"missing":[],"summary":"The 11.3% to 17.5% bar chart is crowded by a recipe stats panel, method cards, subtitle, tags and footer; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the point.","boxes":[[879,77,115,14],[1006,77,9,14],[1027,77,97,14],[860,81,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Eyebrow category line above headline.","boxes":[[95,157,125,15],[231,157,8,15],[250,157,240,15],[76,161,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the chart values and recipe already shown elsewhere.","boxes":[[76,380,848,98],[310,380,232,30],[210,447,138,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Recipe stats panel","reason":"Side panel of training stats serving a second idea; 97 and 64k repeat chart context.","boxes":[[794,493,89,14],[794,530,68,76],[938,540,141,38],[938,583,132,13],[794,655,102,76],[938,667,130,19],[938,691,153,27],[794,779,68,76],[938,782,150,38],[938,825,167,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stage cards","reason":"Pipeline cards beside results are a second idea.","boxes":[[99,920,18,18],[650,920,18,18],[475,921,77,20],[970,921,133,20],[125,923,55,13],[676,923,55,13],[102,924,12,11],[653,924,12,11],[482,925,63,13],[977,925,119,13],[99,939,152,45],[650,939,101,45],[609,972,6,10],[99,983,439,36],[650,983,386,36]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Repeated brand, tagline and URL when logo is already present.","boxes":[[76,1137,64,17],[140,1137,528,18],[1012,1142,112,14],[996,1146,6,6]]}],"usd":0.01085985,"sec":76,"out":17755,"cut":45,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.6},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with a logo, a context tag, value labels and category labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.00465555,"sec":45,"out":7366,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek__raw","clutter":45.9,"shares":{"blue":54.1,"orange":0,"red":45.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.7},"score":6,"words":136,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is surrounded by a subtitle, stat cards, hyperparameter row, side note and duplicate footers; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[973,57,34,14],[1041,57,95,14],[1021,61,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker tags","reason":"Category and kicker lines above the headline add nothing.","boxes":[[74,126,159,15],[64,127,10,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category eyebrow","reason":"Category tag, not needed.","boxes":[[946,127,190,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explaining method; not needed to read chart.","boxes":[[80,314,111,23],[642,314,62,23],[64,315,781,50]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Dataset and pivot counts, a side idea; 97 tasks repeats the header.","boxes":[[90,771,69,103],[448,771,89,103],[806,771,70,103],[90,865,241,39],[90,865,171,18],[448,865,247,39],[448,865,92,18],[806,865,219,39],[806,865,107,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Hyperparameter row","reason":"Training settings serve a second, unrelated point.","boxes":[[64,975,30,13],[299,975,75,13],[514,975,98,13],[728,975,75,13],[943,975,83,13],[64,993,131,18],[299,993,155,18],[728,993,32,18],[943,993,31,18],[514,995,33,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Also checked","reason":"General capability check is a separate point.","boxes":[[64,1050,718,38],[64,1050,84,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the header logo.","boxes":[[977,1075,159,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Bottom footer","reason":"Teacher-student line and URL repeat subtitle and brand.","boxes":[[64,1142,321,14],[1024,1142,112,14]]}],"usd":0.01552665,"sec":163,"out":25533,"cut":42,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__deepseek__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.4},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before/after bar chart with the benchmark, metric, values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.00506775,"sec":75,"out":8053,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":77.7,"shares":{"blue":16.7,"orange":11.2,"red":72.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.4},"score":8,"words":387,"missing":[],"summary":"A small bar chart is buried among pipeline cards, hyperparameter tables, stat rows, a repeated big number and header and footer extras; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag/date/authors","reason":"Category pill, date and authors do not help reading the chart.","boxes":[[857,44,3,17],[874,44,63,17],[951,44,3,17],[969,44,183,17],[721,46,111,14],[709,48,6,10]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Headline is long; could shorten to '5x-style' finding, e.g. '11.3% to 17.5% on τ³-Banking'.","boxes":[[48,119,1066,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence restating the headline and pipeline.","boxes":[[48,180,1068,44],[91,180,396,19],[555,180,98,19],[686,180,90,19],[985,180,55,19],[136,203,91,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Methodology pipeline panel","reason":"Pipeline cards are a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[987,296,140,21],[565,299,255,14],[996,300,122,13],[553,301,6,10],[966,353,146,19],[571,356,238,13],[974,356,130,13],[571,376,267,17],[571,397,518,31],[730,397,73,14],[903,448,9,14],[767,449,132,13],[975,481,137,19],[571,484,126,13],[983,484,121,13],[571,504,211,17],[571,525,535,31],[604,525,66,14],[934,576,9,14],[737,577,193,13],[973,609,139,19],[571,612,225,13],[981,612,123,13],[571,632,271,17],[571,652,507,31],[582,710,104,12],[857,710,120,12],[582,726,148,12],[857,726,167,12],[582,740,185,12],[857,740,173,12],[912,781,9,14],[759,782,149,13],[994,814,119,19],[567,816,118,12],[567,828,200,17],[959,833,154,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Model progression callouts","reason":"Restates 11.3%, 17.5% and +54.9% already shown on the bars.","boxes":[[309,345,163,14],[294,348,7,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat 11.3→17.5","reason":"Repeats values already labelled on the bars.","boxes":[[233,365,142,56],[73,382,87,34],[172,392,49,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability check box","reason":"Second claim unrelated to main result.","boxes":[[111,744,356,45],[111,744,170,14],[85,745,17,17],[89,747,9,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Sample efficiency stats","reason":"Stats row repeats 50 tasks and adds another idea.","boxes":[[79,896,120,13],[67,897,6,10],[67,985,31,30],[184,985,46,30],[67,1015,96,14],[184,1015,66,14],[67,1037,62,30],[184,1037,46,30],[67,1068,86,14],[184,1068,87,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Hyperparameter table","reason":"Table of settings unrelated to reading the main result.","boxes":[[359,896,241,13],[347,897,6,10],[347,955,23,14],[482,956,266,13],[347,979,58,14],[482,980,278,13],[347,1003,68,14],[482,1004,26,13],[347,1027,74,14],[482,1028,149,13],[482,1051,175,26],[347,1057,92,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Evaluation bullets panel","reason":"Repeats eval setup and capability check shown elsewhere.","boxes":[[839,896,189,13],[827,897,6,10],[839,976,270,30],[839,976,117,14],[827,980,5,5],[839,1014,281,30],[839,1014,102,14],[827,1018,5,5],[839,1051,246,30],[839,1051,83,14],[827,1055,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline/contact","reason":"Tagline and second brand mention; the logo already exists.","boxes":[[62,1145,519,15],[48,1148,6,10]]}],"usd":0.315277875,"sec":622,"out":76138,"cut":113,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.4},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, metric, labelled values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.233578125,"sec":555,"out":56293,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":70.8,"shares":{"blue":23.6,"orange":11.2,"red":65.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.1},"score":8,"words":367,"missing":[],"summary":"The small bar chart is buried under stat cards, method panels, parameter tables, a callout, a subtitle and a footer; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Applied Research pill","reason":"Badge/tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[216,43,119,13],[204,46,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow and authors","reason":"Eyebrow kicker and byline unneeded.","boxes":[[150,108,3,16],[161,108,175,16],[62,109,80,15],[48,111,6,10]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Sentence-like headline, longer than needed.","boxes":[[48,120,677,110],[149,166,145,65]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the chart finding.","boxes":[[48,229,1030,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Benchmark Evaluation kicker","reason":"Eyebrow label above the chart adds nothing","boxes":[[73,321,142,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Delta callout and repeats","reason":"Gain restated; 11.3% and 17.5% repeated in subtitle.","boxes":[[876,331,108,50],[997,341,115,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Scale note","reason":"Axis already shows scale.","boxes":[[998,395,129,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards row","reason":"Secondary stats unrelated to main chart reading.","boxes":[[65,605,115,12],[344,605,102,12],[623,605,122,12],[902,605,142,12],[65,612,118,50],[344,612,135,50],[623,612,147,50],[902,612,189,50],[65,658,190,32],[344,658,194,32],[623,658,188,32],[902,658,207,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stage panels","reason":"Method and hyperparameters are a second idea.","boxes":[[416,748,156,16],[975,748,156,16],[69,749,49,13],[628,749,49,13],[423,750,142,12],[982,750,142,12],[69,783,287,31],[628,783,300,31],[69,820,482,52],[628,820,472,34],[665,878,83,15],[748,878,299,16],[641,879,13,13],[106,896,99,15],[205,896,279,16],[82,897,13,13],[665,901,100,15],[765,901,309,16],[641,902,13,13],[106,919,445,32],[106,919,108,15],[82,920,13,13],[665,925,74,15],[739,925,353,16],[641,926,13,13],[106,959,86,15],[192,959,334,16],[82,960,13,13],[80,1005,167,12],[474,1005,87,12],[639,1005,180,12],[1000,1005,120,12],[80,1023,76,11],[244,1023,76,11],[409,1023,76,11],[639,1023,23,11],[803,1023,76,11],[968,1023,82,11],[80,1035,75,13],[244,1035,68,13],[409,1035,102,13],[639,1035,109,13],[803,1035,27,13],[968,1035,95,13],[80,1054,100,11],[244,1054,88,11],[409,1054,65,11],[639,1054,59,11],[803,1054,59,11],[968,1054,59,11],[80,1066,108,13],[244,1066,101,13],[409,1066,109,13],[639,1066,136,13],[803,1066,122,13],[968,1066,149,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline and logo","reason":"Second brand mark plus tagline.","boxes":[[48,1145,559,16],[1052,1145,100,17]]}],"usd":0.223608,"sec":566,"out":53915,"cut":96,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.8},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short title, metric, labelled values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.17738325,"sec":507,"out":42670,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":60.5,"shares":{"blue":39.5,"orange":0,"red":60.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.3},"score":7,"words":235,"missing":[],"summary":"The 11.3% to 17.5% bar chart is buried under stat cards, a pipeline, a config table, a capability bar, a repeated stats row and a footer; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Applied Research tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag with no information.","boxes":[[507,61,137,15],[491,63,6,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date tag","reason":"Date and benchmark tag repeat information found elsewhere.","boxes":[[929,61,207,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the chart numbers and the 50-task claim.","boxes":[[64,245,921,49],[670,245,100,22],[64,246,880,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Stat cards restate and extend the claim beyond the bars.","boxes":[[595,381,41,59],[883,381,84,59],[707,411,114,19],[1022,411,87,19],[713,414,102,13],[1028,414,75,13],[595,438,128,17],[883,438,123,17],[595,458,198,32],[883,458,216,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training pipeline","reason":"Method cards are a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[597,554,234,15],[923,555,184,13],[614,611,55,13],[876,611,55,13],[614,630,81,19],[876,630,53,19],[614,655,213,66],[876,655,205,66],[614,729,214,30],[876,729,202,17],[620,731,175,26],[882,731,190,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Config settings","reason":"Hyperparameter table is unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[593,833,220,13],[1001,833,110,13],[593,858,27,13],[726,858,68,13],[858,858,68,13],[991,858,68,13],[593,874,88,30],[726,874,120,15],[858,874,88,15],[991,874,104,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Pass@5 repeat","reason":"Repeats the bar values in big numbers under the chart.","boxes":[[99,869,112,14],[302,869,152,14],[99,877,96,63],[302,877,95,63],[99,935,167,32],[302,935,158,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"General capability","reason":"Separate claim about general benchmarks.","boxes":[[759,954,295,16],[759,954,311,31],[608,955,102,30],[593,966,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Company tagline and description are not needed.","boxes":[[64,1085,583,44],[64,1132,311,16]]}],"usd":0.072026625,"sec":235,"out":17168,"cut":58,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0.6,"shares":{"blue":99.4,"orange":0,"red":0.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.5},"score":1,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean; the top-right τ³-Banking tag repeats the title, and nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Benchmark tag","reason":"τ³-Banking is already named in the chart title.","boxes":[[1037,51,103,20]]}],"usd":0.043857,"sec":226,"out":10300,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-high__raw","clutter":38.7,"shares":{"blue":61.3,"orange":0,"red":38.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.3},"score":6,"words":131,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is surrounded by method cards, hyperparameters, a capability note, bylines and tags that should go; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[963,65,173,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle restating method","reason":"Explains the method the chart does not need; secondary to finding","boxes":[[64,268,414,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 card","reason":"Method card unrelated to reading the results chart.","boxes":[[64,798,128,21],[64,826,114,27],[64,861,501,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 card and settings","reason":"Method and hyperparameters serve a second idea.","boxes":[[620,798,134,21],[620,826,74,27],[620,861,488,43],[620,920,77,13],[887,920,100,13],[620,935,61,20],[887,935,55,20],[620,965,100,13],[887,965,61,13],[620,980,29,20],[887,980,101,20],[620,1010,77,13],[887,1010,77,13],[620,1025,44,20],[887,1025,42,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"General capability note","reason":"Separate claim about other benchmarks.","boxes":[[64,1085,132,20],[196,1086,823,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author names","reason":"Bylines are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[64,1123,232,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline repeats the brand, which already has a logo.","boxes":[[959,1127,177,14]]}],"usd":0.34674,"sec":954,"out":57329,"cut":27,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.3},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with the benchmark, metric, and a single brand mark.","marks":[],"usd":0.147498,"sec":403,"out":24057,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-medium__raw","clutter":47.1,"shares":{"blue":52.9,"orange":0,"red":47.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29},"score":6,"words":123,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear 11.3% to 17.5% comparison is surrounded by a four-column method and eval stats row, a hyperparameter footer, a date tag and bylines that should go.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[969,71,163,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Method subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explains the method and restates the chart's claim.","boxes":[[68,291,670,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Four stat columns","reason":"Method, eval setup and capability stats serve secondary points beside the main result.","boxes":[[68,770,89,14],[361,770,62,14],[627,770,80,14],[893,770,89,14],[90,779,59,75],[361,779,82,75],[627,779,55,75],[893,779,27,75],[68,791,22,53],[361,852,209,87],[893,852,188,109],[68,853,211,66],[627,853,199,65],[627,854,6,17],[213,899,8,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author names","reason":"Bylines add nothing to reading the result.","boxes":[[1054,1096,78,50]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Hyperparameter footer","reason":"Training hyperparameters are an unrelated method detail, not an eval footnote.","boxes":[[68,1103,721,43]]}],"usd":0.143172,"sec":361,"out":23401,"cut":23,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.8},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with model, benchmark, metric, labels and logo, and nothing extra.","marks":[],"usd":0.070374,"sec":182,"out":11203,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":39.7,"shares":{"blue":60.3,"orange":0,"red":39.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.1},"score":6,"words":148,"missing":[],"summary":"The main before-and-after pass@5 chart is clear, but the stage cards, hyperparameter table, and training-count stat are extra ideas, and the subtitle, eyebrow, date, and footer are unneeded.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Publication date","reason":"Metadata the reader does not need to read the chart.","boxes":[[1038,62,90,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog eyebrow","reason":"Category tag above the headline adds nothing.","boxes":[[72,122,32,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle restating method","reason":"Subtitle explains the method rather than the chart's point.","boxes":[[72,321,431,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training data count stat","reason":"Pivot and trajectory count is a separate point about data scale.","boxes":[[72,734,60,68],[258,734,46,68],[136,763,434,29],[205,763,45,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 and Stage 2 method cards","reason":"Method explanation cards beside the results chart serve a second point.","boxes":[[72,832,51,21],[624,832,54,21],[72,848,167,50],[624,848,111,50],[72,903,453,67],[624,903,491,44],[489,929,7,17],[256,952,7,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Hyperparameter table","reason":"Training settings table is a separate point from the main result.","boxes":[[72,1006,27,18],[480,1006,76,18],[702,1006,36,18],[925,1006,33,18],[72,1028,148,18],[480,1028,37,18],[702,1028,56,18],[925,1028,56,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method and benchmark notes","reason":"Extra method detail and general-capability claim serve other points.","boxes":[[72,1075,656,20],[72,1111,563,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author line and URL footer","reason":"Byline and site URL are decorative sign-off content, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[72,1149,217,20],[1016,1152,112,15]]}],"usd":0.07005,"sec":1479,"out":11214,"cut":32,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.2},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before/after bar chart with a logo, metric context, and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.236844,"sec":656,"out":38948,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok__raw","clutter":51,"shares":{"blue":49,"orange":0,"red":51,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.2},"score":6,"words":128,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is surrounded by a subtitle, two method cards, a capability-check note and tags that should go; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[940,69,188,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates the bar values and explains the method already shown.","boxes":[[72,233,751,60]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 card","reason":"Method card unrelated to reading the results chart.","boxes":[[101,737,64,15],[101,760,135,32],[101,802,452,70]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 2 card","reason":"Method card with hyperparameter pills, a second idea.","boxes":[[639,737,154,15],[639,760,289,32],[639,802,416,46],[639,866,68,27],[715,866,68,27],[791,866,91,27],[891,866,132,27],[649,872,48,15],[725,872,48,15],[801,872,71,15],[901,872,112,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability check","reason":"A separate claim about general benchmarks.","boxes":[[72,1099,748,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Fewer than 250 tasks","reason":"Tagline-like extra not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[952,1129,176,15]]}],"usd":0.052362,"sec":130,"out":8266,"cut":21,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20.5},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short context line, labelled values and axis, and no extras.","marks":[],"usd":0.032088,"sec":102,"out":4822,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-high__raw","clutter":53.7,"shares":{"blue":24.6,"orange":43.4,"red":32,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.9},"score":5,"words":116,"missing":[],"summary":"The results chart is clear and complete, but the method cards and general-capability strip are extra ideas, and the long headline, kicker and URL add clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Website URL","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo; the URL repeats it.","boxes":[[1009,66,127,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog kicker line","reason":"Eyebrow with date and category tag above the headline; restates nothing the chart needs.","boxes":[[82,150,410,17],[64,155,8,8]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Long headline","reason":"Title runs about 12 words over two sizes; shorten to a finding like '11.3% to 17.5% pass@5'.","boxes":[[60,158,826,222],[64,381,554,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline cards","reason":"Four method cards serve a second point about how training works, beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,818,54,15],[85,869,101,14],[365,869,101,14],[645,869,101,14],[925,869,101,14],[85,886,182,50],[365,886,167,50],[645,886,111,50],[925,886,166,50],[330,937,7,12],[610,937,7,12],[890,937,7,12],[85,939,169,43],[365,939,182,66],[645,939,189,66],[925,939,175,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"General capability check","reason":"Separate claim about six other benchmarks, unrelated to reading the main chart.","boxes":[[64,1087,218,15],[64,1110,299,26],[363,1111,666,26]]}],"usd":0.010184700000000001,"sec":124,"out":19938,"cut":26,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.6},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with benchmark, metric, values, and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0049873,"sec":89,"out":9489,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":58.2,"shares":{"blue":41.8,"orange":0,"red":58.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.6},"score":7,"words":129,"missing":[],"summary":"The small bar chart is buried under a huge headline, a repeated big stat, three method cards and footer extras; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date and blog tag tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[915,89,197,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow tag above the headline.","boxes":[[88,173,285,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Subtitle explaining and restating the headline and method.","boxes":[[88,414,925,36],[312,414,250,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big 17.5% stat","reason":"Restates the 17.5% already shown on the bar.","boxes":[[88,466,249,262],[343,511,54,110]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Three method cards","reason":"Method and evaluation cards serve a second idea beside the results chart.","boxes":[[119,802,148,18],[466,802,148,18],[812,802,159,18],[119,836,193,62],[466,836,244,62],[812,836,209,62],[119,913,257,108],[466,913,257,80],[812,913,250,80],[466,1022,251,36],[466,1022,29,18],[620,1022,19,18],[812,1022,232,36],[812,1022,19,18],[919,1022,10,18],[1044,1022,29,18],[119,1040,67,18],[147,1040,10,18],[186,1040,10,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline repeating brand; unneeded.","boxes":[[88,1136,481,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention.","boxes":[[964,1138,148,19]]}],"usd":0.0066727,"sec":82,"out":12914,"cut":31,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short title, labelled values, and one logo; nothing to remove or add.","marks":[],"usd":0.0034348,"sec":48,"out":6384,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":34.1,"shares":{"blue":65.9,"orange":0,"red":34.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.6},"score":5,"words":126,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by the eyebrow, subtitle, date, three method cards and footer branding; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date adds nothing to reading the chart.","boxes":[[939,77,181,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[80,164,382,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Explanatory subtitle that restates the method.","boxes":[[80,401,877,84]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards","reason":"Pipeline and training-setup cards serve a second point beside the results.","boxes":[[104,920,151,17],[460,920,121,17],[816,920,191,17],[104,951,105,22],[460,951,76,22],[614,951,20,22],[1006,951,32,22],[1046,951,17,22],[104,952,271,71],[460,952,239,71],[816,952,274,72],[410,974,22,12],[766,974,22,12],[104,977,96,22],[995,977,17,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer branding","reason":"Brand shown a second time; a logo already exists.","boxes":[[1005,1111,115,22],[80,1116,332,17]]}],"usd":0.0166572,"sec":177,"out":32883,"cut":23,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.5},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before/after bar chart with a short title, one value per bar, and no extras; the AfterQuery logo is visible but absent from the element list, so it could not be graded.","marks":[],"usd":0.008739299999999998,"sec":113,"out":16993,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku__raw","clutter":56.6,"shares":{"blue":27.8,"orange":31.2,"red":41,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.7},"score":6,"words":125,"missing":[],"summary":"The before/after pass@5 result is buried under a pipeline-card row, a stats row, a subtitle, a pill and a footer tagline. Nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date pill","reason":"Badge/tag with no needed information.","boxes":[[851,76,269,44],[868,87,235,22]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline, could be much shorter, e.g. '11.3% to 17.5% on τ³-Banking'.","boxes":[[80,182,1025,143],[798,182,295,77]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Tagline restating method, not the finding.","boxes":[[80,341,635,32]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Bar labels","reason":"Model name repeated; 'selected checkpoint' wordier than needed.","boxes":[[620,608,301,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stage cards","reason":"Pipeline cards serve a second idea beside results.","boxes":[[80,754,195,22],[107,825,181,19],[468,825,206,19],[830,825,173,19],[107,856,167,33],[468,856,132,33],[830,856,197,33],[397,879,38,16],[759,879,38,16],[107,902,224,23],[468,902,253,48],[830,902,243,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset and setting stats unrelated to reading the main chart.","boxes":[[80,999,64,73],[363,999,89,73],[623,999,56,73],[883,999,36,73],[80,1077,213,45],[363,1077,161,45],[623,1077,188,45],[883,1077,186,45]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mention, tagline and URL, with a decorative dot.","boxes":[[459,1155,14,22],[734,1155,386,22]]}],"usd":0.0047177,"sec":44,"out":9004,"cut":32,"shrunk":3},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.6},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one before-and-after bar chart with a short title, labelled values, and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0023608,"sec":26,"out":4236,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-high__raw","clutter":39.4,"shares":{"blue":60.6,"orange":0,"red":39.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":21.8},"score":6,"words":93,"missing":[],"summary":"The pass@5 bar chart is clear and complete, but a training-recipe panel, dataset-count cards, slogans, tags and a footer repeat the brand and add clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category and eyebrow tags","reason":"Category tag and kicker above headline add nothing to the point.","boxes":[[921,67,213,16],[104,153,211,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Focused refinement slogan block","reason":"Section label and slogan headline do not state a finding the chart shows.","boxes":[[66,866,157,14],[66,883,226,81]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe panel","reason":"Method side panel serves a second point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[658,866,120,14],[658,883,227,81],[658,978,99,37],[766,978,75,37],[673,988,69,17],[781,988,45,17],[658,1030,352,37]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset count cards","reason":"Dataset-size stat cards serve a separate point from the main chart.","boxes":[[81,983,36,56],[296,983,47,56],[252,1020,17,28],[81,1035,77,31],[296,1035,69,31]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline and footer rule are decorative and not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[66,1149,168,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo at top.","boxes":[[967,1150,167,14]]}],"usd":0.0034848,"sec":73,"out":6698,"cut":22,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":17.8},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before/after bar chart with model, benchmark, metric and values; only a minor gridline touch on the 17.5% label.","marks":[],"usd":0.0018864,"sec":50,"out":3463,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-medium__raw","clutter":44.7,"shares":{"blue":55.3,"orange":0,"red":44.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.7},"score":5,"words":83,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear before/after bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, eyebrow and tag, method cards and a repeated footer brand.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Research note / Model training tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[839,68,289,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[72,173,351,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan that doesn't state the finding with numbers.","boxes":[[72,195,663,141]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stat cards","reason":"Training-method cards serve a second point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[98,888,124,16],[635,888,171,16],[98,918,183,26],[635,918,155,26],[98,951,342,19],[635,951,333,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand wordmark, tagline and decorative star duplicate the header logo.","boxes":[[1101,1132,27,20],[72,1133,88,17],[954,1134,147,18]]}],"usd":0.0015302999999999998,"sec":43,"out":2789,"cut":15,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":16.4},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, labelled values and the metric named.","marks":[],"usd":0.0011519000000000002,"sec":35,"out":1994,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":82,"shares":{"blue":18,"orange":0,"red":82,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33},"score":7,"words":186,"missing":[],"summary":"A small 11.3% to 17.5% comparison is buried under a slogan headline, three method cards, a large setup band and repeated branding; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Tag and date line adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[890,70,238,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[72,166,169,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, not a finding with numbers.","boxes":[[72,178,458,171]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the chart.","boxes":[[72,346,377,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Second section heading","reason":"Eyebrow, slogan heading and explanatory sentence.","boxes":[[72,489,299,13],[72,503,562,53],[820,528,306,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards","reason":"Three method and settings cards serve a second point.","boxes":[[96,595,168,12],[453,595,147,12],[811,595,216,12],[96,619,270,42],[453,619,260,22],[811,619,249,22],[453,644,62,97],[549,644,79,97],[821,665,29,52],[972,665,29,52],[96,688,98,34],[221,688,92,34],[524,693,15,30],[201,694,13,22],[105,696,80,18],[230,696,74,18],[821,714,66,28],[972,714,55,28],[455,727,84,23],[697,727,48,23],[96,735,283,59],[811,762,279,39],[462,765,276,20],[666,766,6,6],[512,769,4,4],[462,774,276,11],[630,777,4,4],[580,781,8,8],[698,782,6,6],[462,785,276,11],[462,785,276,21],[524,797,4,4],[669,798,6,6],[453,822,293,43],[96,836,293,29],[811,836,293,29],[453,837,268,27],[96,851,124,12],[811,851,216,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Evaluation setup band","reason":"Large green band of setup stats competes with the main result.","boxes":[[762,925,41,63],[894,925,18,63],[1030,925,64,63],[98,943,123,13],[98,958,396,45],[762,984,89,16],[894,984,92,16],[1030,984,72,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark tagline","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already present.","boxes":[[72,1154,215,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer slogan","reason":"Tagline adds nothing.","boxes":[[943,1156,185,11]]}],"usd":0.0053938,"sec":98,"out":10516,"cut":65,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.5},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before-after bar chart with a short title, metric, labels and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.0046539,"sec":104,"out":8998,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna__raw","clutter":71.1,"shares":{"blue":28.9,"orange":0,"red":71.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.7},"score":6,"words":66,"missing":[],"summary":"The before/after bar chart is clear, but a slogan headline, subtitle, stat cards, decorative shapes, tags and a tagline footer clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style category tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[849,74,275,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[76,212,374,73],[76,263,395,90]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Decorative bars","reason":"Faint decorative shapes in the corner.","boxes":[[1016,345,184,185]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explaining method; chart does not need it.","boxes":[[76,362,708,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Method counts serve a second point unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[94,916,29,32],[322,916,38,32],[94,952,151,18],[322,952,113,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Tagline footer","reason":"Tagline and a second brand mention.","boxes":[[989,925,135,40],[1017,968,107,16]]}],"usd":0.0015773,"sec":73,"out":2883,"cut":13,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__luna__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":8.6},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":["benchmark name (τ³-Banking)"],"summary":"Clean, minimal before/after bar chart with nothing to remove, but it never names the τ³-Banking benchmark.","marks":[],"usd":0.0010389000000000002,"sec":49,"out":1768,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-high__raw","clutter":59.2,"shares":{"blue":26.1,"orange":29.5,"red":44.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.1},"score":6,"words":155,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear, but the subtitle, tag and the three method and capability panels crowd the bottom half and should go.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[907,74,221,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Useful but long; could be shortened to the finding.","boxes":[[72,164,953,159],[767,164,256,94],[741,178,26,68]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates the method and does not state the result.","boxes":[[72,324,1019,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Three method panels","reason":"Method, pivot and capability panels serve secondary ideas beside the result chart.","boxes":[[72,784,64,17],[221,784,184,17],[433,784,64,17],[647,784,120,17],[795,784,46,17],[999,784,129,17],[72,808,157,46],[433,808,269,46],[795,808,289,46],[72,860,325,43],[433,860,329,65],[795,860,309,65],[72,969,74,14],[281,969,119,14],[795,979,156,14],[433,990,7,7],[444,990,7,7],[455,990,7,7],[466,990,7,7],[477,990,7,7],[488,990,7,7],[499,990,7,7],[510,990,7,7],[521,990,7,7],[532,990,7,7],[587,990,7,4],[598,990,7,4],[608,990,7,4],[618,990,7,4],[629,990,7,4],[639,990,7,4],[649,990,7,4],[659,990,7,4],[670,990,7,4],[680,990,7,4],[690,990,7,4],[701,990,7,4],[711,990,7,4],[721,990,7,4],[732,990,7,4],[742,990,7,4],[752,990,7,4],[73,991,10,10],[78,996,316,52],[587,996,7,4],[598,996,7,4],[608,996,7,4],[618,996,7,4],[629,996,7,4],[639,996,7,4],[649,996,7,4],[659,996,7,4],[670,996,7,4],[680,996,7,4],[690,996,7,4],[701,996,7,4],[711,996,7,4],[721,996,7,4],[732,996,7,4],[742,996,7,4],[752,996,7,4],[88,1000,36,20],[433,1001,7,7],[444,1001,7,7],[455,1001,7,7],[466,1001,7,7],[477,1001,7,7],[488,1001,7,7],[499,1001,7,7],[510,1001,7,7],[521,1001,7,7],[532,1001,7,7],[587,1001,7,4],[598,1001,7,4],[608,1001,7,4],[618,1001,7,4],[629,1001,7,4],[639,1001,7,4],[649,1001,7,4],[659,1001,7,4],[670,1001,7,4],[680,1001,7,4],[690,1001,7,4],[701,1001,7,4],[711,1001,7,4],[721,1001,7,4],[732,1001,7,4],[742,1001,7,4],[752,1001,7,4],[795,1002,328,24],[813,1006,16,16],[869,1006,16,16],[925,1006,16,16],[981,1006,16,16],[1037,1006,16,16],[1093,1006,16,16],[587,1007,7,4],[598,1007,7,4],[608,1007,7,4],[618,1007,7,4],[629,1007,7,4],[639,1007,7,4],[649,1007,7,4],[659,1007,7,4],[670,1007,7,4],[680,1007,7,4],[690,1007,7,4],[701,1007,7,4],[711,1007,7,4],[721,1007,7,4],[732,1007,7,4],[742,1007,7,4],[752,1007,7,4],[569,1010,5,8],[433,1012,7,7],[444,1012,7,7],[455,1012,7,7],[466,1012,7,7],[477,1012,7,7],[488,1012,7,7],[499,1012,7,7],[510,1012,7,7],[521,1012,7,7],[532,1012,7,7],[587,1012,7,4],[598,1012,7,4],[608,1012,7,4],[618,1012,7,4],[629,1012,7,4],[639,1012,7,4],[649,1012,7,4],[659,1012,7,4],[670,1012,7,4],[680,1012,7,4],[690,1012,7,4],[701,1012,7,4],[711,1012,7,4],[721,1012,7,4],[732,1012,7,4],[742,1012,7,4],[752,1012,7,4],[345,1018,45,20],[587,1018,7,4],[598,1018,7,4],[608,1018,7,4],[618,1018,7,4],[629,1018,7,4],[639,1018,7,4],[649,1018,7,4],[659,1018,7,4],[670,1018,7,4],[680,1018,7,4],[690,1018,7,4],[701,1018,7,4],[711,1018,7,4],[721,1018,7,4],[732,1018,7,4],[742,1018,7,4],[752,1018,7,4],[433,1023,7,7],[444,1023,7,7],[455,1023,7,7],[466,1023,7,7],[477,1023,7,7],[488,1023,7,7],[499,1023,7,7],[510,1023,7,7],[521,1023,7,7],[532,1023,7,7],[587,1023,7,4],[598,1023,7,4],[608,1023,7,4],[618,1023,7,4],[629,1023,7,4],[639,1023,7,4],[649,1023,7,4],[659,1023,7,4],[670,1023,7,4],[680,1023,7,4],[690,1023,7,4],[701,1023,7,4],[711,1023,7,4],[721,1023,7,4],[732,1023,7,4],[742,1023,7,4],[752,1023,7,4],[587,1029,7,4],[598,1029,7,4],[608,1029,7,4],[618,1029,7,4],[629,1029,7,4],[639,1029,7,4],[649,1029,7,4],[659,1029,7,4],[670,1029,7,4],[680,1029,7,4],[690,1029,7,4],[701,1029,7,4],[711,1029,7,4],[721,1029,7,4],[732,1029,7,4],[742,1029,7,4],[752,1029,7,4],[433,1034,7,7],[444,1034,7,7],[455,1034,7,7],[466,1034,7,7],[477,1034,7,7],[488,1034,7,7],[499,1034,7,7],[510,1034,7,7],[521,1034,7,7],[532,1034,7,7],[587,1034,7,4],[598,1034,7,4],[608,1034,7,4],[618,1034,7,4],[629,1034,7,4],[639,1034,7,4],[649,1034,7,4],[659,1034,7,4],[670,1034,7,4],[680,1034,7,4],[690,1034,7,4],[701,1034,7,4],[711,1034,7,4],[721,1034,7,4],[732,1034,7,4],[742,1034,7,4],[752,1034,7,4],[587,1040,7,4],[598,1040,7,4],[608,1040,7,4],[618,1040,7,4],[629,1040,7,4],[639,1040,7,4],[649,1040,7,4],[659,1040,7,4],[670,1040,7,4],[680,1040,7,4],[690,1040,7,4],[701,1040,7,4],[711,1040,7,4],[721,1040,7,4],[732,1040,7,4],[742,1040,7,4],[752,1040,7,4],[389,1043,10,10],[587,1045,7,4],[598,1045,7,4],[608,1045,7,4],[618,1045,7,4],[629,1045,7,4],[639,1045,7,4],[649,1045,7,4],[659,1045,7,4],[670,1045,7,4],[680,1045,7,4],[690,1045,7,4],[701,1045,7,4],[711,1045,7,4],[721,1045,7,4],[732,1045,7,4],[742,1045,7,4],[752,1045,7,4],[587,1051,7,4],[598,1051,7,4],[608,1051,7,4],[618,1051,7,4],[629,1051,7,4],[639,1051,7,4],[72,1065,74,14],[433,1065,111,14],[687,1065,74,14],[795,1065,89,14],[997,1065,126,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1008,1125,120,15]]}],"usd":0.293968,"sec":154,"out":14267,"cut":282,"shrunk":3},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.8},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.091552,"sec":51,"out":4092,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-medium__raw","clutter":52.8,"shares":{"blue":47.2,"orange":0,"red":52.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.4},"score":6,"words":143,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear and labelled, but the big 17.5% card, method cards, and dataset stats row clutter it, and the eyebrow and subtitle add nothing; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category eyebrow","reason":"Category tag above the headline; tells the reader nothing new.","boxes":[[923,79,197,17],[1028,79,17,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Restating subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates the chart and the title's method.","boxes":[[80,306,593,72]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big 17.5% stat card","reason":"Repeats the 17.5% bar label and the 6.2-point change the bars show.","boxes":[[116,440,190,206],[306,518,52,100],[178,617,40,22],[116,618,195,46],[116,683,98,31],[128,690,74,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline cards","reason":"Three method cards beside the results chart serve a second point.","boxes":[[80,827,44,15],[438,827,62,15],[796,828,62,15],[80,848,159,46],[438,848,160,46],[796,849,106,46],[410,855,20,10],[768,855,20,10],[80,898,320,44],[438,899,304,65],[617,899,96,19],[796,900,295,65],[906,900,70,19],[116,921,210,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset counts stats row","reason":"Counts about dataset and setup are a second point, not the chart.","boxes":[[80,1000,43,63],[340,1000,55,63],[600,1000,110,63],[860,1000,73,63],[80,1059,90,38],[340,1059,65,38],[600,1059,141,38],[860,1059,174,38]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer logo mark","reason":"Second brand mark; the header logo already appears.","boxes":[[1091,1120,30,24]]}],"usd":0.179148,"sec":93,"out":8526,"cut":36,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.3},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a title, metric, logo and a small note, nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.075252,"sec":40,"out":3277,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":55.3,"shares":{"blue":27.2,"orange":35,"red":37.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.1},"score":6,"words":132,"missing":[],"summary":"The main before-after chart is clear and complete, but a full-sentence headline, a date tag, a repeated URL, and a large lower half of method panels and a capability line clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Publication metadata; tells the reader nothing about the result","boxes":[[994,68,126,20],[1034,68,4,20],[980,72,4,12]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Twelve-word title; shorten to a finding such as '1.55x pass rate on τ³-Banking'","boxes":[[80,160,986,97],[80,227,985,97]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stage 1 and Stage 2 panels","reason":"Method cards and pipeline visuals beside the results chart; a second story","boxes":[[80,747,58,15],[148,747,141,15],[628,747,58,15],[696,747,108,15],[80,767,192,56],[628,767,128,56],[80,827,426,45],[628,827,455,45],[257,850,123,20],[651,850,93,20],[628,897,24,5],[658,897,24,5],[688,897,24,5],[718,897,24,5],[748,897,24,5],[265,902,10,18],[91,903,56,15],[155,903,88,15],[296,903,56,15],[360,903,80,15],[832,906,6,6],[842,906,6,6],[852,906,6,6],[862,906,6,6],[872,906,6,6],[882,906,6,6],[892,906,6,6],[902,906,6,6],[912,906,6,6],[922,906,6,6],[932,906,6,6],[942,906,6,6],[952,906,6,6],[962,906,6,6],[972,906,6,6],[982,906,6,6],[992,906,6,6],[1002,906,6,6],[1012,906,6,6],[1022,906,6,6],[1032,906,6,6],[1042,906,6,6],[628,907,24,5],[658,907,24,5],[688,907,24,5],[718,907,24,5],[748,907,24,5],[832,916,6,6],[842,916,6,6],[852,916,6,6],[862,916,6,6],[872,916,6,6],[882,916,6,6],[892,916,6,6],[902,916,6,6],[912,916,6,6],[922,916,6,6],[932,916,6,6],[942,916,6,6],[952,916,6,6],[962,916,6,6],[972,916,6,6],[982,916,6,6],[992,916,6,6],[1002,916,6,6],[1012,916,6,6],[1022,916,6,6],[1032,916,6,6],[1042,916,6,6],[628,917,24,5],[658,917,24,5],[688,917,24,5],[718,917,24,5],[748,917,24,5],[832,926,6,6],[842,926,6,6],[852,926,6,6],[862,926,6,6],[872,926,6,6],[882,926,6,6],[892,926,6,6],[902,926,6,6],[912,926,6,6],[922,926,6,6],[932,926,6,6],[942,926,6,6],[952,926,6,6],[962,926,6,6],[972,926,6,6],[982,926,6,6],[992,926,6,6],[1002,926,6,6],[1012,926,6,6],[1022,926,6,6],[1032,926,6,6],[1042,926,6,6],[628,927,24,5],[658,927,24,5],[688,927,24,5],[718,927,24,5],[748,927,24,5],[794,931,16,26],[832,936,6,6],[842,936,6,6],[852,936,6,6],[862,936,6,6],[872,936,6,6],[882,936,6,6],[892,936,6,6],[902,936,6,6],[912,936,6,6],[922,936,6,6],[932,936,6,6],[942,936,6,6],[952,936,6,6],[962,936,6,6],[972,936,6,6],[982,936,6,6],[992,936,6,6],[1002,936,6,6],[1012,936,6,6],[1022,936,6,6],[1032,936,6,6],[1042,936,6,6],[628,937,24,5],[658,937,24,5],[688,937,24,5],[718,937,24,5],[748,937,24,5],[80,941,7,60],[92,941,7,60],[105,941,7,55],[117,941,7,53],[130,941,7,51],[142,941,7,50],[154,941,7,48],[167,941,7,47],[179,941,7,45],[192,941,7,43],[204,941,7,42],[216,941,7,40],[229,941,7,38],[241,941,7,37],[254,941,7,35],[266,941,7,33],[278,941,7,32],[291,941,7,30],[303,941,7,28],[316,941,7,27],[328,941,7,25],[340,941,7,23],[353,941,7,22],[365,941,7,20],[378,941,7,19],[390,941,7,17],[402,941,7,15],[415,941,7,14],[427,941,7,12],[440,941,7,10],[452,941,7,9],[464,941,7,7],[477,941,7,5],[489,941,7,4],[502,941,7,2],[514,943,7,58],[502,945,7,56],[832,946,6,6],[842,946,6,6],[852,946,6,6],[862,946,6,6],[872,946,6,6],[882,946,6,6],[892,946,6,6],[902,946,6,6],[912,946,6,6],[922,946,6,6],[932,946,6,6],[942,946,6,6],[952,946,6,6],[962,946,6,6],[972,946,6,6],[982,946,6,6],[992,946,6,6],[1002,946,6,6],[1012,946,6,6],[1022,946,6,6],[1032,946,6,6],[1042,946,6,6],[489,947,7,54],[628,947,24,5],[658,947,24,5],[688,947,24,5],[718,947,24,5],[748,947,24,5],[477,948,7,53],[464,950,7,51],[452,952,7,49],[440,953,7,48],[427,955,7,46],[832,956,6,6],[842,956,6,6],[852,956,6,6],[862,956,6,6],[872,956,6,6],[882,956,6,6],[892,956,6,6],[902,956,6,6],[912,956,6,6],[922,956,6,6],[932,956,6,6],[942,956,6,6],[952,956,6,6],[962,956,6,6],[972,956,6,6],[982,956,6,6],[992,956,6,6],[1002,956,6,6],[1012,956,6,6],[1022,956,6,6],[1032,956,6,6],[1042,956,6,6],[415,957,7,44],[628,957,24,5],[658,957,24,5],[688,957,24,5],[718,957,24,5],[748,957,24,5],[402,958,7,43],[390,960,7,41],[378,961,7,40],[365,963,7,38],[353,965,7,36],[340,966,7,35],[832,966,6,6],[842,966,6,6],[852,966,6,6],[862,966,6,6],[872,966,6,6],[882,966,6,6],[892,966,6,6],[902,966,6,6],[912,966,6,6],[922,966,6,6],[932,966,6,6],[942,966,6,6],[952,966,6,6],[962,966,6,6],[972,966,6,6],[982,966,6,6],[992,966,6,6],[1002,966,6,6],[1012,966,6,6],[1022,966,6,6],[1032,966,6,6],[1042,966,6,6],[628,967,24,5],[658,967,24,5],[688,967,24,5],[718,967,24,5],[748,967,24,5],[328,968,7,33],[316,970,7,31],[303,971,7,30],[291,973,7,28],[278,975,7,26],[266,976,7,25],[832,976,6,6],[842,976,6,6],[852,976,6,6],[862,976,6,6],[872,976,6,6],[882,976,6,6],[892,976,6,6],[902,976,6,6],[912,976,6,6],[922,976,6,6],[932,976,6,6],[942,976,6,6],[952,976,6,6],[962,976,6,6],[972,976,6,6],[982,976,6,6],[992,976,6,6],[1002,976,6,6],[1012,976,6,6],[1022,976,6,6],[1032,976,6,6],[1042,976,6,6],[628,977,24,5],[658,977,24,5],[688,977,24,5],[718,977,24,5],[748,977,24,5],[254,978,7,23],[241,980,7,21],[229,981,7,20],[216,983,7,18],[204,984,7,17],[192,986,7,15],[832,986,6,6],[842,986,6,6],[852,986,6,6],[862,986,6,6],[872,986,6,6],[882,986,6,6],[892,986,6,6],[902,986,6,6],[912,986,6,6],[922,986,6,6],[932,986,6,6],[942,986,6,6],[952,986,6,6],[962,986,6,6],[972,986,6,6],[982,986,6,6],[992,986,6,6],[628,987,24,5],[658,987,24,5],[688,987,24,5],[718,987,24,5],[748,987,24,5],[179,988,7,13],[167,989,7,12],[154,991,7,10],[142,993,7,8],[130,994,7,7],[117,996,7,5],[628,996,32,46],[832,996,42,46],[105,998,7,3],[96,1017,160,18],[386,1017,140,18],[80,1021,9,9],[370,1021,9,9],[628,1036,84,35],[832,1036,81,35]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"General capability footer line","reason":"Result about other benchmarks, a second point unrelated to the main chart","boxes":[[80,1129,483,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL wordmark","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo at top","boxes":[[1004,1131,116,15]]}],"usd":0.682208,"sec":360,"out":33679,"cut":344,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.1},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with benchmark, metric, labelled values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.151612,"sec":82,"out":7095,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus__raw","clutter":17.6,"shares":{"blue":82.4,"orange":0,"red":17.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":22},"score":4,"words":43,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear before/after bar chart is cluttered by a stats row, an eyebrow tag and redundant sublabels.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag; the benchmark is already named in the headline.","boxes":[[899,86,221,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Model name sublabel","reason":"Qwen3.5-9B is already named in the headline.","boxes":[[80,617,87,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Data-efficiency numbers are a second point beside the result chart.","boxes":[[80,1011,61,87],[427,1011,79,87],[773,1011,123,87],[80,1098,198,22],[427,1098,193,22],[773,1098,134,22]]}],"usd":0.059128,"sec":39,"out":2525,"cut":9,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__opus__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.8},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart naming the model, benchmark, metric and values, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.045932,"sec":26,"out":1811,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-high__raw","clutter":25.3,"shares":{"blue":74.7,"orange":0,"red":25.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.9},"score":4,"words":63,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear before-after chart is crowded by a training-recipe panel, a restating subtitle, a category eyebrow and a duplicate URL; it lacks nothing needed to read it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research category eyebrow","reason":"Category tag above the chart that adds nothing to the reader's reading.","boxes":[[806,69,330,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle restating chart","reason":"Subtitle restates the title and chart rather than adding a finding.","boxes":[[64,341,692,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe panel","reason":"Method and dataset-count panel is a second point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,899,160,21],[105,938,154,38],[673,938,100,38],[64,944,27,27],[632,944,27,27],[75,947,6,20],[641,947,9,20],[569,956,35,16],[64,987,349,57],[632,988,25,26],[657,988,249,58],[632,1018,33,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer website URL","reason":"Second brand mark when the logo already appears at top.","boxes":[[1023,1129,113,22]]}],"usd":0.042716,"sec":121,"out":4000,"cut":16,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.9},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a title, metric, labelled values and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.033008,"sec":99,"out":2991,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-medium__raw","clutter":28.1,"shares":{"blue":71.9,"orange":0,"red":28.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30.9},"score":4,"words":70,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear, but the eyebrow tag, subtitle, arrow, training recipe and stats row, and footer add clutter.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow/category tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[769,72,359,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates the point and adds nothing about the finding.","boxes":[[72,318,564,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe row","reason":"Method and dataset-size cards beside a results chart serve a second idea.","boxes":[[518,885,62,89],[850,885,81,89],[72,901,151,21],[72,934,250,33],[211,934,20,33],[518,968,170,50],[850,968,189,50],[72,980,216,50]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Verifier footnote","reason":"Method sentence unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[72,1083,432,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when a logo already exists.","boxes":[[1022,1083,106,21]]}],"usd":0.034996,"sec":112,"out":3228,"cut":15,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.7},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric label, values, and logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.030938,"sec":82,"out":2784,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":64.7,"shares":{"blue":35.3,"orange":0,"red":64.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32},"score":4,"words":72,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is the main visual, but the slogan headline, category tag, two-stage method cards and footer tagline should go; nothing needed is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Category tag restating the section; tells the reader nothing new.","boxes":[[875,71,261,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; the chart already shows it.","boxes":[[64,160,859,217]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stage cards","reason":"Pipeline cards serve a second point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[64,885,69,18],[648,885,69,18],[64,914,163,40],[648,914,106,40],[567,925,49,22],[64,966,366,60],[648,967,348,27],[648,998,303,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline and URL","reason":"Tagline and URL add no reading value; the logo already brands it.","boxes":[[64,1133,421,22],[1023,1133,113,22]]}],"usd":0.073726,"sec":214,"out":7101,"cut":14,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.4},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric, labelled values and one logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.055138,"sec":175,"out":5204,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol__raw","clutter":34,"shares":{"blue":66,"orange":0,"red":34,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28},"score":5,"words":77,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by an eyebrow, a tag, a subtitle, a recipe card block and a repeated footer brand; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Applied research tag","reason":"Category tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[932,66,196,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline.","boxes":[[72,174,326,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restating the method that the recipe cards also cover.","boxes":[[72,374,584,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training recipe cards","reason":"Method pipeline cards serve a second point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[72,827,213,22],[72,891,51,21],[630,891,54,21],[72,923,176,52],[630,923,117,52],[586,946,26,18],[72,987,324,53],[630,987,343,53],[630,987,89,26],[769,987,199,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"The brand is already shown in the top logo.","boxes":[[976,1124,152,22]]}],"usd":0.029756,"sec":73,"out":2704,"cut":16,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sol__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.2},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with model, benchmark, metric, values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.022598,"sec":63,"out":1950,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":42,"shares":{"blue":42.2,"orange":31.9,"red":26,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.2},"score":4,"words":72,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a wordy headline, a method subtitle, a date tag and a bottom stats row; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[949,76,171,22]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Long two-line headline with the numbers the bars already show.","boxes":[[80,133,993,173],[80,203,383,103]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Method subtitle","reason":"Subtitle explains method and restates context, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[80,341,880,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Stat row on dataset sizes and pivots serves a second point.","boxes":[[80,991,67,100],[436,991,87,100],[793,991,154,100],[80,1083,298,23],[436,1083,238,46],[793,1083,310,46]]}],"usd":0.069644,"sec":58,"out":6533,"cut":11,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.2},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before/after bar chart with a short title, metric, logo and one value per bar.","marks":[],"usd":0.034266,"sec":35,"out":2941,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":29.5,"shares":{"blue":53.9,"orange":33.4,"red":12.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.5},"score":3,"words":30,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean main bar chart with a verbose headline and a removable stats row of dataset counts; nothing essential is missing, but the overlapping headline layers need fixing.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Nine-word headline is wordy; shorten to a finding such as '17.5% from 50 teacher tasks'.","boxes":[[80,166,823,167],[80,166,907,167]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset and eval counts serve a second point, not reading the bars.","boxes":[[80,1009,76,73],[427,1009,104,73],[773,1009,72,73],[80,1082,191,48],[427,1082,205,24],[773,1082,314,24]]}],"usd":0.027634,"sec":23,"out":2332,"cut":7,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":50.2},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, one value per bar, and a logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.042086,"sec":47,"out":3723,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":56.5,"shares":{"blue":26.7,"orange":33.9,"red":39.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37},"score":6,"words":121,"missing":[],"summary":"A good bar chart is buried under two method cards, a subtitle, an eyebrow tag and footer extras, with a sentence-style headline.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date tag","reason":"Eyebrow category and date tag add nothing.","boxes":[[900,64,228,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Long three-line headline; could be shortened to the finding.","boxes":[[72,116,725,246],[553,187,229,103]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates the headline and the stage cards below.","boxes":[[72,365,782,29],[721,365,128,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Hybrid OPD card","reason":"Method explainer card unrelated to reading the result chart.","boxes":[[101,755,64,15],[101,766,178,53],[101,818,316,66],[101,902,42,17],[101,929,12,12],[107,935,324,62],[403,966,42,17],[425,991,12,12],[101,1011,72,19],[358,1011,87,19],[101,1028,63,19],[428,1028,17,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"PivotRL card","reason":"Method card with pivot dot grids and hyperparameters; second idea.","boxes":[[517,755,64,15],[517,766,118,53],[517,818,419,21],[517,852,130,65],[697,852,364,78],[688,885,8,14],[697,930,325,13],[517,934,48,68],[697,934,62,68],[517,990,163,19],[697,990,241,19],[517,1029,469,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline not needed for reading the chart.","boxes":[[72,1135,308,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[999,1137,129,17]]}],"usd":0.224894,"sec":168,"out":22058,"cut":31,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a two-bar before/after chart with labelled values, categories, and benchmark/metric tag, with nothing extra to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.050926,"sec":38,"out":4607,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet__raw","clutter":25.4,"shares":{"blue":58.7,"orange":31.8,"red":9.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.2},"score":3,"words":29,"missing":[],"summary":"The main bar chart is clear and complete, but the bottom row of dataset counts is an extra idea that should go, and the headline is slightly long.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"States the finding but runs nine words, over the seven-word target.","boxes":[[80,196,797,156]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset-size stats row","reason":"Dataset and pipeline counts are a second point, not the bar comparison.","boxes":[[80,1045,55,60],[427,1045,71,60],[773,1045,51,60],[80,1105,172,25],[427,1105,119,25],[773,1105,133,25]]}],"usd":0.033604,"sec":42,"out":2929,"cut":7,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.8},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark-and-metric title, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.021266,"sec":19,"out":1641,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__wonder__raw","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__wonder__raw","clutter":54.9,"shares":{"blue":40.1,"orange":10.1,"red":49.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.4},"score":7,"words":191,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is buried under a subtitle, delta callout, two method cards, a stats band, a capability note and a footer; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date eyebrow","reason":"Category and date tag, not needed.","boxes":[[811,48,325,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above headline repeats benchmark.","boxes":[[110,112,418,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory sentence restating post content.","boxes":[[64,285,935,54],[796,285,124,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Delta callout","reason":"Restates difference already visible in bars.","boxes":[[961,373,142,65],[993,432,110,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method stage cards","reason":"Training pipeline details serve a second idea beyond results.","boxes":[[89,694,65,14],[647,694,65,14],[89,715,95,45],[184,715,59,45],[647,715,103,45],[89,772,162,30],[281,772,155,30],[647,772,166,30],[843,772,86,30],[260,777,12,21],[822,777,12,21],[100,778,140,18],[292,778,133,18],[658,778,144,18],[854,778,64,18],[583,788,34,34],[593,793,14,23],[89,814,464,35],[89,822,276,19],[647,822,275,19],[1016,822,95,19],[89,858,225,19],[465,858,88,19],[647,858,130,19],[958,858,153,19],[89,885,464,35],[647,885,464,35],[89,893,343,19],[647,893,411,19]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Evaluation details panel","reason":"Useful eval details, but a loud black block; shrink to quiet footnote.","boxes":[[212,960,34,48],[441,960,15,48],[670,960,53,48],[898,960,187,48],[92,986,92,32],[212,1003,134,33],[441,1003,155,17],[670,1003,128,17],[898,1003,106,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Capability note","reason":"Separate claim unrelated to the main chart.","boxes":[[82,1069,976,38],[82,1069,164,19],[64,1075,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author footer","reason":"Bylines and tagline are not needed.","boxes":[[64,1148,213,18],[277,1148,251,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1002,1150,134,15]]}],"usd":0.165048,"sec":91,"out":7985,"cut":47,"shrunk":13},{"id":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__wonder__simple","task":"improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen35-9b-on-t3-banking__wonder__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":23.9},"score":0,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a clear title, labelled values and one brand mark, with no clutter to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.110628,"sec":97,"out":5225,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-high__raw","clutter":82,"shares":{"blue":18,"orange":0,"red":82,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":59.3},"score":8,"words":485,"missing":["metric name"],"summary":"A four-panel dashboard buries the one DeepSWE before/after bar chart under training data, pipeline, diagnostics, stat card and footer extras; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tagline and byline","reason":"Tagline, blog tag, date and authors are not needed for the finding.","boxes":[[201,34,311,15],[754,34,26,15],[787,34,3,15],[797,34,66,15],[897,34,51,15],[953,34,3,15],[963,34,58,15],[1027,34,3,15],[1036,34,42,15],[1084,34,3,15],[1094,34,64,15],[741,36,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gain stat card","reason":"Restates +11.3 and 27.8%/39.1% already shown in the bars.","boxes":[[1035,101,105,17],[800,102,168,14],[1042,103,91,13],[800,123,85,65],[894,155,139,20],[1060,160,108,88],[800,203,35,18],[835,203,35,17],[938,203,10,18],[1017,203,90,18],[1107,203,33,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restates the chart's result and adds explanation.","boxes":[[42,176,645,59],[42,176,669,38],[126,176,460,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training data panel","reason":"Dataset stats and task types are a second idea.","boxes":[[644,274,91,14],[631,287,316,31],[643,344,79,34],[820,344,37,34],[996,344,35,34],[643,375,102,14],[820,375,103,14],[996,375,66,14],[791,388,10,8],[967,388,10,8],[643,392,123,41],[820,392,126,41],[996,392,115,41],[631,458,180,14],[975,459,162,13],[631,481,405,24],[1038,481,57,24],[1096,481,41,24],[643,485,129,14],[1053,485,26,14],[1105,486,24,13],[1054,522,22,15],[656,523,90,15],[1080,524,45,13],[643,525,6,11],[785,527,226,8],[785,527,182,8],[1062,561,14,15],[656,562,49,15],[1080,563,45,13],[643,564,6,11],[785,566,226,8],[785,566,26,8],[1068,600,15,15],[656,601,80,15],[1086,602,39,13],[643,603,6,11],[785,605,226,8],[785,605,18,8],[656,624,357,14],[813,669,55,18],[874,669,81,18],[961,669,29,18],[996,669,42,18],[1044,669,81,18],[643,671,147,14],[821,671,39,13],[882,671,65,13],[969,671,13,13],[1004,671,26,13],[1052,671,65,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrows and tag pills","reason":"Section eyebrows, numbered tags and pills are decorative.","boxes":[[76,274,128,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Panel pills and eyebrows","reason":"Redundant tags and kickers on panels.","boxes":[[63,276,6,11],[402,276,167,21],[631,276,6,11],[1002,276,135,21],[411,280,149,13],[1011,280,117,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"External reference bar","reason":"Second, non-comparable bar and note distract from main comparison.","boxes":[[63,471,333,13],[63,491,170,15],[254,491,303,26],[254,491,256,26],[516,495,37,17],[63,509,179,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Benchmark table","reason":"Table of other benchmarks repeats the result and adds unrelated ones.","boxes":[[64,575,155,26],[218,575,156,26],[374,575,75,26],[449,575,135,26],[74,581,68,13],[228,581,111,13],[384,581,55,13],[459,581,115,13],[449,601,135,31],[228,607,136,19],[384,608,7,15],[391,608,32,16],[84,609,56,15],[461,609,113,15],[74,612,4,9],[449,632,135,31],[228,638,136,19],[384,639,7,15],[391,639,32,16],[495,639,78,16],[84,640,101,15],[234,640,124,15],[74,643,4,9],[228,669,136,19],[384,670,7,15],[391,670,32,16],[495,670,78,16],[84,671,124,15],[234,671,124,15],[74,674,4,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"DeepSWE table row","reason":"Repeats the 27.8% to 39.1% result already charted.","boxes":[[234,609,124,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Methodology pipeline panel","reason":"GRPO pipeline diagram and cards are a separate method idea.","boxes":[[76,748,152,14],[63,750,6,11],[441,750,128,21],[450,754,110,13],[63,761,366,31],[230,812,167,205],[243,816,143,13],[63,820,133,197],[432,820,137,197],[646,824,5,10],[84,831,82,13],[443,831,77,13],[74,832,5,10],[238,834,151,18],[245,837,94,11],[346,839,36,8],[74,842,99,36],[443,842,73,33],[196,843,34,76],[398,843,34,76],[998,845,124,12],[238,856,151,18],[245,859,94,11],[346,861,32,8],[443,863,70,33],[196,865,34,54],[398,865,34,54],[74,875,83,14],[238,877,151,18],[245,880,94,11],[346,882,22,8],[196,886,34,32],[398,886,34,32],[238,899,151,18],[245,902,94,11],[346,904,38,8],[74,907,95,15],[196,908,34,10],[398,908,34,10],[443,908,105,15],[192,914,8,8],[428,914,8,8],[196,918,34,12],[196,918,34,34],[196,918,34,56],[196,918,34,78],[398,918,34,12],[398,918,34,34],[398,918,34,56],[398,918,34,78],[238,921,151,18],[74,922,83,15],[443,923,88,15],[245,924,94,11],[346,926,14,8],[74,937,68,15],[443,938,70,15],[238,943,151,18],[245,946,94,11],[346,948,34,8],[74,952,81,15],[443,953,81,15],[238,965,151,18],[245,968,94,11],[443,968,101,15],[346,970,20,8],[74,983,112,22],[238,987,151,18],[74,988,111,11],[245,990,94,11],[346,992,9,8],[63,1033,247,96],[322,1033,247,96],[86,1042,138,15],[345,1042,138,15],[75,1045,5,10],[334,1045,5,10],[75,1063,173,15],[334,1063,169,15],[75,1079,166,15],[334,1079,165,15],[75,1095,142,15],[334,1095,159,15],[75,1111,110,15],[334,1111,104,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy charts are a second idea.","boxes":[[644,748,141,14],[631,750,6,11],[1054,750,83,21],[1063,754,65,13],[631,761,290,31],[989,814,133,34],[658,820,136,17],[646,838,293,14],[732,871,323,18],[732,871,184,18],[1064,873,38,15],[646,874,28,14],[912,876,8,8],[916,884,92,28],[732,906,323,18],[732,906,276,18],[1064,908,38,15],[646,909,56,14],[1003,911,9,9],[646,931,476,18],[709,933,349,13],[994,981,128,34],[658,987,120,17],[646,991,5,10],[646,1005,307,14],[980,1012,142,12],[873,1043,76,38],[646,1047,50,14],[732,1048,390,28],[811,1051,54,22],[957,1051,125,22],[820,1055,35,14],[963,1055,113,14],[882,1059,7,7],[933,1059,7,7],[646,1061,27,14],[646,1092,476,20],[690,1094,388,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mark, tagline and contact lines repeat the header brand.","boxes":[[70,1158,559,16]]}],"usd":0.89678,"sec":1336,"out":89408,"cut":271,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.3},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a short title, metric, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.526628,"sec":1123,"out":52354,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-medium__raw","clutter":59.2,"shares":{"blue":38.3,"orange":5.1,"red":56.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.2},"score":8,"words":360,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is buried among stat cards, a dataset panel, diagnostics charts, benchmark cards and a footer; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date, authors","reason":"Byline and date pill do not help read the chart.","boxes":[[867,38,299,31],[251,45,28,17],[286,45,3,17],[298,45,72,17],[882,45,269,17],[237,48,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline adds nothing.","boxes":[[66,103,495,14],[52,107,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat card","reason":"Restates the +11.3 gain the bars already show.","boxes":[[973,143,169,13],[874,157,268,46],[943,206,199,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the chart and dataset facts.","boxes":[[52,220,664,43],[124,220,282,19],[457,220,225,19],[558,242,98,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training data panel","reason":"Dataset stats, task types and languages are a separate idea.","boxes":[[661,317,227,33],[972,322,170,23],[647,324,4,20],[982,327,150,13],[661,349,292,16],[660,385,84,24],[786,385,36,24],[912,385,36,24],[1038,385,48,24],[660,411,84,29],[786,411,86,29],[912,411,64,29],[1038,411,89,44],[647,480,196,15],[1039,482,102,13],[650,505,388,20],[1041,505,56,20],[1100,505,39,20],[660,508,36,14],[1052,509,32,13],[1106,509,25,12],[663,537,92,15],[824,537,50,15],[984,537,81,15],[647,540,9,9],[808,540,9,9],[968,540,9,9],[663,555,116,13],[824,555,109,13],[984,555,102,13],[663,569,127,15],[824,569,100,15],[984,569,118,15],[800,608,61,21],[866,608,88,21],[960,608,34,21],[1000,608,47,21],[1053,608,88,21],[647,611,131,15],[810,612,41,13],[876,612,68,13],[970,612,14,13],[1010,612,27,13],[1063,612,68,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy charts and methodology cards are a second chart.","boxes":[[661,684,323,33],[1006,689,136,23],[647,691,4,20],[1016,694,116,13],[661,716,304,16],[663,757,131,17],[800,757,79,17],[925,757,116,17],[1046,757,79,17],[807,759,65,13],[1053,759,65,13],[663,779,155,24],[925,779,155,24],[819,816,33,13],[978,825,95,11],[839,831,10,10],[698,836,145,49],[698,836,145,37],[947,841,157,20],[688,853,33,13],[978,865,95,11],[694,869,9,9],[947,889,156,12],[686,890,24,14],[819,890,49,14],[663,919,211,46],[925,919,176,46],[647,1069,129,12],[816,1069,108,12],[984,1069,115,12],[647,1084,107,15],[816,1084,132,15],[984,1084,132,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Benchmark protocol cards","reason":"Other benchmarks with no results; a second idea.","boxes":[[77,937,477,13],[89,971,59,15],[258,971,106,15],[428,971,131,15],[190,972,34,13],[89,989,118,15],[258,989,97,15],[428,989,98,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Harness note","reason":"Useful caveat but a long paragraph.","boxes":[[92,1038,468,50],[92,1038,129,15],[322,1038,200,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline adds nothing.","boxes":[[52,1152,583,16]]}],"usd":0.69062,"sec":974,"out":68792,"cut":118,"shrunk":4},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.6},"score":0,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-and-after bar chart with the benchmark, metric, values and logo, and nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.190318,"sec":330,"out":18723,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon__raw","clutter":71,"shares":{"blue":26.8,"orange":4.4,"red":68.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.7},"score":8,"words":376,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is a small part of a dense dashboard of dataset, method, diagnostics and evaluation panels, plus a repeated stat card and subtitle; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Byline and date","reason":"Authors, blog tag and date are not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[799,40,26,26],[819,40,26,26],[839,40,26,26],[859,40,26,26],[247,45,105,17],[897,45,251,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[66,101,482,14],[52,105,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat card","reason":"Restates the +11.3 pts the bars already show.","boxes":[[958,143,167,13],[973,149,151,68],[971,211,153,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence restates chart and headline.","boxes":[[52,225,666,43],[52,225,736,42],[128,225,282,19],[186,247,98,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset panel","reason":"Second idea: dataset size and composition, unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[590,323,332,30],[935,335,190,13],[607,378,101,44],[784,378,47,44],[960,378,45,44],[765,410,9,18],[941,410,9,18],[607,419,91,15],[784,419,106,15],[960,419,70,15],[607,436,136,15],[784,436,129,15],[960,436,110,15],[590,480,192,15],[898,482,227,13],[590,503,425,28],[1018,503,61,28],[1083,503,42,28],[602,510,78,14],[1033,510,32,13],[1091,511,25,12],[616,552,93,15],[797,552,51,15],[978,552,78,15],[721,554,32,13],[902,554,32,13],[1089,554,26,13],[600,555,9,9],[781,555,9,9],[962,555,9,9],[616,569,101,28],[797,569,129,14],[978,569,122,14],[801,684,58,23],[864,684,85,23],[954,684,31,23],[991,684,45,23],[1040,684,85,23],[590,688,199,15],[810,689,40,13],[873,689,67,13],[963,689,13,13],[1000,689,27,13],[1049,689,67,13]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Harness note","reason":"Useful caveat but a long paragraph; shrink to a footnote.","boxes":[[90,644,142,15],[90,644,390,33],[90,645,332,50],[385,662,120,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"GRPO methodology card","reason":"Method cards beside the results chart.","boxes":[[75,763,166,30],[258,775,116,13],[88,823,44,23],[143,823,113,16],[102,827,15,15],[143,841,209,45],[88,917,44,23],[143,917,100,16],[102,921,15,15],[143,935,199,45],[88,1012,44,23],[143,1012,110,16],[98,1016,23,15],[143,1030,209,45]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics","reason":"Reward and entropy panels are a separate idea.","boxes":[[438,763,170,30],[700,775,102,13],[453,824,127,16],[691,825,96,14],[455,848,16,10],[769,848,16,10],[733,859,12,12],[453,860,334,11],[638,860,11,11],[643,860,96,11],[729,861,7,8],[558,876,78,11],[695,876,90,11],[453,898,318,15],[453,950,112,16],[609,951,178,14],[455,973,16,10],[769,973,16,10],[623,982,32,17],[453,985,334,11],[585,985,30,11],[663,985,30,11],[536,1001,206,11],[453,1024,292,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Evaluation suite","reason":"Other benchmarks and repeated result and harness note.","boxes":[[866,763,133,30],[1016,775,109,13],[879,822,60,16],[978,834,134,21],[987,838,116,13],[879,839,70,28],[879,895,54,32],[978,901,134,21],[987,905,116,13],[879,955,75,32],[978,961,134,21],[987,965,116,13],[878,1030,199,46],[878,1030,233,30],[953,1030,103,15],[958,1031,93,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Second logo and tagline.","boxes":[[79,1150,547,16]]}],"usd":0.40993,"sec":657,"out":40723,"cut":138,"shrunk":5},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__argon__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":23.2},"score":0,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a benchmark title, metric, labelled bars, values, and a change annotation.","marks":[],"usd":0.112638,"sec":217,"out":10955,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-high__raw","clutter":29.7,"shares":{"blue":70.3,"orange":0,"red":29.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.7},"score":5,"words":60,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is surrounded by a breadcrumb, subtitle, restating side text, a stats row and a footer URL that should go.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Breadcrumb tag","reason":"Category tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[827,71,309,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Tagline explaining background, not the finding.","boxes":[[64,338,702,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.3 stat card","reason":"Boxed difference and its explanation restate the bars already shown.","boxes":[[890,543,159,129],[890,661,200,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory sentence","reason":"Paragraph restating what the chart shows.","boxes":[[890,722,209,110]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset and training counts are a second idea beyond the result.","boxes":[[64,1001,73,67],[455,1001,69,67],[813,1001,38,67],[150,1032,111,25],[537,1032,99,25],[864,1032,125,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention, since logo already present.","boxes":[[1030,1131,106,21]]}],"usd":0.17963,"sec":107,"out":3344,"cut":16,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.7},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-after bar chart with a title, metric line, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.14539,"sec":78,"out":2621,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-medium__raw","clutter":42.4,"shares":{"blue":57.6,"orange":0,"red":42.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.8},"score":4,"words":63,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, category tag, dataset stats row and footer; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style category tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[794,68,342,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,146,603,174]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Training-set stats and blurb serve a second point beyond the chart.","boxes":[[64,926,83,76],[410,926,79,76],[725,940,277,89],[64,1000,111,25],[410,1000,99,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats the brand and adds a tagline and URL beside the existing logo.","boxes":[[64,1082,274,21],[1030,1082,106,21]]}],"usd":0.14248,"sec":74,"out":2601,"cut":12,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a title, metric, and value labels; the AfterQuery logo visible top right is not in the element list.","marks":[],"usd":0.11449,"sec":69,"out":2003,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":44.8,"shares":{"blue":55.2,"orange":0,"red":44.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.3},"score":5,"words":53,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear main bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, an eyebrow tag, a footer URL and a dataset-stats band; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section tag","reason":"Category tag in the header; tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[934,66,202,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that doesn't state the finding.","boxes":[[62,191,601,187]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1015,981,121,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats band","reason":"Dataset stats and marketing copy serve a second, unrelated point.","boxes":[[64,1045,95,91],[331,1045,90,91],[636,1067,373,59],[64,1131,174,23],[331,1131,94,23],[636,1139,236,20]]}],"usd":0.40763,"sec":208,"out":7904,"cut":11,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.6},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-after bar chart with benchmark, metric, labelled bars and values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.21324,"sec":103,"out":3978,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra__raw","clutter":47.5,"shares":{"blue":52.5,"orange":0,"red":47.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.3},"score":4,"words":59,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear main bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, an eyebrow tag, a stats row and a footer tagline, and nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research tag","reason":"Category tag above the headline tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[914,67,218,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan, not a finding. The chart shows the result.","boxes":[[68,141,751,189]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training stats row","reason":"Dataset and training counts serve a second point unrelated to reading the bars.","boxes":[[68,865,83,76],[453,865,79,76],[807,865,43,76],[68,937,117,26],[453,937,104,26],[807,937,132,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline and URL","reason":"Second brand mention with tagline, since the logo is already at top.","boxes":[[68,1130,348,22],[1019,1130,113,22]]}],"usd":0.15588,"sec":73,"out":2869,"cut":14,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__astra__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.4},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric label, logo, and one value per bar.","marks":[],"usd":0.11674,"sec":68,"out":2048,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":54.5,"shares":{"blue":26.8,"orange":37.4,"red":35.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.2},"score":7,"words":125,"missing":[],"summary":"A small two-point chart is buried under a restating subtitle, stat callouts, a composition bar and footers; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Tag and date add nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[1033,54,103,13],[1017,70,119,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline.","boxes":[[82,148,263,13],[64,151,8,8]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-title headline is huge and takes a lot of room.","boxes":[[62,152,946,174]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Restates chart values and tasks already shown.","boxes":[[64,323,781,50],[142,323,335,23],[64,324,714,50]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.3 stat callout","reason":"Restates difference the chart already shows.","boxes":[[785,460,200,159],[785,477,90,13],[785,596,211,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training stats list","reason":"Dataset and training counts unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[785,683,47,33],[841,700,101,12],[785,725,46,33],[840,742,86,12],[785,767,25,33],[819,784,86,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stat rows","reason":"Dataset and update counts serve a second point, not the chart.","boxes":[[277,684,16,16],[282,689,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Composition bar","reason":"Second chart about task types, a separate idea.","boxes":[[64,936,196,13],[935,937,201,12],[64,961,859,24],[925,961,124,24],[1051,961,85,24],[79,997,92,16],[556,997,50,16],[984,997,82,16],[179,1000,77,12],[614,1000,70,12],[1073,1000,63,12],[64,1001,7,7],[541,1001,7,7],[969,1001,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Diagnostics footer","reason":"Reward and entropy stats are a different point.","boxes":[[64,1119,579,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark tagline","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline.","boxes":[[878,1119,98,12],[975,1119,161,12]]}],"usd":0.01048095,"sec":79,"out":17152,"cut":35,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one simple before-and-after bar chart with a named benchmark, labelled values and a change annotation.","marks":[],"usd":0.006276449999999999,"sec":41,"out":10096,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-max__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":74.6,"shares":{"blue":25.4,"orange":0,"red":74.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.3},"score":null,"words":183,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is buried under a giant repeated stat hero, a dot-grid second chart, a stats row, side notes, tags and a footer; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[1004,50,30,13],[1044,50,8,13],[1062,50,82,13],[988,54,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Giant stat hero","reason":"Huge 27.8% to 39.1% and +11.3 repeat the bars.","boxes":[[56,107,305,199],[493,107,286,199],[449,236,14,16],[386,239,76,32],[71,284,164,13],[1055,284,89,13],[56,288,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[72,122,100,13],[181,122,8,13],[198,122,77,13],[284,122,8,13],[300,122,31,13],[56,126,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set dot grid","reason":"Second chart about task composition, unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[710,396,169,12],[997,396,120,12],[696,399,6,6],[696,415,321,15],[721,443,12,12],[736,443,12,12],[751,443,12,12],[766,443,12,12],[781,443,12,12],[796,443,12,12],[811,443,12,12],[826,443,12,12],[841,443,12,12],[856,443,12,12],[871,443,12,12],[886,443,12,12],[901,443,12,12],[916,443,12,12],[931,443,12,12],[946,443,12,12],[961,443,12,12],[976,443,12,12],[991,443,12,12],[1006,443,12,12],[1021,443,12,12],[1036,443,12,12],[1051,443,12,12],[1066,443,12,12],[1081,443,12,12],[721,458,12,12],[736,458,12,12],[751,458,12,12],[766,458,12,12],[781,458,12,12],[796,458,12,12],[811,458,12,12],[826,458,12,12],[841,458,12,12],[856,458,12,12],[871,458,12,12],[886,458,12,12],[901,458,12,12],[916,458,12,12],[931,458,12,12],[946,458,12,12],[961,458,12,12],[976,458,12,12],[991,458,12,12],[1006,458,12,12],[1021,458,12,12],[1036,458,12,12],[1051,458,12,12],[1066,458,12,12],[1081,458,12,12],[721,473,12,12],[736,473,12,12],[751,473,12,12],[766,473,12,12],[781,473,12,12],[796,473,12,12],[811,473,12,12],[826,473,12,12],[841,473,12,12],[856,473,12,12],[871,473,12,12],[886,473,12,12],[901,473,12,12],[916,473,12,12],[931,473,12,12],[946,473,12,12],[961,473,12,12],[976,473,12,12],[991,473,12,12],[1006,473,12,12],[1021,473,12,12],[1036,473,12,12],[1051,473,12,12],[1066,473,12,12],[1081,473,12,12],[721,488,12,12],[736,488,12,12],[751,488,12,12],[766,488,12,12],[781,488,12,12],[796,488,12,12],[811,488,12,12],[826,488,12,12],[841,488,12,12],[856,488,12,12],[871,488,12,12],[886,488,12,12],[901,488,12,12],[916,488,12,12],[931,488,12,12],[946,488,12,12],[961,488,12,12],[976,488,12,12],[991,488,12,12],[1006,488,12,12],[1021,488,12,12],[1036,488,12,12],[1051,488,12,12],[1066,488,12,12],[1081,488,12,12],[721,503,12,12],[736,503,12,12],[751,503,12,12],[766,503,12,12],[781,503,12,12],[796,503,12,12],[811,503,12,12],[826,503,12,12],[841,503,12,12],[856,503,12,12],[871,503,12,12],[886,503,12,12],[901,503,12,12],[916,503,12,12],[931,503,12,12],[946,503,12,12],[961,503,12,12],[976,503,12,12],[991,503,12,12],[1006,503,12,12],[1021,503,12,12],[1036,503,12,12],[1051,503,12,12],[1066,503,12,12],[1081,503,12,12],[721,518,12,12],[736,518,12,12],[751,518,12,12],[766,518,12,12],[781,518,12,12],[796,518,12,12],[811,518,12,12],[826,518,12,12],[841,518,12,12],[856,518,12,12],[871,518,12,12],[886,518,12,12],[901,518,12,12],[916,518,12,12],[931,518,12,12],[946,518,12,12],[961,518,12,12],[976,518,12,12],[991,518,12,12],[1006,518,12,12],[1021,518,12,12],[1036,518,12,12],[1051,518,12,12],[1066,518,12,12],[1081,518,12,12],[721,533,12,12],[736,533,12,12],[751,533,12,12],[766,533,12,12],[781,533,12,12],[796,533,12,12],[811,533,12,12],[826,533,12,12],[841,533,12,12],[856,533,12,12],[871,533,12,12],[886,533,12,12],[901,533,12,12],[916,533,12,12],[931,533,12,12],[946,533,12,12],[961,533,12,12],[976,533,12,12],[991,533,12,12],[1006,533,12,12],[1021,533,12,12],[1036,533,12,12],[1051,533,12,12],[1066,533,12,12],[1081,533,12,12],[721,548,12,12],[736,548,12,12],[751,548,12,12],[766,548,12,12],[781,548,12,12],[796,548,12,12],[811,548,12,12],[826,548,12,12],[841,548,12,12],[856,548,12,12],[871,548,12,12],[886,548,12,12],[901,548,12,12],[916,548,12,12],[931,548,12,12],[946,548,12,12],[961,548,12,12],[976,548,12,12],[991,548,12,12],[1006,548,12,12],[1021,548,12,12],[1036,548,12,12],[1051,548,12,12],[1066,548,12,12],[1081,548,12,12],[721,563,12,12],[736,563,12,12],[751,563,12,12],[766,563,12,12],[781,563,12,12],[796,563,12,12],[811,563,12,12],[826,563,12,12],[841,563,12,12],[856,563,12,12],[871,563,12,12],[886,563,12,12],[901,563,12,12],[916,563,12,12],[931,563,12,12],[946,563,12,12],[961,563,12,12],[976,563,12,12],[991,563,12,12],[1006,563,12,12],[1021,563,12,12],[1036,563,12,12],[1051,563,12,12],[1066,563,12,12],[1081,563,12,12],[721,578,12,12],[736,578,12,12],[751,578,12,12],[766,578,12,12],[781,578,12,12],[796,578,12,12],[811,578,12,12],[826,578,12,12],[841,578,12,12],[856,578,12,12],[871,578,12,12],[886,578,12,12],[901,578,12,12],[916,578,12,12],[931,578,12,12],[946,578,12,12],[961,578,12,12],[976,578,12,12],[991,578,12,12],[1006,578,12,12],[1021,578,12,12],[1036,578,12,12],[1051,578,12,12],[1066,578,12,12],[1081,578,12,12],[721,593,12,12],[736,593,12,12],[751,593,12,12],[766,593,12,12],[781,593,12,12],[796,593,12,12],[811,593,12,12],[826,593,12,12],[841,593,12,12],[856,593,12,12],[871,593,12,12],[886,593,12,12],[901,593,12,12],[916,593,12,12],[931,593,12,12],[946,593,12,12],[961,593,12,12],[976,593,12,12],[991,593,12,12],[1006,593,12,12],[1021,593,12,12],[1036,593,12,12],[1051,593,12,12],[1066,593,12,12],[1081,593,12,12],[721,608,12,12],[736,608,12,12],[751,608,12,12],[766,608,12,12],[781,608,12,12],[796,608,12,12],[811,608,12,12],[826,608,12,12],[841,608,12,12],[856,608,12,12],[871,608,12,12],[886,608,12,12],[901,608,12,12],[916,608,12,12],[931,608,12,12],[946,608,12,12],[961,608,12,12],[976,608,12,12],[991,608,12,12],[1006,608,12,12],[1021,608,12,12],[1036,608,12,12],[1051,608,12,12],[1066,608,12,12],[1081,608,12,12],[721,623,12,12],[736,623,12,12],[751,623,12,12],[766,623,12,12],[781,623,12,12],[796,623,12,12],[811,623,12,12],[826,623,12,12],[841,623,12,12],[856,623,12,12],[871,623,12,12],[886,623,12,12],[901,623,12,12],[916,623,12,12],[931,623,12,12],[946,623,12,12],[961,623,12,12],[976,623,12,12],[991,623,12,12],[1006,623,12,12],[1021,623,12,12],[1036,623,12,12],[1051,623,12,12],[1066,623,12,12],[1081,623,12,12],[721,638,12,12],[736,638,12,12],[751,638,12,12],[766,638,12,12],[781,638,12,12],[796,638,12,12],[811,638,12,12],[826,638,12,12],[841,638,12,12],[856,638,12,12],[871,638,12,12],[886,638,12,12],[901,638,12,12],[916,638,12,12],[931,638,12,12],[946,638,12,12],[961,638,12,12],[976,638,12,12],[991,638,12,12],[1006,638,12,12],[1021,638,12,12],[1036,638,12,12],[1051,638,12,12],[1066,638,12,12],[1081,638,12,12],[721,653,12,12],[736,653,12,12],[751,653,12,12],[766,653,12,12],[781,653,12,12],[796,653,12,12],[811,653,12,12],[826,653,12,12],[841,653,12,12],[856,653,12,12],[871,653,12,12],[886,653,12,12],[901,653,12,12],[916,653,12,12],[931,653,12,12],[946,653,12,12],[961,653,12,12],[976,653,12,12],[991,653,12,12],[1006,653,12,12],[1021,653,12,12],[1036,653,12,12],[1051,653,12,12],[1066,653,12,12],[1081,653,12,12],[721,668,12,12],[736,668,12,12],[751,668,12,12],[766,668,12,12],[781,668,12,12],[796,668,12,12],[811,668,12,12],[826,668,12,12],[841,668,12,12],[856,668,12,12],[871,668,12,12],[886,668,12,12],[901,668,12,12],[916,668,12,12],[931,668,12,12],[946,668,12,12],[961,668,12,12],[976,668,12,12],[991,668,12,12],[1006,668,12,12],[1021,668,12,12],[1036,668,12,12],[1051,668,12,12],[1066,668,12,12],[1081,668,12,12],[721,683,12,12],[736,683,12,12],[751,683,12,12],[766,683,12,12],[781,683,12,12],[796,683,12,12],[811,683,12,12],[826,683,12,12],[841,683,12,12],[856,683,12,12],[871,683,12,12],[886,683,12,12],[901,683,12,12],[916,683,12,12],[931,683,12,12],[946,683,12,12],[961,683,12,12],[976,683,12,12],[991,683,12,12],[1006,683,12,12],[1021,683,12,12],[1036,683,12,12],[1051,683,12,12],[1066,683,12,12],[1081,683,12,12],[721,698,12,12],[736,698,12,12],[751,698,12,12],[766,698,12,12],[781,698,12,12],[796,698,12,12],[811,698,12,12],[826,698,12,12],[841,698,12,12],[856,698,12,12],[871,698,12,12],[886,698,12,12],[901,698,12,12],[916,698,12,12],[931,698,12,12],[946,698,12,12],[961,698,12,12],[976,698,12,12],[991,698,12,12],[1006,698,12,12],[1021,698,12,12],[1036,698,12,12],[1051,698,12,12],[1066,698,12,12],[1081,698,12,12],[721,713,12,12],[736,713,12,12],[751,713,12,12],[766,713,12,12],[781,713,12,12],[796,713,12,12],[811,713,12,12],[826,713,12,12],[841,713,12,12],[856,713,12,12],[871,713,12,12],[886,713,12,12],[901,713,12,12],[916,713,12,12],[931,713,12,12],[946,713,12,12],[961,713,12,12],[976,713,12,12],[991,713,12,12],[1006,713,12,12],[1021,713,12,12],[1036,713,12,12],[1051,713,12,12],[1066,713,12,12],[1081,713,12,12],[721,728,12,12],[736,728,12,12],[751,728,12,12],[766,728,12,12],[781,728,12,12],[796,728,12,12],[811,728,12,12],[826,728,12,12],[841,728,12,12],[856,728,12,12],[871,728,12,12],[886,728,12,12],[901,728,12,12],[916,728,12,12],[931,728,12,12],[946,728,12,12],[961,728,12,12],[976,728,12,12],[991,728,12,12],[1006,728,12,12],[1021,728,12,12],[1036,728,12,12],[1051,728,12,12],[1066,728,12,12],[1081,728,12,12],[709,749,23,17],[854,749,15,17],[984,749,16,17],[696,754,7,7],[841,754,7,7],[971,754,7,7],[709,764,98,12],[854,764,64,12],[984,764,86,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Chart legend","reason":"Legend repeats bar labels and gain label.","boxes":[[98,735,54,14],[183,735,69,14],[284,735,71,14],[85,739,7,7],[170,739,7,7],[271,739,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training stats row","reason":"Setup stats serve a different point from the result.","boxes":[[56,867,71,54],[333,867,25,54],[584,867,38,54],[836,867,257,54],[56,927,78,11],[333,927,111,11],[584,927,46,11],[836,927,131,11],[56,944,187,14],[333,944,170,14],[584,944,150,14],[836,944,286,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Side notes","reason":"Validation and entropy notes are separate ideas.","boxes":[[69,1000,337,15],[84,1000,20,14],[268,1000,136,14],[705,1000,439,15],[807,1000,128,14],[56,1005,5,5],[692,1005,5,5]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer branding","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already present.","boxes":[[72,1142,267,11],[1051,1142,94,11],[56,1145,6,6]]}],"usd":0.03301035,"sec":288,"out":54701,"cut":561,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-max__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, values, labels and model name, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.01218225,"sec":114,"out":19939,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":45.5,"shares":{"blue":54.5,"orange":0,"red":45.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.9},"score":7,"words":170,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is a clear main visual, but a training-set card, reward and entropy panels, a subtitle, and header tags clutter it; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header metadata","reason":"Eyebrow and date/category tags above the headline; tell the reader nothing new.","boxes":[[1012,43,140,14],[980,59,172,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating the chart's finding and method.","boxes":[[134,266,262,26],[48,267,763,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated gain stat","reason":"The +11.3 point gain is already shown by the badge.","boxes":[[498,266,90,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section number label","reason":"Section numbering adds no information.","boxes":[[48,404,168,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set composition card","reason":"Second point about dataset makeup, unrelated to the DeepSWE result.","boxes":[[751,455,221,13],[751,465,101,101],[1096,494,32,22],[1013,520,115,36],[751,593,298,18],[1052,593,43,18],[1098,593,30,18],[774,631,100,18],[1051,631,25,17],[1094,633,34,13],[751,635,10,10],[774,669,55,18],[1059,669,17,17],[1094,671,34,13],[751,673,10,10],[774,707,89,18],[1059,707,17,17],[1101,709,27,13],[751,711,10,10],[751,756,377,40],[751,768,367,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Reward and entropy panels","reason":"Training diagnostics are a separate point from the benchmark result.","boxes":[[71,857,84,13],[635,857,91,13],[435,858,130,12],[1051,858,78,12],[71,877,169,48],[635,877,171,48],[154,900,11,16],[719,900,11,16],[995,959,127,11],[690,981,346,14],[686,984,8,8],[1032,984,8,8],[343,986,8,8],[489,986,8,8],[309,1015,75,13],[462,1015,62,13],[78,1016,6,11],[539,1016,19,11],[661,1016,57,11],[1007,1016,57,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo at top.","boxes":[[1061,1155,91,12]]}],"usd":0.00870255,"sec":58,"out":14188,"cut":53,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.7},"score":0,"words":10,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before-after bar chart with the benchmark, metric, model, values and change all stated once.","marks":[],"usd":0.005873850000000001,"sec":47,"out":9425,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":42.9,"shares":{"blue":42,"orange":30.3,"red":27.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.6},"score":6,"words":145,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear main bar chart is surrounded by a task-mix bar, a stats row, a subtitle, tags, and a footer that should go.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Tag and date badge adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[1022,66,106,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category kicker above headline.","boxes":[[88,154,217,13],[72,158,6,6]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Long title; could be shorter, e.g. 'GRPO lifts DeepSWE 27.8% to 39.1%'.","boxes":[[72,169,819,151],[516,230,156,90]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Summary subtitle","reason":"Restates the chart values and stats shown below.","boxes":[[72,323,31,22],[332,323,16,22],[711,323,109,22],[103,324,608,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix bar","reason":"Second chart about training data composition, unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[72,374,120,17],[842,378,286,12],[72,400,846,12],[1044,400,84,12],[86,422,20,14],[309,422,13,14],[480,422,14,14],[113,423,152,12],[329,423,108,12],[501,423,120,12],[72,425,7,7],[466,425,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Higher is better","reason":"Repeats the metric already in the chart title.","boxes":[[1018,530,110,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Training dataset and reward stats, a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[72,1029,50,36],[348,1029,50,36],[585,1029,34,36],[823,1029,196,36],[910,1029,22,36],[72,1071,192,24],[348,1071,178,37],[585,1071,130,24],[823,1071,192,24]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention, with tagline and URL.","boxes":[[91,1132,224,12],[1033,1132,95,12],[72,1135,7,7]]}],"usd":0.00783915,"sec":64,"out":12749,"cut":36,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.8},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values, one logo, and no extra blocks.","marks":[],"usd":0.00593325,"sec":52,"out":9524,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek__raw","clutter":52.2,"shares":{"blue":47.8,"orange":0,"red":52.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.3},"score":7,"words":195,"missing":[],"summary":"The main bar chart is clear, but a repeated stat card, two extra panels, an evaluation row, tags and a second logo bury it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Eyebrow tag and date add nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[1042,58,94,13],[1057,76,79,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Kicker line","reason":"Eyebrow tag line above the headline.","boxes":[[80,155,312,13],[64,158,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Improvement stat card","reason":"Restates +11.3 and both values already shown by bars.","boxes":[[865,360,82,13],[859,367,203,135],[865,485,65,37],[865,591,257,56],[1038,591,63,17],[965,610,34,17],[865,629,33,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set panel","reason":"Dataset stats and task mix are a second idea.","boxes":[[64,723,141,13],[64,737,117,85],[219,737,114,85],[64,816,76,18],[219,816,68,18],[64,850,463,35],[145,850,45,15],[345,850,158,15],[64,869,59,15],[64,910,135,11],[64,930,399,14],[463,930,58,14],[520,930,40,14],[78,956,87,14],[199,956,47,14],[280,956,77,14],[64,959,7,7],[185,959,7,7],[266,959,7,7],[78,970,58,15],[199,970,46,15],[280,970,45,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy charts are a separate idea.","boxes":[[653,723,297,13],[653,757,83,18],[1014,759,122,15],[777,784,10,10],[1085,784,10,10],[645,800,17,11],[806,800,17,11],[967,800,17,11],[1129,800,17,11],[653,824,49,18],[948,826,188,15],[645,867,17,11],[766,867,17,11],[887,867,17,11],[1008,867,17,11],[1129,867,17,11],[653,890,191,15],[653,939,368,15],[817,939,56,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Evaluation protocol row","reason":"Other benchmarks and protocol details beside the main chart.","boxes":[[64,1014,175,11],[64,1036,63,17],[314,1036,113,17],[564,1036,140,17],[764,1040,372,32],[64,1058,114,13],[314,1058,114,13],[564,1058,114,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark and URL.","boxes":[[64,1147,100,17],[174,1149,101,13]]}],"usd":0.01043715,"sec":113,"out":17079,"cut":66,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__deepseek__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a two-bar chart with benchmark title, labels and values, and nothing extra.","marks":[],"usd":0.00581205,"sec":71,"out":9322,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":59.4,"shares":{"blue":40.6,"orange":0,"red":59.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.4},"score":7,"words":297,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is clear, but two extra panels on dataset and training diagnostics, a stat card, a subtitle, tags and a footer crowd it; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header metadata","reason":"Category tag, date and authors are not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[503,50,5,10],[508,50,159,13],[681,50,7,13],[702,50,80,13],[796,50,7,13],[817,50,333,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[63,146,330,13],[50,147,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Summary subtitle","reason":"Restates the numbers the bars already show.","boxes":[[50,222,991,43],[50,222,1069,42],[322,222,189,19],[619,222,67,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Chart eyebrow","reason":"Section tag 'Benchmark Evaluation · Primary Result' is unneeded.","boxes":[[92,348,284,13],[79,350,5,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gain callouts","reason":"The +11.3 pts is shown twice, in a card and on the bar.","boxes":[[1019,352,86,28],[1019,381,86,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Checkpoint pills","reason":"Pills that repeat what the row labels already say.","boxes":[[328,441,131,16],[335,443,117,13],[286,519,118,16],[293,521,104,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Scale note","reason":"Restates what the axis shows.","boxes":[[978,624,143,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset panel","reason":"A second idea about the training data, unrelated to the result chart.","boxes":[[84,736,139,13],[452,736,117,12],[73,738,5,10],[73,748,256,30],[631,748,254,30],[84,788,39,36],[252,788,37,36],[420,788,49,36],[84,821,83,11],[252,821,71,11],[420,821,71,11],[84,834,70,12],[252,834,74,12],[420,834,68,12],[73,866,399,20],[472,866,58,20],[529,866,40,20],[88,896,94,15],[448,896,71,14],[519,896,50,14],[73,899,8,8],[88,916,52,15],[455,916,64,14],[519,916,50,14],[73,919,8,8],[88,936,83,15],[171,937,132,15],[462,937,64,14],[526,937,43,14],[73,940,8,8],[144,961,49,15],[197,961,74,15],[274,961,24,15],[303,961,37,15],[344,961,74,15],[150,962,37,12],[203,962,62,12],[280,962,12,12],[309,962,25,12],[350,962,62,12],[73,963,63,11],[73,1033,496,43],[85,1039,461,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy charts and setup chips are a separate idea.","boxes":[[642,736,147,13],[1065,736,62,12],[631,738,5,10],[631,786,124,15],[897,787,104,14],[1001,787,126,14],[1008,814,98,15],[1018,817,76,10],[647,819,22,10],[1102,821,7,7],[678,824,427,45],[675,834,78,15],[679,837,70,10],[647,842,22,10],[681,850,12,16],[647,865,22,10],[675,866,7,7],[631,892,440,14],[631,917,80,15],[882,918,185,14],[1068,918,59,14],[977,944,129,15],[714,946,52,9],[990,948,102,10],[647,951,22,10],[737,955,6,6],[678,957,427,44],[678,958,427,43],[647,974,22,10],[647,996,22,10],[1015,998,6,6],[992,1004,52,9],[631,1023,439,14],[679,1044,25,12],[785,1044,62,12],[911,1044,62,12],[1048,1044,37,12],[669,1056,45,10],[797,1056,40,10],[917,1056,49,10],[1045,1056,45,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats the brand, adds a tagline and URL.","boxes":[[50,1152,14,14],[72,1153,218,13],[298,1153,7,13],[313,1153,316,13],[1052,1153,98,13]]}],"usd":0.4189548,"sec":866,"out":101293,"cut":124,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.9},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a named benchmark, metric, labelled bars and values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.225887475,"sec":590,"out":54450,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":51.6,"shares":{"blue":48.4,"orange":0,"red":51.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.7},"score":7,"words":250,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is buried among a data-composition panel, three diagnostics cards, stat repeats, tags and a footer; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow date tag","reason":"Category tag and date add nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[902,52,242,17],[889,56,5,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Byline and tags","reason":"Authors, category tag, and subtitle restating 500 tasks.","boxes":[[56,277,261,17],[331,277,6,18],[350,277,137,18],[501,277,6,18],[521,277,207,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training data panel","reason":"Second chart about dataset composition, unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[696,394,191,14],[982,394,134,14],[684,398,6,6],[684,410,88,81],[961,442,154,33],[1042,442,46,15],[776,450,46,26],[981,459,61,15],[684,509,347,24],[1031,509,49,24],[1081,509,34,24],[701,555,101,18],[984,556,131,15],[684,559,9,9],[701,582,56,18],[991,583,124,15],[684,586,9,9],[701,609,182,18],[999,610,116,15],[684,613,9,9],[741,663,24,15],[895,663,8,15],[1042,663,8,15],[715,680,75,14],[867,680,64,14],[1000,680,93,14],[684,767,422,32],[850,767,230,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated +11.3 points pill","reason":"Restates the +11.3 pts bar annotation and the 27.8% base value","boxes":[[467,456,137,32],[480,463,111,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat 39.1%","reason":"Restates the bar value and baseline already shown.","boxes":[[476,494,128,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Diagnostics cards","reason":"Three training diagnostic cards serve other ideas.","boxes":[[302,915,79,19],[659,915,92,19],[1081,915,40,19],[89,917,153,14],[459,917,103,14],[829,917,130,14],[309,918,65,13],[666,918,78,13],[1088,918,26,13],[79,921,4,7],[449,921,4,7],[819,921,4,7],[79,942,194,30],[449,942,194,30],[819,942,254,30],[79,981,297,50],[449,981,288,50],[819,981,269,50]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Tagline and URL repeat the brand.","boxes":[[56,1143,583,16],[1036,1144,108,15]]}],"usd":0.21042367499999998,"sec":423,"out":50740,"cut":69,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.5},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one clear bar comparison with the benchmark, metric, and bar labels present.","marks":[],"usd":0.216267975,"sec":574,"out":52118,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":48.3,"shares":{"blue":51.7,"orange":0,"red":48.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":30},"score":7,"words":207,"missing":[],"summary":"A small bar chart is buried among a giant stat, a distribution card, diagnostics, a stats row and tags; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category pill","reason":"Series tag badge with no information needed.","boxes":[[1052,60,3,17],[893,61,135,15],[881,66,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag and date","reason":"Category pill and date add nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[1067,60,69,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[86,128,181,15],[64,135,14,2]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task distribution card","reason":"Second chart about training data mix.","boxes":[[1028,281,83,17],[711,283,213,14],[1035,283,69,13],[711,310,322,14],[1033,310,46,14],[1079,310,32,14],[727,340,97,18],[1028,342,24,15],[1052,343,59,14],[711,345,8,8],[727,373,53,18],[1036,375,16,15],[1052,376,59,14],[711,378,8,8],[727,406,175,18],[1043,408,16,15],[1059,409,52,14],[711,411,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Updates badge","reason":"Badge adding nothing to the chart.","boxes":[[534,291,85,38],[545,296,54,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat","reason":"+11.3 pts restates bar difference, already annotated.","boxes":[[99,313,145,162],[334,371,191,37]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics","reason":"Side panel on reward and entropy.","boxes":[[982,490,129,17],[711,492,150,14],[989,492,115,13],[726,532,89,14],[933,532,55,14],[827,534,62,12],[1059,534,37,12],[726,552,128,19],[933,552,129,19],[938,593,153,5],[1089,594,4,4],[936,595,4,4],[729,605,5,5],[726,622,149,27],[933,622,133,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Algorithm row","reason":"Method details repeated in title and elsewhere.","boxes":[[99,950,58,16],[157,950,188,15],[479,950,95,16],[574,950,45,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset size stats unrelated to main result.","boxes":[[64,1040,79,14],[338,1040,100,14],[612,1040,74,14],[886,1040,100,14],[64,1058,100,29],[338,1058,43,29],[612,1058,43,29],[886,1058,14,29],[64,1091,247,32],[338,1091,224,32],[612,1091,240,32],[886,1091,224,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer lines","reason":"Other benchmarks and tagline; not shown.","boxes":[[940,1141,196,15]]}],"usd":0.10746367500000001,"sec":226,"out":25780,"cut":70,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27},"score":0,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled bars, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.052868475,"sec":151,"out":12506,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-high__raw","clutter":34.9,"shares":{"blue":65.1,"orange":0,"red":34.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41},"score":6,"words":149,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear main DeepSWE comparison is buried under a training-set panel, a diagnostics panel, a subtitle, a date tag and a byline; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[973,59,163,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Method subtitle","reason":"Subtitle paragraph explains method, not the chart.","boxes":[[64,275,808,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set panel","reason":"Dataset stats and task-type breakdown are a second, unrelated idea.","boxes":[[64,726,109,14],[64,740,78,75],[188,740,74,75],[64,804,88,40],[188,804,78,20],[64,862,289,19],[64,887,350,20],[64,934,472,21],[536,934,68,21],[604,934,47,21],[86,976,112,20],[556,976,27,20],[611,978,40,15],[64,980,12,12],[86,1001,61,20],[565,1001,18,20],[611,1003,40,15],[64,1005,12,12],[86,1026,99,20],[565,1026,18,20],[619,1028,32,15],[64,1030,12,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy diagnostics are a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[728,726,136,14],[728,763,187,18],[728,775,232,63],[827,775,34,63],[728,832,391,40],[728,905,69,18],[728,917,211,63],[728,974,367,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author byline","reason":"Author names do not help read the chart.","boxes":[[64,1098,288,20]]}],"usd":0.261162,"sec":952,"out":43102,"cut":37,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart naming the benchmark, metric, and values, with no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.1722,"sec":495,"out":28210,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-medium__raw","clutter":50.8,"shares":{"blue":49.2,"orange":0,"red":50.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.7},"score":6,"words":168,"missing":[],"summary":"The 27.8% to 39.1% result is a small part of the canvas, and the dataset, diagnostics, language list, byline and paragraph text crowd it; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag adds nothing to reading the result.","boxes":[[980,46,164,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author list","reason":"Bylines are not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[56,210,290,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gain stat","reason":"The +11.3 difference is already visible from the two values and bars.","boxes":[[904,328,124,100],[904,329,35,14],[904,413,132,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set breakdown","reason":"Dataset composition is a second, unrelated point.","boxes":[[847,580,297,20],[56,584,318,14],[56,612,875,22],[930,612,127,22],[1056,612,88,22],[72,648,113,19],[505,648,61,19],[821,648,100,19],[56,655,8,8],[489,655,8,8],[805,655,8,8],[56,663,143,46],[489,663,114,46],[805,663,114,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics row","reason":"Reward, entropy and GRPO stats are a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[56,750,97,14],[481,750,62,14],[826,750,35,14],[56,762,204,56],[481,762,186,56],[826,762,152,56],[56,815,304,38],[481,815,294,38],[826,815,280,38]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory sentences","reason":"Paragraph text explaining the data and method, not the chart.","boxes":[[56,872,931,37],[56,914,706,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Language list","reason":"Language list is dataset detail unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[56,1153,47,19],[121,1153,73,19],[212,1153,20,19],[249,1153,31,19],[298,1153,71,19]]}],"usd":0.212148,"sec":511,"out":34933,"cut":37,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.1},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with the model, benchmark, metric and labelled values; nothing needs removing.","marks":[],"usd":0.098328,"sec":263,"out":15898,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":40.3,"shares":{"blue":59.7,"orange":0,"red":40.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.6},"score":6,"words":161,"missing":[],"summary":"The 27.8% vs 39.1% bars are a small part of the canvas; a giant duplicate stat, three diagnostic panels and long captions bury them.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date, eyebrow, authors","reason":"Metadata and a kicker line that tell the reader nothing about the result.","boxes":[[982,55,154,15],[64,102,83,15],[64,245,297,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big 39.1% stat","reason":"Restates the 39.1% and the gain the bars already show.","boxes":[[64,571,144,35],[208,571,145,35]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory captions","reason":"Paragraph and note explaining the chart; not needed.","boxes":[[64,624,419,67],[403,624,111,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set panel","reason":"Dataset composition is a second point unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[64,802,112,14],[64,820,67,65],[64,882,186,20],[64,924,373,16],[437,924,54,16],[491,924,37,16],[84,956,112,20],[434,956,27,19],[484,956,45,20],[64,961,10,10],[84,984,61,20],[443,984,18,19],[484,984,45,20],[64,989,10,10],[84,1012,99,20],[443,1012,18,19],[493,1012,36,20],[64,1017,10,10],[64,1050,446,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Mean reward panel","reason":"Training diagnostic, a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[590,802,103,14],[590,820,224,65],[693,844,17,29],[590,882,103,20],[590,916,234,85]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Entropy panel","reason":"Training diagnostic, a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[893,802,65,14],[893,825,176,53],[893,878,71,20],[893,912,235,85]]}],"usd":0.311634,"sec":850,"out":51514,"cut":38,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":6,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: two labelled bars, a metric label and a logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.238038,"sec":723,"out":39183,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok__raw","clutter":52.1,"shares":{"blue":43.8,"orange":8.2,"red":48,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.2},"score":6,"words":181,"missing":[],"summary":"The 27.8% to 39.1% hero is buried under a task-mix chart, reward and entropy stats, three method cards, a footer, and a redundant +11.3 callout.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[959,66,177,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Evaluation subtitle","reason":"Useful eval details, but two lines; shorten to a footnote.","boxes":[[64,275,784,53]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task type breakdown","reason":"Dataset composition is a second, unrelated idea.","boxes":[[64,599,207,15],[641,632,32,23],[64,641,136,23],[268,642,239,22],[632,655,42,19],[652,696,22,23],[64,705,74,23],[268,706,35,22],[632,719,42,19],[652,760,22,23],[64,769,120,23],[268,770,24,22],[640,783,34,19],[64,824,546,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Reward and entropy stats","reason":"Training diagnostics are a separate idea from the result.","boxes":[[730,599,148,15],[730,639,114,68],[947,639,114,68],[730,704,116,19],[947,704,176,19],[730,755,114,68],[947,755,114,68],[730,820,145,19],[947,820,163,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method cards","reason":"Method cards are a side idea beneath the results.","boxes":[[86,937,59,15],[450,937,79,15],[814,937,138,15],[86,952,75,44],[450,952,99,44],[814,952,78,44],[86,999,266,61],[450,999,296,61],[814,999,299,61]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark and tagline.","boxes":[[64,1132,74,19],[138,1132,144,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Author list","reason":"Bylines are not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[848,1132,288,20]]}],"usd":0.063912,"sec":209,"out":10227,"cut":47,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":17.4},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark label, values and a logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.028206,"sec":75,"out":4211,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-high__raw","clutter":59.5,"shares":{"blue":18.1,"orange":44.9,"red":37,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.6},"score":6,"words":100,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is buried under a sentence headline, a repeated +11.3 stat, three side-topic cards and a footer wordmark; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Date and category tag tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[937,78,183,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence title at 80px takes much room; could be '27.8% → 39.1% on DeepSWE'.","boxes":[[80,129,873,291],[80,212,775,125],[602,295,217,125]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big delta stat","reason":"Restates the difference and both values the bars already show.","boxes":[[136,504,313,195],[136,682,243,37],[136,745,166,32],[211,745,20,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Three stat cards","reason":"Training reward, task mix and dataset size are separate side ideas.","boxes":[[108,870,176,15],[463,870,176,15],[817,870,106,15],[108,903,157,18],[463,903,221,18],[683,903,32,18],[715,903,22,18],[108,932,235,18],[108,962,114,55],[463,962,122,55],[817,963,79,55],[108,1024,266,66],[463,1024,258,43],[817,1025,252,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mention with tagline; logo already at top.","boxes":[[80,1135,304,17]]}],"usd":0.0110309,"sec":136,"out":21668,"cut":24,"shrunk":3},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.7},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, labelled bars, values and a difference annotation.","marks":[],"usd":0.0066065,"sec":79,"out":12765,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":46.6,"shares":{"blue":53.4,"orange":0,"red":46.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39},"score":6,"words":124,"missing":[],"summary":"The main bar chart is clear but shares the canvas with a duplicate +11.3 callout, a stat row, a task-mix chart, an eyebrow, a date and a footer URL.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Blog metadata that the reader does not need.","boxes":[[937,83,183,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above the headline.","boxes":[[80,168,336,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.3 callout","reason":"Big stat restates the difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[773,442,252,193],[773,609,178,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Callout subtitle","reason":"Explanatory sentence under the stat; the point is made without it.","boxes":[[773,646,294,42]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat row","reason":"Dataset size, repository count and updates serve a second idea.","boxes":[[80,780,108,100],[436,780,103,100],[792,780,57,100],[80,875,300,48],[436,875,308,48],[792,875,313,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix bar","reason":"Second chart about the training data mix, separate from the main result.","boxes":[[80,953,161,17],[80,984,836,36],[916,984,121,36],[1037,984,83,36],[98,1032,32,22],[539,1032,20,22],[932,1032,21,22],[130,1033,187,22],[560,1033,126,22],[953,1033,167,22],[80,1039,10,10],[521,1039,10,10],[914,1039,10,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Entropy footer note","reason":"Entropy finding is a second point; comparability caveat is extra","boxes":[[80,1096,796,41]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mark when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[968,1113,152,27]]}],"usd":0.0078929,"sec":108,"out":15392,"cut":30,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.7},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a metric title, value labels and category labels.","marks":[],"usd":0.0029885,"sec":41,"out":5529,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":46.4,"shares":{"blue":53.6,"orange":0,"red":46.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.8},"score":6,"words":119,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is clear, but the graphic is buried under a stat row, a task-mix chart, a subtitle, tags and a footer.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag does not help read the chart.","boxes":[[937,78,183,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[80,183,304,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating the post's setup.","boxes":[[80,393,950,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stat row","reason":"Dataset and training stats unrelated to the pass-rate result.","boxes":[[80,782,93,87],[365,782,88,87],[625,782,30,87],[885,782,132,87],[80,866,222,47],[365,866,183,47],[625,866,200,47],[885,866,208,47]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix bar","reason":"Second chart about task types, a separate idea.","boxes":[[80,954,283,17],[80,987,836,28],[916,987,121,28],[1037,987,83,28],[102,1031,48,22],[449,1031,40,22],[795,1031,38,22],[150,1032,170,22],[489,1032,106,22],[833,1032,149,22],[80,1037,12,12],[427,1037,12,12],[773,1037,12,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Company tagline","reason":"Tagline and footer add nothing to the result.","boxes":[[80,1122,746,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already present.","boxes":[[978,1123,142,18]]}],"usd":0.0196214,"sec":214,"out":38849,"cut":31,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.9},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a title, labelled values, a logo and a change annotation.","marks":[],"usd":0.0081905,"sec":90,"out":15933,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku__raw","clutter":45.6,"shares":{"blue":54.4,"orange":0,"red":45.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.7},"score":6,"words":126,"missing":[],"summary":"The 27.8% to 39.1% bar chart is repeated in a big stat and buried among a stats row, two extra charts, an entropy footer and kicker/subtitle text.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog kicker tag","reason":"Category tag in the corner; tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[788,68,324,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates what the chart and title already cover.","boxes":[[88,316,851,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset counts serve a different point from the result.","boxes":[[88,722,95,87],[462,722,90,87],[804,722,30,87],[88,804,279,52],[462,804,244,25],[804,804,276,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Reward chart","reason":"Second chart about training diagnostics.","boxes":[[88,894,350,22],[505,938,51,24],[550,966,14,14],[108,973,449,70],[108,1012,50,24],[101,1036,14,14],[88,1072,388,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task type breakdown","reason":"A third chart, about dataset composition, unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[624,894,363,22],[624,930,392,47],[1016,930,57,47],[1073,930,39,47],[647,989,131,23],[946,989,93,22],[624,994,14,14],[647,1014,71,23],[946,1014,75,22],[624,1019,14,14],[647,1039,238,23],[946,1039,73,22],[624,1045,14,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Entropy footer sentence","reason":"A side diagnostic that is unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[88,1142,627,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"A second brand mark when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[991,1142,121,23]]}],"usd":0.0057969,"sec":55,"out":11200,"cut":34,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart naming the benchmark, metric, and values, with no extras and no rendering defects.","marks":[],"usd":0.0028455,"sec":39,"out":5243,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-high__raw","clutter":56.5,"shares":{"blue":43.5,"orange":0,"red":56.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":19.7},"score":6,"words":89,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is surrounded by a slogan headline, dataset stat band, language chips, a header tag and a footer tagline.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[891,60,233,14],[873,63,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[76,141,297,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[76,167,482,67],[76,215,462,83]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Bar end tags","reason":"BASE and TRAINED repeat the row labels.","boxes":[[811,473,34,14],[1014,586,57,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats band","reason":"Dataset size stats serve a second point.","boxes":[[120,842,77,76],[619,842,73,76],[217,859,146,19],[711,859,79,19],[217,882,213,19],[711,882,211,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Language chips","reason":"Training data languages are unrelated to the result chart.","boxes":[[791,981,59,31],[858,981,78,31],[944,981,39,31],[991,981,47,31],[1046,981,77,31],[803,989,35,15],[870,989,54,15],[956,989,15,15],[1003,989,23,15],[1058,989,53,15],[77,990,153,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand tagline","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline.","boxes":[[868,1135,256,23],[90,1139,196,15],[76,1144,5,5]]}],"usd":0.0036978000000000002,"sec":77,"out":7147,"cut":29,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":6,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a metric title, labelled bars and values, and nothing extra.","marks":[],"usd":0.0015919,"sec":40,"out":2897,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-medium__raw","clutter":70,"shares":{"blue":30,"orange":0,"red":70,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":19.4},"score":7,"words":91,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear, but a slogan headline, eyebrow, two side panels and footer branding take up most of the canvas.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[746,63,386,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[68,207,410,69],[68,256,513,86]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Chart subtitle","reason":"Vague tagline restating the chart.","boxes":[[106,468,454,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix panel","reason":"Training data breakdown is a second, unrelated point.","boxes":[[94,811,243,17],[94,845,112,20],[538,845,79,20],[94,871,421,6],[94,888,61,20],[554,888,63,20],[94,914,61,6],[94,931,99,20],[555,931,62,20],[94,957,42,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy stats are a separate idea.","boxes":[[687,811,289,17],[687,849,77,73],[906,849,88,73],[764,867,8,15],[906,901,8,15],[687,926,113,16],[906,926,41,16],[906,942,62,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already at the top.","boxes":[[68,1136,224,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline adds nothing.","boxes":[[904,1136,228,16]]}],"usd":0.0017772999999999999,"sec":45,"out":3306,"cut":31,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.9},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete, but the bars are misaligned with the axis ticks, which exaggerates the gap between them.","marks":[],"usd":0.0010579,"sec":31,"out":1829,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":50.9,"shares":{"blue":49.1,"orange":0,"red":50.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25},"score":6,"words":123,"missing":[],"summary":"The lower training panels, stat card, and header tags clutter a clean before-and-after ring chart; the chart itself is complete with benchmark, metric, and values.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow and category tags","reason":"Applied research tag and category kicker add nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[996,57,140,15],[979,61,7,7],[64,143,220,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the post's purpose without adding chart information.","boxes":[[64,304,503,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.3 stat card","reason":"Big callout restating the 11.3-point gap the rings already show.","boxes":[[713,482,155,14],[713,483,126,108],[713,578,106,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training data panel","reason":"Dataset stats and task-type breakdown serve a second point, not the result.","boxes":[[485,739,66,30],[89,747,104,14],[557,747,109,15],[89,778,108,45],[197,778,198,45],[89,823,342,18],[89,862,464,9],[553,862,67,9],[620,862,46,9],[103,888,114,13],[338,888,60,13],[504,888,97,13],[89,892,7,7],[324,892,7,7],[490,892,7,7],[103,909,33,22],[338,909,23,22],[504,909,23,22],[136,915,36,15],[361,915,31,15],[528,915,30,15],[89,947,577,28],[89,960,273,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training diagnostics panel","reason":"Reward and entropy curves are a separate training-health point.","boxes":[[1031,739,81,25],[733,744,163,14],[1041,746,61,11],[733,782,140,11],[733,791,66,44],[825,791,62,44],[804,807,12,22],[733,832,124,15],[733,878,132,11],[733,897,54,36],[816,897,53,36],[795,904,13,21],[733,937,102,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline and footer bar are decorative and not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[64,1037,168,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand repeat","reason":"Brand shown again in footer after the logo already appears.","boxes":[[996,1037,140,13]]}],"usd":0.0067663,"sec":135,"out":13284,"cut":51,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":23.5},"score":0,"words":6,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with the benchmark, metric, values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0049279,"sec":92,"out":9569,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna__raw","clutter":66.5,"shares":{"blue":33.5,"orange":0,"red":66.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":23.4},"score":6,"words":106,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear and complete, but a slogan, subtitle, eyebrow, stats row, two cards and footer clutter it with extra points.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header category tag","reason":"Series tag restating context; the reader does not need it.","boxes":[[916,59,220,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker line","reason":"Category tag above the headline; does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,138,423,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Generic slogan that does not state the 27.8% to 39.1% finding.","boxes":[[64,155,501,145]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle restating method","reason":"Subtitle restates the chart's method and data; the chart already shows it.","boxes":[[64,304,555,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset and update counts serve a second point, not reading the chart.","boxes":[[103,768,50,48],[458,768,47,48],[790,768,26,48],[103,821,70,16],[458,821,130,16],[790,821,86,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training and data cards","reason":"Method and data description cards beside the results chart; a second point.","boxes":[[88,922,125,16],[635,922,183,16],[88,948,477,42],[635,948,439,42]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline and descriptor","reason":"Tagline and descriptor add nothing to the chart's point.","boxes":[[64,1147,275,16],[939,1147,197,16]]}],"usd":0.0017282999999999999,"sec":80,"out":3208,"cut":22,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__luna__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":14.2},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a named benchmark, metric and labelled values; only the logo fails to render.","marks":[],"usd":0.0009769,"sec":28,"out":1667,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-high__raw","clutter":55.9,"shares":{"blue":28.2,"orange":31.8,"red":40,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.9},"score":6,"words":122,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a long headline, subtitle, tag, and two stat panels about training data and run that serve other ideas; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style category tag adds nothing.","boxes":[[851,70,277,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Three-line sentence headline; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[72,137,570,224]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Finding is right but the headline is a long sentence; shorten to about seven words, e.g. '+11.3 points on DeepSWE'","boxes":[[560,137,290,94]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph describing tasks; not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[72,366,654,57]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set panel","reason":"Task type breakdown is a second, unrelated idea.","boxes":[[72,838,214,17],[72,859,377,71],[72,947,388,18],[463,947,56,18],[521,947,39,18],[96,983,126,22],[459,983,31,22],[509,983,51,22],[72,988,12,12],[96,1015,69,22],[470,1015,20,22],[509,1015,51,22],[72,1020,12,12],[96,1047,112,22],[470,1047,20,22],[519,1047,41,22],[72,1052,12,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training run stats","reason":"Reward, updates and dataset stats are a second idea.","boxes":[[641,838,107,17],[641,859,273,71],[641,932,227,59],[939,932,45,59],[742,950,26,34],[641,986,141,20],[939,986,99,20],[641,1018,146,59],[939,1018,22,59],[641,1072,207,20],[939,1072,117,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1012,1128,116,15]]}],"usd":0.231016,"sec":120,"out":11157,"cut":33,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28.3},"score":0,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before-and-after bar chart with a clear title, labels and change annotation.","marks":[],"usd":0.13312,"sec":68,"out":6208,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-medium__raw","clutter":54.3,"shares":{"blue":27.5,"orange":36.6,"red":36,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":29.6},"score":6,"words":97,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is clear, but two big secondary cards (training set, training run stats), an eyebrow tag, a footer and a sentence headline crowd it; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style tag with category and date; tells nothing needed.","boxes":[[796,69,332,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Two huge lines, sentence-like; could be much shorter, e.g. '+11.3 points on DeepSWE'.","boxes":[[72,136,763,103],[72,205,993,103]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training set card","reason":"Task-type breakdown and languages serve a second, unrelated point.","boxes":[[103,703,432,23],[103,732,358,14],[103,786,413,44],[516,786,60,44],[575,786,41,44],[127,860,134,23],[522,860,32,23],[576,864,40,15],[103,866,12,12],[127,899,73,23],[533,899,22,23],[576,903,40,15],[103,905,12,12],[127,938,119,23],[533,938,22,23],[584,942,32,15],[103,944,12,12],[103,1045,514,36],[103,1061,270,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training run stats","reason":"Stat card of training details unrelated to reading the main chart.","boxes":[[699,703,94,23],[699,776,88,87],[906,776,30,87],[699,853,73,19],[906,853,107,19],[699,922,49,87],[906,922,132,87],[699,999,92,19],[906,999,86,37]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1014,1130,114,14]]}],"usd":0.157796,"sec":90,"out":7496,"cut":32,"shrunk":2},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.6},"score":0,"words":17,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before-after bar chart with a benchmark title, metric footnote and logo, nothing extra.","marks":[],"usd":0.08936,"sec":53,"out":4020,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":51.1,"shares":{"blue":48.9,"orange":0,"red":51.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":38.4},"score":6,"words":101,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear DeepSWE before/after bar chart is crowded by a task-mix waffle chart, a stats row, a subtitle and a date tag, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[987,68,32,21],[1030,68,4,21],[1044,68,84,21],[972,72,5,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating post context, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[72,335,845,58]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix waffle chart","reason":"Second chart about training data composition, unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[692,453,135,22],[980,455,148,20],[692,505,18,8],[714,505,18,8],[736,505,18,8],[758,505,18,8],[780,505,18,8],[802,505,18,8],[824,505,18,8],[846,505,18,8],[868,505,18,8],[890,505,18,8],[912,505,18,8],[934,505,18,8],[956,505,18,8],[978,505,18,8],[1000,505,18,8],[1022,505,18,8],[1044,505,18,8],[1066,505,18,8],[1088,505,18,8],[1110,505,18,8],[692,518,18,8],[714,518,18,8],[736,518,18,8],[758,518,18,8],[780,518,18,8],[802,518,18,8],[824,518,18,8],[846,518,18,8],[868,518,18,8],[890,518,18,8],[912,518,18,8],[934,518,18,8],[956,518,18,8],[978,518,18,8],[1000,518,18,8],[1022,518,18,8],[1044,518,18,8],[1066,518,18,8],[1088,518,18,8],[1110,518,18,8],[692,531,18,8],[714,531,18,8],[736,531,18,8],[758,531,18,8],[780,531,18,8],[802,531,18,8],[824,531,18,8],[846,531,18,8],[868,531,18,8],[890,531,18,8],[912,531,18,8],[934,531,18,8],[956,531,18,8],[978,531,18,8],[1000,531,18,8],[1022,531,18,8],[1044,531,18,8],[1066,531,18,8],[1088,531,18,8],[1110,531,18,8],[692,544,18,8],[714,544,18,8],[736,544,18,8],[758,544,18,8],[780,544,18,8],[802,544,18,8],[824,544,18,8],[846,544,18,8],[868,544,18,8],[890,544,18,8],[912,544,18,8],[934,544,18,8],[956,544,18,8],[978,544,18,8],[1000,544,18,8],[1022,544,18,8],[1044,544,18,8],[1066,544,18,8],[1088,544,18,8],[1110,544,18,8],[692,557,18,8],[714,557,18,8],[736,557,18,8],[758,557,18,8],[780,557,18,8],[802,557,18,8],[824,557,18,8],[846,557,18,8],[868,557,18,8],[890,557,18,8],[912,557,18,8],[934,557,18,8],[956,557,18,8],[978,557,18,8],[1000,557,18,8],[1022,557,18,8],[1044,557,18,8],[1066,557,18,8],[1088,557,18,8],[1110,557,18,8],[692,570,18,8],[714,570,18,8],[736,570,18,8],[758,570,18,8],[780,570,18,8],[802,570,18,8],[824,570,18,8],[846,570,18,8],[868,570,18,8],[890,570,18,8],[912,570,18,8],[934,570,18,8],[956,570,18,8],[978,570,18,8],[1000,570,18,8],[1022,570,18,8],[1044,570,18,8],[1066,570,18,8],[1088,570,18,8],[1110,570,18,8],[692,583,18,8],[714,583,18,8],[736,583,18,8],[758,583,18,8],[780,583,18,8],[802,583,18,8],[824,583,18,8],[846,583,18,8],[868,583,18,8],[890,583,18,8],[912,583,18,8],[934,583,18,8],[956,583,18,8],[978,583,18,8],[1000,583,18,8],[1022,583,18,8],[1044,583,18,8],[1066,583,18,8],[1088,583,18,8],[1110,583,18,8],[692,596,18,8],[714,596,18,8],[736,596,18,8],[758,596,18,8],[780,596,18,8],[802,596,18,8],[824,596,18,8],[846,596,18,8],[868,596,18,8],[890,596,18,8],[912,596,18,8],[934,596,18,8],[956,596,18,8],[978,596,18,8],[1000,596,18,8],[1022,596,18,8],[1044,596,18,8],[1066,596,18,8],[1088,596,18,8],[1110,596,18,8],[692,609,18,8],[714,609,18,8],[736,609,18,8],[758,609,18,8],[780,609,18,8],[802,609,18,8],[824,609,18,8],[846,609,18,8],[868,609,18,8],[890,609,18,8],[912,609,18,8],[934,609,18,8],[956,609,18,8],[978,609,18,8],[1000,609,18,8],[1022,609,18,8],[1044,609,18,8],[1066,609,18,8],[1088,609,18,8],[1110,609,18,8],[692,622,18,8],[714,622,18,8],[736,622,18,8],[758,622,18,8],[780,622,18,8],[802,622,18,8],[824,622,18,8],[846,622,18,8],[868,622,18,8],[890,622,18,8],[912,622,18,8],[934,622,18,8],[956,622,18,8],[978,622,18,8],[1000,622,18,8],[1022,622,18,8],[1044,622,18,8],[1066,622,18,8],[1088,622,18,8],[1110,622,18,8],[692,635,18,8],[714,635,18,8],[736,635,18,8],[758,635,18,8],[780,635,18,8],[802,635,18,8],[824,635,18,8],[846,635,18,8],[868,635,18,8],[890,635,18,8],[912,635,18,8],[934,635,18,8],[956,635,18,8],[978,635,18,8],[1000,635,18,8],[1022,635,18,8],[1044,635,18,8],[1066,635,18,8],[1088,635,18,8],[1110,635,18,8],[692,648,18,8],[714,648,18,8],[736,648,18,8],[758,648,18,8],[780,648,18,8],[802,648,18,8],[824,648,18,8],[846,648,18,8],[868,648,18,8],[890,648,18,8],[912,648,18,8],[934,648,18,8],[956,648,18,8],[978,648,18,8],[1000,648,18,8],[1022,648,18,8],[1044,648,18,8],[1066,648,18,8],[1088,648,18,8],[1110,648,18,8],[692,661,18,8],[714,661,18,8],[736,661,18,8],[758,661,18,8],[780,661,18,8],[802,661,18,8],[824,661,18,8],[846,661,18,8],[868,661,18,8],[890,661,18,8],[912,661,18,8],[934,661,18,8],[956,661,18,8],[978,661,18,8],[1000,661,18,8],[1022,661,18,8],[1044,661,18,8],[1066,661,18,8],[1088,661,18,8],[1110,661,18,8],[692,674,18,8],[714,674,18,8],[736,674,18,8],[758,674,18,8],[780,674,18,8],[802,674,18,8],[824,674,18,8],[846,674,18,8],[868,674,18,8],[890,674,18,8],[912,674,18,8],[934,674,18,8],[956,674,18,8],[978,674,18,8],[1000,674,18,8],[1022,674,18,8],[1044,674,18,8],[1066,674,18,8],[1088,674,18,8],[1110,674,18,8],[692,687,18,8],[714,687,18,8],[736,687,18,8],[758,687,18,8],[780,687,18,8],[802,687,18,8],[824,687,18,8],[846,687,18,8],[868,687,18,8],[890,687,18,8],[912,687,18,8],[934,687,18,8],[956,687,18,8],[978,687,18,8],[1000,687,18,8],[1022,687,18,8],[1044,687,18,8],[1066,687,18,8],[1088,687,18,8],[1110,687,18,8],[692,700,18,8],[714,700,18,8],[736,700,18,8],[758,700,18,8],[780,700,18,8],[802,700,18,8],[824,700,18,8],[846,700,18,8],[868,700,18,8],[890,700,18,8],[912,700,18,8],[934,700,18,8],[956,700,18,8],[978,700,18,8],[1000,700,18,8],[1022,700,18,8],[1044,700,18,8],[1066,700,18,8],[1088,700,18,8],[1110,700,18,8],[692,713,18,8],[714,713,18,8],[736,713,18,8],[758,713,18,8],[780,713,18,8],[802,713,18,8],[824,713,18,8],[846,713,18,8],[868,713,18,8],[890,713,18,8],[912,713,18,8],[934,713,18,8],[956,713,18,8],[978,713,18,8],[1000,713,18,8],[1022,713,18,8],[1044,713,18,8],[1066,713,18,8],[1088,713,18,8],[1110,713,18,8],[692,726,18,8],[714,726,18,8],[736,726,18,8],[758,726,18,8],[780,726,18,8],[802,726,18,8],[824,726,18,8],[846,726,18,8],[868,726,18,8],[890,726,18,8],[912,726,18,8],[934,726,18,8],[956,726,18,8],[978,726,18,8],[1000,726,18,8],[1022,726,18,8],[1044,726,18,8],[1066,726,18,8],[1088,726,18,8],[1110,726,18,8],[692,739,18,8],[714,739,18,8],[736,739,18,8],[758,739,18,8],[780,739,18,8],[802,739,18,8],[824,739,18,8],[846,739,18,8],[868,739,18,8],[890,739,18,8],[912,739,18,8],[934,739,18,8],[956,739,18,8],[978,739,18,8],[1000,739,18,8],[1022,739,18,8],[1044,739,18,8],[1066,739,18,8],[1088,739,18,8],[1110,739,18,8],[692,752,18,8],[714,752,18,8],[736,752,18,8],[758,752,18,8],[780,752,18,8],[802,752,18,8],[824,752,18,8],[846,752,18,8],[868,752,18,8],[890,752,18,8],[912,752,18,8],[934,752,18,8],[956,752,18,8],[978,752,18,8],[1000,752,18,8],[1022,752,18,8],[1044,752,18,8],[1066,752,18,8],[1088,752,18,8],[1110,752,18,8],[692,765,18,8],[714,765,18,8],[736,765,18,8],[758,765,18,8],[780,765,18,8],[802,765,18,8],[824,765,18,8],[846,765,18,8],[868,765,18,8],[890,765,18,8],[912,765,18,8],[934,765,18,8],[956,765,18,8],[978,765,18,8],[1000,765,18,8],[1022,765,18,8],[1044,765,18,8],[1066,765,18,8],[1088,765,18,8],[1110,765,18,8],[692,778,18,8],[714,778,18,8],[736,778,18,8],[758,778,18,8],[780,778,18,8],[802,778,18,8],[824,778,18,8],[846,778,18,8],[868,778,18,8],[890,778,18,8],[912,778,18,8],[934,778,18,8],[956,778,18,8],[978,778,18,8],[1000,778,18,8],[1022,778,18,8],[1044,778,18,8],[1066,778,18,8],[1088,778,18,8],[1110,778,18,8],[692,791,18,8],[714,791,18,8],[736,791,18,8],[758,791,18,8],[780,791,18,8],[802,791,18,8],[824,791,18,8],[846,791,18,8],[868,791,18,8],[890,791,18,8],[912,791,18,8],[934,791,18,8],[956,791,18,8],[978,791,18,8],[1000,791,18,8],[1022,791,18,8],[1044,791,18,8],[1066,791,18,8],[1088,791,18,8],[1110,791,18,8],[692,804,18,8],[714,804,18,8],[736,804,18,8],[758,804,18,8],[780,804,18,8],[802,804,18,8],[824,804,18,8],[846,804,18,8],[868,804,18,8],[890,804,18,8],[912,804,18,8],[934,804,18,8],[956,804,18,8],[978,804,18,8],[1000,804,18,8],[1022,804,18,8],[1044,804,18,8],[1066,804,18,8],[1088,804,18,8],[1110,804,18,8],[692,817,18,8],[714,817,18,8],[736,817,18,8],[758,817,18,8],[780,817,18,8],[802,817,18,8],[824,817,18,8],[846,817,18,8],[868,817,18,8],[890,817,18,8],[912,817,18,8],[934,817,18,8],[956,817,18,8],[978,817,18,8],[1000,817,18,8],[1022,817,18,8],[1044,817,18,8],[1066,817,18,8],[1088,817,18,8],[1110,817,18,8],[722,856,119,21],[1024,858,28,18],[1082,858,46,18],[692,863,18,8],[722,888,65,21],[1033,890,19,18],[1082,890,46,18],[692,895,18,8],[722,921,105,21],[1033,922,19,18],[1091,922,37,18],[692,927,18,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Repo count, attempts and reward are side facts unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[72,1016,72,72],[453,1016,24,72],[805,1016,269,72],[920,1016,40,72],[72,1087,302,43],[453,1087,290,43],[805,1087,263,21]]}],"usd":0.466416,"sec":319,"out":22927,"cut":532,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one two-bar chart with a title, values, a delta annotation and a logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.2334,"sec":150,"out":11222,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus__raw","clutter":21.5,"shares":{"blue":78.5,"orange":0,"red":21.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.2},"score":5,"words":59,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid before-after bar chart is crowded by a side column of training stats, a task-mix bar and a category tag that should go; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Category tag above the graphic adds no information about the result.","boxes":[[919,84,201,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training dataset stat","reason":"Dataset size stat card serves a separate point about training data.","boxes":[[710,475,108,100],[710,557,366,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training reward stat","reason":"Reward diagnostic is a separate training-dynamics point, not the main visual.","boxes":[[710,612,387,100],[710,694,361,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix breakdown","reason":"Task-type stacked bar and legend serve a second, unrelated point beside the results chart.","boxes":[[710,767,83,29],[710,812,330,22],[1040,812,48,22],[1087,812,33,22],[710,850,17,25],[727,850,203,86],[710,880,17,25],[710,911,17,25]]}],"usd":0.069196,"sec":39,"out":3066,"cut":13,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__opus__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.9},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a short benchmark title, two labelled bars with values, and one logo. The metric (pass rate) is implied by the percentages rather than named, which is a minor gap.","marks":[],"usd":0.04572,"sec":48,"out":1838,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-high__raw","clutter":50.8,"shares":{"blue":49.2,"orange":0,"red":50.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.3},"score":5,"words":53,"missing":[],"summary":"The bar chart is clear and complete, but a slogan headline, eyebrow tag, a repeated +11.3 stat card, and a dataset stats row clutter it.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Section eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above the headline; tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[931,53,205,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,144,719,198]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.3 percentage points card","reason":"Restates the 11.3-point gain the bars already show, plus a tagline.","boxes":[[808,596,165,106],[976,624,30,44],[808,697,184,30],[808,747,213,52]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset and training-size stats serve a second point, not the chart.","boxes":[[64,960,73,70],[452,960,69,70],[810,960,38,70],[64,1029,149,23],[452,1029,195,23],[810,1029,119,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL wordmark","reason":"Brand shown a second time beside the existing logo.","boxes":[[1030,1136,106,21]]}],"usd":0.041946,"sec":96,"out":3946,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.3},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric label, values and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.032438,"sec":132,"out":2957,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-medium__raw","clutter":24.4,"shares":{"blue":75.6,"orange":0,"red":24.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.7},"score":5,"words":70,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid bar chart is cluttered by a kicker tag, a subtitle, takeaway lines, a stats row and a footer URL. Nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Kicker tag that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[918,64,218,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Explanatory subtitle that is not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[64,299,685,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Large +11.3 stat callout","reason":"Restates the difference the bars already show","boxes":[[857,432,126,100],[859,519,168,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Same agent lines","reason":"Slogan-like takeaway lines. The footnote already says this.","boxes":[[859,600,105,25],[859,628,182,25],[859,656,168,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset and training counts serve a second idea beside the result.","boxes":[[64,939,73,70],[453,939,69,70],[811,939,38,70],[64,1007,149,23],[453,1007,200,23],[811,1007,119,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1015,1120,121,17]]}],"usd":0.040776,"sec":124,"out":3829,"cut":17,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.3},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single bar chart with a clear title, metric, labels and values, and no extra elements.","marks":[],"usd":0.021938,"sec":54,"out":1907,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":48.4,"shares":{"blue":38.7,"orange":25.8,"red":35.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.8},"score":5,"words":63,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear before/after bar chart is surrounded by a tag, eyebrow, subtitle, gain card and dataset stats row that should go, and the headline is oversized.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Top-right category tag","reason":"Category tag, tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[918,61,218,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above the headline.","boxes":[[64,151,236,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Large two-line headline, longer than needed; it could be shorter and smaller.","boxes":[[61,169,673,173]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Slogan-like subtitle that explains nothing about the chart.","boxes":[[64,345,603,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gain stat card","reason":"Restates the difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[871,526,158,17],[871,556,248,114],[871,669,187,32],[871,755,224,61]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Dataset size and codebase claims are a second point unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[64,1001,86,67],[364,1001,86,67],[726,1001,263,21],[726,1024,294,77],[164,1030,123,28],[464,1030,110,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when a logo is already present.","boxes":[[1030,1131,106,21]]}],"usd":0.070046,"sec":139,"out":6756,"cut":17,"shrunk":1},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.8},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before-and-after bar chart with a short title, metric, and logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.045758,"sec":88,"out":4289,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol__raw","clutter":43.7,"shares":{"blue":56.3,"orange":0,"red":43.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35},"score":5,"words":66,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear two-bar chart is cluttered by a slogan headline, an eyebrow tag, a dataset stats row and a footer URL; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag, tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[821,71,309,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[70,150,659,171]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Callout box","reason":"Restates the 11.3-point gain the bars already show","boxes":[[840,400,168,56],[840,454,146,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats row","reason":"Training dataset stats are a second point unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[70,919,77,74],[391,919,72,74],[682,931,357,58],[70,989,238,23],[391,989,195,23],[682,997,320,23]]}],"usd":0.032356,"sec":93,"out":2987,"cut":14,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sol__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.9},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a clear title, metric, labelled bars and a logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.019828,"sec":52,"out":1696,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-high__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":21.3,"shares":{"blue":78.7,"orange":0,"red":21.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37},"score":5,"words":103,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear bar chart is cluttered by a wordy headline, a paragraph, a bottom stats row of training details, and a tagline and URL footer; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date tag","reason":"Eyebrow-style category and date tag.","boxes":[[904,67,224,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explaining training setup, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[832,634,282,22],[832,660,242,22],[832,686,227,22],[832,712,76,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training stats row","reason":"Training details and reward stats serve a second, unrelated point.","boxes":[[72,945,87,81],[344,945,27,81],[590,945,45,81],[837,945,291,81],[72,1023,244,38],[344,1023,219,38],[590,1023,209,38],[837,1023,253,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline that tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[72,1133,361,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[1005,1133,123,15]]}],"usd":0.062788,"sec":49,"out":5885,"cut":18,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-high__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: two labelled bars, a delta annotation, a short title and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.03607,"sec":33,"out":3159,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":17.2,"shares":{"blue":82.8,"orange":0,"red":17.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.4},"score":3,"words":39,"missing":[],"summary":"The results chart is clear and complete; the header tag and the bottom stats row are extras that should be removed.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Category tag in the header that adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[837,80,283,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset and training stats row","reason":"Dataset sizes and training diagnostics form a second point unrelated to the results chart.","boxes":[[80,1012,85,78],[301,1012,80,78],[523,1012,303,78],[899,1012,44,78],[80,1094,117,26],[301,1094,104,26],[523,1094,186,26],[899,1094,71,26]]}],"usd":0.037378,"sec":38,"out":3344,"cut":10,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before-and-after bar chart with a clear metric, labelled values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.02387,"sec":24,"out":1939,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":44.7,"shares":{"blue":55.3,"orange":0,"red":44.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.9},"score":6,"words":123,"missing":[],"summary":"The DeepSWE bar chart is a clear main visual, but a repeated +11.3 stat card, a method paragraph, a stats row, a task-mix chart and a footer brand take up much of the canvas.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date tag","reason":"Category and date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[868,59,260,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Gain stat card","reason":"Restates +11.3 and 27.8% to 39.1%, which the chart already shows.","boxes":[[841,301,130,19],[841,308,270,212],[841,490,233,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Method paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explaining training setup that the chart does not need.","boxes":[[924,543,83,24],[841,544,271,133]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset counts and reward stats serve secondary ideas unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[72,809,108,103],[417,809,102,103],[732,809,368,103],[923,852,10,18],[72,906,107,23],[417,906,95,23],[732,906,169,23],[72,907,268,47],[417,907,216,72],[901,907,128,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task mix bar","reason":"A second chart about task types; unrelated to the main result.","boxes":[[72,1020,336,19],[72,1051,844,16],[919,1051,122,16],[1044,1051,84,16],[92,1081,32,23],[133,1081,192,23],[379,1081,21,23],[410,1081,127,23],[590,1081,22,23],[621,1081,170,23],[72,1087,11,11],[359,1087,11,11],[570,1087,11,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Repeats the brand already shown by the logo.","boxes":[[72,1130,310,18],[996,1130,132,18]]}],"usd":0.148768,"sec":117,"out":14483,"cut":35,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single before-and-after bar chart with a short title, metric line, and labelled values, with no extras to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.06522,"sec":58,"out":6074,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet__raw","clutter":14.2,"shares":{"blue":85.8,"orange":0,"red":14.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.1},"score":4,"words":43,"missing":[],"summary":"A stats row of training facts and a date tag clutter an otherwise clear before/after result, and the headline is wordy; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date tag","reason":"Category and date tag tells the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[897,90,223,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training stats row","reason":"Training details and reward serve a second idea unrelated to the result.","boxes":[[80,1011,92,84],[324,1011,87,84],[568,1011,29,84],[812,1011,308,84],[80,1095,111,25],[324,1095,99,25],[568,1095,145,25],[812,1095,208,25]]}],"usd":0.032218,"sec":27,"out":2828,"cut":10,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.1},"score":0,"words":8,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.02255,"sec":26,"out":1807,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__wonder__raw","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__wonder__raw","clutter":53.3,"shares":{"blue":46.7,"orange":0,"red":53.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.9},"score":7,"words":209,"missing":[],"summary":"The simple before/after bar chart is buried under a long headline, a stat badge, two extra chart cards, a dark stats strip and footers; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research blog pill","reason":"Category tag pill, no information needed.","boxes":[[952,40,184,36],[969,50,150,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline, restates topic.","boxes":[[64,121,302,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains dataset background, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[64,267,889,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Headline result tag","reason":"Eyebrow label above chart title.","boxes":[[99,360,144,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+11.3 stat badge","reason":"Restates difference the bars already show.","boxes":[[1020,368,63,37],[1026,407,51,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Diagnostics and composition cards","reason":"Second and third charts unrelated to the headline result.","boxes":[[93,696,277,15],[640,696,387,15],[93,714,268,37],[640,714,250,37],[644,766,370,44],[1018,766,53,44],[1067,766,8,44],[1075,766,29,44],[159,767,23,11],[465,776,9,9],[207,781,262,75],[664,832,112,20],[1079,832,28,19],[786,833,38,18],[640,835,14,14],[202,852,9,9],[160,860,22,11],[664,861,61,20],[1089,861,18,19],[735,862,32,18],[640,864,14,14],[195,873,25,12],[457,873,25,12],[294,874,89,11],[664,890,99,20],[1088,890,19,19],[773,891,30,18],[640,893,14,14],[93,897,466,41],[229,897,155,18],[640,925,455,38]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats strip","reason":"Stats row about dataset sizes and other facts.","boxes":[[98,1013,119,52],[355,1013,53,52],[612,1013,18,52],[869,1013,16,52],[98,1064,231,37],[355,1064,231,37],[612,1064,210,37],[869,1064,231,37]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"About and contact footer","reason":"Tagline and boilerplate.","boxes":[[64,1141,749,39]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Brand shown a second time.","boxes":[[984,1164,152,18]]}],"usd":0.173456,"sec":79,"out":8426,"cut":52,"shrunk":0},{"id":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__wonder__simple","task":"improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/improving-qwen38-27b-on-deepswe__wonder__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.1},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple before/after bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.076556,"sec":49,"out":3542,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"argon-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-high__raw","clutter":77.4,"shares":{"blue":18.8,"orange":7.7,"red":73.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":59.5},"score":8,"words":610,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic has a results panel that is buried under a method diagram, config table, example cards, capability checks, repeated metrics and several brand and header extras. It lacks nothing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header metadata","reason":"Blog tag, date, authors, tagline are not needed.","boxes":[[884,35,3,16],[895,35,66,16],[969,35,3,16],[980,35,176,16],[851,36,26,15],[203,37,353,13],[837,38,6,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline.","boxes":[[58,93,434,13],[44,96,6,6]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline sentence","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[44,103,628,95],[672,103,108,56]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Summary paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restating the results.","boxes":[[836,117,306,71],[836,135,310,33],[836,153,289,33],[911,153,48,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Experiment pills","reason":"Badges and tags.","boxes":[[63,266,251,17],[629,266,304,17],[70,268,237,12],[636,268,290,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Big stat cards repeat the margin, rubric and win-rate numbers the bars already show.","boxes":[[63,332,111,14],[266,332,99,14],[435,332,82,14],[629,332,111,14],[832,332,99,14],[1001,332,82,14],[63,339,81,55],[266,339,56,55],[435,339,57,55],[629,339,77,55],[832,339,59,55],[1001,339,56,55],[144,357,15,30],[322,357,27,30],[492,357,15,30],[706,357,15,30],[891,357,27,30],[1057,357,15,30],[63,388,126,15],[266,388,120,15],[435,388,103,15],[629,388,72,15],[832,388,120,15],[1001,388,120,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Win/tie/loss breakdown","reason":"Repeats win rate and margin already given in cards.","boxes":[[76,482,18,14],[99,482,67,15],[194,482,14,14],[213,482,21,15],[261,482,13,14],[279,482,51,15],[63,485,8,8],[181,485,8,8],[248,485,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Task example cards","reason":"Example task cards unrelated to main result.","boxes":[[73,517,90,17],[331,517,90,17],[78,518,80,12],[229,518,74,12],[336,518,80,12],[487,518,74,12],[73,535,197,30],[331,535,216,30],[639,551,158,17],[916,551,90,17],[644,553,148,12],[801,553,87,12],[921,553,80,12],[1028,553,99,12],[639,570,227,30],[916,570,173,30]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Panel footers","reason":"Config and repeated margin details.","boxes":[[63,627,235,15],[448,627,123,14],[629,627,284,15],[1043,627,94,14],[236,628,58,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method diagram","reason":"Pipeline diagram is a second idea.","boxes":[[63,677,504,28],[609,687,528,15],[65,717,234,116],[335,717,248,116],[619,717,244,116],[899,717,236,116],[77,727,102,18],[347,727,126,18],[631,727,118,18],[911,727,128,18],[87,731,82,11],[360,731,100,11],[649,731,82,11],[925,731,100,11],[77,744,185,25],[347,744,166,25],[631,744,176,25],[911,744,140,25],[77,770,165,15],[347,770,168,15],[631,770,158,15],[911,771,212,23],[923,777,188,13],[77,785,150,15],[347,785,157,15],[631,785,173,15],[911,799,163,15],[631,800,131,15],[347,806,38,18],[389,806,38,18],[431,806,54,18],[489,806,66,18],[77,810,167,12],[357,810,18,11],[399,810,18,11],[437,810,41,11],[499,810,47,11],[911,814,153,15],[459,833,558,25],[523,847,430,21],[558,850,359,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Config table","reason":"Training settings are a side idea.","boxes":[[61,910,155,25],[271,919,86,12],[61,956,62,15],[201,957,156,13],[61,977,114,26],[175,977,182,26],[61,982,68,15],[175,983,182,13],[61,1003,114,26],[175,1003,182,26],[61,1008,101,15],[298,1009,58,13],[61,1029,114,26],[175,1029,182,26],[61,1034,90,15],[201,1035,156,13],[61,1055,114,26],[175,1055,182,26],[61,1060,75,15],[246,1061,110,13],[61,1081,114,26],[175,1081,182,26],[61,1086,114,15],[233,1087,123,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qualitative patterns","reason":"Text bullets about qualities are a separate idea.","boxes":[[409,910,276,25],[706,919,79,12],[422,951,336,31],[422,951,144,14],[422,989,353,31],[422,989,144,14],[422,1027,362,31],[422,1027,165,14],[422,1065,333,31],[422,1065,71,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"General capability panel","reason":"Regression check and harness are other ideas.","boxes":[[837,910,195,25],[1053,919,86,12],[837,951,291,46],[914,951,127,14],[1053,951,63,14],[856,1010,26,13],[915,1010,52,13],[1000,1010,26,13],[846,1014,5,5],[905,1014,5,5],[990,1014,5,5],[856,1037,84,13],[973,1037,45,13],[846,1041,5,5],[963,1041,5,5],[837,1077,284,47],[837,1077,143,14],[1053,1077,36,14],[890,1109,91,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mark and tagline.","boxes":[[44,1157,15,15],[67,1157,58,14],[125,1157,480,15]]}],"usd":0.759982,"sec":1000,"out":75095,"cut":197,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"argon-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.6},"score":1,"words":29,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled values, a legend and a logo; only the sublabels are slightly long.","marks":[],"usd":0.47147,"sec":777,"out":46205,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"argon-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-medium__raw","clutter":78.7,"shares":{"blue":16.4,"orange":9.9,"red":73.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":61},"score":8,"words":642,"missing":[],"summary":"Dense infographic with a recipe diagram, repeated stat cards, and three bottom panels burying the results bars; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Header stat pills","reason":"Dataset and step count pills repeat details shown elsewhere.","boxes":[[643,36,181,23],[832,36,160,23],[1000,36,154,23],[653,41,161,13],[842,41,140,13],[1010,41,134,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog byline","reason":"Date and authors are not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[224,40,293,15],[211,42,6,11]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be '+21.4% win-loss on GDPval'.","boxes":[[46,79,627,96],[673,79,107,56]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Why on-policy callout","reason":"Explanatory analogy box, not the finding.","boxes":[[846,126,204,12],[846,142,281,82]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explaining method restates the post.","boxes":[[46,176,592,57]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Recipe diagram","reason":"Method pipeline is a second idea beside the results.","boxes":[[60,250,381,14],[525,250,629,13],[46,251,6,11],[64,287,234,188],[328,287,504,188],[862,287,274,188],[340,297,480,74],[76,299,6,11],[88,299,167,12],[876,299,6,11],[888,299,161,12],[352,306,6,10],[364,306,230,11],[685,306,123,11],[76,309,169,29],[876,309,175,29],[352,324,76,36],[442,324,82,36],[538,324,110,36],[662,324,146,36],[689,329,93,13],[364,330,53,11],[448,330,70,11],[555,330,76,11],[76,336,157,15],[876,336,219,15],[676,343,117,12],[355,344,71,10],[448,344,71,10],[544,344,98,10],[876,357,120,32],[1002,357,120,32],[76,359,210,26],[884,362,76,10],[1010,362,65,10],[97,365,166,14],[84,368,7,7],[884,373,91,13],[1010,373,110,13],[388,377,252,11],[76,391,210,26],[340,395,480,70],[876,395,120,32],[1002,395,120,32],[97,397,152,14],[84,400,7,7],[884,400,76,10],[1010,400,82,10],[352,404,6,10],[364,404,339,11],[884,411,97,13],[1010,411,84,13],[352,421,286,34],[76,423,210,40],[650,424,143,14],[86,430,123,11],[359,432,273,13],[876,433,246,30],[650,439,115,14],[884,443,230,11],[86,444,149,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Result badges","reason":"Pills and subtitle restate setup and significance.","boxes":[[596,513,558,13],[501,551,71,21],[1002,551,133,20],[1010,555,117,12],[509,556,55,12],[981,726,155,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen cross-family panel","reason":"Second model family and chart; its stats mostly repeat the Nemotron panel.","boxes":[[639,551,276,12],[628,553,5,9],[628,628,102,50],[628,673,111,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Student and teacher config rows","reason":"Configuration detail the chart does not need.","boxes":[[119,597,119,18],[310,597,138,18],[682,597,76,18],[830,597,119,18],[65,600,49,12],[126,600,105,12],[244,600,62,12],[317,600,124,12],[628,600,49,12],[689,600,62,12],[763,600,62,12],[837,600,105,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Secondary stat cards","reason":"Win rate and rubric repeat the bars shown below.","boxes":[[271,628,83,50],[433,628,109,50],[834,628,83,50],[996,628,109,50],[271,673,82,14],[433,673,99,14],[834,673,82,14],[996,673,99,14],[65,689,130,12],[271,689,130,12],[433,689,136,12],[628,689,117,12],[834,689,130,12],[996,689,136,12]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Chart titles","reason":"Wordy chart titles and header counts repeat the bar values.","boxes":[[628,724,289,14],[628,748,266,14],[69,749,180,14],[351,749,39,14],[515,749,53,14],[628,805,253,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated Nemotron stats","reason":"p-value, win counts and margin restate values already in stats and bar.","boxes":[[387,726,185,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Summary strip","reason":"Restates the counts and margin already in the bars.","boxes":[[65,824,507,28],[75,833,283,11],[386,833,176,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom three panels","reason":"Qualitative patterns, regression table and harness are unrelated ideas.","boxes":[[60,886,554,14],[726,887,428,13],[46,888,6,11],[62,921,198,14],[475,921,199,14],[814,921,209,14],[337,923,90,11],[676,923,90,11],[1035,923,103,11],[483,957,26,13],[617,963,141,15],[72,965,139,14],[259,965,141,14],[623,965,129,11],[483,970,108,13],[835,976,252,11],[825,977,5,8],[72,980,147,40],[259,980,137,40],[825,988,272,14],[483,995,52,13],[617,1001,141,15],[623,1003,129,11],[825,1006,270,23],[483,1008,120,13],[483,1034,26,13],[72,1039,157,14],[259,1039,123,28],[617,1039,141,15],[623,1041,129,11],[483,1047,112,13],[835,1052,271,11],[72,1054,145,40],[825,1054,5,8],[825,1065,239,14],[259,1068,150,40],[483,1072,97,25],[825,1082,282,23],[617,1084,141,15],[623,1086,129,11],[483,1097,122,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Tagline and second logo repeat the brand.","boxes":[[76,1155,548,15],[88,1155,536,15]]}],"usd":0.652272,"sec":822,"out":64324,"cut":178,"shrunk":8},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"argon-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25},"score":0,"words":22,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single grouped bar chart with title, legend, values and one logo, nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.26004,"sec":399,"out":25062,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"argon","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon__raw","clutter":78.9,"shares":{"blue":16.9,"orange":8.4,"red":74.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":56.3},"score":8,"words":508,"missing":[],"summary":"The results cards are a small part of a dense infographic that also carries a method diagram, config table, qualitative cards, a regression strip and repeated stats; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date and authors","reason":"Byline, date and category tag are not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[897,34,257,26],[223,39,173,17],[910,40,231,14],[209,42,6,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[46,110,562,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Summary callout","reason":"Paragraph restating the results shown in the cards.","boxes":[[831,124,307,73],[889,124,51,17],[849,143,155,17],[831,161,289,35]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be shortened to '+21.4% on GDPval'.","boxes":[[46,121,583,100],[346,121,440,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Family badges","reason":"Category pills and tags over each card; decorative.","boxes":[[69,269,262,18],[632,269,318,18],[77,272,246,13],[640,272,302,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards restating bars","reason":"Stat cards and captions repeat the margin, win rate, and rubric gain the bars already show.","boxes":[[82,375,107,14],[253,375,88,14],[425,375,89,14],[645,375,107,14],[804,375,88,14],[976,375,89,14],[82,384,92,45],[253,384,63,45],[425,384,75,45],[645,384,92,45],[804,384,63,45],[976,384,75,45],[316,401,22,22],[867,401,22,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Restated stats","reason":"Subcaptions and repeated numbers the cards and bars already show.","boxes":[[253,425,136,12],[425,425,130,12],[645,425,117,12],[804,425,136,12],[976,425,142,12],[82,426,129,12],[406,464,162,13],[962,465,169,13],[760,511,197,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Distillation loop diagram","reason":"Method pipeline is a second idea beside the results.","boxes":[[69,595,324,30],[762,600,388,21],[772,604,368,13],[403,605,347,16],[69,635,1062,162],[83,649,218,128],[83,649,218,24],[331,649,248,128],[331,649,248,24],[609,649,248,128],[609,649,248,24],[887,649,230,128],[887,649,230,24],[95,656,130,12],[343,656,136,12],[621,656,155,12],[899,656,142,12],[95,680,151,15],[343,680,188,15],[621,680,168,15],[899,680,153,15],[95,697,158,15],[343,697,191,15],[621,697,178,15],[899,697,143,15],[899,716,206,24],[95,717,92,21],[193,717,96,21],[343,718,50,23],[403,718,54,23],[467,718,54,23],[531,718,36,23],[621,719,64,11],[691,719,90,10],[787,719,59,11],[103,722,70,11],[201,722,70,11],[905,723,194,11],[346,724,43,12],[405,724,49,12],[469,724,49,12],[540,724,18,12],[621,736,64,11],[691,736,34,10],[731,736,82,11],[95,744,92,21],[193,744,96,21],[103,749,59,11],[201,749,59,11],[899,750,161,14],[343,753,222,11],[621,753,217,11],[455,777,547,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Config table","reason":"Training settings table is an unrelated side panel.","boxes":[[67,864,316,30],[395,873,80,12],[67,903,77,16],[261,905,204,13],[67,931,71,16],[261,933,204,13],[67,959,71,16],[179,961,286,13],[67,987,64,16],[179,989,286,13],[67,1015,92,16],[193,1017,272,13],[67,1043,89,16],[241,1045,224,13],[67,1071,84,16],[186,1073,279,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qualitative panel","reason":"Qualitative patterns and regression checks serve other points.","boxes":[[525,864,489,30],[1026,873,161,12],[548,908,147,15],[884,908,147,15],[537,924,297,30],[873,924,290,30],[548,983,156,15],[884,983,176,15],[537,999,287,30],[873,999,285,30],[537,1067,143,14],[680,1067,122,15],[817,1068,6,12],[827,1068,25,12],[872,1068,6,12],[881,1068,49,12],[951,1068,6,12],[960,1068,25,12],[1005,1068,6,12],[1014,1068,80,12],[1115,1068,6,12],[1124,1068,43,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mention and tagline, with a contact line.","boxes":[[46,1157,58,14],[104,1157,501,15]]}],"usd":0.277002,"sec":417,"out":26797,"cut":156,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"argon","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__argon__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":48.3},"score":1,"words":32,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; the net-margin callouts are slightly redundant with the bars but useful, and the 220-task count is absent.","marks":[],"usd":0.27051,"sec":501,"out":26109,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-high__raw","clutter":61,"shares":{"blue":39,"orange":0,"red":61,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.8},"score":6,"words":90,"missing":[],"summary":"The two net-margin stats are clear, but a slogan headline, kicker tags, subtitle, rubric-delta rows, a method diagram and a data note crowd them.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Kicker tag top right, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[853,69,279,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow label","reason":"Eyebrow kicker above headline.","boxes":[[89,167,219,17],[68,172,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, not a finding, and very large.","boxes":[[68,186,632,195]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle sentence","reason":"Subtitle restates what the stat cards show.","boxes":[[68,383,587,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Rubric score deltas","reason":"Second metric beyond the main net margin.","boxes":[[68,780,95,40],[644,780,98,40],[176,793,137,22],[755,793,137,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method diagram","reason":"Pipeline diagram is a second idea beside the results.","boxes":[[95,882,345,15],[107,923,151,30],[466,923,225,30],[919,923,157,30],[192,963,808,30],[479,979,243,28],[527,983,146,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training data note","reason":"Dataset provenance, a side point unrelated to reading results.","boxes":[[155,1051,345,23],[68,1052,507,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1032,1137,100,20]]}],"usd":0.21012,"sec":77,"out":3355,"cut":20,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":48.8},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a title, metric subtitle, value labels, and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.16833,"sec":70,"out":2481,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-medium__raw","clutter":65.9,"shares":{"blue":31.3,"orange":5.7,"red":63,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.9},"score":6,"words":98,"missing":[],"summary":"The two stat cards are the main visual, but a slogan headline, eyebrow, subtitle, a method flow diagram, a note and a footer URL clutter the graphic.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above headline; tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[801,64,335,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, does not state the finding or numbers.","boxes":[[64,145,678,183]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates what the stat cards show.","boxes":[[64,329,725,32]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Rubric score rows","reason":"Secondary metric; wordy 'in mean rubric score' repeated on both cards.","boxes":[[95,674,94,26],[632,674,96,26],[189,675,184,26],[728,675,184,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method flow diagram","reason":"Pipeline diagram is a second idea unrelated to reading results.","boxes":[[64,768,366,48],[897,781,239,22],[65,840,300,102],[450,840,300,102],[835,840,300,102],[130,860,169,30],[525,860,151,30],[909,860,151,30],[130,896,169,22],[500,896,199,22],[884,896,202,22],[600,953,385,37],[672,975,242,29],[721,979,144,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory note","reason":"Sentences explaining training; not needed to read the results.","boxes":[[64,1033,545,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1030,1136,106,21]]}],"usd":0.18392,"sec":83,"out":2831,"cut":19,"shrunk":6},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a finding headline, metric line and value labels; the visible AfterQuery logo has no element entry.","marks":[],"usd":0.13833,"sec":61,"out":1881,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-xhigh__raw","clutter":56.1,"shares":{"blue":42.2,"orange":3.5,"red":54.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":33.3},"score":6,"words":81,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear stat panel is surrounded by an eyebrow, slogan headline, subtitle, a method pipeline and a footer URL, while little is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above headline, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[815,60,321,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"'Better at real work. Trained on-policy.' is a slogan, not a finding","boxes":[[64,130,604,123],[64,212,590,123]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restating the chart's cross-family result.","boxes":[[66,341,625,33]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Rubric score lines","reason":"Secondary metric with wordy repeated phrase under each stat.","boxes":[[116,689,41,30],[658,689,43,30],[167,693,239,26],[711,693,239,26],[98,701,6,6],[640,701,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline","reason":"Method diagram and slogan serve a second idea beside results.","boxes":[[64,830,590,48],[137,905,179,29],[529,905,146,29],[920,905,161,29],[65,907,55,55],[457,907,55,55],[848,907,55,55],[468,917,34,33],[869,917,15,34],[76,920,32,22],[859,922,33,24],[137,936,124,26],[529,936,172,26],[920,936,123,26],[101,939,7,7],[93,982,988,30],[493,999,214,26],[506,1002,188,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already present.","boxes":[[1023,1130,113,22]]}],"usd":0.32662,"sec":137,"out":5685,"cut":23,"shrunk":6},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.2},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with title, metric, values, labels and logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.20003,"sec":122,"out":3115,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra__raw","clutter":53.7,"shares":{"blue":46.3,"orange":0,"red":53.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.5},"score":5,"words":104,"missing":[],"summary":"The stat comparison is clear, but a large method pipeline, eyebrow, subtitle and slogan headline add clutter; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above headline adds nothing.","boxes":[[850,62,286,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding; replace with a finding title or remove","boxes":[[64,141,649,168]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Restates what the stats show.","boxes":[[64,312,524,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline diagram","reason":"Method diagram is a second idea unrelated to reading results.","boxes":[[64,757,492,46],[883,774,253,23],[110,868,162,29],[459,868,144,29],[870,868,145,29],[110,905,159,21],[459,905,166,21],[870,905,190,21],[601,941,377,52],[423,978,356,23],[436,978,330,23]]}],"usd":0.18277,"sec":71,"out":2808,"cut":18,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"astra","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__astra__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.3},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a clear title, metric, values, labels and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.13983,"sec":55,"out":1911,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-high__raw","clutter":75.6,"shares":{"blue":23,"orange":2.9,"red":74.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.2},"score":7,"words":196,"missing":[],"summary":"A small family bar chart is buried under a slogan headline, a big stat repeating it, a head-to-head chart, a quote panel and a stats row.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note date","reason":"Eyebrow-style tag, not needed to read chart.","boxes":[[898,73,234,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[85,153,254,13],[68,157,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat callout","reason":"Repeats Qwen's +21.4% and 57.3% already in the bars.","boxes":[[802,157,144,12],[866,161,257,148],[802,162,64,156],[1124,216,35,77],[802,308,140,33],[802,308,68,15],[802,343,76,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding","boxes":[[68,162,459,194],[306,237,303,119]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence restating the chart.","boxes":[[68,357,554,50]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Teacher captions","reason":"Wordy sub-captions under each bar; could be shortened.","boxes":[[68,579,347,12],[195,579,184,12],[415,579,57,12],[68,707,283,12],[195,707,120,12],[351,707,156,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Head-to-head bar","reason":"Second chart for a second point.","boxes":[[68,763,308,13],[1067,763,65,13],[68,788,587,31],[655,788,105,31],[760,788,372,31],[79,796,46,15],[666,796,36,15],[771,796,49,15],[82,828,93,14],[215,828,19,14],[274,828,78,14],[68,830,7,7],[201,830,7,7],[260,830,7,7]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Mechanism quote panel","reason":"Explanatory quote block unrelated to reading the chart.","boxes":[[318,897,440,91],[68,906,95,12],[68,927,101,33],[464,936,162,52],[318,995,660,35]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset and setup counts, secondary facts.","boxes":[[68,1075,50,36],[363,1075,67,36],[728,1075,67,36],[1030,1075,33,36],[123,1093,40,13],[435,1093,40,13],[800,1093,40,13],[1069,1093,63,13],[68,1116,131,11],[363,1116,201,11],[728,1116,138,11],[1030,1116,76,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when a logo exists.","boxes":[[1046,1143,86,11]]}],"usd":0.0096567,"sec":72,"out":15021,"cut":46,"shrunk":6},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.2},"score":0,"words":19,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, metric label, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.010152,"sec":65,"out":15798,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-max__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-max__raw","clutter":19.5,"shares":{"blue":80.5,"orange":0,"red":19.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":6,"words":152,"missing":[],"summary":"The Nemotron square grid is clear, but a slogan headline, 50-steps stat, Qwen panel with settings table, and tags crowd it out.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta tags","reason":"Research note / date breadcrumb adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[841,64,93,12],[956,64,7,12],[985,64,43,12],[1050,64,7,12],[1079,64,57,12],[827,65,6,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"50 steps stat","reason":"Training budget stat is a second point beside the chart.","boxes":[[979,106,151,236],[979,136,101,11],[979,297,37,12],[979,320,90,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Huge slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,135,458,231],[264,221,254,145]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[79,137,159,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Sentence restating the chart.","boxes":[[64,355,703,62]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen replication panel","reason":"Second model panel with stats, settings table and quote.","boxes":[[823,480,120,11],[998,480,108,11],[810,502,146,33],[810,536,230,128],[810,541,194,11],[1057,579,38,50],[810,666,61,63],[874,703,7,12],[1061,704,45,10],[810,727,170,4],[810,738,65,63],[878,775,20,12],[1010,776,96,22],[810,846,76,10],[1004,866,102,15],[810,869,33,10],[1076,897,30,15],[810,900,33,10],[1029,928,77,15],[810,931,71,10],[810,1009,36,3],[810,1024,277,57],[810,1090,207,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Card tags","reason":"Section tags above the card title.","boxes":[[109,480,139,11],[620,480,108,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Margin formula","reason":"Restates the +20.9% already shown large.","boxes":[[96,1084,54,14],[150,1084,219,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Brand repeated; logo already present.","boxes":[[64,1153,111,10],[1002,1153,134,10]]}],"usd":0.0271911,"sec":494,"out":44245,"cut":49,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-max__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-max","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-max__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.6},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, labelled bars, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.038660999999999994,"sec":397,"out":63313,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-medium__raw","clutter":59.6,"shares":{"blue":40.4,"orange":0,"red":59.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42},"score":7,"words":227,"missing":["square colour key"],"summary":"The win-loss ledger is the main visual, but a Qwen stat panel, three explainer columns, a subtitle, tags and a footer take up most of the canvas.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta","reason":"Blog tag and date add nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[908,60,33,13],[969,60,50,13],[1019,60,117,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[82,137,262,13],[66,141,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains and restates the chart.","boxes":[[66,330,759,54],[528,357,249,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen stat panel","reason":"Second model family; big +21.4% repeats the headline.","boxes":[[102,430,335,245],[102,459,255,13],[437,461,68,132],[102,623,289,20],[102,669,194,29],[102,669,72,12],[102,761,61,28],[195,761,41,28],[102,791,52,11],[195,791,97,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"+20.9% callout box","reason":"Big stat card restating the margin the grid already shows.","boxes":[[985,747,115,57],[991,797,109,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Three explainer columns","reason":"Method, recipe and generalization cards; pills repeat results.","boxes":[[64,890,114,12],[427,890,114,12],[790,890,114,12],[64,907,179,74],[427,907,153,74],[790,907,235,74],[64,987,317,82],[427,987,313,61],[427,987,296,39],[790,987,345,82],[427,1044,60,94],[790,1089,105,22],[902,1089,112,22],[1021,1089,74,22],[800,1095,85,11],[912,1095,92,11],[1031,1095,54,11],[80,1103,157,15],[196,1103,8,15],[497,1104,52,25],[427,1147,93,22],[527,1147,69,22],[603,1147,57,22],[437,1153,73,11],[537,1153,49,11],[613,1153,37,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand mention and URL; logo already present.","boxes":[[64,1158,195,11],[1042,1158,94,11]]}],"usd":0.0081069,"sec":64,"out":12438,"cut":51,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":20,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean, simple bar chart with a short title and labelled bars; the axis ticks are redundant with the value labels, but nothing needs removing.","marks":[],"usd":0.0057342,"sec":48,"out":8435,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__raw","clutter":49.3,"shares":{"blue":48.7,"orange":4,"red":47.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.8},"score":5,"words":188,"missing":[],"summary":"A good waffle chart is surrounded by a slogan headline, a giant duplicate stat, a Qwen panel, a regression note, a quote and footer extras.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag line","reason":"Category and date tag, not needed.","boxes":[[821,59,307,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[100,139,180,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[72,149,633,178]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big Qwen stat","reason":"Qwen +21.4% is repeated in the side panel.","boxes":[[818,198,310,169],[991,200,137,25],[1034,343,94,32]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating the chart and its claims.","boxes":[[72,330,592,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen panel","reason":"Second model family is a separate idea.","boxes":[[788,478,220,11],[788,673,71,13],[788,689,40,15],[828,689,179,15],[788,695,159,86],[959,735,74,23],[788,772,25,18],[923,772,36,18],[819,774,83,16],[966,774,42,16]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Nemotron stat card","reason":"Useful net margin but oversized and wordy.","boxes":[[788,520,164,13],[788,536,40,15],[828,536,226,15],[788,542,168,86],[968,582,74,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Nemotron sub-stats","reason":"Win rate repeats the legend; others are side details.","boxes":[[788,619,23,18],[922,619,38,18],[1030,619,16,18],[817,621,83,16],[966,621,42,16],[1053,621,29,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"No regression note","reason":"General benchmark claim unrelated to the main visual.","boxes":[[788,840,318,51],[788,840,168,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Pull quote","reason":"Takeaway quote and tag add nothing.","boxes":[[72,990,521,39],[942,1010,186,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention.","boxes":[[1120,1142,8,14],[1018,1144,93,11]]}],"usd":0.010784700000000001,"sec":76,"out":16901,"cut":32,"shrunk":6},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":14.6},"score":1,"words":22,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, labelled bars, values, axis and a quiet footnote.","marks":[],"usd":0.0099552,"sec":90,"out":15470,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek__raw","clutter":22.2,"shares":{"blue":77.8,"orange":0,"red":22.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":6,"words":114,"missing":["comparison baseline"],"summary":"A slogan headline, a second waffle chart with counts and paragraph, and a footer crowd out the two headline stats; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research note tag","reason":"Category and date tag, not needed.","boxes":[[920,63,208,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Three-line slogan that doesn't state the finding, and it is huge.","boxes":[[70,149,620,193],[70,298,534,119],[70,298,534,119]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Record headings and counts","reason":"Second visual with win/tie/loss counts and legend.","boxes":[[72,814,152,13],[224,814,200,13],[1016,814,112,13],[588,824,77,94],[699,824,61,94],[795,824,60,94],[588,906,32,13],[699,906,32,13],[795,906,48,13],[603,933,21,16],[658,933,16,16],[708,933,25,16],[588,936,9,9],[643,936,9,9],[693,936,9,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Waffle grid top","reason":"Second chart repeating Nemotron result.","boxes":[[72,850,17,17],[95,850,17,17],[118,850,17,17],[142,850,17,17],[165,850,17,17],[188,850,17,17],[211,850,17,17],[234,850,17,17],[258,850,17,17],[281,850,17,17],[304,850,17,17],[327,850,17,17],[351,850,17,17],[374,850,17,17],[397,850,17,17],[420,850,17,17],[443,850,17,17],[467,850,17,17],[490,850,17,17],[513,850,17,17],[72,874,17,17],[95,874,17,17],[118,874,17,17],[142,874,17,17],[165,874,17,17],[188,874,17,17],[211,874,17,17],[234,874,17,17],[258,874,17,17],[281,874,17,17],[304,874,17,17],[327,874,17,17],[351,874,17,17],[374,874,17,17],[397,874,17,17],[420,874,17,17],[443,874,17,17],[467,874,17,17],[490,874,17,17],[513,874,17,17],[72,897,17,17],[95,897,17,17],[118,897,17,17],[142,897,17,17],[165,897,17,17],[188,897,17,17],[211,897,17,17],[234,897,17,17],[258,897,17,17],[281,897,17,17],[304,897,17,17],[327,897,17,17],[351,897,17,17],[374,897,17,17],[397,897,17,17],[420,897,17,17],[443,897,17,17],[467,897,17,17],[490,897,17,17],[513,897,17,17],[72,920,17,17],[95,920,17,17],[118,920,17,17],[142,920,17,17],[165,920,17,17],[188,920,17,17],[211,920,17,17],[234,920,17,17],[258,920,17,17],[281,920,17,17],[304,920,17,17],[327,920,17,17],[351,920,17,17],[374,920,17,17],[397,920,17,17],[420,920,17,17],[443,920,17,17],[467,920,17,17],[490,920,17,17],[513,920,17,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Waffle grid middle","reason":"Second chart repeating Nemotron result.","boxes":[[72,943,17,17],[95,943,17,17],[118,943,17,17],[142,943,17,17],[165,943,17,17],[188,943,17,17],[211,943,17,17],[234,943,17,17],[258,943,17,17],[281,943,17,17],[304,943,17,17],[327,943,17,17],[351,943,17,17],[374,943,17,17],[397,943,17,17],[420,943,17,17],[443,943,17,17],[467,943,17,17],[490,943,17,17],[513,943,17,17],[72,966,17,17],[95,966,17,17],[118,966,17,17],[142,966,17,17],[165,966,17,17],[188,966,17,17],[211,966,17,17],[234,966,17,17],[258,966,17,17],[281,966,17,17],[304,966,17,17],[327,966,17,17],[351,966,17,17],[374,966,17,17],[397,966,17,17],[420,966,17,17],[443,966,17,17],[467,966,17,17],[490,966,17,17],[513,966,17,17],[72,990,17,17],[95,990,17,17],[118,990,17,17],[142,990,17,17],[165,990,17,17],[188,990,17,17],[211,990,17,17],[234,990,17,17],[258,990,17,17],[281,990,17,17],[304,990,17,17],[327,990,17,17],[351,990,17,17],[374,990,17,17],[397,990,17,17],[420,990,17,17],[443,990,17,17],[467,990,17,17],[490,990,17,17],[513,990,17,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory paragraph","reason":"Training details and p-value paragraph, not needed to read the stats.","boxes":[[588,974,478,65],[624,974,18,19],[757,974,28,19],[799,996,60,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Waffle grid bottom","reason":"Second chart repeating Nemotron result.","boxes":[[72,1013,17,17],[95,1013,17,17],[118,1013,17,17],[142,1013,17,17],[165,1013,17,17],[188,1013,17,17],[211,1013,17,17],[234,1013,17,17],[258,1013,17,17],[281,1013,17,17],[304,1013,17,17],[327,1013,17,17],[351,1013,17,17],[374,1013,17,17],[397,1013,17,17],[420,1013,17,17],[443,1013,17,17],[467,1013,17,17],[490,1013,17,17],[513,1013,17,17],[72,1036,17,17],[95,1036,17,17],[118,1036,17,17],[142,1036,17,17],[165,1036,17,17],[188,1036,17,17],[211,1036,17,17],[234,1036,17,17],[258,1036,17,17],[281,1036,17,17],[304,1036,17,17],[327,1036,17,17],[351,1036,17,17],[374,1036,17,17],[397,1036,17,17],[420,1036,17,17],[443,1036,17,17],[467,1036,17,17],[490,1036,17,17],[513,1036,17,17],[72,1059,17,17],[95,1059,17,17],[118,1059,17,17],[142,1059,17,17],[165,1059,17,17],[188,1059,17,17],[211,1059,17,17],[234,1059,17,17],[258,1059,17,17],[281,1059,17,17],[304,1059,17,17],[327,1059,17,17],[351,1059,17,17],[374,1059,17,17],[397,1059,17,17],[420,1059,17,17],[443,1059,17,17],[467,1059,17,17],[490,1059,17,17],[513,1059,17,17],[72,1082,17,17],[95,1082,17,17],[118,1082,17,17],[142,1082,17,17],[165,1082,17,17],[188,1082,17,17],[211,1082,17,17],[234,1082,17,17],[258,1082,17,17],[281,1082,17,17],[304,1082,17,17],[327,1082,17,17],[351,1082,17,17],[374,1082,17,17],[397,1082,17,17],[420,1082,17,17],[443,1082,17,17],[467,1082,17,17],[490,1082,17,17],[513,1082,17,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats brand, adds tagline and URL.","boxes":[[72,1143,80,13],[170,1143,256,13],[1016,1143,112,13]]}],"usd":0.0126279,"sec":170,"out":19973,"cut":247,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"deepseek","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__deepseek__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":58.1},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single outcome grid under a finding headline, with the benchmark, model, and counts all shown.","marks":[],"usd":0.0089334,"sec":507,"out":13767,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__raw","clutter":71.8,"shares":{"blue":22.2,"orange":12,"red":65.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":48.6},"score":8,"words":481,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic fits about ten panels, cards and footers around one small results chart, so the main point is buried. It lacks nothing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header pills","reason":"Tag pills and date add nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[1067,40,90,22],[601,45,249,12],[889,45,160,12],[1077,45,70,12],[590,47,5,9],[878,47,5,9]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[54,122,327,13],[43,124,5,9]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be '+21.4% net win-loss on GDPval'.","boxes":[[43,132,848,99],[609,132,111,57]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Intro paragraph","reason":"Paragraph restating the chart and the post.","boxes":[[43,232,1045,59]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Restate margins already in the chart; duration and held-ability are extra.","boxes":[[58,353,111,11],[340,353,142,11],[621,353,105,11],[903,353,92,11],[58,364,111,40],[340,364,111,40],[621,364,138,40],[903,364,171,40],[58,405,118,15],[340,405,118,15],[621,405,142,15],[903,405,158,15],[58,422,188,11],[340,422,217,11],[621,422,176,11],[903,422,223,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Architecture diagram","reason":"Method pipeline panel beside the results chart.","boxes":[[641,510,272,15],[1038,510,103,28],[1045,513,50,22],[641,527,346,22],[652,583,139,56],[822,583,139,56],[991,583,139,56],[660,590,91,10],[829,590,86,10],[999,590,91,10],[660,602,109,14],[829,602,94,14],[999,602,81,14],[816,608,6,6],[985,608,6,6],[660,619,132,10],[829,619,132,10],[999,619,121,10],[718,639,6,4],[721,639,339,21],[785,649,212,23],[813,656,155,10],[724,681,334,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Paired comparison pill","reason":"Badge.","boxes":[[485,510,106,28],[492,513,56,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat rows in cards","reason":"Win rate, margin and rubric repeat the bar values and the stat cards.","boxes":[[73,598,65,13],[138,598,32,13],[182,598,78,13],[260,598,39,13],[311,598,84,13],[396,598,52,13],[73,699,65,13],[138,699,32,13],[182,699,78,13],[260,699,39,13],[311,699,84,13],[396,699,52,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Off vs on-policy cards","reason":"Second idea explaining methods.","boxes":[[661,729,134,11],[915,729,99,11],[651,731,5,9],[905,731,5,9],[651,744,225,42],[905,744,219,42]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qualitative pattern cards","reason":"Four text cards, a separate point.","boxes":[[659,811,133,13],[913,811,106,13],[650,813,5,9],[904,813,5,9],[650,826,227,25],[904,826,217,25],[659,872,135,13],[913,872,102,13],[650,874,5,9],[904,874,5,9],[650,887,208,25],[904,887,209,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Win tally cards","reason":"Repeat the counts and percentages already on the bar.","boxes":[[93,851,78,11],[263,851,61,11],[433,851,50,11],[82,853,7,7],[252,853,7,7],[422,853,7,7],[82,863,30,15],[252,863,23,15],[422,863,23,15],[112,866,34,12],[275,866,28,12],[445,866,34,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom panels","reason":"Training config and general-ability panels are separate ideas.","boxes":[[507,995,86,17],[1051,995,92,17],[59,996,262,14],[639,996,322,14],[514,998,72,11],[1058,998,78,11],[667,1024,42,9],[768,1024,42,9],[882,1024,19,9],[979,1024,28,9],[1078,1024,32,9],[66,1027,59,10],[201,1027,69,10],[336,1027,59,10],[471,1027,69,10],[676,1033,23,11],[766,1033,47,11],[879,1033,23,11],[969,1033,47,11],[1074,1033,41,11],[66,1039,80,12],[201,1039,68,12],[336,1039,80,12],[471,1039,49,12],[663,1044,49,10],[765,1044,49,10],[866,1044,49,10],[968,1044,49,10],[1070,1044,49,10],[59,1065,534,16],[639,1065,504,16],[59,1071,436,10],[639,1071,420,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats brand, dataset and authors; not needed.","boxes":[[43,1150,182,11],[231,1150,6,11],[243,1150,100,11],[899,1150,258,11]]}],"usd":0.37009747499999995,"sec":755,"out":88800,"cut":159,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.5},"score":0,"words":28,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, labelled bars, values, one logo, and no extras.","marks":[],"usd":0.35894347499999996,"sec":733,"out":86057,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__raw","clutter":65.4,"shares":{"blue":25.9,"orange":17.4,"red":56.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":45.1},"score":7,"words":327,"missing":[],"summary":"The two-model results cards are the real visual, but they are buried under stat tiles, a qualitative strip, three extra panels, and header and footer metadata.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Badge, eyebrow, subtitle","reason":"Research badge, kicker, accent bar and subtitle restate the title.","boxes":[[228,46,115,14],[218,48,4,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header meta strip","reason":"Benchmark, task count and harness are repeated elsewhere in the graphic.","boxes":[[710,45,144,16],[869,45,5,16],[887,45,116,16],[1017,45,5,16],[1036,45,116,16],[698,50,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[70,131,484,13],[48,137,14,2]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline over 7 words; could be shorter.","boxes":[[48,143,1022,112]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Restates the finding and the setup in a long sentence.","boxes":[[48,254,1004,43]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Pills and test callouts","reason":"Step pills, sign-test strips and author/date line add nothing to the chart.","boxes":[[498,369,69,21],[1060,369,69,21],[507,373,51,13],[1069,373,51,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Rubric point stats","reason":"Big stat callouts that duplicate the rubric delta shown in the cards.","boxes":[[280,452,62,59],[834,452,65,59],[280,506,126,13],[834,506,126,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat tiles","reason":"Repeat the wins, ties, losses, win rate and margin already in the bars.","boxes":[[90,595,27,12],[258,595,22,12],[426,595,39,12],[652,595,49,12],[820,595,64,12],[988,595,71,12],[80,598,6,6],[248,598,6,6],[416,598,6,6],[642,598,6,6],[810,598,6,6],[978,598,6,6],[80,609,77,14],[248,609,63,14],[416,609,70,14],[642,609,35,14],[810,609,42,14],[978,609,56,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Note strips","reason":"Sign-test and generalization lines explain rather than show.","boxes":[[82,648,107,14],[644,648,126,14],[320,649,236,13],[900,649,218,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qualitative shifts","reason":"A second point, with text-only behavior claims unrelated to the chart.","boxes":[[279,741,158,30],[279,741,136,14],[509,741,182,30],[509,741,88,14],[750,741,179,30],[750,741,92,14],[971,741,149,30],[971,741,72,14],[83,749,180,13],[66,751,10,10],[272,754,3,4],[502,754,3,4],[742,754,3,4],[963,754,3,4]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Loop diagram","reason":"A method diagram beside the results, serving a separate idea.","boxes":[[87,838,176,13],[70,839,7,11],[72,895,116,48],[348,895,116,48],[81,901,69,13],[357,901,67,13],[81,915,98,10],[357,915,98,10],[81,927,71,10],[357,927,62,10],[131,943,67,18],[339,943,67,18],[201,946,134,31],[131,948,57,54],[222,949,93,11],[206,963,124,9],[188,990,161,23],[193,997,150,10],[67,1049,403,28],[76,1049,348,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Config table","reason":"Training hyperparameters unrelated to reading the results.","boxes":[[548,838,159,13],[529,840,10,10],[529,843,10,7],[528,913,60,15],[726,914,83,13],[528,938,68,15],[726,939,83,13],[528,963,82,15],[687,964,122,13],[528,988,68,15],[706,989,103,13],[528,1013,66,15],[783,1014,26,13],[528,1038,90,15],[694,1039,115,13],[528,1063,74,15],[790,1064,19,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Regression panel","reason":"A separate general-benchmark claim, a second idea.","boxes":[[887,838,163,13],[868,839,11,11],[872,840,7,5],[874,875,26,13],[1047,880,80,15],[1052,882,70,11],[874,888,79,12],[874,914,51,13],[1047,919,80,15],[1052,921,70,11],[874,927,70,12],[874,953,26,13],[1047,958,80,15],[1052,960,70,11],[874,966,71,12],[874,992,83,13],[1047,997,80,15],[1052,999,70,11],[874,1005,67,12],[874,1031,45,13],[1047,1036,80,15],[1052,1038,70,11],[874,1044,75,12],[867,1065,191,12]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Repeats the brand and adds credits and harness details already given elsewhere.","boxes":[[48,1146,162,14],[864,1146,288,13]]}],"usd":0.2175591,"sec":401,"out":51821,"cut":151,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":36.7},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with a short title, axis, values and labels. It never says the margin is versus the base model, which is a small gap.","marks":[],"usd":0.29673022499999996,"sec":606,"out":70975,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash__raw","clutter":57.5,"shares":{"blue":31.9,"orange":21.2,"red":46.9,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.3},"score":7,"words":266,"missing":[],"summary":"The rubric-gain chart is a small part of the canvas, surrounded by stat cards, a second chart, config strip, badges and footer repeating the same results.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Empirical Research badge","reason":"Category badge.","boxes":[[986,74,133,14],[973,78,6,6]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Company tagline","reason":"Tagline next to logo; unnecessary.","boxes":[[68,97,523,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow above headline.","boxes":[[68,200,5,14],[81,200,247,14]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline; could be '+21.4% on GDPval in 50 steps'.","boxes":[[68,217,958,109],[243,217,315,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat cards","reason":"Big stat cards restate margins and results the charts show.","boxes":[[95,405,224,24],[490,405,72,21],[638,405,112,24],[1007,405,98,21],[499,409,54,13],[1016,409,80,13],[95,432,328,16],[638,432,289,16],[95,444,181,90],[638,444,172,90],[292,499,149,14],[826,499,149,14],[292,516,173,15],[826,516,139,15],[95,562,76,22],[254,562,51,22],[413,562,92,22],[638,562,76,22],[797,562,51,22],[956,562,63,22],[95,586,137,15],[254,586,149,15],[413,586,100,29],[638,586,137,15],[797,586,149,15],[956,586,121,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Head-to-head panel","reason":"Second chart on win/tie/loss, repeating counts twice.","boxes":[[994,761,113,15],[773,834,25,18],[902,834,17,18],[1027,834,17,18],[750,854,70,14],[883,854,56,14],[994,854,83,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Regression note","reason":"Capability regression claim is a separate idea.","boxes":[[93,907,530,30],[93,907,137,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training config strip","reason":"Method details unrelated to the result chart.","boxes":[[91,1034,117,13],[322,1034,128,13],[525,1034,105,13],[728,1034,135,13],[950,1034,127,13],[91,1050,170,15],[322,1050,159,15],[525,1050,151,15],[728,1050,163,14],[950,1050,100,14]]}],"usd":0.096098475,"sec":294,"out":22376,"cut":62,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"gemini-flash","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__gemini-flash__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":27.3},"score":1,"words":33,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete: a clear two-bar chart with a benchmark title, labelled net values and a legend, with nothing extra to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.1594461,"sec":435,"out":37694,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-high__raw","clutter":22.8,"shares":{"blue":77.2,"orange":0,"red":22.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.2},"score":5,"words":134,"missing":[],"summary":"Two big stat panels, a win/tie/loss bar, a subtitle, teacher lines, secondary stats and config footnotes crowd the single net win-loss point; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date","reason":"Publication date is not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[1028,55,108,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[64,133,223,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explains method and training data, not needed to read the result.","boxes":[[64,308,655,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow and family tags","reason":"Kicker above headline and category tags that add no finding","boxes":[[641,407,103,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Teacher lines","reason":"Teacher model names are method detail the reader does not need.","boxes":[[64,466,284,21],[641,466,215,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated metric label","reason":"Same 'Net win-loss vs. the base model' label already shown under the first figure","boxes":[[641,604,213,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Secondary stats","reason":"Extra metrics, rubric points and win rate, repeat the win-loss idea.","boxes":[[64,640,65,50],[228,640,83,50],[641,640,65,50],[805,640,83,50],[64,686,128,19],[228,686,52,19],[641,686,128,19],[805,686,52,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training hyperparameters","reason":"Configuration details serve a separate point.","boxes":[[64,1075,597,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Regression benchmarks note","reason":"Separate claim about general benchmarks.","boxes":[[64,1104,809,21]]}],"usd":0.238226,"sec":784,"out":38251,"cut":18,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":1,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short title, value labels and model names; only the unlisted logo and missing axis unit are worth a look.","marks":[],"usd":0.317906,"sec":1007,"out":51466,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-medium__raw","clutter":75.5,"shares":{"blue":24.5,"orange":0,"red":75.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.1},"score":6,"words":121,"missing":["comparison baseline"],"summary":"A big headline stat is surrounded by a second model's stat card, a win/tie/loss bar and a dataset footer; the baseline for the margin is unclear.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research date tag","reason":"Category tag and date add nothing needed.","boxes":[[923,67,217,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle paragraph","reason":"Long paragraph restating the chart and the Nemotron result.","boxes":[[60,397,975,64]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Qwen stat card","reason":"Repeats the headline +21.4% and the models named in the subtitle.","boxes":[[88,530,96,15],[88,553,254,23],[88,593,66,63],[241,593,94,63],[395,593,116,63],[88,652,118,19],[241,652,50,19],[395,652,77,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Nemotron stat card","reason":"Second model's results, a second point beside the headline.","boxes":[[638,530,144,15],[638,553,269,23],[638,593,63,63],[791,593,95,63],[945,593,122,63],[638,652,118,19],[791,652,50,19],[945,652,77,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Win/tie/loss bar","reason":"Separate Nemotron breakdown; a second chart with a sign-test note.","boxes":[[60,814,385,20],[60,846,599,84],[663,846,97,84],[765,846,375,84],[82,875,84,27],[699,875,26,27],[786,875,90,27],[60,944,568,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Dataset stats footer","reason":"Training steps and dataset sizes row, unrelated to the main stat.","boxes":[[382,1079,110,44],[818,1079,106,44],[60,1088,92,44],[382,1120,262,37],[818,1120,259,37],[60,1129,280,19]]}],"usd":0.152432,"sec":356,"out":23952,"cut":35,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":49},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a title, logo, labelled values and axis; only the vague 'vs base' could be clearer.","marks":[],"usd":0.127028,"sec":336,"out":19653,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-xhigh__raw","clutter":47.2,"shares":{"blue":52.8,"orange":0,"red":47.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.9},"score":5,"words":172,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic carries two stat panels, a win/loss bar, a config strip and footnotes, with a slogan headline and duplicate logos burying one main point.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date byline","reason":"Date and authors tell reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[954,56,182,35],[1029,56,27,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Second logo mark","reason":"Brand shown a second time beside eyebrow.","boxes":[[79,132,5,2],[77,136,5,2],[75,139,9,2],[74,143,5,2],[72,147,16,2],[70,150,5,2],[87,150,5,2],[69,154,5,2],[89,154,6,2],[64,158,12,2],[87,158,11,2]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[110,139,282,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,164,645,122]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Secondary stat rows","reason":"Rubric and win rate restate or add side metrics; win rate repeated.","boxes":[[64,576,58,56],[324,576,87,56],[637,576,61,56],[897,576,86,56],[64,627,126,17],[324,627,46,17],[637,627,126,17],[897,627,46,17],[64,663,114,14],[637,663,212,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Bar caption","reason":"Restates win rate and sign-test detail.","boxes":[[64,941,550,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training config row","reason":"Hyperparameters are a second, unrelated idea.","boxes":[[64,982,277,15],[64,1001,37,56],[243,1001,60,56],[421,1001,14,56],[600,1001,65,56],[779,1001,33,56],[957,1001,32,56],[64,1054,33,17],[243,1054,101,17],[421,1054,83,17],[600,1054,75,17],[779,1054,62,17],[957,1054,61,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Footnote paragraphs","reason":"Methods and general-benchmark claims, extra ideas.","boxes":[[64,1086,1046,40],[64,1132,836,19]]}],"usd":0.382976,"sec":871,"out":62376,"cut":43,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":["baseline or comparison"],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart, short title, logo, and axis; bars slightly misaligned with the axis, and the chart doesn't say 'vs. base model'.","marks":[],"usd":0.393254,"sec":883,"out":64024,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok__raw","clutter":26.3,"shares":{"blue":73.7,"orange":0,"red":26.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":24.3},"score":5,"words":101,"missing":[],"summary":"Two result cards are a decent main visual but are surrounded by eyebrow, subtitle, paragraph, pills and footer extras, with large empty space in the cards.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Kicker tag top right adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[960,73,168,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Subtitle restates what the cards show.","boxes":[[700,279,410,89],[823,310,85,27]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explainer paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explains and restates results.","boxes":[[646,984,432,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Footer pills","reason":"Dataset size and p-value pills serve secondary points.","boxes":[[287,1107,180,37],[87,1116,26,18],[113,1116,149,19],[302,1116,150,19],[492,1116,122,19],[613,1116,57,18]]}],"usd":0.046004,"sec":110,"out":6214,"cut":12,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"grok","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__grok__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":["distilled vs base indication"],"summary":"Clean single chart with logo, title, labels and values; it only omits that the margin is distilled model versus base.","marks":[],"usd":0.049004,"sec":114,"out":6649,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-high__raw","clutter":66.8,"shares":{"blue":33.2,"orange":0,"red":66.8,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":57.3},"score":6,"words":104,"missing":[],"summary":"The 21.4% headline is a Qwen result but the waffle chart shows Nemotron's +20.9%, and score-gain cards plus a pipeline strip add extra ideas and repetition.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date","reason":"Date tag adds nothing to the finding.","boxes":[[955,73,173,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker line","reason":"Kicker above the headline; the caption already names GDPval","boxes":[[94,155,299,17],[72,158,10,10]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Score-gain cards","reason":"Rubric-score gains are a second metric beside the margin result.","boxes":[[812,224,96,17],[812,234,190,94],[812,319,255,22],[812,386,144,17],[812,396,186,94],[812,481,258,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Nemotron win-loss legend block","reason":"Second visual about Nemotron task outcomes, unrelated to the main Qwen claim","boxes":[[72,567,501,17],[848,595,83,94],[974,630,37,23],[812,633,18,18],[848,671,65,94],[974,706,29,23],[812,709,18,18],[848,747,64,94],[974,782,50,23],[812,785,18,18],[900,855,56,22],[812,856,286,22],[812,881,280,22],[812,905,69,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Nemotron 220-task waffle","reason":"Second chart of Nemotron outcomes; competes with the main Qwen visual","boxes":[[72,604,26,26],[105,604,26,26],[138,604,26,26],[171,604,26,26],[204,604,26,26],[237,604,26,26],[270,604,26,26],[303,604,26,26],[336,604,26,26],[369,604,26,26],[402,604,26,26],[435,604,26,26],[468,604,26,26],[501,604,26,26],[534,604,26,26],[567,604,26,26],[600,604,26,26],[633,604,26,26],[666,604,26,26],[699,604,26,26],[72,637,26,26],[105,637,26,26],[138,637,26,26],[171,637,26,26],[204,637,26,26],[237,637,26,26],[270,637,26,26],[303,637,26,26],[336,637,26,26],[369,637,26,26],[402,637,26,26],[435,637,26,26],[468,637,26,26],[501,637,26,26],[534,637,26,26],[567,637,26,26],[600,637,26,26],[633,637,26,26],[666,637,26,26],[699,637,26,26],[72,670,26,26],[105,670,26,26],[138,670,26,26],[171,670,26,26],[204,670,26,26],[237,670,26,26],[270,670,26,26],[303,670,26,26],[336,670,26,26],[369,670,26,26],[402,670,26,26],[435,670,26,26],[468,670,26,26],[501,670,26,26],[534,670,26,26],[567,670,26,26],[600,670,26,26],[633,670,26,26],[666,670,26,26],[699,670,26,26],[72,703,26,26],[105,703,26,26],[138,703,26,26],[171,703,26,26],[204,703,26,26],[237,703,26,26],[270,703,26,26],[303,703,26,26],[336,703,26,26],[369,703,26,26],[402,703,26,26],[435,703,26,26],[468,703,26,26],[501,703,26,26],[534,703,26,26],[567,703,26,26],[600,703,26,26],[633,703,26,26],[666,703,26,26],[699,703,26,26],[72,736,26,26],[105,736,26,26],[138,736,26,26],[171,736,26,26],[204,736,26,26],[237,736,26,26],[270,736,26,26],[303,736,26,26],[336,736,26,26],[369,736,26,26],[402,736,26,26],[435,736,26,26],[468,736,26,26],[501,736,26,26],[534,736,26,26],[567,736,26,26],[600,736,26,26],[633,736,26,26],[666,736,26,26],[699,736,26,26],[72,769,26,26],[105,769,26,26],[138,769,26,26],[171,769,26,26],[204,769,26,26],[237,769,26,26],[270,769,26,26],[303,769,26,26],[336,769,26,26],[369,769,26,26],[402,769,26,26],[435,769,26,26],[468,769,26,26],[501,769,26,26],[534,769,26,26],[567,769,26,26],[600,769,26,26],[633,769,26,26],[666,769,26,26],[699,769,26,26],[72,802,26,26],[105,802,26,26],[138,802,26,26],[171,802,26,26],[204,802,26,26],[237,802,26,26],[270,802,26,26],[303,802,26,26],[336,802,26,26],[369,802,26,26],[402,802,26,26],[435,802,26,26],[468,802,26,26],[501,802,26,26],[534,802,26,26],[567,802,26,26],[600,802,26,26],[633,802,26,26],[666,802,26,26],[699,802,26,26],[72,835,26,26],[105,835,26,26],[138,835,26,26],[171,835,26,26],[204,835,26,26],[237,835,26,26],[270,835,26,26],[303,835,26,26],[336,835,26,26],[369,835,26,26],[402,835,26,26],[435,835,26,26],[468,835,26,26],[501,835,26,26],[534,835,26,26],[567,835,26,26],[600,835,26,26],[633,835,26,26],[666,835,26,26],[699,835,26,26],[72,868,26,26],[105,868,26,26],[138,868,26,26],[171,868,26,26],[204,868,26,26],[237,868,26,26],[270,868,26,26],[303,868,26,26],[336,868,26,26],[369,868,26,26],[402,868,26,26],[435,868,26,26],[468,868,26,26],[501,868,26,26],[534,868,26,26],[567,868,26,26],[600,868,26,26],[633,868,26,26],[666,868,26,26],[699,868,26,26],[72,901,26,26],[105,901,26,26],[138,901,26,26],[171,901,26,26],[204,901,26,26],[237,901,26,26],[270,901,26,26],[303,901,26,26],[336,901,26,26],[369,901,26,26],[402,901,26,26],[435,901,26,26],[468,901,26,26],[501,901,26,26],[534,901,26,26],[567,901,26,26],[600,901,26,26],[633,901,26,26],[666,901,26,26],[699,901,26,26],[72,934,26,26],[105,934,26,26],[138,934,26,26],[171,934,26,26],[204,934,26,26],[237,934,26,26],[270,934,26,26],[303,934,26,26],[336,934,26,26],[369,934,26,26],[402,934,26,26],[435,934,26,26],[468,934,26,26],[501,934,26,26],[534,934,26,26],[567,934,26,26],[600,934,26,26],[633,934,26,26],[666,934,26,26],[699,934,26,26]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline strip","reason":"Teacher-student diagram is a second idea and repeats +5.1 pts.","boxes":[[0,1000,1200,200],[373,1040,74,30],[757,1040,83,14],[91,1042,132,14],[479,1042,182,14],[867,1042,116,14],[867,1052,133,65],[91,1066,179,26],[479,1066,173,26],[448,1076,10,12],[836,1076,10,12],[91,1095,72,20],[479,1095,62,20],[867,1111,173,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; the logo is already present.","boxes":[[72,1167,116,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer tagline","reason":"Method tagline repeats the topic tag.","boxes":[[781,1167,347,14]]}],"usd":0.0008264999999999999,"sec":819,"out":283,"cut":267,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.8},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one waffle chart, a headline stat, a context line, a legend and a logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0096521,"sec":101,"out":17880,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-medium__raw","clutter":49,"shares":{"blue":50.7,"orange":0.6,"red":48.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.5},"score":5,"words":142,"missing":[],"summary":"The two result cards are the core, but a slogan headline, a subtitle, secondary stat rows, a win/tie/loss bar, method cards and brand repeats crowd them out.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date tag","reason":"Research/date tag is not needed.","boxes":[[932,78,188,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[80,166,347,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the finding, and it is huge.","boxes":[[80,184,564,215],[176,268,150,131]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating the method.","boxes":[[80,399,821,63]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen secondary stats","reason":"Secondary stats row, a different metric from the main one.","boxes":[[113,791,47,32],[256,791,68,32],[113,827,107,18],[256,827,46,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Nemotron secondary stats","reason":"Secondary stats row, a different metric from the main one.","boxes":[[645,791,44,32],[788,791,72,32],[896,791,31,32],[645,827,107,18],[788,827,46,18],[896,827,78,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Eval caption","reason":"Eval details are useful but sit large above the bar.","boxes":[[958,895,162,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method steps","reason":"Pipeline cards are a second idea beside the results.","boxes":[[80,1030,17,15],[441,1030,17,15],[803,1030,17,15],[399,1051,38,14],[761,1051,38,14],[80,1053,268,51],[441,1053,278,51],[803,1053,288,51]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention.","boxes":[[991,1149,129,17]]}],"usd":0.0078355,"sec":100,"out":14301,"cut":29,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":50.1},"score":0,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one waffle chart, big stat, short subtitle, logo and legend.","marks":[],"usd":0.0069716000000000005,"sec":80,"out":12519,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__raw","clutter":35.4,"shares":{"blue":64.6,"orange":0,"red":35.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37.8},"score":6,"words":96,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic has a solid main visual but adds a tagline, eyebrow, subtitle, a second win-rate bar, a rubric stat, a quote, and footers; it lacks nothing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Applied research lab tagline","reason":"Tagline, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[916,71,212,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Eyebrow line above the headline.","boxes":[[72,150,329,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining method and restating the result.","boxes":[[72,378,886,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen replication panel","reason":"Second model family and its win-rate bar, rubric stat and quote","boxes":[[710,526,212,17],[710,549,225,22],[710,703,296,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Qwen big stat","reason":"+21.4% already shown in the headline","boxes":[[710,560,314,162]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen win-rate bar","reason":"Second metric, win rate, unrelated to net margin.","boxes":[[1012,762,68,32],[710,771,63,22],[710,806,212,12],[883,826,23,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Rubric points stat","reason":"Another metric, mean rubric gain, a separate point.","boxes":[[710,860,99,87],[710,940,144,40]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Pull quote","reason":"Takeaway sentence restating the result.","boxes":[[710,1011,370,49],[726,1012,315,47]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Blog date footer","reason":"Footer tag, not needed.","boxes":[[72,1123,191,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Website footer","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[979,1123,149,17]]}],"usd":0.0225625,"sec":215,"out":43755,"cut":19,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":43.9},"score":1,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one waffle chart with a headline number, legend, benchmark-and-metric subtitle and logo; at most the legend counts duplicate the headline, which is harmless.","marks":[],"usd":0.0232231,"sec":243,"out":45022,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku__raw","clutter":64.8,"shares":{"blue":34,"orange":2.4,"red":63.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.7},"score":5,"words":102,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid stat-row main visual is cluttered by a slogan headline, subtitle, eyebrow tag, and a redundant win/loss bar with footnotes.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Eyebrow tag like 'Research · GDPval' adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[911,89,197,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Names the method, not the finding; large and slogan-like.","boxes":[[92,161,840,143],[92,255,814,143]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining method and restating setup.","boxes":[[92,403,829,67]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Teacher detail lines","reason":"Wordy teacher/steps descriptions; could be shortened.","boxes":[[92,641,491,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen stat card","reason":"Second model family is a separate point from the main chart.","boxes":[[648,748,188,105],[898,748,144,105],[838,764,27,47],[92,783,148,32],[92,822,439,25],[648,853,189,18],[898,853,179,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Win/tie/loss bar","reason":"Second chart restating Nemotron margin already shown above.","boxes":[[969,979,139,18]]}],"usd":0.0042715,"sec":40,"out":7173,"cut":14,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"haiku","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__haiku__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":100},"score":1,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean: one segmented bar with labels; the headline could be shorter, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[],"usd":0.0040351,"sec":41,"out":6646,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-high__raw","clutter":64.3,"shares":{"blue":35.7,"orange":0,"red":64.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":20.7},"score":6,"words":103,"missing":["comparison baseline"],"summary":"A solid win-loss chart is buried under a sentence headline, subtitle, tags, stat cards, a method strip and a footer; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Top-right tag","reason":"Category tag with no information the reader needs.","boxes":[[921,73,203,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above the headline.","boxes":[[108,160,190,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan, not a finding; the chart already states the result.","boxes":[[76,185,507,130]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restating context; the chart label already names Qwen3.5-9B.","boxes":[[76,315,436,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Distilled vs base pill","reason":"Badge; the comparison is already implied by the margin.","boxes":[[942,418,142,30],[954,426,118,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Win rate card","reason":"Win rate is derived from the bar already shown.","boxes":[[850,487,106,75],[850,557,61,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Rubric score card","reason":"A second metric that is unrelated to reading the win-loss bar.","boxes":[[850,708,60,61],[850,762,204,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Learning signal strip","reason":"Method diagram beside a results chart; a second idea.","boxes":[[76,856,156,14],[907,856,217,15],[90,899,56,13],[439,899,56,13],[789,899,47,13],[76,902,6,6],[425,902,6,6],[775,902,6,6],[76,919,166,22],[425,919,188,22],[775,919,208,22],[76,944,201,16],[425,944,193,16],[775,944,225,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Second brand wordmark, tagline and category tag.","boxes":[[76,1149,77,13],[153,1149,190,14],[870,1149,254,14]]}],"usd":0.0041912,"sec":81,"out":7535,"cut":31,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":15.7},"score":0,"words":9,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one bar chart with title, labels, values and a single logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.0026773,"sec":61,"out":4469,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-medium__raw","clutter":62.5,"shares":{"blue":27.7,"orange":19.6,"red":52.7,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25},"score":6,"words":134,"missing":[],"summary":"A small bar chart is buried under a redundant big-stat card, a stats row, a subtitle, an eyebrow and a duplicate footer brand.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[914,66,214,16]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Eyebrow/kicker above headline.","boxes":[[72,155,402,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Headline is a slogan-like sentence, large; could be a short finding title.","boxes":[[72,173,476,145]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explainer subtitle","reason":"Paragraph restating what the chart shows.","boxes":[[72,325,759,48]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big stat card","reason":"Restates the +21.4% already shown in the bar chart.","boxes":[[106,452,274,16],[106,463,229,177],[335,531,42,84],[106,627,261,47]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Secondary Nemotron stats row serves a separate idea.","boxes":[[76,856,93,45],[433,856,107,45],[791,856,137,45],[76,905,194,18],[433,905,180,18],[791,905,229,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand tagline","reason":"Second brand mark plus tagline; logo already in header.","boxes":[[188,1137,260,16],[72,1138,18,15],[98,1138,82,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Footer method tag","reason":"Method tag adds nothing needed.","boxes":[[949,1137,179,16]]}],"usd":0.0020621999999999997,"sec":40,"out":3277,"cut":22,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":7.1},"score":1,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Nearly clean single bar chart; only the redundant 'NET MARGIN' label is extra, and the axis is clipped and misaligned with the bars.","marks":[],"usd":0.0021243,"sec":52,"out":3363,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-xhigh__raw","clutter":72.5,"shares":{"blue":27.5,"orange":0,"red":72.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":25.3},"score":6,"words":121,"missing":[],"summary":"A method diagram, bottom stats row, slogan headline, tags and footer crowd the two stat cards that carry the point; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research tag","reason":"Category tag, not needed.","boxes":[[1007,60,129,13],[1075,60,8,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Kicker line above headline.","boxes":[[64,148,168,13]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan about learning, not the finding.","boxes":[[64,156,473,147]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining the method, not the result.","boxes":[[64,304,916,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Training signal diagram","reason":"Method diagram serves a second idea unrelated to the results.","boxes":[[97,395,132,12],[864,395,239,12],[113,474,17,17],[853,474,17,17],[138,476,49,12],[878,476,49,12],[118,477,6,11],[858,477,6,11],[529,482,142,11],[378,484,21,37],[801,484,21,37],[113,494,184,30],[853,494,139,30],[696,501,13,25],[492,504,41,21],[540,504,53,21],[600,504,34,21],[641,504,48,21],[215,595,12,7],[221,595,758,25],[434,624,332,15],[447,626,306,11]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Bottom stats row","reason":"Second metrics and a win-tie-loss bar, beyond the main result.","boxes":[[64,997,231,11],[486,997,143,11],[1053,997,83,11],[64,1000,64,63],[486,1022,361,13],[849,1022,59,13],[910,1022,226,13],[131,1031,41,20],[486,1043,17,14],[503,1043,25,15],[793,1043,13,14],[806,1043,20,15],[1091,1043,12,14],[1103,1043,33,15],[64,1056,108,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer","reason":"Tagline and second brand mention.","boxes":[[64,1127,165,11],[1051,1127,85,11]]}],"usd":0.0110022,"sec":210,"out":21157,"cut":51,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":26.2},"score":0,"words":7,"missing":["benchmark name (GDPval)","comparison baseline"],"summary":"The graphic is clean and uncluttered, but it never names GDPval or says the margin is against the base model.","marks":[],"usd":0.0065543,"sec":134,"out":12223,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna__raw","clutter":58.6,"shares":{"blue":31.1,"orange":20.9,"red":48.1,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":28},"score":6,"words":172,"missing":[],"summary":"A pipeline diagram, subtitle, tags, extra stats and a second brand mention clutter two good result cards; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Header tag","reason":"Category tag; adds nothing.","boxes":[[975,61,161,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above headline.","boxes":[[64,150,395,18]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Large slogan-like headline; states no number or finding.","boxes":[[64,166,579,147]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Sentence restating what the cards show.","boxes":[[64,312,790,49]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen extra stats","reason":"Extra score and win-rate stats beyond main margin.","boxes":[[636,605,99,77],[980,635,125,36],[735,644,37,27],[636,691,68,16],[636,719,93,38],[741,724,17,28],[649,729,67,18],[783,729,35,17],[818,729,54,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Nemotron footer stats","reason":"Repeats win rate and points; extra stats.","boxes":[[90,783,37,17],[127,783,164,18],[291,783,62,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Transfer caption","reason":"Sentence restating the two-family point.","boxes":[[636,783,138,17],[774,783,278,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method pipeline","reason":"Method diagram is a second idea beside results.","boxes":[[90,863,283,22],[929,868,181,16],[105,926,85,15],[375,926,87,15],[645,926,76,15],[915,926,78,15],[105,939,86,42],[375,939,101,42],[645,939,89,42],[915,939,70,42],[105,981,76,16],[375,981,77,16],[645,981,95,16],[915,981,127,16],[90,1020,354,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer brand","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[79,1079,248,16],[64,1084,7,7]]}],"usd":0.0023686999999999996,"sec":51,"out":3890,"cut":42,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"luna","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__luna__simple","clutter":2.5,"shares":{"blue":97.5,"orange":0,"red":2.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":9.6},"score":1,"words":19,"missing":["comparison baseline"],"summary":"Clean, focused win-tie-loss chart; only the repeated footer wordmark should go, and the graphic does not say the pairs are against the base model.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer wordmark","reason":"Second brand mark; the top logo already covers branding.","boxes":[[78,1108,142,24]]}],"usd":0.0013608,"sec":56,"out":1836,"cut":1,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-high__raw","clutter":46.1,"shares":{"blue":36.2,"orange":35.5,"red":28.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.2},"score":6,"words":127,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid result chart is surrounded by a wordy sentence headline, subtitle, eyebrow, repeated secondary stats, a general-ability footer and a second brand mark; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category kicker above headline.","boxes":[[823,65,313,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Three-line sentence; could be 'Distillation: +21% net win-loss on GDPval'.","boxes":[[64,124,991,228],[775,190,186,97]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Method subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining method, not needed to read results.","boxes":[[64,359,882,60]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen second-family card","reason":"Second model family is a separate point beside the main grid.","boxes":[[643,490,185,15],[711,523,77,21],[918,523,20,21],[654,528,51,13],[861,528,51,13],[811,529,27,9],[643,543,248,131],[905,622,123,46]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Secondary stat rows","reason":"Rubric score and win rate are extra metrics; win rate repeats waffle.","boxes":[[95,707,84,32],[337,707,71,32],[643,707,87,32],[885,707,67,32],[95,743,119,20],[337,743,53,20],[643,743,119,20],[885,743,53,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"General ability footer","reason":"Separate claim about other benchmarks, unrelated to GDPval chart.","boxes":[[64,1136,695,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mark when logo already present.","boxes":[[1013,1139,123,15]]}],"usd":0.2695,"sec":124,"out":12105,"cut":27,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-high__simple","clutter":11.8,"shares":{"blue":76.4,"orange":23.6,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":51.5},"score":1,"words":16,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean single waffle chart with logo and labels; only the three-line headline could be shorter.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Three-line headline","reason":"Names the finding but is long and very large; could be shorter.","boxes":[[60,143,562,243],[308,143,518,103],[606,213,209,103]]}],"usd":0.202344,"sec":109,"out":8693,"cut":0,"shrunk":3},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-medium__raw","clutter":48.3,"shares":{"blue":34.5,"orange":34.5,"red":31,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":35.6},"score":5,"words":129,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid win/tie/loss bar chart is cluttered by a sentence headline, subtitle, eyebrow, oversized callouts, teacher lines, and a stats row; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag above headline, tells reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[833,68,295,17]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline, too long; and the +21.4% in it repeats a card.","boxes":[[72,121,820,213],[632,182,173,90]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle restating setup; details fit a footnote.","boxes":[[72,343,695,54]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Big net-margin stat cards","reason":"Net margins repeat the headline and are derivable from the bars","boxes":[[913,495,174,87],[972,571,115,18],[921,711,166,87],[972,787,115,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Sub-bar notes","reason":"Extra stats and tagline beneath bars add a second metric.","boxes":[[858,657,229,19],[113,873,217,19],[923,873,164,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Stats row","reason":"Dataset and setup stats serve a separate idea from the chart.","boxes":[[72,962,43,63],[359,962,69,63],[623,962,63,63],[887,962,19,63],[72,1023,144,19],[359,1023,213,38],[623,1023,191,38],[887,1023,196,38]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when logo already exists.","boxes":[[72,1127,125,17]]}],"usd":0.15302,"sec":67,"out":6281,"cut":22,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":56.8},"score":0,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one waffle chart with a short title, legend with counts, net margin and a logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.117924,"sec":56,"out":4472,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-xhigh__raw","clutter":27.5,"shares":{"blue":57.2,"orange":30.4,"red":12.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.4},"score":5,"words":166,"missing":[],"summary":"The graphic has a good main visual, but it also has a badge, eyebrow, subtitle, formula and footer URL that should go, and the headline is a full sentence.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Research pill and date","reason":"Category badge and date tell the reader nothing needed.","boxes":[[956,60,87,32],[1057,66,79,20],[970,67,59,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow line","reason":"Kicker above the headline.","boxes":[[64,176,281,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline at 60px; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[64,193,995,158]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining method and restating the chart.","boxes":[[64,357,937,55]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Qwen results card","reason":"Second family card is useful but repeats the layout and wording.","boxes":[[1016,501,90,14],[643,740,87,32],[884,740,67,32],[643,775,172,19],[884,775,102,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Margin formula","reason":"Restates +20.9% already shown in the card.","boxes":[[65,1040,301,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention; logo already present.","boxes":[[1043,1125,93,19]]}],"usd":0.48212,"sec":256,"out":22736,"cut":7,"shrunk":6},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":49.5},"score":0,"words":18,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single waffle chart with a descriptive title, legend with counts, and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.322604,"sec":161,"out":14706,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus__raw","clutter":18.5,"shares":{"blue":80.1,"orange":2.9,"red":17,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":32.8},"score":3,"words":96,"missing":[],"summary":"Two big stat panels with repeated win-rate bars, plus a method subtitle, a tagline and a footer URL, add clutter; the content is otherwise complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explaining method and data; not needed to read the results.","boxes":[[80,408,900,60]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Metric caption lines","reason":"Name the metric but pack in extra stats; could be shortened.","boxes":[[612,766,485,25]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Qwen win-rate bar","reason":"Win rate is already in the caption line above.","boxes":[[612,813,291,34],[903,813,217,34],[622,821,96,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Recipe tagline","reason":"Takeaway-like caption, not needed to read the chart.","boxes":[[612,855,233,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention, since the logo is already present.","boxes":[[1014,1115,106,21]]}],"usd":0.07948,"sec":33,"out":2604,"cut":6,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"opus","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__opus__simple","clutter":8.1,"shares":{"blue":83.8,"orange":16.2,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":49},"score":1,"words":25,"missing":["unit of each square"],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; only the headline is wordier than needed, and the grid's unit is implied rather than stated.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Finding is right but ten words; could shorten to about seven, e.g. 'Distillation wins more GDPval tasks than it loses'.","boxes":[[66,239,789,139]]}],"usd":0.082544,"sec":42,"out":2703,"cut":0,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-high__raw","clutter":60.8,"shares":{"blue":37,"orange":4.4,"red":58.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":31.2},"score":5,"words":92,"missing":[],"summary":"A giant slogan headline, tag, subtitle, and a method pipeline panel crowd out the two-number results; otherwise complete.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Research / Model training tag is an eyebrow-style tag.","boxes":[[911,65,225,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Huge slogan that states no finding and dominates the canvas.","boxes":[[64,139,610,213]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Tagline restating topics; explains nothing needed.","boxes":[[67,351,707,32]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Rubric score gains","reason":"Secondary metric repeated per column with wordy label; could be shortened.","boxes":[[64,745,89,37],[641,745,91,37],[165,755,222,23],[744,755,222,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method diagram","reason":"Pipeline explaining the method, a second idea beside the results.","boxes":[[757,851,352,22],[91,854,276,15],[144,896,187,30],[493,896,153,30],[843,896,148,30],[98,899,25,32],[104,899,19,28],[796,899,25,32],[802,899,19,24],[444,900,31,30],[380,905,25,14],[730,905,25,14],[450,906,19,18],[144,932,197,21],[493,932,212,21],[843,932,243,21],[248,999,697,30],[481,1016,236,26],[508,1019,181,21]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo already exists.","boxes":[[1036,1135,100,20]]}],"usd":0.054604,"sec":97,"out":4613,"cut":24,"shrunk":4},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":48.7},"score":0,"words":13,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a short title, metric subtitle, logo, and labelled values.","marks":[],"usd":0.040496,"sec":115,"out":3164,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-medium__raw","clutter":68.2,"shares":{"blue":31.8,"orange":0,"red":68.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":37},"score":6,"words":115,"missing":[],"summary":"The big stats are clear, but a slogan headline, subtitle, eyebrow tag and a large method-diagram panel clutter it; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tag","reason":"Category tag with dot; not needed.","boxes":[[944,66,192,21],[924,71,8,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Slogan that does not state the measured finding; should name the result.","boxes":[[64,133,827,200]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Sentence restating what the stats show.","boxes":[[64,338,624,66]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method diagram panel","reason":"Pipeline explaining method is a second idea, larger than needed.","boxes":[[97,794,541,48],[947,813,156,22],[115,885,212,26],[453,885,198,26],[858,885,130,26],[115,918,187,43],[453,918,206,43],[858,918,200,43],[229,978,742,40],[457,1007,287,21],[509,1007,184,21]]}],"usd":0.045614,"sec":110,"out":3714,"cut":19,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":47.2},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a simple two-bar chart with a benchmark title, metric subtitle, value labels and a logo, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.034126,"sec":87,"out":2527,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-xhigh__raw","clutter":60.9,"shares":{"blue":36.7,"orange":4.6,"red":58.6,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":34.2},"score":5,"words":89,"missing":[],"summary":"A slogan headline, eyebrow, tag, subtitle, footer URL and a large method diagram clutter the two-number result; nothing important is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Category tag in the top corner.","boxes":[[888,66,248,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow","reason":"Eyebrow line above headline.","boxes":[[64,162,218,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Large slogan that does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,185,725,197]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Finding subtitle","reason":"States the finding, but as a long sentence; shorten to a headline-length claim.","boxes":[[64,385,633,33]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Method diagram","reason":"Pipeline diagram is a second idea unrelated to results.","boxes":[[94,820,480,48],[947,844,159,14],[399,884,265,84],[802,884,304,84],[420,895,151,30],[823,895,151,30],[151,898,155,28],[95,899,39,49],[104,899,30,39],[420,928,166,21],[823,928,190,21],[151,929,125,21],[531,969,423,38],[577,1025,332,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention beyond the logo.","boxes":[[1015,1144,121,17]]}],"usd":0.098924,"sec":240,"out":9045,"cut":19,"shrunk":1},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":47.9},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: two labelled bars, a short title, and a metric line, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.055436,"sec":144,"out":4658,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol__raw","clutter":70.3,"shares":{"blue":29.7,"orange":0,"red":70.3,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":41.3},"score":5,"words":90,"missing":[],"summary":"A slogan headline, subtitle, tag and a pipeline diagram crowd the two big result numbers, which are the real content, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category tag","reason":"Kicker tag in the header adds nothing the reader needs.","boxes":[[807,64,329,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline","reason":"Three-line slogan that does not state the finding and takes much of the canvas.","boxes":[[64,148,763,256]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle","reason":"Subtitle restates what the stats already show.","boxes":[[64,409,569,67]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Pipeline diagram","reason":"Method diagram is a second idea unrelated to reading the results.","boxes":[[64,542,388,21],[65,587,291,102],[454,587,291,102],[843,587,291,102],[87,599,157,30],[476,599,187,30],[865,599,153,30],[87,641,227,23],[476,641,185,23],[865,641,205,23],[600,701,389,32],[703,720,183,26],[722,722,143,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Mean rubric score rows","reason":"Second metric row is a separate point, not needed to read the margins.","boxes":[[64,1043,141,37],[641,1043,144,37],[217,1055,145,23],[797,1055,145,23]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention, since the logo is already at the top.","boxes":[[1023,1143,113,22]]}],"usd":0.033864,"sec":70,"out":2539,"cut":24,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sol","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sol__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.7},"score":0,"words":12,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete chart; the only defect is the brand mark e1 that fails to render at top right.","marks":[],"usd":0.026316,"sec":54,"out":1746,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-high__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-high__raw","clutter":35.2,"shares":{"blue":64.8,"orange":0,"red":35.2,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":39.9},"score":5,"words":113,"missing":[],"summary":"The chart and +20.9% margin are clear, but the Qwen card, intro paragraph, stat row and date tag are clutter, and nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Category and date tag","reason":"Date and category tag adds nothing to the finding","boxes":[[894,74,230,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory intro paragraph","reason":"Subtitle explaining method and restating the chart","boxes":[[76,327,956,63],[912,327,89,28],[76,360,43,28]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen reproduction card","reason":"Second model family is a separate point beside the main chart","boxes":[[645,466,172,15],[645,491,274,28],[782,491,18,28],[645,501,285,206],[932,576,54,103],[645,674,210,22],[645,741,69,63],[785,741,98,63],[645,804,104,20],[785,804,53,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat row under margin","reason":"Win rate 55.9% repeats the bar counts; rubric points is extra","boxes":[[109,741,66,63],[249,741,99,63],[109,804,104,20],[249,804,53,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer website URL","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo at top","boxes":[[997,1130,127,15]]}],"usd":0.07475,"sec":57,"out":6105,"cut":22,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-high__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet-high","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-high__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":61.1},"score":0,"words":11,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single title, logo and two labelled value bars with no extras.","marks":[],"usd":0.014802,"sec":741,"out":56,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-medium__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-medium__raw","clutter":37.2,"shares":{"blue":43.7,"orange":38.3,"red":18,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":46},"score":6,"words":89,"missing":[],"summary":"A sentence headline, tag, subtitle, secondary metrics, a second win/tie/loss chart and a footer URL bury the two margin cards; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Topic tag","reason":"Category tag above headline; the headline already says GDPval.","boxes":[[729,84,387,26]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence, three-line headline; could be much shorter.","boxes":[[84,139,975,255]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Full-sentence headline","reason":"Finding is right, but the headline runs about 12 words over three lines; shorten it.","boxes":[[393,212,211,109]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Explanatory subtitle about method and training data.","boxes":[[84,403,879,70]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated metric label","reason":"Same 'net win-loss margin vs. base' label already given in the left card.","boxes":[[649,710,273,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Secondary metrics","reason":"Rubric points and win rate are extra metrics beyond the main margin.","boxes":[[119,769,57,42],[301,769,94,42],[649,769,61,42],[831,769,90,42],[119,813,152,29],[301,813,77,29],[649,813,152,29],[831,813,77,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Second brand mention when the logo is already shown.","boxes":[[990,1131,126,25]]}],"usd":0.05234,"sec":37,"out":3864,"cut":12,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-medium__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet-medium","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-medium__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":53},"score":0,"words":15,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a single waffle chart with a clear title and one legend, with nothing to remove.","marks":[],"usd":0.056322,"sec":42,"out":4208,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__raw","clutter":48.4,"shares":{"blue":37.8,"orange":27.8,"red":34.5,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.4},"score":5,"words":133,"missing":[],"summary":"A clear waffle chart is buried under a second-family stat panel, a long headline, a restating subtitle, and repeated brand and margin text; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Date stamp","reason":"Publication metadata that does not help read the chart.","boxes":[[977,64,159,15]]},{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Headline","reason":"Finding is clear but runs eleven words over two lines; could shorten to a tighter title.","boxes":[[64,104,960,177],[123,104,203,106]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Explanatory subtitle","reason":"Paragraph explains the method and restates the chart's context.","boxes":[[64,281,852,57]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Margin formula line","reason":"Restates the +20.9% margin the headline and panel already show.","boxes":[[371,696,56,22],[64,697,307,22]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Second model family panel","reason":"Qwen comparison is a second result; it serves a separate point from the main chart.","boxes":[[64,762,273,15],[64,787,411,53],[624,787,176,53],[64,839,272,21],[624,839,205,21],[458,869,118,59],[1024,869,112,59],[64,897,155,14],[624,897,155,14],[64,926,357,8],[624,926,365,8],[484,931,92,59],[1045,931,91,59],[64,959,65,14],[624,959,65,14],[64,988,286,8],[624,988,293,8],[462,993,114,59],[1019,993,117,59],[64,1021,138,14],[624,1021,138,14],[64,1050,261,8],[624,1050,404,8]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Repeated panel label","reason":"Restates the 'distilled vs. base model' label already used above the chart.","boxes":[[924,762,212,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Footer URL","reason":"Brand already shown by the logo at top.","boxes":[[1022,1115,114,14]]}],"usd":0.18014,"sec":147,"out":16644,"cut":36,"shrunk":2},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet-xhigh","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet-xhigh__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":60.5},"score":0,"words":22,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: one waffle chart, a short headline, a context line, a legend and one logo.","marks":[],"usd":0.105092,"sec":96,"out":9085,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet__raw","clutter":18.4,"shares":{"blue":81.6,"orange":0,"red":18.4,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":40.8},"score":4,"words":50,"missing":[],"summary":"A solid main win-loss visual is followed by a Qwen stats row and an eyebrow and tagline that should go; nothing essential is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow kicker","reason":"Category tag above the headline adds nothing the reader needs","boxes":[[80,80,338,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Second-model stats row","reason":"Qwen results and rubric scores serve a separate point, not the main chart","boxes":[[80,841,108,100],[440,841,113,100],[800,841,197,100],[80,941,283,29],[440,941,310,29],[800,941,238,29]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Method tagline","reason":"Explanatory tagline restating what the chart already implies","boxes":[[80,1101,517,29]]}],"usd":0.03759,"sec":35,"out":2389,"cut":9,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"sonnet","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__sonnet__simple","clutter":0,"shares":{"blue":100,"orange":0,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":42.3},"score":0,"words":14,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and complete: a title naming the GDPval comparison, a 220-square outcome grid, and one legend with counts.","marks":[],"usd":0.043732,"sec":36,"out":2949,"cut":0,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__wonder__raw","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"wonder","variant":"raw","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__wonder__raw","clutter":77,"shares":{"blue":23,"orange":0,"red":77,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":44.9},"score":8,"words":311,"missing":[],"summary":"The win/loss bar is buried under stat cards, a second chart, a pipeline diagram, side panels and repeated brand text; nothing is missing.","marks":[{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Header/footer brand repeats","reason":"Brand and URL repeated; logo already present.","boxes":[[939,39,197,37],[1037,1153,99,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Eyebrow tags","reason":"Category pill and kicker line add nothing needed.","boxes":[[64,126,204,30],[76,133,180,17],[679,133,457,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Slogan headline line","reason":"Slogan 'Taught on its own mistakes' does not state the finding.","boxes":[[64,159,570,78]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Subtitle paragraph","reason":"Paragraph explaining and restating the findings.","boxes":[[64,283,799,87]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Stat card row","reason":"Restates margins, win rates and scores shown in charts; dataset stat is extra.","boxes":[[64,403,227,34],[430,403,284,34],[797,403,284,34],[64,431,160,81],[430,431,168,81],[797,431,91,81],[64,506,236,21],[300,506,76,19],[430,506,239,21],[669,506,74,19],[797,506,308,43],[970,506,30,19]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Qwen replication side panel","reason":"Second chart and teacher list make a separate replication point.","boxes":[[749,588,347,24],[749,617,263,19],[763,663,154,18],[755,685,366,20],[763,688,46,17],[763,725,84,18],[755,747,375,20],[763,750,43,17]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Bar legend and formula","reason":"Legend duplicates bar labels; formula and percentages are extra.","boxes":[[91,729,340,15]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Rubric and sign test rows","reason":"Secondary stats beyond the main visual.","boxes":[[604,758,73,36],[91,769,186,20],[587,807,90,36],[91,818,248,20],[91,857,348,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"unneeded","name":"Bar scale note","reason":"Explains the chart scale, which is unneeded.","boxes":[[755,770,284,14]]},{"label":"red","type":"repetition","name":"Rubric and win-rate rows","reason":"Repeats values already shown elsewhere.","boxes":[[1062,806,97,36],[749,817,205,20],[1026,855,133,36],[749,866,185,20]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"Teachers and regression note","reason":"Teacher names and general-benchmark claim serve separate ideas.","boxes":[[763,920,375,60],[825,920,157,18],[992,920,97,18]]},{"label":"red","type":"extra_idea","name":"How-it-works pipeline","reason":"Method diagram and hyperparameters are a second idea.","boxes":[[91,1031,470,15],[91,1031,470,15],[785,1031,324,15],[118,1067,207,53],[374,1067,207,53],[629,1067,207,53],[885,1067,199,53],[146,1076,150,18],[404,1076,145,18],[652,1076,161,18],[927,1076,115,18],[332,1086,34,15],[588,1086,34,15],[844,1086,34,15],[157,1098,127,15],[417,1098,120,15],[658,1098,150,15],[927,1098,115,15]]}],"usd":0.243076,"sec":135,"out":11317,"cut":70,"shrunk":0},{"id":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval__wonder__simple","task":"on-policy-distillation-gdpval","model":"wonder","variant":"simple","img":"shots/on-policy-distillation-gdpval__wonder__simple","clutter":6.8,"shares":{"blue":86.5,"orange":13.5,"red":0,"unlabelled":0,"paintedOfCanvas":63},"score":1,"words":21,"missing":[],"summary":"Clean and nearly complete; the headline is a full sentence that could be shorter.","marks":[{"label":"orange","type":"verbose","name":"Sentence headline","reason":"Full-sentence headline at 52px; could be shorter, like 'Distilled wins 123 of 220'.","boxes":[[64,145,876,137]]}],"usd":0.107876,"sec":71,"out":4518,"cut":0,"shrunk":1}],"agreement":{"test":{"grader":"consensus-v4","runs":12,"elements":397,"labelAcc":80.9,"runAcc":82.8,"cutAcc":84.9,"scoreMAE":1.33,"scoreRho":0.91,"shareMAE":5.4,"missing":"1/2 caught, 1 false","seconds":null,"usd":null,"tokens":null,"conf":{"blue":{"blue":193,"orange":1,"red":9},"orange":{"blue":15,"orange":4,"red":37},"red":{"blue":14,"orange":0,"red":124}}}}}